From the history videos I’ve watched so far it seems like every continent had at least one major civilization form (South/Central America, Europe, Asia, Africa). How come there wasn’t one in North America? Is there any trace/information about pre-colonized North America? Did they have forms of writing? I know they did trade art with other peoples but was it more tribe to tribe or did they know of the Central/South American empires?
How can I read up more on the americas pre-colonization? Sorry if this has been asked before.
Edit: as a follow up question, since it is theorized that the people in the Americas came from Asia, how come there were so many more people in South America than in the north? Is it that there were perhaps an equal number of people that migrated over time and the places that formed civilizations were able to grow their population, is it differences in lifestyle/resources, or was it some disaster out phenomenon that maybe happened to North America?
2 Answers 2020-11-22
The breakup of Yugoslavia involved brief conflict in Slovenia, and longer wars in Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Kosovo. I know that Serbian paramilitary groups were involved, but the Yugoslav People's Army was also involved. Certainly involvement of aircraft and large ships seems like their involvement, and not something paramilitaries could do on their own.
It's interesting how such a large and well established army lost against Croatia, who were building up their armed forces from almost nothing. It's also interesting how JNA did seemingly very stupid things, like bombarding civilians in Dubrovnik's old town.
I'm curious what happened inside the JNA, in their chain of command. How did they become willing to attack people who they were until recently meant to protect? How did they accept the change of command, towards becoming more like a Serbian army? How did they lose so easily? Why were they willing to engage in war crimes which didn't seem useful for accomplishing military objectives? What happened to officers and soldiers who weren't willing to do these things?
I suppose some of this has been documented by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), but I'm looking for a summary of what happened.
1 Answers 2020-11-22
What is the historical consensus on this claim?
"Stop sending assassins to Belgrade. We've already captured five of them, one of them with a bomb and another with a rifle (...) If you don't stop sending killers, I'll send one to Moscow, and I won't have to send a second."
The story goes that "someone" discovered the note in Stalin's desk, when he passed away.
If this is true, who found that note? Are they trustworthy? And what happened to those assassins?
Is there any way a layman like myself can investigate, as the Yugoslav government itself has been dissolved?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
1 Answers 2020-11-22
This might be better as a cross-post with AskScience, but I am also curious about the historical component. The Northeast was, in large swathes, considered completely deforested due to agriculture and the appetite for wood and charcoal in early industry. Did tree seeds in the soil seed bank survive the full duration of this period of deforestation? Or was it a gradual spread, or did people in the Northeast help along the process by planting new forests?
Additionally, since this is such a dramatic change to a landscape, I am curious how Americans of this region reacted to, and felt about, the change from a widely-deforested environment to one that was quickly returned to forest cover. Did people notice the change happening? Did they have some sense of unease as farms and pastureland was swallowed up by the old "howling wilderness" that their ancestors had described? When old farm towns were abandoned and forests overgrew them, did Northeasterners feel a sense of community decline, like someone in an old factory town watching a boarded-up abandoned factory crumble?
Since it seems that the notion of progress would have been in many ways different in the 19th century than our notion of it today, I am wondering if they saw the regrowth of forest as a bad sign rather than a good one!
1 Answers 2020-11-22
My grandfather died three years ago on the 16th.
He served briefly in World War 2 and longer in Korea. I spoke to him a great deal, took notes, and was really hoping that someone here could tell me what unit he served in. By the time we spoke, he couldn’t remember everything perfectly, but I do have some films he took at the time and my uncle and I plan to get them digitized.
Here’s the information I have:
He was in Company F in an old, well established unit, with lots of WW2 vets in it, but many new men as well. He was a driver. He started basic training stateside but finished it overseas, and remembered hearing about a police station that was overrun by North Koreans.
He knew that he arrived at his first station by rail or truck, but remembered that it was via “Inchon Po Hang Dong”, which he remembered as a fishing village. His next stop was “Yung Heil Bay”, which was below the 38th parallel. He remembered that there was a mountain range that enclosed the bay.
He was stationed about ten miles from the bay, and there were lots of traditional Korean huts. This area had been a Japanese base at some point, and when he moved on from there, he went to Taegu along the Naktong River. He remembered very clearly that there were lots of mountains, and one mountain had a notch in it cut toward the mountain range.
He said that he spoke to a few English speaking Koreans there that said this notch was where Noah’s Ark was.
In this area were some Buddhist places or worship, and he drove up to a monastery. He said a river flowed down from there, and he visited the valley below. Apparently this area had been the site of what he called the “Silla” dynasty. I’m pretty sure that’s not spelled right, but it might help. There were lots of turtles carved in stone.
I have more personal stories and I can answer a few questions, I think, but I’m really hoping someone can tell me what unit he served in and where exactly he was.
1 Answers 2020-11-22
As I understand it, the Gulags were the worst prison in the Soviet Union, dedicated to prisoners who the state felt committed crimes of political nature (and I’d imagine other crimes as well)
What actually happened to the Gulag once the Soviet Union collapsed?
Was it shut down? Were prisoners released? Does it still exist in some form today?
If it does still exist, who gets sent there, and how does it compare to what it was like during the soviet era?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
During the Great Northern War, when Sweden invaded Russia, IIRC, their objective was to take Moscow. However, in July 1709, they wound find themselves defeated at Poltava. Poltava is roughly 900km south of Moscow, so how did they end up there?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Hello,
I was wondering if anyone is familiar with sources regarding the civilian (everyday) life during the Spanish Civil War. The best one I was able to dig up is “Blood of Spain: An oral history of the Spanish War”, a book by Ronald Fraser. Scientific articles are welcome too.
Thank you.
3 Answers 2020-11-22
It doesn't seem like it would be easy to find me if I manage to get a brief head start, so what's stopping me?
And if I understand correctly, as long as I'm not a slave miner or something awful like that my life could be pretty good. Was that a motivation for slaves to stay at their post?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Hi,
I'm looking for a source or historian that basically believes that Alfred the Great wasn't so great. Any help or guidance would be much appreciated!
2 Answers 2020-11-22
Is this book worth reading? I’m just looking for a good book on US History from the beginning up to the middle-end of the 20th century. Any other recommendations?
Thanks!
1 Answers 2020-11-22
John F. Kennedy gave this speech to the American Newspaper Publishers Association on April 27, 1961:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u928MLkKcrM&list=PLIWqIiBGci2jq6xSN5lFVht86AhZRKSeV&index=3
This video is often used as proof that a secret society runs the world and that JFK was assassinated for what he knew about it.
Okay sure.
But if we ignore conspiracy theories, what was JFK actually referring to when he said, "opposed to secret societies, to secret oaths and to secret proceedings"? What prompted him to make this speech?
Was there an instance of a real "secret society" being uncovered around this time? I'm not talking about the Illuminati or reptilians or anything. I'm talking about a legitimate, documented instance where certain politicians and/or businessmen conspired in a way that benefited each other? Something closer to crony capitalism? And then this news story prompted JFK to address the topic of secret groups?
I know very little about American history so I apologize if this question is obvious.
2 Answers 2020-11-22
So I was researching Iberian surnames, and from what I got, by the high Middle Ages both noblemen and commoners were using only patronyms, but starting in this period nobles started adopting into their names the names of their manors or of the lands they controled - so Pero Gomez who controled the lands of Souza would become Pero Gomez de Souza.
But the thing is - surnames of this kind are among the most common surnames in Spanish and Portuguese speaking countries - especially Portuguese ones. If you search for the origin of a Portuguese toponymic surname you'll often find sites saying that it comes from a homonymous manor in some small village in Portugal or Galicia.
So how did these surnames adopted by nobles from some manor somewhere became so popular? Did the villains from these manors adopt them and then they spread through pure chance? Or did the common folk just start adopting surnames in a way that would fit them? For instance, Costa, Oliveira, Pereira, are all very common and have "literal" meanings. However, Andrade, Araújo, Almeida are also common and they mean nothing except the manors they originate from. How did it work?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Hey guys I have a paper where I have to focus on those that are missing from our history particularly in the medieval period. Does anyone know of any primary sources or readings I should look into?? I know this is really general I just don’t know where to look.
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Why didn't Genoa, Venice or the Ottomans have any colonies outside the Mediterranean and Black Seas? I've seen this asked and answered before specifically about the New World, but why not colonize coastal parts of Africa or India, or any islands in the Indian Ocean or West Atlantic?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Every time I read about history, the Persian civilization (and some incarnation of it as an empire) is ubiquitous. But while the Chinese, Indian, Egyptian, Mesopotamian and Hellenic civilizations are well-remembered with their place in history well defined, the Persian civilization seems to only ever be recognized in relation to the history of other civilizations.
Why is this?
Every time I take the time to read about the Persian civilization it seems very rich with a long list of novel accomplishments that are historically noteworthy. But instead we don’t hear much about this civilization compared to the other major ancient Eurasian civilizations.
2 Answers 2020-11-22
Looking at the casualty counts for Chinese wars - the Three Kingdoms wars, An Lushan revolt, Taiping rebellion, Chinese civil war - are all massive, enough to depopulate entire European nations. However, death during a rebellion almost seems counterproductive - not only is war and murder morally repugnant, but assuming that the rebellion succeeded, they'd be taking a land devastated by the very war they fought, rebuilding what they destroyed. So, what made Chinese revolutions so destructive? And why are some revolts, such as the Xinhai revolution, comparatively peaceful?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
It must have been expensive to produce a new steel ship, especially when they just came out, so I believe the process must have been gradual. How quickly and in what ways were wooden ships phased out? Were there any naval battles involving ships of the line and early ironclad or steel warships?
1 Answers 2020-11-22
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Hi-
I am a writer based in Maryland, USA, and I am writing a novel which is initially set in 1930's London. I am trying to find some resources on British foodways in 1930, as well as some information about social demographics for the city during the interwar period.
-My main character is a middle class doctor-- Where would he have likely lived? I am not native to Britain, though I have been several times, and I know neighborhoods in London have likely changed vastly.
-Are there any good books that give an overview of London life during that period? I've been sort of swamped with results, and am looking for something that is concise with a good index.
Thanking you in advance.
1 Answers 2020-11-22
Hello,
This might seem like a stupid question but I am curious to know if anyone can help me out.
I tried googling my question but I don’t seem to get results for what I look up.
My question is did the vikings ever conquer Scotland entirely? or did they only really manage to take over parts of Scotland?
I ask as my good friend is very interested in vikings and their way of life and how they did things like raiding.
I personally don’t really know much about this time era of vikings besides the name King Alfred the Great and Ragnar lol so any help answering my question would be greatly appreciated
2 Answers 2020-11-22
Today:
Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.
3 Answers 2020-11-22
Hi r/AskHistorians! I'm Gurinder Singh Mann, Sikh historian and Director of the Sikh Museum Initiative based in Leicester, United Kingdom. I am the author of three books. I have covered Sikh history and heritage for two decades in the form of books, exhibitions and now digital technologies.
My specific focus is the Sikh Martial Tradition on how the Sikhs became a militarized set of people, the development of their history as part of the Misls or Sikh Confederacies in the eighteenth century. This includes the relationship with the East India Company during this time and the interactions with the Governor Generals of the company.
This is together with how the Sikhs under Maharajah Ranjit Singh developed the Sikh Empire leading to one of the most prosperous states in northern India. There was much interactions with the British and after the Maharajah’s death several bloody battles took place between the EIC and the Sikh Empire known as the Anglo Sikh Wars between 1845-1846 and 1848-1849. Leading to the annexation of the Panjab, India. However the Sikhs would be employed on a mass scale within the British India Army eventually leading to their pivotal contribution in World War 1 and 2. These interactions can be read about in my latest book: The British and the Sikhs: Discovery, Warfare and Friendship c1700-1900 [ for USA readers- https://www.casematepublishers.com/the-british-the-sikhs.html#.X7EK3mj7RhF
I am also digital Curator of the world first Anglo Sikh Virtual Museum which is a repository of 3d models of relics and artefacts which link the British and the Sikhs, these models tell the story of how many artefacts were taken from the Panjab to the UK. The project can be seen at www.anglosikhmuseum.com
So feel free to ask me any questions on these topics from 10am to 2pm eastern time, (2pm-6pm UK).
*******Thanks for all the thought provoking questions. The 4 hour window is now finished i will try and answer as many other questions in the next day or so. It has been a privilege to be part of this Q and A. Thanks to AMA and everyone who has taken part.
74 Answers 2020-11-22