Polish Legions of the Duchy of Warsaw and the French Army?

The French Army during the Napoleonic Wars contained multiple units of Polish origin (Vistula Legion, Nord, Lancers). But later on the Duchy of Warsaw was created by Napoleon. What was the command relation between the new state and the units under French command? And what units did the Duchy hold command over themselves?

Also what was the deal with Poniatowski being a Prince and Marcheal at the same time?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Is there a Japanese account of the "Battle of Ramree Island" and ensuing crocodile massacre?

All accounts of this on wikipedia that I could find were from the perspective of the allies. Surely if such a terrible fate befell the Japanese there would be some mention of it in Japan, no?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

When the effects of modern colonialism (16thC onwards) are discussed, why is British colonialism the main focus?

When I see posts and discussions about the effects of colonialism during the colonisations of places such as Africa, the Americas, and Australia/New Zealand, I've noticed people only tend to talk about the effects of Britain's actions during this time, and never seem to bring up the actions of other European countries. Why is this? Is this because Britain's actions are the most commonly known? Or is it that, despite other countries getting as involved in the negative actions Britain did, Britain's actions are worse? Or maybe Britain was more "successful"?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

In "The Huns, Rome and the Birth of Europe" Hyun Jin Kim makes the case that the Huns were responsible for the fall of the Western Empire and the political organization of the early Middle Ages. How is his thesis viewed by others in the field?

Kim's thesis is that the Huns have been given short shrift in the scholarship of Late Antiquity. He makes a convincing argument that the Hunnic state was far more organized and powerful than it has traditionally been given credit for.

However, as the book progresses Kim make increasingly incredible claims. He makes the case that every barbarian of consequence was a Hun, including Odoacer, Theodoric, Orestes, and Valamer, among others. He also directly ties the incipient fuedalism of the Frankish state to Hunnic and more generally Inner Asian steppe political organization and even says that the Medieval focus on meat consumption at feasts was a result of steppe influence. And that's not to mention art and diadems and all sorts of other things.

How is Kim's scholarship viewed by the academy? I've found a couple reviews that seem to have the same issues I did:

https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2014/2014.03.40/

https://muse.jhu.edu/article/563962

Is this the general consensus?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

What was the perspective of German History and Historiography by British Historians during Imperial Germany and how did it change from WWI and after?

The German Empire coincided with the Gothic Revival and Medieval Romanticism in art and architecture. There was a German House on the British throne. The Anglo-Saxons; germanic tribes, returned to popularity.

Kaiser Wilhelm spent a lot of money finishing several massive medieval cathedrals and rebuilding castles, etc.

So did British; particularly English historians study German history with a favorable eye as sister 'Teutonic Nations'?

And during WWI and after, did english historians completely disown any connection with Germany and see the 'sister nation' more like '3rd cousins twice removed' so-to-speak?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Did knight cavalry charges really have such devastating impacts as games and movies lead us to believe?

On one hand, I've learned that horses were bred, trained and disciplined for years just to charge properly and obey the rider.

On the other hand, I find it hard to believe that horses would run straight into a formation of infantry or other cavalry armed with Spears, pollarms and other sharp and unpleasant things with anything but the horse's best interests at heart

I'd imagine that the horses would slow down significantly before impact or even change direction completely in face of a tight formation of infantry

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Is the origin of cop (as in police officer) actually the Committee of Public Safety during the Reign of Terror from France? Is this why some times officers don't like being called Cops?

As a kid in school I immediatly thought this many years ago and it stuck with me. That's one of the reasons why it was always easy for me to remember the Commitee of Public Safety on exams.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Why was early Hollywood obsessed with the French Foreign Legion?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Especially before the industrial revolution, parents had sex while their children were (presumably) sleeping in the same room. When and by whom, then the claim that children witnessing sex or pornography traumatising children has come from?

I realise that the title contains several assumptions that may very well be incorrect, in which case please do correct me. I also am very ill informed in the field of child development, and not making a claim that children witnessing (not experiencing) a sexual act in an early age may or may not be traumatising.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

What did young people listen to before Elvis and Beatles was a thing?

What was “cool” before Elvis was a thing? Who did women scream at from excitement and men wanted to be like? Were there musical superstars before Elvis or superstar groups before the Beatles?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Why isn't the Russian language common in Alaska?

The language of the past colonizers are usually spoken in their former colonies. Like French is still spoken in parts of Canada and how Spanish is still spoken in parts of the US that were previously parts of the Spanish Empire or Mexico. But I know that French isn't spoken in Louisiana because of active discouragement of it in the 20th century. But what is the reason behind Russian not being spoken as much in Alaska? Is it similar to that of Lousiana French?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Why exatcly is the term 'feudalism' controversial among medievalists?

I know what Feudalism means. I know that it is controversial amongst historians of that era. But it hasn't been explained to me satisfactorially why is is controversial.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | February 21, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2021-02-21

Did people living in the Sengoku period ever get confused by the constant name-changing of samurai?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Requesting help in identifying uniforms of a set of tin/lead soldiers

My girlfriend is currently in possession of some old sets of tin and lead soldiers and we are trying to identify the regiments and eras of the uniforms of these soldiers.

Any general pointers would be immensely useful in helping us identifying these old toy soldiers.

https://imgur.com/a/hwvYWwU

Thank you very much for your help!

2 Answers 2021-02-21

What was the old world like in the year 176 AD?

I'm trying to make a fictional world with a situation like that of 176 AD Asia and I was just hoping smoke could help me understand this specific Year and what Asia was like for this specific Year.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

In the year 176 AD the Roman Empire, Lisha Empire, Parthian empire and Han dynasty were the four major powers of the old world. They are known to stay in contact with each other and we're aware of each others existence. How so?

So my question is two fold. These four major powers were aware of each others existence via the silk road and kept in touch with each other.

But how did they do so and how was diplomacy conducted between the four?

Should have been the Kushan empire. Fucking auto-correct.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

It’s 10AD in Ancient Rome. My wife has just dropped dead suspiciously and all the locals think that I did it, they want justice. What kind of judicial process (if any) will there be and what rights of defence do I have?

2 Answers 2021-02-21

I've heard somewhere that Aristotle's reputation with medieval scholars was so high that nobody questioned him writing that files have 4 legs instead of 6 despite how easy it would be to verify. Is this anecdote true?

And if it's true, was the man exceptionally poor of sight, or he just got that "fact" from some earlier scholar?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

How did unions and labor organizing work in the USSR and Eastern Germany? Given that they were "worker's paradises," were workers allowed to strike and boycott for change?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

In Mad Men the ad-men are always depicted with a decanter of whiskey in their offices and taking drinks in the afternoon. When did alcohol become a “thing” in the workplace and when did it stop becoming such a thing?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

How did Communist Poland commemorate the Warsaw Uprising, in light of the fact that the Soviet Red Army refused to come to the aid of the Polish Home Army in 1944? Did official or unsanctioned public commemorations occur?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Why did the soldiers/ or commanders on both sides of the war for Independence seem to not care about protection from bullets?

So, first off I want to say I'm not American or British so forgive my ignorance if this is obvious, but I had just finished watching a very good movie called "The Patriot." In the movie, both sides, Americans and English, line up in a long horizontal lines where they would face, and march towards each other, causing many soldiers from both sides to be completely slaughtered by the other sides bullets.

I'm mainly curious as to why this was the case? To me, this doesn't seem very strategic at all, lots of unnecessary death occurred, and they didn't seem to even want to protect themselves it seemed. Surely even wooden shields of sorts, at a certain distance, would be more favorable to have than just literally walking towards your own death? So, why did they do it that way? Or i guess, why did the soldiers' commanders and generals use this tactic?

I know the patriot is just a movie and like every movie has exaggerations but in other forms of media I've seen this too and was just curious if anyone could explain this? Also, I'm writing this on mobile so I apologize for any errors or formatting issues it might cause.

1 Answers 2021-02-21

How did armies convince men to stand in the front ranks (during late 18th and early 19th cen) during musket volleys? How could anyone just stand there? Why not lie down?

1 Answers 2021-02-21

Who was, if anyone, the quintessential "worst person ever" before Hitler?

Hitler is often used in comparison or in allusion to the worst human being ever. For example "They're worse than Hitler!" Or the line from The Office "if I was in a room with Hitler and Toby and had a gun with 2 bullets, I'd shoot Toby twice."

Was there any historical figure before Hitler that was used in this regard in normal conversation? English speaking or not.

2 Answers 2021-02-21

838 / 7255

Back to start