I’m a citizen of an ancient Greek city-state and I have, ironically, injured my Achilles tendon during army training. Are there any specialists for treating such injuries? Do I have any hope of recovery?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Kramer and alternative media in NYC during the early '90s

In the Seinfeld episode The Old Man (Season 4, episode 18, 1993) Kramer spouts some nonsense conspiracy theory regarding Senior Citizen's Volunteer, when asked where he gets his information he replies: "The alternative media, Jerry. That's where you hear the truth."

 

I consider myself fairly well acquainted with the alternative media landscape of today be it the good, the bad or the ugly (let's be honest it's mostly the latter two), but what did the alternative media landscape look like in the early '90s, what might Kramer have been reading or listening to and what would he have learnt?

I am well aware that the internet existed back then, but it didn't look much like it does today, wasn't as widely used and Kramer just does not strike me as a tech-savvy early adopter of the internet lifestyle.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

CPG Grey’s video “How to be a pirate” mentions that pirates agreed upon a contract before engaging on a voyage. Do we have any specifics on what these contracts contained and would the contents of a contract differ between crewmates?

2 Answers 2020-08-17

At the start of the Spanish Civil War, was it clear which side would likely prevail? (I recall how Assad’s days seemed numbered in 2012...) And why did the Nationalists eventually win- what key advantages did they possess?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Can you recommend a good book on history of China?

Title. Thanks!

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Who was the man who proposed using Solar Power in the early 1900s to green the desert?

When I was in high school I took AP US history, during our discussion of the 1900s, our teacher told us about a man who wanted to use solar power to green the desert. While he called it solar power it seemed to have nothing to do with electrical production and more to do with greening the desert to use the land for farming. I can't seem to find the man's name or anything about his project all I can remember is it was suggested in the early to mid 1900s and he used a curved metal sheet as the solar energy collector. I really just want to know more about him and his work becuase its and interesting and important idea.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

How often was seppuku practiced in 1600s Japan?

I have been reading Shōgun by James Clavell recently and it is an excellent book so far. The history is va Rey interesting and from what I’ve read it is generally correct yet I am not sure about the extreme use of seppuku in the book. I found it hard to gain actual information on seppuku in medieval japan so I am asking here. Was seppuku an extremely common form of suicide by samurai for even slight mishaps? Furthermore, was it true that samurai would actively ask their superiors to commit seppuku for a dishonorable action?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Why did feudalism decline in Europe more quickly than in the rest of the world?

I’m currently reading though Paul Kennedy’s “The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers”, and when talking about Europe’s rose to prominence he references that European adoption of capitalism allowed it to innovate more quickly.

Plague making the worker more valuable is often cited as a reason for the demise of feudalism, but the plague ravaged every corner of the world, including China, the previous center of technological innovation. So why was Europe able to throw off feudalism significantly earlier than the other parts of the world?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Where to start?

Is there a reading list or reading/viewing materials that you guys could recommend for someone who is woefully ignorant regarding history? Want to gain a grasp of early human civilisation to present.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

I am a sailor who is unhappy with my lot during the height of the age or piracy. How safe an option is it for me to join a pirate crew?

How likely is it that I would be caught and brought to justice? Would I be more likely to be killed or or wounded in the act than being brought to trial? Would it be a one way ticket, or would I have a realistic prospect to leave with my share of the booty whenever I wanted? If I did, would it be likely that the authorities would eventually catch up to me? And what are the realistic chances of making my fortune?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Military officers of 'common breeding' in the time of the British Empire

Recently, for absolutely no reason I can think of, YouTube has started throwing clips at me from the historical drama series 'Sharpe', based on the novels by Bernard Cornwell. I've never watched the program or read the novels, but I gather the premise is that Sergeant Richard Sharpe saves Arthur Wellesley from an assault by three French dragoons and Wellesley gives him an officer's commission on the spot, thereby 'raising him from the ranks.'

This led me to wonder - how many times, if ever, did this actually happen? I'm no historian by any means, but being English myself, I know a little about the history of the British Empire and of all the major military figures I've read about, I can't recall one who started out as an enlisted man.

Now, 'Sharpe' takes place during the Napoleonic wars, and much of what I know about the Empire and its army is from the mid to latter part of the 19th century (India, Elphinstone's disastrous retreat from Afghanistan, Henry Havelock and the Sepoy Mutiny, etc), so my question is this - are there any stories or records of particular officers in the British military who rose from the ranks in the 19th century? Did this ever actually happen?

2 Answers 2020-08-17

When did Indonesia became independent? 1945 or 1949?

Hey, I am Indonesian and I have on the independence day of my country because our education system is so biased and full of propaganda narrative. Indeed Sukarno and Muh Hatta proclaimed the independence of Indonesia on 17th August 1945, but it took the Dutch four years to recognize the sovereignty of the nascent nation. My question is when is the independence? From what I know, a country has to have two "factors" to be considered a sovereign country: de jure and de facto.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Did Caesar pull the strings in his own assassination, thereby basically committing suicide?

I have read a theory that Caeser orchestrated his own assassination. The theory was that his epilepsy was growing worse, he had maneuvered himself into a political corner, was running out of money and just could not live up to his fame and nimbus. So, in order to take the "easy" way out and to die with his honor and glory intact, he chose to die an idol.

A fact that supports this theory is that he had been warned but insisted to attend the session of the senate without his bodyguards.

Is there any evidence to support this theory, or has it just been spread to add to Caesar's myth?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

How come former English colonies in the Americas are mostly white but former Spanish colonies aren’t?

If English colonies ended up becoming places where the predominant race was white, then why didn’t the same thing happen to Spanish colonies? I’m guessing it’s because the places Spain colonized in the Americas were more populated by natives, but I’m no historian ;)

1 Answers 2020-08-17

What were the elections of the 1789 Estates-General like?

So something that most French Revolution books I've read seem to gloss over is the election of the initial third estate.

All that most books seem to say is that only propertied men could vote in it. However, given the political atmosphere, there must have must be campaigning and conflict across the entire nation. I'm really struggling to find any sources. Unfortunately, I can't really read French so most of the pamphlets of the era are out of bounds to me.

-----

Edit*: to expand on this, lots of the members of the third estate were prominent citizens like: Bailly, mayor of Paris; and Sieyes, who authored the pamphlet "What is the 3rd Estate".

There were 44 Parisian deputies, surely they can't have run unelected? Also how did they vote for these people?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Do we have any knowledge past civilizations finding fossilized remains of prehistoric creatures and if so do we have records of what they believed them to be?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

I recently signed up for a trial of The Great Courses Plus and have immensely enjoyed the lectures and courses I have watched. Curious what historians think of it and its accuracy/usefulness. Also, would love recommendations of similar platforms and ways to find good ancient primary sources.

As noted, I have really been enjoying The Great Courses Plus. I finished a course of 48 or so lectures titled "History of the Ancient World" by Dr Gregory Aldrete and binged it over just a week or two. I've now started a bunch of other lectures in different topics but mainly history and philosophy.

Just curious what their reputation is with the historian community. They seem very academic and well researched and the professors appear to be respected researchers and professors. But i am curious if that is the view of historians in general.

Also, one of the things I liked about the ancient world course was the delve into various primary sources and info about how we know some of things we know. But I always have trouble finding good places to locate ancient primary sources for myself or overviews of artifacts and information about how we came to know what we know about the ancient world.

I'm looking for recommendations of perhaps some databases, websites, platforms, etc that have lots of primary sources, archeological information and stories or info about our discoveries of ancient ruins and how we came to theorize about the ancient world.

Also, any other platforms like The Great Courses that have great lectures or classes are welcome as well!

2 Answers 2020-08-17

AskHistorians Digital Conference: Announcing the Panels, Papers and Speakers!

A few months back, AskHistorians decided to take one of our biggest steps ever: to try and host a conference. Not just our first conference, but to our knowledge the first conference ever held on Reddit.

We wanted this conference to reflect who we are. We hoped to get excellent scholars from inside and outside academia, to put together panels that reflect the diversity of perspectives, topics and approaches that get discussed on our subreddit every day. We hoped that both our community here, and the history community more broadly, would respond enthusiastically.

We’re very happy to now report that these hopes have all been fulfilled.

First of all, a huge thanks to our community here. When we launched our conference a couple of months ago, we had no idea what to expect. But not only did that thread receive over 200 comments, everything was so positive that there was not one removed comment. Even better: our crowdfunder hit what we thought was an immensely ambitious goal - $3000 - in less than 24 hours. As things stand, we’re 97% of the way to our stretch goal of $5000 AS THINGS STAND WE JUST HIT 5K! We’re all immensely grateful that so many of you were willing to support us in such a tangible way.

We also received a great response to our call for papers, from historians you read every day on the subreddit, as well as many more who have had to have Reddit explained to them carefully and slowly (“No, it’s not all Nazis”). We received so many applications that the organising committee has had a very difficult time selecting who to accept.

But, after much discussion, negotiation and heartbreak, we managed to put together the conference we dreamed of. Without further ado: we’re very, very pleased to share with you all the final line up of papers for our first-ever conference!

The AskHistorians Digital Conference 2020: Business as Unusual: Histories of Rupture, Chaos, Revolution, and Change.

Be the Change that Others Don’t Want: Affirming and Resisting Racial Hierarchies in Midcentury North America

Ryan Abt: Everyone I Don’t Like is Hitler: The Appropriation of Anti-Nazi Axioms by American Fascists, 1944-1949

Stephanie Hunt: Bringing the Millennium to Birmingham: To Kill a Mockingbird and Racial Protest in Alabama’s Magic City

Tyler Wentzell: Fascists in Hogtown: Toronto’s Reaction and Resistance to the National Unity Party during the Summer of 1938

Building the Nation, Dreaming of War: Nation-Building through Mythologies of Conflict

Andrei Oprea: War: The Defining Catastrophe of 17th Century Moldavia

Cullan Bendig: ‘Behold the Heresiarch’: Jan Hus, Mythologies, and Nationalism in Postwar Czechoslovakia

Buğra Can Bayçifçi: The Balkan Wars from an Ottoman Perspective: Rupture as Creative Destruction?

Liam Connell: “Building a nation, dreaming its destruction”: Australian Federation and Fantasies of War

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Apocalypse: Imagining Mass Destruction

Victoria Cooper: The End of the World As We Know It: Social Disruption and Catastrophe in Medieval Literature and Modern Analogues

Malcolm Craig: The Nuclear 1979: Revolution, Islam, and 'The Bomb'

Kenneth Reilly: More Powerful Than The Atomic Bomb: Dinosaur Extinction and Nuclear Warfare

Joshua Porter: Samantha Smith: Citizen Diplomacy in the Cold War

In Whose Trenches? Violence, Voice, and the Experience of War from Below

Matilda Greig: The Extraordinary Experience of Battle, as told by Napoleonic Soldiers in Spain

Patrick O’Brien: “Gilded Misery”: Reconsidering Emotions and Community during the American Revolution

Hediye Özkan: The Rupture Between the South and North: The Diary of Nancy Emerson and War Discourse

Edwin Tran: Crossing Sect and Race: Civilian Ingenuity during the Lebanese Civil War

Indigenous Histories Disrupting Yours: Sovereignties, History, and Power

Ali Al-Jamri: Countering Cultural Erasure Through Community History: The Baharna as a Case Study

Wayne Buchanan: Rupture and Resilience: The Muckleshoot People

Kyle Pittman: Inherent Sovereignty: Disruptions to Indigenous Nationhood

Miguel Rivas Fernandez: Remembering Malinche: The Evolving Role of Language in the Events and Memory of the Early Spanish Conquest

Laugh with the Sinners, Cry with the Saints: Historical Women and Cultural Propaganda

Joshua Anthony: Through Chimalmantzin’s Eyes: A Family History of the Conquest of Mexico

Ronald James: Sex, Murder, and Myth: How a Soiled Dove Earned a Heart of Gold

Lois Leveen: When Black History Becomes Multiculti Clickbait, Manure Happens: "Mary Bowser" as a Case Study

Cait Stevenson: Elisabeth Achler’s Dirty Laundry, or, the Medieval Saint and Her Suffering Sisters

Pick Your Poison: Climate, Disease, and Human Disaster from the Middle Ages to Today

Adam Bierstedt: Galt margr óverðr þessa ófriðar: The Samalas Eruption, Unusual Weather, and the end of the Icelandic Commonwealth.

Daria Berman: The Anti-Jewish Riots in the First Castilian Civil War

Chris Day: Computing Cholera: Topic Modelling Catalogue Entries for the Correspondence of the General Board of Health (1848-1871)

Christopher Rose: The Importance of Epidemics for Social History

Power and Projections of Trauma in the 19th and 20th Centuries

Melissa Brzycki: Young People in the Chinese Great Leap Forward and its Aftermath, 1958-1962

Adam Franti: His Gallant Soul Had Fled: Death, Remembrance, and Race in Early America

Stephanie Montgomery: “A Den of Monsters”: Women, Crime, and the City in 1930s China

Katie Truax: Dealing with Catastrophe: Medical Men and the Diseases of Women in 19th century Britain

We’re very happy with this line up of papers and panels – despite the tough decisions, we feel they reflect the diversity of perspectives, subjects and approaches that make this subreddit what it is. As well as grad students and academics, we'll also be hearing from archivists, activists and public historians. We hope that you’re all as excited as we are to hear what they have to say - let us know in the comments!

This isn’t the last time you’ll hear from us before September 15th - there will be more news to share about the schedule, live events and other ways to get involved. If you want to keep in touch regarding the conference’s progress, including first dibs on access to networking and social events, you can sign up to receive our newsletter here.

24 Answers 2020-08-17

If European serfs were not typically paid in wages, why is it commonly said that the Black Death caused an increase in peasant wages?

What is meant by "wages" here? Because presumably it doesn't mean what it does in the modern sense, i.e. hourly cash wages or even a salary/stipend of cash

📷

1 Answers 2020-08-17

When did the Roman Empire (or Republic) became aware of the Chinese Han Empire ?

I read how China was frequently referenced in Latin and Greek texts as the Land of the Silk, when the Silk Road began to take shape between the two Empires. When did those two Empires became truly aware of eachother's existence (not as simple myths), and what account can I read about eachother's views, both in Latin/Greek and Chinese ?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Were air-dropped smoke screens actually used in naval combat?

https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/iavdxv/this_is_prewwii_footage_of_a_smoke_curtain_used

This video is making the rounds again, but I previously never really looked into it's origins or whether it was actually used in warfare (and the comments in the thread aren't too helpful).

Would smoke screens like this actually have been used in combat (whether in the era specified or around it)?

My understanding is that naval smoke screens were mostly generated either by the smoke of the guns or the exhausts of ships like destroyers.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Moeller van der Brook was a German Nationalist who coined the term "drittes reich". 15 years or so later, his books were burned by the Nazis. Why?

Dritte reich*

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Are there any history podcasts that focus mainly on tribal civilizations e.g (germanic, celtic, scythians) ?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Is there any historical truth in the legend of the Aeneid or was the whole story fabricated by Virgil and the Romans?

Historians think that the Iliad was a dramatised telling of a real event and I was wondering if the same could be said about the Aeneid.

2 Answers 2020-08-17

How expensive, labor-intensive and time-consuming to make were medieval illuminated manuscripts such as bibles, gospels, books of hours, breviaries, bestiaries, apocalypses, etcetera?

Obviously, during a time before the invention of the printing press, the introduction of paper and widespread literacy, books must have been object that were highly costly to produce and procure. But exactly just how pricey were they?

Let’s say I’m a wealthy French noblewoman in the 1300s-to-1500s who is commissioning an illuminated book of hours like this one from a well-known monastery, how much would it cost me? Would this investment be like someone today spending a couple thousand dollars on a new computer or is the value of such a book more like buying a new car? How long would it take before my book of hours is completed? How much parchment or vellum goes into the making of it, and do I provide it or does the payment include materials as well as labor? Would it even be considered to be a payment or is it more like a donation to the monastery or abbey that I’m commissioning? Also, how customizable or bespoke is this service, would I be able to request specific prayers or passages be included? What about the design of the codex, can I choose my favorite colors, calligraphic fonts, specific images and motifs? Or did the scribes have set layouts that they copied from and I would basically get a slightly customized facsimile of an older book?

Finally, kind of a random question: if books and manuscripts were highly valuable then were they ever stolen or looted as spoils during wartime?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

1147 / 7255

Back to start