Are the later games of Assassins Creed (Origins, Odyssey, Valhalla) historically accurate?

Well its a game so it wont be 100% accurate. But im asking about the enviroments, the story, the time period, the weapons, buildings, stuff like that. Can i learn anything from it?

2 Answers 2021-01-30

The Canary Islands are just 62 miles off the coast of Morocco, so why and how had they remained isolated and unconverted to Islam when the Castilian conquest of the islands began in the early fifteenth century?

My understanding is that it would be about a day's voyage to get there from the coast of Morocco with the nautical technology existing at the start of the fifteenth century.

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Are most Ancient Greek myths “set” in Mycenaean Greece?

I have the general impression that it is, given how many myths are referenced in the Odyssey, Iliad,etc as having already happened. However, I haven’t read enough myths to draw a confident conclusion and cannot find conformation

1 Answers 2021-01-30

I’m a skilled laborer in the Middle Ages working at my shop, lunchtime rolls around, how am I typically getting food?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Why did Cyrus the Great let the Jews simply walk back home? Why were the attitudes of the Achaemenids towards slavery so different from the Babylonians?

I remember from my christian upbringing (correct me if I'm wrong) that at some point in their history, the Jews were conquered by the Babylonians and deported as slaves: the so called babylonian exile. Then, when the babylonians were conquered by the Achaemenid empire, Cyrus the Great allowed the Jews to go back home.

Why were the attitudes of the Achaemenids towards slavery so different from the Babylonians? Why did Cyrus just let them go? What were his motives to do so?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Is the "baby yeeting" of Ancient Sparta historically accurate? If not, where did this idea originate?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

(WW1 Help) I found a Swiss/German ancestor of mine who died in Flanders in 1918. I need help with specific info and places to look.

In researching my family history recently, I found this man who might be a relation of mine, from my father's side of the family.

This is the link to him on Findmygrave: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/147748570/karl-vaterlaus

I've struggled to find anymore information on his circumstances, at the time of his death. My German isn't that great and my living relatives aren't too familiar this far back in my family history.

If you can help me with the following questions, especially if you speak German and are well learned in WW1 history. I'd greatly appreciate it.

  1. How common was it for Swiss nationals to end up serving in the German Imperial Army thru 1914 - 1918? (I know he moved as a kid, but I'm not sure if he was a German citizen or not)

  2. I'm struggling to find information on his regiment, 3rd Bayern inf.regiment, Company commander of 1st Komp (?) Who are they? And what did they do during the 1st world war?

  3. Is it possible to find his medals? (Iron cross 1st and 2nd class, along with Bayern military service cross 1st class) Could they help me connect with his other living relations, therefore my living relatives?

  4. Are there any German records that can help with this? Such as a national or historical archives, that can help me find more information on him and his family?

Thank you for reading, anything you can share could be helpful. Danke Schön!

2 Answers 2021-01-30

Why did the Austrian Habsburg’s allow Marie Louise to marry Napoleon, who had not only been excommunicated but also was a divorcee?

It just seems weird to me that the devoutly Catholic Austrians were okay with her marrying someone like that. Not to mention the fact that Napoleon had invaded Vienna twice at that point. Was there a lot of opposition within Austria over this decision? Was there a lot of opposition within the Habsburg family? How about within the church itself?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

How can I better help younger people understand history?

I honestly apologize if this isn't the purpose of this sub, but I thought who better to go to about history than historians.

So, a family member of mine is very into history, but he's still relatively young (12 to be precise). I've also been into history myself and he always looks to me to discuss history.

I want to make sure that I am teaching him right, and to encourage his curiosity. However, I know how complicated and frankly confusing history often is. What I want to know is how I could properly teach him the nuances of history while also encouraging him to think about it himself. I would hate to misinform him or confuse him too much that he will give up on this completely.

2 Answers 2021-01-30

Does anyone know the percentage of men who went to the theatre in the 1660s?

I'm currently doing a monologue from the play Nell Gwynn and it would be interesting to know if the number of male audience members went up due to the arrival of women on stage.

Is there any evidence for the actual number of theatre goers in Restoration England?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Korea changed their official name to Taehan Cheguk, or "Korean Empire", and their rulers title from King to Emperor in 1897. How did China and Japan react to this?

How did this impact the regional politics, and how did people react? Why would Korea declare themselves an "Empire" for that matter?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Were there any non-Afrikaner apartheid supporters in South Africa before 1994?

In South Africa before 1994 (i.e., during apartheid), were there any non-Afrikaners who were so racist as to supporter apartheid? I’m wondering about individuals of British Isles descent, or other white ethnic groups: Portuguese ancestry, maybe, or Greek, etc....

1 Answers 2021-01-30

What did Medieval peasants eat, prior to the introduction of potatoes, in order to fulfil the daily caloric intake for an adult?

I've read that wheat, a high calorie food, was mainly for the higher classes. Potatoes are high in calories but were only introduced in the 15th century.

I've gathered they mainly ate vegetables and not much meat.

However, to get 2,500 calories (daily caloric requirement for a male) you would need to eat something like 4 whole heads of cabbages and 3kg of carrots. That's an incredible amount of food which I'm pretty sure they wouldn't have access to every day.

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Manichaeism is said to have been a syncretism of Zoroastrianism, Buddhism and Gnostic Christianity. How much did Mani know about Buddhism, and how was its philosophy amalgamated with the other two?

Mani was supposedly raised in an obscure Jewish-Christian sect in Persian Babylon, which he later distanced himself from to found a new religious movement which blended Gnostic Christianity with Zoroastrianism and, ostensibly, Buddhism.

Given that he spent much of his life in Persia and Mesopotamia, and was patronised by Shapur, it makes sense that Mani would have been intimately familiar with Zoroastrianism. Gnostic Christianity, which was also dualistic, would have been easily paired with Zoroastrian philosophy, but Buddhism is a rather different tradition entirely, and one which, while present in the Sassanid Empire, would likely have been far more distant and alien to Mani than Christianity or Zoroastrianism.

Nonetheless, Mani seems to have considered Buddha, along with Zarathustra and Jesus, part of a succession of prophets that each revealed part of the truth. Do we know how how Mani learned about Buddhism, and the extent to which he was familiar with it? Do we know enough about the teachings and worldview of Manichaeism to pinpoint ideas and practices in the Manichaean religion that were Buddhist influences? Indeed, other than the obvious inclusion of Zarathustra in its line of prophets, what were the Zoroastrian influences?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

What's this sub's opinion on "Vietnam" by Max Hastings?

Max Hastings seems to be a very polarising author in his field and I'm curious to hear what this sub thinks of his book on Vietnam. Goodreads seems to be fairly mixed and so does Reddit. Historically and factually, is this book up to scratch and worth a read?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

What was the Satanic Panic of the 80s and Early 90s? What kind of cultural and political impact did it have on the United States?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

How did the Western Christians (pope and kings) react to the islamic victory at the Siege of Jerusalem in the seventh century?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

I’m a miner in Roman Britain in the West Midlands 50 CE, and magically transported 1800 years into a mine in Victorian Britain. How different is my experience?

The Romans placed an emphasis on mining in the Black Country almost 2,000 years before the revolution, and you can read about poor working conditions in both eras. Other than the obvious language barrier, does my life really change that much?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Why did France or Britain never mention the negotiations with Stalin prior to WW2?

I am a new to the sub, so forgive my ignorance on how to place questions.

My WW2 history knowledge come to me from my parents, who lived through the war in the Netherlands, a few popular books, numerous TV shows & movies and lots of stories from people that was interviewed for documentaries. I am gen-x and WW2 has been told to us at school, on TV and I have visited lots of memorials and museums in Europe. I thought I had good grasp on the aspects that happened prior to the war until I was made aware that there were negotiations between Russia, Britain and France before the war. (I will paste the text into comments)

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/3223834/Stalin-planned-to-send-a-million-troops-to-stop-Hitler-if-Britain-and-France-agreed-pact.html

At first, I was wondering if it is true. If it is not true, okay. Else more questions arise. Why would France and Britain keep this secret, Chamberlain was very vocal in appeasement with Hitler the year before? Did Chamberlain and Churchill discuss any of this, they were both Tories? Did Churchill or Chamberlain mention it in their diaries? Is the documents in itself correct or would a deal simply be "shutting the barn door after the horse has bolted"? Could they not commit to a deal, even if possible because making a deal with Stalin is a declaration of war breaking with appeasement? Was Stalin already maneuvering against the West in a divide and concur sort of way, after all Britain made clear they will declare war if Hitler invade Poland? Did Chamberlain know of the Molotov-Ribbentrop negotiations? Was negotiations between all nations happening all time anyway, and is this a moot point? It strikes me that the "Western Betrayal" is still something that affects our current world and deciphering how it all started seems to get more complex as I get older.

My question: Why are these negotiations not part of our historical narrative?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Was Portugal considered to be ungovernable by the Romans?

Since moving to Portugal a couple of years ago, I have come across a quote more than once that some Portuguese use half ironically, half proudly:

“Há, na parte mais ocidental da Ibéria, um povo muito estranho: não se governa nem se deixa governar!”

“There is, in the westernmost part of Iberia, a very odd people: they refuse to govern themselves and they refuse to be governed!”

The quote is sometimes attributed to “a Roman general” from the 3rd century B.C., sometimes to Julius Caesar. Google has not been particularly helpful in finding the source or the original Latin quote, or even a translation into English (substituting Iberia with Hispania did not improve it).

Is it known if the Romans had any specific thoughts on the people of West-Hispania?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2021-01-30

How sharp was an early medieval sword?

I have read many times that the early medieval spatha was made of poor quality iron that couldn’t keep an edge, that it was more for bludgeoning than for cutting. Is that really true? It has a whiff of the “stupid Dark Ages” about it, which makes me wonder if it’s a pop-history myth rather than the opinion of current scholarship.

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Hearing loss and tinnitus during World War II?

I’ve heard about friends who have had their hearing impaired or even got tinnitus. And they got that from firing a rifle or being to close to one, without wearing any protection. From one day to another, their hearing had been impaired.

So that got me thinking. Maybe I haven’t researched enough, but it feels like you haven’t heard about all World War II veterans suffering from tinnitus, lost their hearing and so on. But I guess that they did and do?

One thing I know for sure, is that the regular private didn’t have any protection (or did they?). I’ve seen photos of artillerymen covering their ears. I guess that pilots had some sort of protection and maybe also tank crews. But there are still millions of soldiers who most likely never had any protection or chance to cover their ears.

How come that this isn’t talked about more? Or at least I haven’t heard about it. Is it just a common fact that firing a weapon without protection will worsen your hearing? Or were the weapons back then less powerful? The veterans who didn’t suffer from PTSD, panic attacks, and so forth, are rarely talking about how they’ve lived with tinnitus since the war, or how they cant hear anything. (And once again, I may be wrong, that is why I’am asking).

To summarize, how can it be that one can severly damage your hearing by firing a gun or a rifle a few times without protection. Whilst not hearing too much about damaged hearing from World War II veterans (also other wars, of course), when they obviously fired their own rifles, were close to others who fired their rifles, artillery barrages, airplanes, tanks, most likely on a daily basis. So, how many veterans have lost or damaged their hearing?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Aug 2, 1914: "A train full of German soldiers arrived at the station at Luxembourg during the night and sized the station." What were the logistics for this? Was it a regular train? Or did the Germans put their own train on the tracks?

I am quoting a wire service news report from Luxembourg on Aug 2, 1914. "A train full of German soldiers arrived that the station at Luxembourg during the night. The troops seized the station and the bridges on the Treves and Trois Vierges line."

The details are left out. Was this a regular train that they got on? Or did the Germans put their own train on those tracks? I am curious what the details were about how this was orchestrated.

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Egyptian Poop Bricks?

Caught your attention didn't I? So I'm watching this course on "The Great Courses" and I'm following along with what the teacher is saying by googling the stuff to understand the context better. He mentions an ancient literature called: "The Satire of Trades." So naturally I read it...

Segment #10 reads: " I shall also describe to you the like of the mason-bricklayer. His kidneys are painful [his work pains him]. When he must be outside in the wind, he lays bricks without a loin cloth. His belt is a cord for his back, a string for his buttocks. His strength has vanished through fatigue and stiffness, kneading all his excrement. He eats bread with his fingers, although he washes himself but once a day."

Can someone elaborate on this? I can't find anything on le google. Is there a good chance most bricks found in ancient Egypt can have traces of human feces?

https://www.ancient.eu/article/1074/the-satire-of-the-trades/

1 Answers 2021-01-30

The Mongols while invading Song Dynasty China, destroyed what some consider to be the first signs of industrialisation. What was the state of industrialisation in the late Song Dynasty China? How much did they utilise steam power and mining? How was the quality of life in their factories?

2 Answers 2021-01-30

877 / 7255

Back to start