How were foreigners treated in Nazi Germany?

If you had migrated to Germany before 1933 and didn't have German citizenship how would Hitler's rise to power influenced your live.

The question is about non-Jewish foreigner as I'm sure that Jewish foreigners would have been killed.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

I read in a book that women in Sengoku Japan used a "red apron called mō", yet I cannot find other references to it. How would such an undergarment look like?

Specifically, I was reading the Sengoku RPG book — which I know not to be a historical source as Academia is concerned, but is still pretty well written and well-informed.

I found in a website that a "mou?" was a half-apron, but the question remains.

I believe it would hold the bottom half, not the upper one, due to its color. However, how it was used and the details of the appearance still eludes me.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

How should I get started researching the criminal element during the 70s/80s in my small hometown?

I feel like this may be a question too broad in scope, but I didn't really know what else to ask. I'm endeavoring on a personal, non-academic research project regarding events in my hometown during the 1970s and 1980s. I'm really unsure how to get started, as I have never really done anything like this before. I am reading through the The Study of History and Historical Method wiki pages, and specifically about finding primary sources, but I think I could still use a little guidance specific to my subject and circumstances.

In a nutshell, there was a part of my town in the 1980s that was an open-air drug market. It was pretty notorious, and I have heard a lot of lore about it throughout my life time, but it's mostly hearsay and stories from indirect witnesses and very few eyewitnesses. On the other hand, I have been able to find little bits of news via the internet, specifically one or two articles referencing the situation. I have also been made aware of a 60 Minutes episode about it, though I have no idea how to get access to it.

My first thought was to find old newspaper articles from the era, but I only have a vague idea of how to do that and I am also concerned that much of it went unreported. Growing up, I was very aware of a lot of events that took place that I never saw covered in the local news, so I know that even if I can find those sources, they may be a lot more lacking than what I hope for.

Outside of that, I am lucky enough to have met a local author who is a retired police officer that worked the area during his time, and who has written a novel inspired by the events. I think he may introduce me to some other former law enforcement members who may be able to tell me about it too. Then on top of that, there's another local author and historian who has written several books about the more antiquated history of our area that I have contacted.

I'm not really sure what else to do to pursue this and would really appreciate some tips and advice.

3 Answers 2022-10-20

is Charlotte Corday a royalist or republican?

I did some search about Charlotte Corday's political views.

On Britannica (https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charlotte-Corday), they said Charlotte Corday is "royalist by sentiment, yet susceptible also to the ideals of the Enlightenment".

On history.com, they also mentioned that she is "a Royalist sympathizer".

However, Wikipedia, mentions that "She stressed that she was a republican and had been so even before the Revolution, citing the values of ancient Rome as an ideal model. "

I know she is viewed as Girondins to some degree, but Girondins contains many royalists after Louis XVI got killed. What are exactly her political views? Is she someone like Marquis de La Fayette or Tocqueville who think republican is a good idea and ideal country but doesn't think French should abolish the monarchy just because of that, or like Jacques Pierre Brissot who believes the king should not be killed but the country should be turned into a republic?

Edit here: I think my title is a bit wrong. Someone who likes the republic but doesn't think it is a pragmatic solution might also call them "republican" in 19th century France. Many "republicans" support the revolution but don't support abolishing the monarchy. I want to know what she thinks about abolishing the monarchy on 1792 September 21st. Does she support it or not?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Maltese derives from Siculo-Arabic, the Arabic-variety spoken in Islamic-era Sicily, but what actually was Siculo-Arabic?

Modern Maltese is very heavily influenced by Latin and Romance-languages, but Wikipedia states this started after the rechristianisation of Malta was completed in the 1250's, and reading on the Emirate of Sicily it would seem the pre-conquest Romance-variety of the island had more or less died out by the time of the Norman conquest, leaving me to assume Siculo-Arabic lacked the strong Romance-influence that would come to define Maltese? But what about a Greek-influence? Wikipedia states the emirate's commonfolk would've been a mix of Siculo-Arabic-speaking muslims and Greek-speaking christians, and then ofc the Romance-speakers puttering on in the background, did this sizable Greek community leave any linguistic mark on Siculo-Arabic?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Were there any Mesopotamian philosophers? If not, why do you think so?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Did Sailors in the Age of Sail suffer from the ailments related to excessive sodium intake?

Since Salt was used as a preservative for meats and all sorts of perishables - is it fair to say that Sailors would suffer from high blood pressure and too much sodium? Were there any other ill effects from a diet at sea aside from Scurvy?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Greek gods are often referred to as being "the God of X" (War, Love, Revenge). Did the Greeks themselves actually catalogue their gods this specifically, or is this a simplification applied by historians?

4 Answers 2022-10-20

Where can I find Palestinian Arab Primary Sources Related to Jewish-Arab Relations from 1914-1932?

I'm working on an university research project regarding Jewish-Arab relations in Mandatory Palestine up to 1932. I have a plethora of British and Jewish primary sources to supplement my study. However, I'm struggling to find primary sources from Arab perspectives. I can only read and speak English, but I haven't been able to find a reader or collection of Palestinian Arab primary sources relevant to the topic of Jewish-Arab relations from 1914-1932.

I'm seeking two main Palestinian Arab perspectives: a "history from below" approach (letters, interviews, diaries from "average" Palestinian Arabs), and then sources from Palestinian Arab elites (memoirs, party platforms, political newspapers, etc.) While I have found an archive of Palestinian Arab newspapers, they are not translated into English. I do have Walid Khalidi's collection of Palestinian Arab photographs, as well as his reader, but the latter contains no Arab sources from the period of interest.

I've become a bit desperate and wonder if translations of Palestinian Arab primary sources from 1914-1932 even exist. I'm hoping you all would be able to help!

I'd appreciate any scholars who are able to point me in the right direction or even provide me with the link to a Palestinian Arab reader or collection of primary sources from 1914-1932. Are there any readers or collections out there? Are there any sites which have translated newspapers, diaries, letters, etc. ?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Why is Greek, being derived from Phoenician, not read and written from right to left?

All of Greeks "derivative languages" are read and written left to right. (Latin, Etruscan, Georgian, Cyrillic) Whereas Aramaic (also deriving from Phoencian) and it's derivatives are all right to left.

  • Was it an intentional break for cultural conflict reasons?

  • Are there any accounts of deliberation or debate over the intentional structure for written Greek?

  • Are there practical benefits to writing left to right that they might have considered?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

How did the witch hunting authors of the 15th century Malleus Maleficarum come to their conclusions?

I stumbled on an online copy of a 15th century witch hunting manual the Malleus Maleficarum. Here is a link if you are interested: https://www.sacred-texts.com/pag/mm/index.htm

Apparently, this document was used in official proceedings for around 300 years. It's full of all the usual stuff, sucubi, hail storms, witches making men's private parts appear to vanish, formalised trial procedures etc. I've been discussing this document with the reddit philosophers and it got me thinking how the authors of this document arrived at some of the detailed descriptions of witch activity. Did they just make it up or was there a methodological reasoning that led them to some of their conclusions? Was their thought process similar to modern conspiracy theorists?

For example, in their section entitled: Whether Witches may work some Prestidigatory Illusion so that the Male Organ appears to be entirely removed and separate from the Body. Here https://www.sacred-texts.com/pag/mm/mm01_09a.htm

How did they arrive at the conclusion that witches were removing men's penises? Did they completely make this up or was there a spate of missing penises in the early 1400s that had people concerned?

In this one: How they are Transported from Place to Place, https://www.sacred-texts.com/pag/mm/mm02a03a.htm , they mention witches flying on broomsticks an/or chairs. Their reasoning seems to be very loosely based on claims of non-witches being mysteriously transported from place to place then directly leads to: therefore broomsticks. Was there urban legends prior to this or did these guys make this up specifically for this document?

Did anyone from church heirarchy vet this document before it was released into circulation? It seems many, many people were tortured and killed based on some pretty sketchy reasoning.

[edit] Kind of answering my own question a bit here, someone posted this link in another thread, apparently there was a "penis panic" in 1400s Central Europe. https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/72227/6-penis-panics-around-world

1 Answers 2022-10-20

The Golden Age of Piracy: Supposedly, flying the red flag meant that the pirates were going to slaughter everyone on board. How commonly was this promise kept, and why would pirates signal their intentions in this way?

I mean, doesn't "We are going to kill all of you regardless" force a crew to fight to the last drop, making things all the harder?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Did/Do all religions integrate / believe in the concept of "Satan" / "The Devil" / "Lucifer"?

I couldn't find a lot about it on the internet (I was not sure about the right keywords).

To be clear, I'm asking if it is all or most religions, be ancient or modern, that are based on the concept of Good VS Evil. Furthermore, is "Satan" - or whatever you want to call him - as a personified Evil present in most/all of them? Thank you.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Why didn't Hitler postpone the Holocaust to focus resources on WWII?

The Holocaust ate up a lot of resources, time, and personnel that Germany could have spent directly on trying to win WWII.

Surely an advisor to Hitler said something to the tune of, "Hey, Adolf. This Holocaust is a money pit. I know we're obscenely racist, but how about we focus our resources on killing the enemies who are actually shooting at us in our giant multifront war? We'll get around to genocide after we win."

Why didn't the Nazis do this? Were they just so racist that they couldn't stomach the idea of delaying the Holocaust for the sake of war strategy? Or are there other reasons this didn't happen?

Since Hitler obviously turned down this idea, another advisor must've said something like, "How about we just conscript all the Jews and other undesirables and use them as cannon fodder, putting them in battles where they're highly likely to die? When the war's over, we can swing back around and finish off any who manage to survive. It'll kill two birds with one stone and we'll let the Allies spend a fortune killing them rather than wasting our own money."

Why didn't the Nazis take this path?

I don't understand why the Nazis didn't postpone the Holocaust to focus resources on the war and I would appreciate any light you can shed on this.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Queen Victoria reigned well after the USA gained independence. Yet 'Victorian' is still used in the USA to refer to houses from that period, why?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Spain?

The spanish once had a global empire. Can someone explain, how a nation that stole a continent worth of gold and silver managed to still be poor ?

2 Answers 2022-10-20

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | October 20, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

4 Answers 2022-10-20

In the US, why are there so many cities with names ending in -Ville or -Burg but almost none ending in English suffixes like -Ham?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

What evidence do we have for the food that medieval peasants ate?

I know of cookbooks such as the Liber de Coquina, but surely peasants would not have access to these…

1 Answers 2022-10-20

How were important POWs in late medieval to renaissance times treated, and how were they used by the side holding them captive?

I'm more specifically interested in how exactly they were used, I know ransoming rich and important prisoners was common, but for how much? What exactly would holding minor nobility get the captors vs someone more important like royalty or such?

How many important prisoners of war were ransomed compared to how many were used by the captors in other ways such as prisoner trades or political bargaining chips? Is there any specific examples of important POWs being used as political bargaining chips?

Was being killed in captivity, or simply dying due to poor conditions, common for political prisoners, or were they usually treated decently?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Why were the armies of antiquity so much bigger than the armies in the late middle ages sometimes armies early modern era?

And I'm not talking about Rome or Carthage or Persia here, I'm talking about small not very populated states like Epirus (in the Pyrrhic War) and Macedon (in the Macedonian Wars), who were able to field at least 25000 men, which was already larger than many medieval armies and nearly as large as the fully mobilized French army at that time.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

When were Hesiods epic poems written down for the first time?

Can anyone link me to some references about when Hesiods poems were first recorded and written down? Was it during his lifetime? and how were they written down? on parchment with a quill pen?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-10-20

What would the "Standard Fantasy Setting" during medieval times be, if there even was one?

So, it's pretty well know nowadays that the standard fantasy setting is often a medival-esqe setting, usually with at least elves and dwarves. We have Tolkien to thank for that.

However, because storytelling is about as old as humanity itself, I was wondering what the standard setting for a fantasy tale would be during the time period that, nowadays, we often associate with fantasy.

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Did fights or duels ever occur in Feast Halls, Mead Halls, Courts etc etc like in fiction and legends?

I was reading an article about knights and misconceptions about them and came across certain claims such as:

These modern expectations exist because they have precedent in medieval literature. The opening of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight—the decapitation of the Green Knight (he got better) by the noble Sir Gawain—takes place in King Arthur’s feast hall. In Thomas Malory’s fifteenth-century Arthurian tales (Le Morte d’Arthur), Arthur’s court is the setting for countless duels, brawls, and other acts of violence. In Beowulf, the titular hero’s fight with the villainous Grendel rages through Heorot—the imposing mead hall of King Hroðgar...

But the thing is, these knightly and heroic tales are clearly fiction. They are medievalist tropes used by medieval authors, but they are still medievalist tropes. Malory and the other later medieval authors gleefully imposed the ideas and ideologies of their own time on the earlier medieval periods they described. They used popular ideas of the early medieval to tell their stories. Actual events were an afterthought.

Is there any historical precedence for such battles? Are they entirely the invention of later authors?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

Today, in the Western context, there are often considered to have been eight numbered crusades to the Holy Land. Who decided on this numbering, and when was this numbering formalized/popularized? Furthermore, what distinguishes a numbered crusade from a minor "non-numbered" one?

1 Answers 2022-10-20

82 / 7255

Back to start