Did they have any special cares for it? Did they just carry it in a common pouch? Was there anything invented to carry gunpowder and avoid it getting wet or to just make it more stable?
1 Answers 2021-03-28
I have been fascinated by the Polynesians because they were superb sailors despite their ships being incomparable to the ships European countries would build. I’ve been wondering how could they possibly be this good at travel it just is hard to comprehend for me.
1 Answers 2021-03-28
1 Answers 2021-03-28
In many cases, when archaeologists reached a tomb, they found that it had already been extensively damaged by robbing. It is also said that these robbings did NOT take place in the modern era. Who were these premodern robbers who had the knowledge to know where the tombs were and how to get inside them?
1 Answers 2021-03-28
Went down this train of thought while participating in the sacred Passover ritual of watching Prince of Egypt, and thinking about how Moses's adoptive brother is named Ramses, as opposed to any of the other proposed Pharaohs. I do remember in sixth grade history class that it was mentioned that he was that Pharaoh—though I forget if it was taught as fact or hypothesis, nor do I remember if the implication was that the Exodus did in fact happen, or if this was presented as "If Exodus had happened, then he was the Pharaoh at the time." Of course, I am familiar with what the general consensus among historians is on the veracity of the Biblical story, so I suppose asking if any of those alternatives hold any water is a bit of a goose chase, but I am curious about the overall reasoning behind these theories and how compelling the cases are in pinpointing the real figure that aligns with the Biblical narrative.
Nevertheless, though, what's the reasoning for Ramses II to be the most popular name for Exodus Pharaoh, both in and out of academia?
2 Answers 2021-03-28
2 Answers 2021-03-28
My introduction to /r/AskHistorians came from a comment onto which I stumbled from /r/All. It was a massive, detailed, three-comment write-up of armored train usage on the Eastern front in WWII.
I never, ever would have thought to ask a question about that subject, but it was a delightful read and I was very grateful that someone asked the question that lead to it. It makes me wonder how many other potential goldmines like that are out there from the passionate contributors on this forum, lacking the question that could lead to their discovery.
Could we have a contained space where someone with a great deal of niche knowledge would be free to talk about it and share their enthusiasm about the subject? The usual rules and standards for sourcing would apply. I might not think to ask, but I would probably enjoy reading a detailed write-up on the methods of elephant husbandry by early Indian farmers or something equally unlikely to come up via standard question.
Actually, although it's a meta post, if anyone would like to talk about the early domestication of elephants, please do so.
And finally if anyone remembers that armored train thread, please post it in the comments because I would love to read it again.
1 Answers 2021-03-28
2 Answers 2021-03-28
Basically this all began with my new found interest in history and archeology, which was sparked when I started researching the origins of religion in antiquity, the beginnings of civilization, epic of gilgamesh etc. Eventually I stumbled upon the Aztec civilization, and after being fascinated by them, I began researching the Olmecs.
The first thing I thought when I seen the Olmec heads was “Well those look like African people...” and since then I’ve been trying to figure out what exactly is going on here. The head dubbed “El Negro” looks especially African in appearance. I’ve seen pictures showing how the Olmec heads also somewhat resemble the Native Americans in that area, but I still feel that they more closely resemble African people. Since this is inconclusive and can’t really be considered solid evidence, I continued my research.
What I found was similar small inconclusive pieces of evidence, some left open ended, some disproven, but then I stumbled upon this anomaly: https://blog.cansfordlabs.co.uk/hair-testing-cocaine-mummies-real-or-fake
How do these Egyptian mummies have narcotics in their system which can only be found in the Americas? I tried to google it to find an answer, but I literally could find nothing. There’s no reputable sources which explain this, in fact all I could find are news articles which reported it and conspiracy websites talking about the trans Atlantic communication conspiracy. Is there any explanation for this, or is this some actual evidence which needs to be examined?
When I googled DNA/genetic testing of Native American and ancient Native American bones, it appears that no African DNA has been found in these peoples. I’m also not certain on the conclusiveness of this though, as I don’t trust my amateur (at best) researching skills, so does this irrefutably disprove an African connection with the Americas?
Some other small evidences I’ve seen: -Claims of Olmec language being very similar to African Mande language -Olmec heads also seem to have braids -Aztec codex which shows some individuals appearing with darker skin and greater stature than the lighter skinned individuals (I know Aztec=/=Olmec but it suggests the presence of black Africans in the Americas) -Apparently some African artifacts and African metals have been found in the Americas? (not sure the legitimacy on this one, again researching these things it’s actually surprisingly hard to find conclusive data) -African and Meso-American art being made of the same jade material (same inconclusive data as above) -Apparently the Olmecs and Aztecs worshipped “black gods” (according the Clyde Winters)
I’ll add that all of these claims come from Clyde Winters and Van Sertima, and you can even see them saying these things yourself on Quora if you try to research this stuff.
So, can a historian tell me what’s going on here? Is there actual legitimacy to Winters and Sertimas claims of an African presence in the America’s? Or are these just Afrocentrists trying to play culture culture and rewrite history?
2 Answers 2021-03-28
I’ve heard some laypeople argue that she was black, but it also seems to be a somewhat politically charged topic. Are there varying accounts in the literature?
1 Answers 2021-03-28
I mean they lost manpower, pilots (which is hard to train) and planes? Wasn’t it a bad strategy in the long run?
2 Answers 2021-03-28
Hi,
I'm a student who is going to be writing a 4000 ish word paper which requires the use of sources prior to Hellenistic Greece. The question, though not entirely formalized yet, is as follows : "How did cult behavior influence the shift in portrayal of Dionysus from Mycenaean to Hellenistic Greece?" I have access to JSTOR, and have found some great articles about Linear B on there, for example. Unfortunately the Mycenaeans were an overly organized people that didn't keep particularly many records outside of practical & legal applications. At least that's what I found from my research so far. I do know, however, that there are mentions of the original 12 Greek gods traditionally included in the Pantheon. I just am unsure of where exactly to find this.
Thank you so much for any help/advice on gathering valuable sources!
1 Answers 2021-03-27
Was this just a crazy idea or was it seriously considered?
1 Answers 2021-03-27
Here's an image of a snap of the census record
About 1 year later he's seen working in development in the Springfield Armory just prior to WWII. He's apparently a fully capable guy. Had worked as a chicken dealer in the 20's, a weaver at a carpet mill in the '00s, but has no higher than a 3rd grade education. Lives in Springfield, Mass., USA. Born in 1882.
Edit: I also just saw on the census that he said 'yes' to working in the public sector, and 'no' to the private sector.
2 Answers 2021-03-27
1 Answers 2021-03-27
2 Answers 2021-03-27
When discussing the aftermath of battles, we always hear about the tactical outcomes. If we hear about casualties, it’s usually little more than a number in a box.
Some battles had hundreds of thousands of deaths. All of those corpses had to end up somewhere but what actually happened to them once the fighting ceased?
I know Americans had the Graves Registration services and Germany had protocols for burials, but I can only find handbook-like level of detail. How closely did soldiers actually follow these rules? How quickly did the process take? Did most countries bring the bodies home or did they use on-site mass graves? The nitty-gritty of what happened doesn’t seems to have many primary accounts, especially in the Pacific Theater.
My grandfather was a WWII veteran and he never liked to talk about these types of experiences but I feel like this is an important part of what actually happened in the War.
1 Answers 2021-03-27
Apologies if this is a stupid question, which it very likely is seeing as I'm about to sleep and I can't think straight right now, but both the ancient Greek empire(?) and ancient Roman empire had a huge impact on today.
So my questions is specifically about the capital cities, in Athens there's really only a select few ancient ruins to see, while in Rome it seems that every other corner you turn there's an ancient ruin. Why is that? Was ancient Athens a lot smaller than I think it was, or has it just happened that almost everything except for the few ruins it has now have been destroyed, while Rome has so many well preserved ancient ruins you lose track of them. I'm pretty sure Rome has like 40+ ruins you can visit
1 Answers 2021-03-27
1 Answers 2021-03-27
Can someone recommend a book in the style of "The Making of the Atomic Bomb" that covers the time from 1945 to roughly 1990? I.e. about the H-bomb research and tests, the arms race and the cold war.
1 Answers 2021-03-27
1 Answers 2021-03-27
Title.
Reason I ask is because I know sailors were low in the social hierarchy, and I wonder if stigma was associated with their work songs.
1 Answers 2021-03-27
You all do brilliant work and I am grateful for that, but I am just curious.
Edit: Delighted by all the response. Your contributions make this one of the best subreddits, thank you for that.
62 Answers 2021-03-27