How did medieval knights/men at arms train/condition themselves?

Besides training with weapons and horses what kind of exercises did they utilize? It seems logical to me that there would be some kind of calisthenics and perhaps even rudimentary weightlifting to keep match fit for war and tourney.

1 Answers 2022-10-14

To what extent are American 'manifest destiny' and Nazi post WW2 expansion plans similar?

So I was looking around a few old threads and came across this comment by u/depanneur . This leads onto my question, was the US expansion westward similar to the Nazis plans for eastern Europe had they won WW2?

The main things I'm curious about are:

  1. How similar were their genocide of the native population?

  2. Was Americas expansion driven by a desire to completely destroy the Native Americans like the Nazis goal to eradicate slavic people?

  3. Did the Nazis look towards the US for inspiration for their East Europe plan?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

How did central Bohemia manage to retain its Slavic culture and language when surrounded by Germans so tightly on three sides for centuries until 1945?

Mountains? A tolerant Habsburg regime? More mountains?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

Was American weaponry so drastically inferior to Germans during WW2 as this Atlantic article suggests?

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1989/08/the-real-war-1939-1945/306374/

They (American soldiers) knew that despite the advertising and publicity, where it counted their arms and equipment were worse than the Germans'. They knew that their automatic rifles (First World War vintage) were slower and clumsier, and they knew that the Germans had a much better light machine gun. They knew, despite official assertions to the contrary, that the Germans had real smokeless powder for their small arms and that they did not. They knew that their own tanks, both American and British, were ridiculously underarmed and underarmored, so that they would inevitably be destroyed in an open encounter with an equal number of German panzers. They knew that the anti-tank mines supplied to them became unstable in subfreezing weather, and that truckloads of them blew up in the winter of 1944-1945. And they knew that the single greatest weapon of the war, the atomic bomb excepted, was the German 88-mm flat-trajectory gun, which brought down thousands of bombers and tens of thousands of soldiers. The Allies had nothing as good, despite the fact that one of them had designated itself the world's greatest industrial power. The troops' disillusion and their ironic response, in song and satire and sullen contempt, came from knowing that the home front then could (and very likely historiography later would) be aware of none of these things.

3 Answers 2022-10-14

How did horses become a womanly interest?

In pre-modern times, women either weren’t allowed to ride horses or they had to ride side-saddle. Horses were usually for men

How did it come to be that horses are now seen as a womanly interest, to the point that some action movies need to put beards on women for scenes where characters are on horseback?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

Why did South Vietnam lose to North Vietnam despite having better and more equipment?

One thing that puzzled me when I was reading about the Vietnamese war was the fact that during the invasion of South Vietnam, North Vietnamese army had far less mechanized units and was far less high-tech compared to South Vietnam yet the South Vietnamese army seemed to almost completely collapsed in the face of the North Vietnamese army. Why did this happen?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

Is it true that in the medieval Europe some women married in there mid teens?

When I first started researching for this project I would use Google and click on the first result not thinking if it was wrong or right,simply because I didn't know it could be wrong.Two years later and I definitely not making that mistake again,but I was think of one fact that I'm always hearing people say ,the thing with teen/kids getting married. I would always hear people say "if you where born back in the day (or some time) you would have been already married with two kids.."or a version of that. In the past when I looked it up I on Google it said "Women during the dark ages usually married in their teens."

Since I'm suspicious of Google and can't buy books at this time or know few books to buy that give the right facts.I have no idea if the fact is true.Is it true that in the medieval Europe some women married in there mid teens, specifically in 8th century Europe .I absurdity need to know because if it's false I'm very screwed but it is better that I know ,so I don't making the biggest mistake of my life.

(I did already check to see if anyone else asked this question on this subreddit but the answer weren't really clear)

1 Answers 2022-10-14

When did the trial by combat go out of fashion?

When did the trial by combat go out of fashion?

Did it ever exist? All the way from stone age to today?

Which parts of the world stopped it first and which was the last?

Thank you.

2 Answers 2022-10-14

Were there any Asian explorers that visited Europe "Marco Polo style"? If yes, how was the voyage?

Not sure if this is a weird question but i could only find articles about Marco polo when trying to search for "Asian explorer Europe".

1 Answers 2022-10-14

Are Danish/Scandinavian folk costumes, dances and music historically accurate?

Hi r/AskHistorians! In Denmark, many old people enjoy dancing traditional folk dance to traditional music, such as seen here. I can't say if it is the same in all other Scandinavian countries, but I do know that Norwegians wear likewise folk costumes during celebrations and the like, as do the Faroese.

I'm curious as to if such folk costumes worn in Scandinavia (and specifically curious about those worn in Denmark) are true to what would've been worn historically in the past by the Danes and other Scandinavians, as well as if that's also the case for the music usually played to the dances where such costumes are usually worn -- if so, was it usually worn by upper class or lower class, and how come there is such a large regional difference in the different national folk costumes?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

How much is truly known about Socrates? Is Plato a reliable source?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

What's a good replacement for the book 'Sapiens'?

My friend pitched me this book. He told the book talks about the origin of religion, language, currency, agriculture and human society and evolution in general. I loved his description but I wanted to know whether the book was factual or not. I came across many threads here and in ask anthropology and most of them claimed that the research wasn't that good.

I want a book that is accurate and talks about the origin of language, religion, currency, agriculture, government- basically origin of the things that are the pillars that hold today's society. I don't mind reading text books and I don't mind of ALL these ideas aren't in the same book - I'll gladly read multiple books. I never knew that the origins of such things would interest me so much. The moment my friend pitched the book, I instantly wanted to read it but I want something that is accurate and isn't too much biased. From what I've searched on my own - the dawn of everything looks like a book that has much more meticulous research behind it. So please - suggest me some books

6 Answers 2022-10-14

What is the oldest writing or literature a westerner (here, someone from areas that used Latin as a lingua franca) would have access to around 1400?

I made a comment recently (https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/y33iff/the_polishlithuanianswedish_union_the_most/is8yz4s/) where I mentioned that a lot of nations converted to Catholicism, because by doing so, they got literacy (or expanded it), an entire literate class (clergy) and frequently some level of bureaucracy (again provided by said literate clergy).

You'll notice, I mention also that they got access to a continual literary tradition stretching back to around 800 BCE (Homer).

But then I wondered - is that the oldest piece of literature available to someone in the Latin (broader Latin Christian literary tradition, not just Romance speaking) west? Not knowingly to the westerners, of course, but something we today know.

I'm wondering if some Egyptian or Sumerian or Akkadian (or whatever other ancient group) story or knowledge was passed down pretty much as-is. I'm aware of how the Noah story in the Bible was inspired by the Sumerian version, but I'm wondering if there's anything that's even more direct - pretty much survived more or less in its ancient form, just translated (probably a few times, as I suspect you'd need a transitory Greek stage at the minimum).

My guess would be that there might be some part of the Bible that's pretty much a direct parallel to something older, or maybe some old Greek source that transcribes an Egyptian work pretty much directly, at least in part.

I'm also wanting to constrict it to before the huge Byzantine importation of Greek texts into Latin after/around the fall of Constantinople, before colonialism (when Latin Europeans got access to literature completely outside of the western canon) and especially before modern archaeology, when a lot of ancient writing got rediscovered.

Am I pretty much on the money with Homer being the earliest piece of literature available to such a westerner, or is there an even older one?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

What what the status of the title "Prince of Wales" during the reign of George VI? Did Elizabeth hold the title "Princess of Wales" in her own right?

1 Answers 2022-10-14

Announcing the Best of September Award Winners

Another month down, and after some putzing, its time to announce the September 'Best Of' awardees.

Taking this month's Users' Choice Award is newcomer /u/fianarana, and their insight for 'How did Moby-Dick, a peculiar commercial failure, become a "Great American Novel?"'.

Meanwhile, for the Flairs' Choice Award, it was old hand /u/itsallfolklore who fascinated with "What are the origins of the practice of telling the bees?".

No "Dark Horse Award" for the month, with a non-flair taking top honors outright!

Finally, for this month's 'Greatest Question', voted on by the mods, the eyes fell upon "How did the computer game Oregon Trail become ubiquitous in US schools during the 80s?", asked by /u/takeoffdpantsnjaket, and with some excellent responses from /u/jbdyer and /u/snowblindalbino.

As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

5 Answers 2022-10-14

Friday Free-for-All | October 14, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

3 Answers 2022-10-14

How do we know how ancient proper names are spelled?

Say you have a name like Rameses that’s spelled in hieroglyphics. If you can translate that language you know @$?! = horse, but unless the proper name %#*€ is “horse town” or “horse lord”, how are you supposed to know what it sounds like or how it’s spelled in English? I’m using Egyptian as an example, and maybe for that case there’s a particular explanation, like Greek contemporaries wrote about Rameses in their own language and we know how Greek is supposed to sound. Or more generally if you can map an entire alphabet to English you could just sound it out as it would sound in English, even if the language as spoken didn’t originally sound like that. But I mean the question more generally for all ancient languages, even ones where we’ve never heard someone speak it or read someone write about it.

1 Answers 2022-10-14

How dangerous was "being cast into the water" in Hammurabi's Code? Did Mesopotamians swim?

I'm a History teacher looking over Hammurabi's Code with students, and for them it's incomprehensible that this is a real punishment (we have a very large swim team.) This got me thinking, in the Code of Hammurabi it's treated as a fairly serious punishment.

Could most Mesopotamian's swim? If not, was that why it was so dangerous?

Were people tied up? It specifies adulterers were tied together, but were others?

Is it less serious a punishment than I think it is? It sounds like trial by combat to be honest.

Thanks for anyone who can help explain this!

2 Answers 2022-10-14

How was the relationship between the women’s movement and the other student movements in western Germany around the 60/70s?

So I have to write a like 10 page long essay about how the womens movement and the other movements in the 60s/70s worked together or how they tried to keep them down. Or like if they were „friends“ or „enemies“ If anyone can help me with articles, books or other literature that would be awesome too since i have to cite these in my work

(The title in german is: „Freund oder Feind? – Frauenbewegung und die deutschen Bürgerrechtsbewegungen in den 1960/70ern“)

1 Answers 2022-10-14

What's up with this global western phenomenon of formerly rich industrial areas being incredibly poor now? Areas like the Rustbelt, Ruhr Valley, Northern England and Wales, the former mining areas in the Netherlands, Belgium and Northern France?

2 Answers 2022-10-14

what books would you recommend to under the experience of a Napoleonic soldier?

I'm doing research for a story I am writing. I want to understand their daily routine, what they see/experience on the march and their experience during battles/skirmishes as well. Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2022-10-14

Was Mary Shelley's "Frankenstein" really the first horror/sci-fi novel?

I frequently hear Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, written in 1818, credited as the first ever horror and/or science fiction novel. It's the oldest major one that I can think of, written 79 years before Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897) and 46 years before Jules Verne's Journey to the Center of the Earth (1864). However, science fiction and especially horror are such broad genres that it strikes me as odd that there weren't any novels written in them before the 19th century. I know that the distinctions between genres of fiction can be fuzzy, but if we define them somewhat liberally, is the claim that Shelley was the first horror and science fiction novelist really true, or were there other (perhaps lesser known) novelists in those genres before her?

3 Answers 2022-10-14

what was the prices of goods and land during 15th century ming dynasty ?

2 Answers 2022-10-14

I've been watching the anime VINLAND SAGA and it depicts the Vikings as still pagan around the year 1000. Am I right in thinking that's an anachronism or were there still pagan communities that late?

1 Answers 2022-10-13

Did the Ancient Greeks or Romans know about the Sumerians and Sargon the Great?

1 Answers 2022-10-13

89 / 7255

Back to start