How long after the US Civil War ended did Civil War reenactment start? When and why did it become so popular?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

I’m a Palestinian Jew living near the Mediterranean coast during the first Crusade. What is my life like as regarding Europeans and Muslims?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

In WW2, did the Allies have their own versions of 'Tokyo Rose' broadcasting in German, Italian, or Japanese to hurt enemy morale?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

A minority of modern western people don't identify with the male/female dichotomy and embrace an intermediate space, or third gender. Beyond the west and through prior ages of history, how common were such orientations? How did societies deal with nonbinary genders?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Italian WW1 Research

For the last two years I have been trying to get my hands on my Great Grandfathers' 'Foglio Matricolare' or military file from Italy. My main objective out of all of this is just to know what he did during the Great War. I know of his life here in the United States but no one in the family knows of his military service. Well, let me start off with some facts...

-I have a copy of his birth certificate, so I know for a fact his birth location, province, parents, birth date and birth name are accurate (unless it was typed wrong)

-I have a picture of him in his uniform, so I know he served... me, not being an Italian WW1 Uniform expert by any means, I had multiple people of varying degrees of expertise look at his picture and they came up with the following assumptions...

  1. almost everyone agrees his uniform hat is a basic infantry hat ... but now the confusion comes in.
  2. people were split on his pants because he had pockets on the sides and they were tailored high and tight as if he was in a cavalry unit or an officer
  3. everyone believes his boots were alpine or mountain boots they way they are wrapped
  4. his coat has pockets which they believed were mostly reserved for NCOs or Officers and his lapel has some sort of insignia or metal on it but it is hard to tell

With that said, when I first contacted the archives from the province he was born in, they told me he was on their 'Liste di Leva' with a date of 1/12/1915. They told me to contact the Regional Archives which I did. Long story short, I contacted the village archives, Province archives, Regional Archives, General Army Archives in Rome and Rome State Archives all coming back with negative results. I would assume (and they as well) either he wasn't an officer or his record was lost, damaged or misplaced.

In any case, he was born in Pesaro e Urbino. The closest unit to where he was born was Brigata Pesaro 239th/240th Regiment. They in turn along with Brigata Grosseto eventually formed the 52nd Alpini Division. I feel like that might explain the possible mismatch of the uniform? There are a few other Regiments and Cavalry units I could mention but they are further away from his hometown than the one I previously mentioned.

Now, is it safe to assume he would have possibly been in the 239/240 Regiment and then the 52nd Alpine Division? Is there some other archive I should contact or website I should look at? I am at a complete loss and really don't know where else to look for information. Thank you very much.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Why was Newfoundland a separate colony from Canada?

Newfoundland merged with Canada in 1949 because it was having economic issues as a colony separate from Canada. Why did it take so long for Newfoundland to join Canada? Was there a specific reason that Newfoundland stayed separate for so long? Did Newfoundlanders think of themselves as being culturally distinct from Canada?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Mussolini is well known for his effect on Italian trains...

Why is he known for apprently sorting the punctuality of the Italian rail network? Is it a myth or was he a transport genius?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Advice on hstorical South American representation

I'm unsure if there are better subreddits to ask about this topic, but this was the first place I could think of. If there is a sub someone knows of that will have a more reliable perspective on cultural feelings and representation, I'd highly appreciate it if you could direct me there.

Essentially, I'm trying to write a novel that has an absurdist take on oldschool treasure hunter adventures, and part of the quest involves bumping into a township, near where the fabled "lost temple" supposedly filled with Indiana Jones traps and treasure is supposed to be.

Though the world my story is set in is fictitious, I have previously been advised that making a culture like this look "generally indiginous" could lead to some uncomfortable sideways glances, due to issues concerning homogenisation. In which case, if I were to select a specific group for aesthetic influence in terms of clothing and buildings etc, I'd go with the Maya. Wondered if anyone could recommend sites detailing reliable accounts on these topics? One thing I found that I thought could be counted on for reference for clothes is this artist's rendition: https://www.deviantart.com/kamazotz/art/Postclassic-Maya-of-Yucatan-Set-Females-297302232 They provided sources (though you gotta squint to read them), so should assume this is reliable?

The main part these locals would play into the story is briefly providing lodgings for the protagonists, and the protagonists might learn some life lessons and the sort while they're there. Otherwise I wasn't planning to go into detail on local traditions or anything (I was going to avoid any "they're so unlike us!" tropes if I could catch myself).

But eventually, they'd feature into the climax, with the central villain coming to take something, and they and the protagonists team up to take him down. I want to be careful to avoid falling into a "white saviour" trap, so I figured it was necessary to present the victory as a group effort.

If there's some basic pointers I've failed to consider, I'd be happy to hear about them

1 Answers 2021-04-28

When Henry VIII dissolved the monasteries in 1536-41, they were portrayed as greedy, immoral, practically brothels, full of fake relics and miracles, etc. How much of this was truth and how much was propaganda?

Were the monasteries as bad as claimed by the government and Henry VIII's commissioners, or were they saying that to justify a policy they had already decided upon?

2 Answers 2021-04-28

Yuan Shao's defeat at the Battle of Guandu.(200 A.D)

My Question is Why did Yuan Shao lose the battle when he had a vastly superior force then what Cao Cao could muster, how could he be defeated? when he had very talented general his command and again his superior army?. What were the causes of his defeat and later death? Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

why did Washington want to wait until after his and his wife's deaths to free the slaves at Mt. Vernon?

.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

What language(s) did Jesus Christ speak?

Is it known what languages Jesus spoke? Does anyone have any examples of what they look or sound like? Also, are they related to any modern day languages? I think it would be very interesting to know what languages he may have spoken, and what they sound like, with him being the figure of the largest religion worldwide.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

I have been told that the caste system in India was an invention or serious distortion of pre-colonial practices. Is it true that the caste system is the fault of the British?

I want to read up more on the supposed historiographical debate on this topic, but I don't even know how to learn more, so I was hoping I could be corrected that there is no serious debate, or directed to some literature about it at least.

2 Answers 2021-04-28

Why did Xerxes I use Elamite in the inscription at Van?

The fortress at Van is far from Elamite territory, and reading up on the Elamites, they would seem to be a small minority at that point, in Persia.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

In Roman cities, so many aspects of what we think of as private home life - eating, bathing, shaving - were done in public. How did this impact cultural feelings of community, home life, and personal privacy?

I'm reading Mary Beard's The Fires of Vesuvius (my first Mary Beard book and I'm utterly captivated) and was interested to learn that most ordinary folks ate out at street shops. I'm sure we all saw those beautiful "fast food" shops that were recently excavated at Pompeii! How did this wider phenomenon of doing things that we would take for granted as happening inside the home (cooking, bathing, eating) change cultural ideas of privacy? As modern people, would Roman notions of privacy vs public life seem strange to us?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

In the 800 years prior to the Hyskos conquest, Egypt built 6 pyramids. In the 800 years after the conquest, Egypt built 0 pyramids. Did something happen?

The conquest itself only lasted 100 years or so, I think. And I have heard the Egyptians pushed out the Hyskos by adopting Hyskos bronze making techniques which would have probably made it easier to build pyramids, if anything. Yet no pyramids got built!

It looks like most of the pyramids were built prior to the Hyskos conquest around 1600 BC. I wonder if post-hyksos Egypt was somehow (for a long time) too economically traumatized to build any more pyramids. What do people think?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_pyramids

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Were European Powers Looking to Carve up Ancien Régime France on the Eve of the French Revolution?

I was listening to the Revolutions podcast series on the French Revolution and in one of the first episodes, Mike Duncan (the podcaster) compares Ancien Régime France to the declining country of Poland-Lithuania, which would only survive a few more years until the Third Partition of Poland in 1795. He goes so far as to say that France was in such disorder and financial ruin in the run up to the French Revolution other European Powers had begun to imagine a Europe without France.

Was there ever any real plans by, say England or Prussia, to annex French land in a similar fashion as the Partitions of Poland?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

When did idols/statues enter into Buddhism?

I've been reading conflicting reports as to whether Buddhism has idols in it or not.

The teachings of Buddha himself seem to directly contradict attachment to anything physical, certainly to forms meant to represent the divine. The entire theme is a rejection of the transient—sort of discovery of oneness through negation of all else.

I read somewhere that they actually never had it, rather it was something which was introduced with the Greek invasion under Alexander of Macedonia, and later that Buddhists saw these formidable statues of the Greeks and began to imitate them.

I was wondering if anyone had more knowledge than I on this question.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Why was the Venetian Navy so dominant in the 15 / 16 / 17th centuries? Why were the Ottomans unable to land an invasion force and take the city of Venice?

From all of my readings about the Ottoman Empire. It seemed like the Republic of Venice was not only a thorn in its side but a rival power. The Ottomans and the Venetians fought 7 wars over a 300 year period, and to my understanding. Never have the Ottomans come close to landing an invasion force on the island of Venice.

I am having difficulty understanding how that could be the case. The Ottoman Empire had more than 100 times the landmass and more than 100 times the population of Venice.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/mzydj1/the_ottoman_empire_in_1593_gregorian_oc/

And if the Ottomans were not wealthier than the Venetians. They were definitely not poor as they controlled all trade between Europe and Asia. My point with all this. Is that the Ottomans should have had the resources to take Venice.

Sure, the Ottomans were more experienced with land warfare. But I am just not understanding this. Why was the Empire never able to take the city of Venice?

Were the Venetians just unbeatable on the water? Did the Ottomans not wish to take out the Venetian Republic? Were the Ottomans genuinely unable to build a naval force to rival Venice? Were Venice's allies so powerful that the Ottomans could never hope to approach the city?

Please help me understand this, I would also appreciate recommendations on good books from the era.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

How bad was the US-UK relationship during the early stages of WWI? Did the US really come almost as close to war with Britain as with Germany?

A friend of my asserted yesterday that the US came almost as close to war with Britain as with Germany during WWI. I'm wondering if this is true. I'm aware that Anglo-American relations got pretty tense over the blockade, so my question is basically: how tense? Was there a real risk the relationship would break down?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

The Mughal Empire's downfall

Was Aurangzeb the reason to Mughal Empire's downfall or did the Empire's state start deteriorating even before Aurangzeb started to rule?

1 Answers 2021-04-28

What was the living standards situation in the USSR in "the golden years"

Although bread lines are commonly used as arguments against the Soviets, they were most intense under bad economic policies and other crises (early years, ww2, the 80s etc) I was wondering if such instances occured, and on what scale, during periods such as the Khrushchev thaw

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Do we know what Julius Caesar looked like ? If so, how can we be sure ?

Basically the title

1 Answers 2021-04-28

Short Answers to Simple Questions | April 28, 2021

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

45 Answers 2021-04-28

What was the endgame in India for British Empire ?

I am studying history right now and especially Government of India act 1935.

It seems to include many things on which ultimate Indian constitution is based on. And Independence movements were also picking up pace acter 1930s what was the plan for British Empire in India ? Was it ultimately "pack up and leave" or more like Canadian dominion status ? Because i have heard contradictory statements that Freedom fighters were asking for full independence and the Empire was discounting a dominion status to India as a colony.

1 Answers 2021-04-28

730 / 7255

Back to start