What is the best book to read about Weimar-Germany?

Pretty basic question, I know, but I’m looking for a 100-200 (this isn’t a hard limit) that discusses the historical fact of Weimar Germany.

The reason for this ask is because I want to understand the conditions that led to the rise of Hitler and why the citizenry would support the Nazi party. In my opinion an important aspect of opposing Nazi-similar movements is to understand what led to the original Nazi movement in a historical context.

2 Answers 2020-08-17

Why was the Roman Senate kept separate from the army after the 3rd Century

Been listening to and relistening to Mike Duncan’s “The History of Rome”. One thing that seems agreed upon in the literature is that one of the main reasons the West fell is because the super-rich landowning classes withheld money, manpower, and political support from the army more and more throughout the 5th century. One of the main reasons for this as far as I can tell is that the senatorial class — which to my mind is basically synonymous with “wealthy landowning elites” — were barred from serving in senior positions in the military from the reign of Gallienus on. This seems like it completely divorced the elites from the needs and realities of the military over time, leading, in part, to the complete degradation of the West’s military.

I understand this question is kind of predicated on that causal inference being correct — but why was this division kept (If it was indeed kept until at least the fall of the West)? Romans always seemed so concerned about becoming effete and detached from their martial traditions so why wasn’t this reversed

Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Why did the Aztecs and Incas loose to the Spanish? Was it because of disease? Better armor/weaponry? Tactics?

I might be wrong on this, but this is my opinion on the "disease" reason:

If the Aztecs and Incas were conquered because of disease, how were the Aztecs and Incas still able to send so many reinforcements? The Aztecs and Incas always had more than enough soldiers available, even when disease was rampant. During the siege of Tenotitlian, for example, the Spanish and their allies were severely outnumbered, yet the city fell to them.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

In 19th century gas illumination, where did the gas come from?

I know London had gas streetlights as early at 1816, though it took until the 1860s for them to become common inside homes. I'm curious about the infrastructure.

Would gaslights would normally be fed from some central location in a city, or by individual gas canisters within a building? And how did it work for homes away from population centers? If you had a remote manor like Downton Abbey, would someone have dug a long gas line out from a natural gas plant, or did the building have a room full of flammable gases in canisters, and if so, where?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

During the Spanish Civil war, both sides saw many foreigners come volunteer to fight, a few notable examples being George Orwell and Ernest Hemingway. How did a person volunteer to fight in the Spanish Civil War?

I am excluding volunteers who were sent by their government, such as the troops sent by Nazi Germany and Italy. I wish to learn more about those who came of their own free will because they supported the ideals of either side. How were they organized? Did they just show up to Spain and ask to enlist? And why did the Spanish civil war attract so many foreign volunteers in the first place?

2 Answers 2020-08-17

Have we physically changed or have our depictions?

Hoping this is the appropriate sub to ask, as I can’t seem to find a more relevant one. I’ve always wondered why we look so different as compared to artistic depictions of humans from ~1500 AD (Lucas Cranach the Elder comes to mind) and before, and if it was perhaps because we actually differ physically (height, stature, etc.) or if artists intended to depict humans in a certain way. I understand there was a higher prevalence of incest, as well as large disparities between classes (nobility and biblical figures were more likely to be used as subjects), but is there any academia as it pertains to history? Thanks in advance for any help!

2 Answers 2020-08-17

What are some good books to use to debunk Holocaust deniers?

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Is the prescription against the split infinitive in English actually based off the fact you can't split the infinitive in Latin?

This is claimed all over the internet, and I am highly, highly, highly skeptical about this reasoning...just seems like a bunch of wokes wanting a reason to criticize old timey white european traditionalist academics without actually putting their research in.

I tried reading through Robert Lowth's grammar book, and although he spoke a lot of the infinitive, I couldn't find the section about split infinitives.

I'm just curious if any 18th--or whatever--century grammarian actually said "You are not allowed to split the infinitive in English because I really, really like Latin a lot". I'm sure that they did prescribe against it, but I doubt that reasoning.

I have seen other sources say that there's no evidence that the prescription against the split infinitive is based off foreign languages.

Many people who ought to know better—"authorities" on English—declare that the objection to separating to from the infinitive verb that follows is based on Latin (or some other language) where infinitives are single words. If some purist has made such a comparison, I can find no record of it. Henry Alford (The Queen's English [1866]) thinks the to and the verb are "inseparable" but he does not mention foreign languages (p. 227). This idea is part of the folklore of linguistics.

Richard Bailey.

The reason I'm so skeptical about this is that it seems to reduce actually rather brilliant academics from the past to latin-obsessed simpletons who didn't seem to realize that not only didn't the romans split the infinitive...they physically couldn't!

Thanks for your assistance.

1 Answers 2020-08-17

Are the two kingdoms of Galicia (1700’s Poland and medieval Spain) related in any way?

In English, the two names are identical but I have no reason to believe that they were related in any way. Any help on the matter as this has been bothering me for a while now. Thank you!

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Why is the Enontekiö Municipality of Finland part of Finland rather than Sweden or Norway?

Is it caused bt physical geography or is there a cultural reason?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

What happens when a monarch passes away but his wife is pregnant with his son?

Oddly specific question but I am curious if there are any historical precedents for this kind of event.

Would they wait for the child to be born? Is the child completely left out of succession when he is born?

Also assuming the monarch has no children aside from the unborn child.

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Italian cuisine

Everyone knows that Italian food is based on a handful of main ingredients including tomatos but considering they weren't introduced to Italy until the mid 16th century what could have been the alternative and how vastly different was Italian food pre-introduction from today's perspective it seems like atleast every popular Italian dish contains them?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

For what reasons would a Russian serf decide to participate in Pugachev's Rebellion or any of the peasant revolts of the previous decade? And what would their experience be like?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

American colonial medical salts

I've been reading through the journal of Nicholas Cresswell, 1774-1776. Early on in his arrival he became ill with "flux"(diarrhea as I understand it) and his doctor gave him the wrong medicine which exacerbated his condition. What medicines would they normally use for flux? He was given a "mercurial" medicine by accident and I'm generally aware of the story that the Lewis and Clark expedition can be tracked by their stomach ailment cure of mercury. As far as I'm aware it flushes the system out and further causes dehydration. He later speaks for several months of taking "salts" and having a bad taste in his mouth all day. I tried googling medical salts and salt remedy and historical salts. I'm not sure what my key words should be here. I'd like to know what was the actual medicine he was taking in current medical or chemical terms.

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Why didn't romans explore and conquer middle and south Africa?

Like title.They already had provinces in North Africa. They indeed had the possibility. What did prevent them to explore and conquer the rest of Africa?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

What did the nonparticipating European powers think of the partitions of Poland?

Were states like France, Great Britain, The Ottoman Empire, and so on concerned about the large territorial gains of the their neighbors? Were they apathetic?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Narvik's importance during WW2

I have done some reading about the battle of Narvik. What I can't seem to understand is how important this town was for both sides. I get that Germany was interested due to its connection to the Swedish iron mines and that Britan did not want Germany to have this iron. But I can't seem to find how dependant Germany was on the Swedish iron that was coming through Narvik.

My question is: How important was Narvik as a strategic location for both Germany and Britain?

I would love if you have some recommendations for books or texts about this subject.

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Did Robert E Lee directly or indirectly support slavery and secession?

In California, I’ve learned that Robert E Lee disliked both slavery and secession but still became a general in the confederate army due to his loyalty and his duty towards the state of California. However someone is claiming that Lee actively supported both slavery and secession. Most articles and teachers seem to support me, but this is the final nail in the coffin.

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Han settlers in Taiwan during the Qing dynasty practiced cannibalism on the indigenous peoples. How did they justify this to themselves? Did similar things happen on the Qing's southwestern frontier?

I read about how the meat of indigenous people was sold in Qing-era markets in Taiwan, and how the settlers even believed that the body parts of indigenous people had medicinal properties. But I've never heard of cannibalism practiced on "mainland" China, except as a tragic and desperate survival strategy during severe famines. The government officials and other literate-class members who wrote about the practice seem fairly horrified or at least disapproving, so do we know what brought the settlers to do this? Did they view the indigenous people as less than human somehow? And did Han settlers in southwestern China also treat the indigenous populations there in the same way?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Why were the Federalist Papers anonymous?

Curious about the intentions here. Wouldn't they have carried more weight coming from important figures like Madison and Hamilton? Or was the thought that since they were part of the Constitutional Convention, they were biased? If it's the latter, wouldn't the anonymity be a bit unethical and serve to trick the public, like an early form of astroturfing?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Why did Japan decide to be isolationist during the Tokugawa Shogunate? Were the losses during the conquest of Korea so devestating that he lost interest with any expansion?

Edit: Was he just a xenophobe?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

How did rice become so relevant in the diet of Latin Americans?

I'm from Latin America, from Uruguay most specifically, i noticed that Argentina, Uruguay and Chile don't consume as much rice as the rest of the region, but still the consumption is significant, i know that rice is very common in countries like Brazil, Peru, Colombia and most countries in Central America. Seems like all social classes eat it since it's pretty cheap and efficient.

The question is why? how did this grain that is native to Asia ended up as one of the most consumed grains in Latin America?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Why did Christianity/ Catholicism become more popular religion in the western world over paganism/norse mythology/ etc?

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Were chariots in the bronze age actually used for fighting, or just to bring warriors to the fight? If so, how were they used? Did this change over time?

I'm particularly interested in the very early Bronze Age.

1 Answers 2020-08-16

Dear AskHistorians, please could you help me and my dad to identify the rank/job/shipping line company of my great, great uncle?

My dad has found a photo of my great, great uncle and my great, great auntie at their wedding. We think the photo is circa 1925. We believe he was in the British merchant navy or marines, but we're not sure.

Hopefully his uniform gives some clues as to his rank or shipping line for some eagle-eyed Redditor!

Photo: https://imgur.com/a/XBCyxsm

2 Answers 2020-08-16

1148 / 7255

Back to start