Where ancient and medieval battles as brutal and costly as they are shown to be in TV and video games?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

How did Polynesians discover new islands? Did they know where to look or did they just find them?

I have heard that the Polynesians knew how to navigate based on the ocean currents (and the stars?) between islands, and that they elaborated maps of where islands were located with respect to one another, and in Polynesia and Micronesia I imagine it was relatively easy to find new islands. Did they have some kind of system to locate far-fetched islands? How did they colonize Hawai'i or Rapanui?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

The “Clean Wehrmacht” narrative has been debunked regarding the Heer’s conduct, but the “Clean Kriegsmarine” narrative persists largely unchallenged. How clean was the Kriegsmarine?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Why was the Soviet agency in charge of nuclear development called Ministry of Medium Machine Building

So lately I've been reading Serhii Plokhy's quite excellent Chernobyl: A History of a Tragedy. There he briefly mentions that the Soviet agency in charge of developing both Soviet nuclear weapons and nuclear power plants was called Ministry of Medium Machine Building.

So my questions are: Why such a name? To me it sounds quite suspicious. Was it a common practice naming secret programs with such names? Was it meant to mislead foreigners, Soviet citizens or both? And the name work or did everyone just guess what the agency really was about anyway?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Is there any surviving architecture from the Latin Empire of Constantinople?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

What would Marco Polo have eaten during his travels on the Silk Road when actually on the road and not stopped at a settlement?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

What did people in Afghanistan do for fun after the Taliban banned nearly every pastime?

According to Wikipedia,

The Taliban forbade pork and alcohol, many types of consumer technology such as music, television, and film, as well as most forms of art such as paintings or photography, male and female participation in sport, including football and chess; recreational activities such as kite-flying and keeping pigeons or other pets were also forbidden, and the birds were killed according to the Taliban's ruling. Movie theaters were closed and repurposed as mosques. Celebration of the Western and Iranian New Year was forbidden. Taking photographs and displaying pictures or portraits was forbidden, as it was considered by the Taliban as a form of idolatry. Women were banned from working, girls were forbidden to attend schools or universities, were requested to observe purdah and to be accompanied outside their households by male relatives; those who violated these restrictions were punished. Men were forbidden to shave their beards and required to let them grow and keep them long according to the Taliban's liking, and to wear turbans outside their households.

Banning everything from pet-ownership and sport to nearly every form of art and performance seems like it would make the life of an ordinary person immensely boring.

How widely were these policies enforced?

And if they were enforced, what did ordinary Afghans living under the Taliban do in their free time?

2 Answers 2021-04-18

What would a farm kid from America experience as a Marine in the Pacific during WWII?

Hi r/AskHistorians missing my dad a lot today. He enlisted into the Marines in 1942 when he turned 17. He grew up on a farm in Michigan's UP and until the war had never been more than a few miles from it. For the rest of his life he refused to talk about the war aside from a few stories about boot camp and how Pearl Harbor looked one year after the attack. (Like an eerie boat graveyard with all the downed ships dragged to the side as best as possible to allow entry into the harbor. He said the entire ship was silent as they sailed in.) When pressed for more information he would say that some things are better forgotten. When I was a kid he had his cap and a few medals in a box but he threw them away before I was a teen. I do not now remember what the medals looked like.

What little I know is he was a Marine, a private first class, and I believe he spent time as a military police. He lost two fingers and in one of his only comments said, "well, they missed." He was classed as a sharpshooter but he said all farm kids were. Finally, he was dismissed honorably after the war's end. Is there anywhere I could get specific information about where he was? I wrote the National Archives but was only able to get his dates of service. Could you suggest some of the best books on the reality of serving in the Pacific Theater?

He was a wonderful dad and a very good man. He married his sweetheart a few years after the war and they spent 64 years together before passing away a few days apart in 2015. Thinking about him today and this 'missing' part of his life.

2 Answers 2021-04-18

Why didn't the Vikings share the route they took to reach Newfoundland with other European nations?

Sounds like the sort of knowledge that would be very valuable for commercial reasons.

1 Answers 2021-04-18

What stopped the invention of magazines and clips?

Basically we see muskets and muzzle loading rifles for hundreds of years before the invention of a cartridge and either a breach loading or multi round capacity weapons such as the martini-henry or winchester rifles. Why couldn’t they make that much earlier? It seems obvious that making a cartridge would make it easier.

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Foreigners were banned from Japan except for a few ports, and yet the Jesuits managed to go inland, live with regular people, and even publish a book about the Japanese language, how were they able to do all this?

Foreigners were only allowed to be at a few designated ports, right?, and the Jesuits just... walked away?, no one stopped them?... and then they got a house at a town and started just... living there?... no one alerted the authorities?, no government official came to check on the group of foreigners living illegally in the country?, and then they even published a book about the Japanese language?!... I mean, cool for them but... weren't they at least trying to keep a low profile or something?

I'm so confused and wikipedia does not help

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Gerald of Wales (c. 1146-1223) is infamous in Ireland for having reported the Irish as backwards and barbaric, which impacted and was used to justify English rule over Ireland. But do any other contemporaneously written works by others exist which refute Gerald’s damaging perspectives?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

What could you buy with 30 pieces of silver in the NT time in Judea and in other parts of Rome?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

In school, I learned a lot about about Ancient Greek theater and Elizabethan theater but very little theater in between those time periods. Why?

3 Answers 2021-04-18

How did the fighting in the first half of WW2 differ from the latter half for the average infantry soldier?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Did Asians know about Australia?

I mean Australia is much closer to Asia than Western countries. Why wasn't Australia colonized by Japan or China? Did they lack the ships and equipment in the age of great discoveries, or weren't they ambitious to expand their territory or explore the seas?

3 Answers 2021-04-18

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | April 18, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2021-04-18

How did Boudica lose to the Romans?

Boudica started the Iceni revolt in 60 AD and raised an army of over 200,000 men! She was against the governor of Britain named Gaius Suetonius Paulinus who had a much smaller garrisoning force of 10,000 men and turned around to fight Boudica to stall her and let the people escape. Then Boudica lost! With over 200,000 men and 20:1 odds, she still lost! I have tried looking for answers but can never find a detailed answer and they usually say that superior discipline won over numbers. Can anyone please explain?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Were there competitors to Mormonism at the time of its founding?

Recently, I’ve been reading about how there were several competing movements to early Christianity, and that the late Roman Empire was a hotbed for new religions. I then remembered that the United States had some periods of proliferative religiosity itself. While 19th century American culture is obviously its own unique thing, it still struck me as interesting from a sociological perspective that a radically new theology emerged at this time. The fact that it took off probably meant it fulfilled some need for its followers.

I wonder, were there other prophets leading movements that could be compared to Mormonism at this time?

2 Answers 2021-04-18

Where is the testimony of my ancestor in a criminal case from 1560's Antwerpen?

Hello,

I have discovered that on of my ancestors testified in a case in 1560's Antwerpen. It was against Marcus Saligant who had disrupted a preach of a preacher.

I found the story here. (I'm sorry it's in Dutch.)

When I went searching for the primary source of this testimony, I failed. I couldn't find it. Then I tried searching for the case, but could only find a chronic from 1743 about it, or sources that were written after 1950!

Then I went a step further and tried searching for court cases in general pre-1700 like those about the witches. But I still haven't succeeded in finding any court case from before 1700 from anywhere in the Netherlands and Belgium!

Am I just searching for something that doesn't exist? Where criminal cases only partially documented like when the punishment was executed or what the bills where, but the rest was just known and not written down?

My main question still is: Where is the testimony of Emmanuel Alvarez, the man in question? But by now, if you could show me any primary source that talks about a court case in the Netherlands/Belgium before 1700, I would already be happy. So my second question by now is: How can I find pre-1700 court cases? I hope you can help me with both.

Thanks in advance for taking the time to answer. :)

(Answering in Dutch is fine by me, IDK if the subreddit likes it though)

Kind regards

2 Answers 2021-04-18

Where did the custom/gesture/habit of placing fingertips on chest/near clavicle come from? Usually seen with media depictions of Western/European nobility, or women regardless of status, in 1800s setting and older.

Example screenshots of some depictions: https://imgur.com/a/MQ6VQzf

I have always noticed this tendency with depictions of I think British/French nobles in films, and women regardless of status from 1800s an older. But I've noticed that it doesn't seem to be something depicted if for Asian media.

And this gesture doesn't seem to be done these days anymore.

Upon reading online and from what I know, I know that the gesture can be related to the concept of "namaste" or well with national anthems.

I've also seen, and was wondering about if it's just a self-soothing gesture, or a gesture meant to accompany making statements that are heartfelt, or to show that what's being listened to/said is being considered. I'm not sure why it died down these days though.

I'm not sure if it was just a trend of the past.

Thanks for any insights on this! :D

1 Answers 2021-04-18

How does one find a historical topic or field to special in?

Hey there! I'm not sure whether this question fits the subs rules, but since it could be interpreted as a question on methodology I'm gonna post it anyway. Plus this is arguably the most appropriate sub to post anyway.

So how does one find a historical topic or field to special in?

I'm in the middle of my master's in history and have not yet found a field to specialize in. I have the feeling that most of my peers have already found something that they are focussing on, while I pick courses from all fields and epochs simply on the basis of what sounds interesting and read about everything I can get my hands on. But I realize that at one point I too should find something to specialize in, no one can't be an expert on everything after all.

So I wanted to ask what the experience of other historians are, how and when they found the topic they can be considered an expert on and whether on should worry about this in the first place

2 Answers 2021-04-18

What is the history of Five Finger Fillet in the "Old West"?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Fear of nuclear war/fallout was a common theme in 80's thrash/death metal. In the Cold War's final decade, was this fear genuinely held, or did it just provide appropriately edgy and brutal imagery for early extreme metal?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

Is it feasible at all that an Arch Duke would hire beggars off the street in Medieval Times?

I'm writing a story where the archduke recruits people who are at vulnerable pounts in their lives into a cult where they carry out shady and illegal tasks for him and their cover is he is charitable and hires people off the street and trains them to work in his household, some join his sort of personal guard of soldiers if they prove fit enough. Is there any chance of this happening in medieval times or is it just ridic?

1 Answers 2021-04-18

746 / 7255

Back to start