Hi guys!
I’ve just quit my soul destroying retail job, and I really want to try and make history my career. I have an undergrad arts degree with a history major, and I’m totally open to doing a masters or PhD. But I’m realizing more and more than I don’t really have a firm grip on what it is historians actually do, and how they make a living.
What different full-time, salaried roles are there? What do you do all day in those roles, and how did you land them?
Is there such a thing as a freelance historian? If so, how do you pay the bills?
1 Answers 2021-04-03
2 Answers 2021-04-03
I have been taking a course on Ancient Greek mythology and was wondering why a religion like Christianity worships a single deity, whereas the Ancient Greeks worshiped many. Was there a cultural significance to these choices, and what made polytheism seem to fade out?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
1 Answers 2021-04-02
I was taught in school (in the US) that most Americans did NOT know about the holocaust or the genocide of the Jews even though there were photographic evidence and testimony of escaped inmates circulating in at least 1941. I have to assume that once these rumors came out the Germans—who were no strangers to shouting "fake news" themselves, would have pushed a disinformation campaign... but I don't know. To draw a contemporary parallel—what is happening with the Uyghurs in China—might something like that have happened in the 1940s?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
For example the Browning Automatic Rifle had less ammunition then a M1A1 Grease gun but was still considered a Light Machine gun, same with the Japanese Type 11 and Type 96 which had 30 rounds, a bit more than the BAR's 20 but still was on the same level as SMG's.
[EDIT] Forgot to mention the Bren, and Chauchat as well.
1 Answers 2021-04-02
Did Valmiki influence Homer, or vice-versa?
In the Odyssey, Penelopeia has the suitors attempt to take Odysseus's bow, string it, bend it, and then try to shoot an arrow between a row of axes, with the winning suitor having her hand in marriage. (which Odysseus wins while disguised)
In the Ramayana, Sita's father holds a contest with a bow, all being the same as what happened in the Odyssey sans the shooting between the axes, and the winner gets her hand in marriage. (which Rama won because he's like 2/3s Vishnu)
It struck me as interesting that these two completely different cultures have the same practice for a woman's hand in marriage shown in an example of their mythology.
So I wondered, was this an actual practice across ancient cultures, or was it just happenstance and just a good way of showing the god-likeness of their heroes in a story?
Thanks!
<original question: reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4v0x27/in_both_the_odyssey_and_the_ramayana_there_is_a/>
1 Answers 2021-04-02
1 Answers 2021-04-02
Hello
I recently watch the death of Stalin on Netflix. I became intrigued by Zhukov and his actions during the transition period after Stalin’s death. My question is why did Zhukov fall out of favor during the Brezhnev years? Thank you in advance.
1 Answers 2021-04-02
To my admittedly amateur eyes, it seems like Napoleon's strategy at Waterloo was to split the Prussians and English so he could defeat each in turn (rather than allow them to combine, outnumber, and overwhelm him as they did). The turning point to me seems to hinge on Grouchy's inability to drive off the Prussians, which ultimately allowed Blucher and his forces to engage Napoleon's right flank that afternoon, sealing the French general's fate.
My question: was Napoleon justified in taking this risk based on the intel that he had? I don't mean to turn this into a history-what-if discussion, but based on what Napoleon knew at the time, was his gamble that Grouchy could keep the Prussians out of the fight a reasonable one, or was this a desperate/hubris-inspired mistake with little to back up its assumption(s)? Or is this question coming from a faulty place in that Napoleon would have lost regardless of the Prussian presence on the field?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
Just been wondering lately.
2 Answers 2021-04-02
I've heard he was a sword-bearer for Nobunaga but not given the official title of samurai.
1 Answers 2021-04-02
I'm doing some research into SDI and I'm not too sure if it was ever planned to be used or if it was more sort of fearmongering on the US' behalf. Was it just a mad claim by Reagan to try and flex showing the US could achieve anything? Or was it actually considered a viable option as a nuclear deterrent? Any info relating to SDI would be greatly appreciated
1 Answers 2021-04-02
I am asking whether if Prussia ever establish important colonies outside of Europe before unification of Germany in 1871?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
I was recently reading the Trial of Eichmann wiki entry and I saw that it is claimed that a dozen Holocaust survivors sought to testify for the defense. A citation was made to “Bitter Reckoning: Israel Tries Holocaust Survivors as Nazi Collaborators”. Does anyone know more about this or just any general resources for Holocaust survivors making defenses or excuses for Nazis?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
1 Answers 2021-04-02
I was scrolling through the wikipedia page of the naval battle of the war of 1812, and it appears that at several occasions, the american Navy had the upper hands aigainst the royal navy, notable exemple the capture of HMS cyane and HMS Levant (of whom one was re-capture) who were 6th rate ship.
It's baffling to see that the newly created american navy was able to compete with the almighty Royal navy, keep in mind that the early 1800 was the height of the power for both Britain and the Royal navy, moreover both the French, Spannish and Dutch were in now way able to contest the British dominance over the sea so the "the Royal navy were too busy with the Europeans" idea doesnt work as Napoleon abandonned his dream of having a superior Navy.
So let's jump to the conclusion, why the (newly created) American navy was able to gain the upper hand with the British?
3 Answers 2021-04-02
Askhistorians Podcast Episode 172 is live
The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!
This Episode
In this episode, P.H. Jones and Johannes Breit discuss one of the largest publishing hoaxes of the 20th century: The Hitler Diaries. When German journalist Gerd Heidemann entered a world of Nazis, old and new, WWII memorabilia, and collectors of Hitler paintings in the 70s, he never expected to find the alleged diaries of Adolf Hitler. Allegedly smuggled out of East Germany, this was the find of a lifetime. While Heidemann and his employer, Stern, already had dollar signs in their eyes, they didn’t expect to find themselves at the centre of one of the largest journalistic and publishing scandals of the last century that would ruin them, make the forger a star and humiliate Rupert Murdoch. Jones and Breit will take you through the whole story that involves everything from Hermann Göring’s Yacht to a forger of German lunch vouchers to David Irving and that ends with several millions Mark missing and several people in prison.
3 Answers 2021-04-02
Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
8 Answers 2021-04-02
Also is this phenomenon seen in other countries?
2 Answers 2021-04-02
So I’ve been wondering about the reaction of the north and it’s citizens to the surrender of Fort Sumter , were the men heckled for giving up the fort and first battle of the civil war to the rebels in the south ? What happened to the man who led the forts garrison? Did he fight again ?
2 Answers 2021-04-02
Did they? And what were Hitlers main errors and what actions /non-actions could have lead to a different outcome of the war. (At least in Europe.)
1 Answers 2021-04-02
Are the letters sent by Muhammad to Heraclius and vice versa considered genuine?
1 Answers 2021-04-02
What were the elites eating in this highly stratified society, with wide ranging access to produce? I'm guessing that peasants ate simple things like maize and beans, but were there any accounts of special dishes served, e.g., to the Spanish while they stayed in Tenochtitlan?
Also, how much of Aztec food would be recognizable to someone familiar with Mexican food today? When did signature dishes develop, like tacos, enchiladas, tamales, etc? I'm guessing a big innovation would have been the introduction of cheese?
2 Answers 2021-04-02