Marco Polo gives us an account of China as seen from the perspective of a westerner. Are there any instances of the reverse? That is, travelers from lands foreign to the medieval west (the middle east, north africa, maybe even Byzantium) that would show us what an outsiders perspective on western christendom looked like?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
I’ve been looking for some good answers to this question but have had trouble finding a good answer. I know there was a mass movement in rebuilding and cleaning up cities after the end of WWII, but what was done during the war? Were there military assigned people or civilians? After a battle was won was there still issues of clearing out the enemy?
2 Answers 2020-12-17
My history teacher said that the native didn't know what land ownership was or how trade worked, and that that was how the Europeans tricked them out of their territory. This seems kinda sus to me
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Could someone here help me to know when was the name Yeshua translated to Jesus in Modern English? Is Jesus mentioned in any literary works?
2 Answers 2020-12-17
Did the various horrific medical experiments performed by both the imperial Japanese and the Nazis result in anything of medical value? Did they make any important discovers that proved medically or scientifically useful or important after the war like was the case for much of there advanced weapons experiments? Or Was it all just pointless cruelty for the sake of it?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Sorry if this isn't the right form for a question, but my Google-Fu is failing me at finding info for a specific English battle.
English on both sides, where both sides were waiting for a powerful Lord to choose who to join, but instead of choosing they stayed on the sidelines until the battle was more or less decided, then joined the winner.
I remember learning about on a Great Histories course about the English... But the English seemed to have fought each other a lot and this isn't one of the more famous battles.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
https://imgur.com/gallery/PhHFTmI
We have this bullet, but I don’t know anything about it really. It was found in the North Sea. It’s 6.5 cm long and a bit more than 2 cm wide. It’s also fairly heavy for its size.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Hello Historians !
I am a 1st semester student of history and I am currently writing my exam on the use and decline of mercenaries, specifically Landsknechts, in european armies during the 17th century. However, I'm having trouble finding primary sources. The focus of my assignment is the view common people, clergy, nobility etc. had on mercenaries and why they still chose to use them. (It is my understanding that mercenaries were seen as vile, corrupted, godless men only interested in coin). Any help, analysis, comments etc. will be greatly appreciated. To be clear, I am asking for references to primary sources or any and all help in regards to the use of mercenaries in europe in the 17th century.
For Konge og Fædreland!
2 Answers 2020-12-17
Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
5 Answers 2020-12-17
Hi! I'm Dr Marjorie Gehrhardt from the University of Reading in the UK. I'm a cultural historian specialising in the history of disability and of facial differences in particular.
My first monograph explored the experiences and representations of WW1 facially disfigured combatants in France, Britain and Germany; I first started investigating this topic when I realised that the term used to refer to WW1 disfigured soldiers in French - ‘gueules cassées’ – had no equivalent in English. I'm particularly interested in how the voluntary sector was mobilised to help disabled and disfigured combatants reintegrate into society during and after the First World War.
My research interests have inspired me to design undergraduate modules on the cultural history of the Great War and its legacies in France, and on the history of philanthropy, and to take on the position of Departmental Director of Academic Tutoring, a role that enables me to support students who are facing challenges circumstances.
Thanks very much for all the questions! It’s time to wrap up but you can still get in touch with me on twitter. AMA about the history of disability, disfigured WW1 soldiers and their plastic surgery, the attitudes of society at the time, and more :)
23 Answers 2020-12-17
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Most of Eastern Europe saw pro-soviet regimes installed and joined the Warsaw Pact; yet Finland, right on the USSR's border, a repeated thorn in their side during the war and occupying a strategically useful position on the Baltic, escaped this fate and maintained a precarious independence. Why did Stalin not push for the installation of a puppet regime here also? Was he prevented by the US/UK in some manner, or were other factors at play?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
One of my first 'experiences' of WWI was the black and white adaptation of All Quiet On the Western Front. One of the scenes that shaped how I viewed trench warfare was the charge and counter charge where both sides seemingly get mown down to a man. As I learn more and more about the horrors of the war, I am actually surprised that more people weren't killed considering the myriad of ways to die. Figures like '1 in 10 of the regiment were killed' are reported with an air of despair about them. I hear them and think "How was it that low when they were charging machine guns, rapid firing rifles, barbed wire, mud, shrapnel, tanks, gas and aircraft while also dealing with rats, trench foot, malnutrition, PTSD, low morale and such?" I expected figures more on the ratio of 7 out of 10 being killed or even higher.
3 Answers 2020-12-17
Early 20th Italy was monarchy, then how socialists and communists get legal position?
Italian Socialist Party was even largest party at 1919 general election.
I wonder why Italian government does not illegalized them at that time.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
A post on r/historyporn about them has raised questions of how much of what is commonly known about them is propaganda.
Specifically, the question u/ownage99988 raised was whether they would really switch off their engines and glide in to the attack in order to evade detection and/or scare the bejeezus out of the targets.
Some claims were also made about the aircraft used (the Polikarpov Po-2 if memory serves), for example that its top speed was slower than the stall speed of German fighters, or that its light construction meant it wouldn't show up on radar.
(Someone then said the "stall speed" bit was actually about an F-86 Sabre during the Korean war, when one crashed while trying to shoot down a DPRK Po-2,giving the type an air-to-air kill credit)
So yeah, with the user suggesting that the gliding bit was either Soviet or German propaganda, can r/askhistorians do its usual magic in sorting fact from myth?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Perhaps they could’ve gone through the Monaco/Nice area and avoided the Alps? As an alternative question, if there was no avoiding a landing in northern France, why did they bother with Italy?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Growing up in Ontario in the 1990s, the local Orange Lodge was just another local service club. They ran a burger booth at the local fair and donated money to community causes.
However, I'm aware that earlier in their history they were a powerful political force and engaged in anti-catholic violence.
How did they get from one to the other?
1 Answers 2020-12-17
I know that they were related to the Aztecs but are there any remaining individuals who practice the beliefs of this culture? For those related to these people, would I refer to them as Mexicans ? I apologize for my ignorance, I’m sort of going off my understanding of the Incas and how I refer to their descendants as Peruvians.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
Currently watching “The White Queen” and the issue of guardianship has come up several times. Currently the young Prince of Wales is being sent away to be raised by a male guardian while both his parents are alive. I’ve seen this take place in other historical pieces as well, and I’m so curious as to the origins and reasons for this custom.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
1 Answers 2020-12-17
This is a two part question. 1: Why aren’t the Dutch considered Nordic, they’re extremely close to Scandinavia in terms of culture, and at one point were a part of Denmark (I will admit ignorance as to what constitutes a Nordic state, and I do understand immigration and the movement of people contribute).
2: Why haven’t the Dutch been recognised as having Viking ancestry. It’s well documented that the Frisians played a relatively large role in the Viking sphere, they were known for their boat building ability, and even accompanied the Danes in raids on England - is that not the definition of Viking? They were also pagan and worshipped the Germanic Gods (This is a given since they were Germanic in origin). This is information I’ve picked up over a period of time, but could be wrong and would love to learn more.
1 Answers 2020-12-17
I hope the question I’m asking is pretty straightforward, But I want to ask about Japans militarization and how deep it ran, I know that a lot of the military personnel were either fanatical in forcefully establishing their idealized japan on the world stage or complacent out of fear of the increasingly hostile environment the country was spiraling into. After the war, Many of Japan’s militaristic policies were undone due to Unconditional surrender and their own volition.
Except Hirohito wasn’t dethroned
I understand why they didn’t dethrone him strategically, America wanted a strong ally in the Pacific against communism who wasn’t alienated.
But I want to ask how involved Hirohito actually was in the war effort of japan and all the atrocities they committed in China. I heard he claimed that he was powerless in the Political sphere and was relegated to a mere symbol of the war, Which makes sense but yet again he also has a motive to divert as much blame from himself as possible.
So, Hirohito, Powerless monarch who was a slave to the war effort?
Blood thirsty emperor?
Or maybe a mix of both?
How involved was he in Japans war effort and politics?
1 Answers 2020-12-17