What were the reasons for feudal domains to support or oppose the Meiji Restoration?

The victory of the pro-imperial Satchou alliance against the Tokugawa bakufu ultimately resulted in the Meiji Restoration of 1868, which set Japan on the path to rapid modernization. This involved the creation of a strong central government centered around the figure of the Emperor and the enforcement of universal conscription, which meant the abolition of feudal domains and ultimately of the samurai as a class (even though many in the new ruling class were former Satsuma or Choushuu samurai).

What were the reasons for some feudal domains to support (Satsuma, Choushuu, Tosa, Hiroshima, etc) and others to oppose (Aizu, Takamatsu, Sendai, Yonezawa, etc) the Meiji Restoration? Did the 1877 Seinan War show that many of the samurai who fiercely supported the Restoration didn't expect it to turn out the way it actually did? Did former clan rivalries survive the end of Japanese feudalism?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Did the 1941 Soviet evacuation east shift the center of gravity of Russia permanently? Or did people and materiel return west after the war?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

How do we know about the Black Death and it’s timeline?

I’m just wondering how we know all the info we do about a pandemic from 700 years ago. Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Do we have any evidence the Titans of Greek mythology and their predecessors (ouranos, Gaia) were an earlier pre Greek pantheon?

Is there aything pointing towards their worship by the mycenean Greeks or the Minoans before them? It would make logical sense as a reason the later Greeks had the gods defeat them and seal them in Tartarus.

2 Answers 2021-01-30

[NSFW] How in the world did Genghis Khan Get So Many Women Pregnant?!

I mean he didn’t become khan until he was like 50. And he was only Khan for 21 years; meaning he could only have a harem for about two decades. And in the later bits he’d be getting elderly meaning likely less women each day right.

And it’s not like he could spend ALL of his day fucking 24/7 right? Like he had battles to command and locations to ride to.

So how in the world can he fuck SO MANY WOMEN that 1% of the world is related to him

1 Answers 2021-01-30

Were there any verified American POWs who were released by Vietnam after 1973?

There’s a trope among action movies and TV shows from the 1980s of American forces fighting to rescue and free Americans still held in captivity in Vietnam after the signing of the Paris Peace Accords of 1973 (Rambo 2, Missing in Action, etc). I’m curious if there have ever been verified cases of such military actions taking place and actually freeing prisoners still being held by the Vietnamese. I’m aware of organizations such as POW/MIA, for whom this idea is the crux of their existence, and that such missions would likely be classified but are there any documented US soldiers who had been held captive and were returned to the states years or decades after the end of the Vietnam War?

1 Answers 2021-01-30

How did Finland win the war against the Soviet Union?

I only about Simo Hayha who killed two soviet divisions.

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Was Victor Fankl a nazi collaborator?

I posted a quote by Victor Frankl and on r/GetMotivated and someone replied with:

Source

Viktor Frankl was a fascist and a nazi collaborator. He was a member of the Fatherland Front from 1934, the far-right austrofascist party.

In 1942 he volunteered, with no medical training, to help the Nazis conduct lobotomies, trepanations, and medical experiments on Jews, that included various ways of inserting amphetamines into the brain.

Once he himself was interned in a low-security Ghetto for upper-class Jews, he secured privileges for himself by helping the SS manage the ghetto’s “psychohygiene” so that it could be presented as a “model community” to mask the conditions in the concentration camps.

His own autobiography recounts numerous instances of collusion with the nazis in exchange for special treatment.

His “Gutachten” Gestapo file described him as “politically perfect.”

After the war, he lied about being an “Auschwitz survivor” and remained a fascist. He gave a speech in 1978 at the Institute for Adult Jewish Studies, where he was booed off stage and repeatedly called a “nazi pig.”

His logotherapy has been criticized for being authoritarian.

It bears repeating: He voluntarily performed unqualified lobotomies on Jewish resistors to ingratiate himself with the Nazis.

And

Oh yeah, and if you want sources for this, go to his wikipedia entry’s “Talk” page or look in its revision history for the revisions in April 2020, where Frankl’s grandson deleted about 2/3rds of the wikipedia article, replacing several lengthy sections of controversy, criticism and biographical details (including over 70 references) with like two sentences.

I have found no supporting evidence of these claims or this being remotely mentioned anywhere else.

2 Answers 2021-01-29

Logistics of the British Empire

When the British Empire was at its height how did it possibly keep up with the logistics of maintaining itself? If you need gunpowder in New Delhi and 2 frigates in Jamaica and more troops in Hong Kong and some sabres in Australia, how did they hold onto all those disparate places for so long especially when the high end supplies needed could not be produced locally but had to travel from Britain while the threat levels from Britain’s rivals in Europe as well as the local populations was constantly fluid, yet the decision making of what to do about it, took place in London and took weeks or months to communicate back and forth?

2 Answers 2021-01-29

What is the modern understanding of Migration Period?

I've seen a well-known Croatian historian say that, for the last 30 years, science has moved from a population-based view of the Slavic migration towards the view that it was actually identities and languages that migrated while the population was relatively static.

He added that it was difficult to explain and that simplification tended to fail.

Can someone explain modern views on this issue?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Do historians accept Grady McWhiney's claim that the South was heavily influenced by Celtic culture, and that the US Civil War was partly born out of hostility between a Celtic South and an English North? This seems wrong to me given how Irish and Scottish immigrants impacted the northeast US

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Three of the four Presidents on Mt Rushmore were Surveyors. Land surveyor to President seems a strange career progression. Why did this happen?

2 Answers 2021-01-29

So a question. I know back before pens and pencils were invented, people used quills. But what happens when they have to write on the go? Like with a notepad or having to write a checklist for work? Did they have to carry a pot of ink with them?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Two questions about Ulster Scots in America.

A) I have seen a post about Ulster Scots fighting for the confederacy during the Civil War. I tried to do my own research and apparently Ulster Scots were overrepresented on both sides. Can anyone tell me a little bit more about Ulster Scots in the civil war. I do know the general consensus was that where you were indicated who you fought for. How did Ulster Scots feel knowing they would fight those from their homeland?

B) I have also seen a recent post about the confederacy (or Dixie in general) opposing American independence. To what extent is this true? Could this be due the large immigration population from Ulster Scots who typically have a staunch unionist outlook?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Why isn't Lady Jane Grey considered the first Queen of England?

I know she was a contested Queen and only held the crown for 9 days , but why do we not remember her as Queen Jane?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Before Darwin's Theory of Evolution, was there thought to be any connection between great apes and human beings? Or were the similarities merely thought of as a coincidence?

Another thought: Considering much of the development of evolution was done in Europe, where there is a lack of great apes, did natives near them have any differing thoughts on a connection or lack thereof between the two species?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Need some help

I am currently trying to to find my great great grandfathers military records, I’m just wondering where I could access British military records from the 19th century. Any help is appreciated.

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Looking for accessible source Letter from pope clement iv to mongols

I am looking for the letter pope clement iv sent to the Mongols (1267) I have been able to find the translation of it on Wikipedia but I would like a accessible source on it as the letter on Wikipedia is from rene grousets history of the crusades 3 but I cannot find an English version of the book nor can I find French pdf version of the book. Can someone guide me because my Googlefu is not strong enough.

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Were famines during colonial India "engineered"? How many died during them?

This tweet suggests the Raj engineered famines, and killed a total of 80 million Indians as a result. Is it true famines were engineered, and how many died because of famine?

2 Answers 2021-01-29

I heard that one of the reasons why Great Britain became the birthplace of industrial evolution is due to the mass migration to America, which caused a worker shortage, is there any truth to it?

So basically the argument goes that since many British people migrated to the America in the 18th century, the country experienced a worker shortage. This resulted in a significant increase in labor cost. Since the labor cost rose, people were forced to adopt new experimental manufacturing techniques, to maximize the efficiency of workers and reduce their number to cut the costs.

On the other hand, places like China did not experience any mass migration, and so the cost of labor was low. No point in experimenting with some new technologies when a bunch of peasants can do the work for pennies. And as such Great Britain was the first to experience industrialization.

Is there any credence to this argument? Did Great Britain suffer from a worker shortage in the 18th century, and if so, did it have any influence in starting the industrial revolution?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

How effective was the selection process for the Doge of Venice?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Ableness and Disability: How were minor physical impairments regarded in Nazi Germany/Nazi ideology? It's very interesting that Felix Wankel was too near-sighted to get a driver's license, yet was Obersturmbannführer in the SS and commandant of the Hitler Youth.

About Wankel, specifically, is the degree of his friendship with Hitler known? Also, what were the responsibilities of an Obersturmbannführer? It literally translates to "senior assault unit leader," which I doubt Wankel literally was.

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Did any Levantine influences on Jewish cuisine survive in the European diaspora?

Are/were there any Ashkenazi dishes that had Mediterranean or West Asian influences?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Why isn't the "cessation of miracles at the time of Christ's death" documented in the Talmud discussed more in Christian-Jewish dialogues throughout history?

I'm not interested in whether the events in these references actually occurred. I'm dumbfounded as to why these references weren't used in any of the ancient Christian-Jewish dialogues/debates that I can find. Even now, I can't find many people referencing them, and I don't know why.

There were three regularly-occurring miracles documented in the Talmud (Yoma 39b.5-6) that stopped 40 years prior to the destruction of the second temple (70 AD), which would have been right when Jesus died.

What I can't understand is why these references would have been passed up by so many historians throughout history. It seems like a "smoking gun" that would have been used repeatedly. I'm missing something here, and since this isn't my area of expertise, I would love to know from an actual historian why these seem to have been ignored.

Modern references:

I've found one modern scholar who discusses them (the above bullet points are taken from his article), but he doesn't give an explanation as to why they weren't discussed previously. He was kind enough to respond to an email inquiring about this; his article was from 15 years ago, and he doesn't recall enough about the subject to answer. Also, no paper that cites this work discusses these references.

https://www.etsjets.org/files/JETS-PDFs/48/48-2/48-2-pp301-316_JETS.pdf

Other old sources that don't mention this at all (I relied on the search functions provided):

Justin Martyr in his Dialog with Typho discusses scapegoats, but doesn't reference this passage (thought I don't know that he references the Talmud at all in this) https://d2y1pz2y630308.cloudfront.net/15471/documents/2016/10/St.%20Justin%20Martyr-Dialogue%20with%20Trypho.pdf

Judaism on tiral: Jewish-Christian disputations in the Middle Ages: https://archive.org/details/judaismontrialje00macc/page/209/mode/2up

The Dialogues of Athanasius and Zacchaeus and of Timothy and Aquila: https://archive.org/details/dialoguesofathan00cony/page/n37/mode/2up?q=temple

Jewish-Christian Dialogues on Scripture in Late Antiquity:https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/jewishchristian-dialogues-on-scripture-in-late-antiquity/C66901ABCD5700A096877599CD04DD13/listing

1 Answers 2021-01-29

Essential books for historians

I got a History degree from a community college, and unfortunately the syllabus was awful for most subjects. Issues were not explored deeply - or sometimes the material didn’t even touch the surface. I’d like to become a better historian. Which books do you recommend me to read? Which books are essential to historians?

1 Answers 2021-01-29

878 / 7255

Back to start