Did people in the early Middle Ages differentiate between magic, religion and science? Or was it all just seen as, well, how the world worked?

Or would they perhaps instead differentiate between, say, chanting a mysterious phrase in Latin in front of a big stone cross with words invoking Deus (good) and chanting a phrase in the vernacular in front of a tree with words invoking Wotan (bad)?
Or something else?

2 Answers 2020-07-17

Did Philip II really not understand inflation?

I heard it multiple times that the gold flowing in from the Spanish colonies in the Americas caused disastrous levels of inflation in Spain and the reason for this was that Philip II didn't understand the basic principles of inflation so he didn't try to limit the amount of gold coming to Spain. Is this really true? I know that it's thanks to modern education that inflation seems like such a simple concept to us and it wouldn't be understood by everyone in the late medieval period, but it seems strange that no one at the Spanish court foresaw this problem.

I can remember reading multiple times about medieval monarchs decreasing the amount of silver/gold in coinage which resulted in the currency loosing it's value. I was under the impression that this process, which is basically inflation, was understood at the time.

2 Answers 2020-07-17

How would you have survived the sinking of the Titanic? In the movie, Jack tells Rose that they need to stay on the ship for as long as they can. In terms of survival, how correct is this?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

Why some terrifying historical peoples like norses (vikings), pirates or romans are romanticised in popular culture but others like conquistadores or Mongols not?

There's a game coming up from the Assasins's Creed series which is going to be protagonized by a "viking" and there was already another one protagonized by a pirate. I have a hard time imagining something similar with a conquistador as the hero and the Aztecs as the baddies. Why the difference in treatment for these historical figures?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

Did Romans create antisemitism?

With all the roman-jewish wars

1 Answers 2020-07-17

I’m Dr Jitske Jasperse, here to talk about my book ‘Medieval Women, Material Culture, and Power: Matilda Plantagenet and Her Sisters’, which deals with material culture as a source for understanding elite women’s power. AMA!

Dear readers! My name is Jitske Jasperse and I am assistant professor of medieval art history at the Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. I work on medieval women and material culture. What can the material record tell us about women’s lives, which are so often absent from written sources? What light do artefacts shed on women’s (familial) networks? And did some items hold special personal and emotive meaning to women and men? How would women (and men for that matter) have interacted with objects? But also, how did material items contribute to women’s performance of power?

Some of these questions I have addressed in my recent book ‘Medieval Women, Material Culture, and Power: Matilda Plantagenet and Her Sisters’: https://arc-humanities.org/products/m-77101-114115-80-7415/ (affordable paperback available end of July!) and https://library.oapen.org/handle/20.500.12657/37333 (Open Access). In it, I follow the visual and material traces left by the three daughters of King Henry II of England (d. 1189) and Queen Eleanor of Aquitaine (d. 1204): Matilda, Leonor and Joanna.

Do share your questions with me and the AMA community. I am available today (17 July 2020) from 14.00 to 18.00 CET.

18 Answers 2020-07-17

During the waning days of the Ottoman Empire, mistreatment and deportation of Muslims, were not as well documented and the other ones. Why was it no more people talking about this? Could you guys help me if you know more about this stuff like a book or blog about it?

During the disillusionment of the Ottoman Empire after World War 1 and and the early 1920s, Balkan Muslims (like Albanians, Bosnians, Greeks, Pomaks, Circassians, Ottoman Turks and others) were persecuted, massacred, or ethnic cleansed by non Muslims.

There's little to no info about this and the only thing that I found that explains about this stuff clearly was a Wikipedia page https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Muslims_during_Ottoman_contraction#

Is there any books of blogs that explains about this event throughly? I haven't been able to find a good explanation about this, considering the Balkan Muslims also when through the same stuff the Armenian, Assyrians and others went through.

2 Answers 2020-07-17

How were new gods created in ancient history? Do we have some account of the "birth" of a new good in a polyteistic religion?

I recall that in ancient Greece some gods were patrons of specific cities, and that these gods prominence reflected that of the city, but how these gods were created in the first place? Did an important person made a story up about an ancestor god to justify their power, like the whole Aeneas thing being the ancestor of Julius Caesar? We surely have first accounts of gods, do we know the specific process that brought them into "existence"?

2 Answers 2020-07-17

Seeing as how China is way closer to America than mainland Europe, why wasn’t it the Chinese that first discovered America?

3 Answers 2020-07-17

How much did Germany change economically during Hitlers rule?

Is it true that he took Germany from a poor country to a superpower? If so, how did he do it?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

What happened to the army of the Western Roman empire?

I've read in numerous places (not least the Wikipedia article) that by the late 4th and early 5th centuries, the Western Roman Empire's armies largely consisted of foreign mercenaries and Germanic barbarian levies. What I've never understood is how this could happen. How was it that Roman elites and Roman citizens got to the point where their entire armies were made of people of suspect loyalty to the empire? What cultural, economic, and political changes were required for this to happen? What happened to the famously organized Roman military organizational infrastructure? Did people somehow turn against military activity? I know Gibbons suggested that Christianity might have had something to do with this -- but given that the next two millenia of Christian history was full of plenty of formidably militaristic peoples, I'm dubious.

1 Answers 2020-07-17

How did the Japanese execute the attack on Pearl Harbor? Was it an all out blitz? Or was it more choreographed, with squadrons on station waiting for orders to fly sorties on the harbor?

watching Midway and it occurred to me that it was likely an all out blitz but I wanted to be sure...

1 Answers 2020-07-17

Direct Descendant of Pope Innocent VIII - Curious about his relationship with Christopher Columbus and the speculation around his journey to the New World in 1492

Hi everyone,

I have been working on my family lineage for some time now and have made some breakthroughs - one of them being that I am a direct descendant of Pope Innocent VIII, Bishop of Rome in the 1400's. I have come across this speculation while learning more about him:

"Ruggero Marino , a writer and historian, said the 1492 journey was a return visit. He said this emerged from study of an early 16th-century Ottoman map, which showed that Columbus found America in 1485, during the reign of Pope Innocent VIII. Mr. Marino said there was corroborative proof in an inscription on the tomb of Innocent VIII, in St Peter's Basilica, which reads "Novi orbis sua aevo inventi gloria", meaning that during his pontificate "the glory of the discovery of the New World" took place. Innocent VIII died at the end of July 1492, before Columbus set sail and three months before he landed at the Bahamas. "The inscription either anticipates Columbus's success or else refers to an earlier journey," Mr. Marino said. The accepted version is that Columbus was dispatched in 1492 by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella, but Signor Marino said that the venture was originally financed by Innocent VIII and the Medici banking dynasty to which the Pope was related."

Here is the link to the source I got this info from: https://www.ruggeromarino-cristoforocolombo.com/papa-innocenzo-viii.html

I am wondering if there are any other sources / any historians on here that can speak to this in any way. Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2020-07-17

What is the death toll of communism?

I hear people say "100 million is a fabrication" when someone brings up the death communism caused.why is this? Is is there any historical evidence to support this claim?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

Did Mussolini seek aid from the English against Hitler?

I’ve been told that in the months/years leading up to WWII, Mussolini sought help from the English in defense against Hitler’s war preparations. And that the English refused to help Fascist Italy defend itself against the Nazis. This inspired Mussolini to seek an alliance with Hitler himself. Is there any truth to this theory or is it more fascist apology. Are there any hints in Galeazzo Ciano’s diary as to whether this might have actually happened?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

How and what were WWI troops stuck in trenches fed? How were they able to cook and distribute food in wet, muddy trenches while surrounded by the enemy?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

In Abbott & Costello's Who's On First, what is the meaning of Dizzy and Daffy Dean's French Cousin Goofé Dean?

Here's the version I always heard growing up:

Bud Abbott: Strange names. Pet names, like Dizzy Dean

Lou Costello: His brother Daffy

Abbott: Daffy Dean

Costello: And their French cousin (or maybe he says "I'm their French cousin."?)

Abbott: French?

Costello: Goofé

Abbott: Goofé Dean! Oh I see

[audience laughs]

The audience thinks it is funny, but I never got the joke. Does Goofé have some meaning that we don't get now, or is it just a nonsense joke?

While looking for a video to link, I found many versions where they don't use this joke, and 2 where they use this variant:

Here's one version:

Bud Abbott: Strange Names, like Dizzy Dean

Lou Costello: Brother Daffy

Abbott: Daffy Dean

Costello: I'm their cousin

Abbott: Who are you?

Costello: Goofy

Abbott: Goofy? Goofy!

Another with the same bit

Maybe it is a reference to Goofy meaning a left-handed player?

I just don't get it.

1 Answers 2020-07-17

Were there any alternatives to dropping the atomic bombs or land invasion of Japan at the end of WW2?

I’ve been in a number of science ethics discussions and one prevailing idea was that the atomic bombs were “shiny new toys” and there were people pushing to use them at the expense of any other alternatives. (Obviously less flippantly than that.) This, of course, doesn’t make scientists look very good. So that’s what seems to make the narrative of saving more lives by dropping the bombs instead of a land invasion seem more palatable. Were there any alternatives being pursued? If so, what were they?

2 Answers 2020-07-17

How much did french peasants pay in taxes before the revolution, and roughly how much of it was used to support the frivolous lifestyle of the nobility?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, Frankenstein’s monster weeps upon hearing about how Native Americans were treated. Was this a common sentiment for Europeans in the late 18th and early 19th centuries?

2 Answers 2020-07-17

Why is bread presented in baskets?

Why and when did this practice of serving bread in a basket (as opposed to, say a plate) come about?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

How much has English actually changed in England?

So I'm from England myself and my question really is, I guess, how far back in time would I have to go that I would struggle to converse with a fellow Englishman? And what were the notable milestones for the language changing significantly?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

American Executions after the Revolution.

So I've been reading a little bit about the Cuban Revolution. Growing up in America you are told, basically every country is evil, except Canada, France, and Britain (but they used to be). So it's not really suprising their's A lot of misinformation about Cuba and its crimes. I was trying to find out how many of their "own" they killed, and was surprised to find very low estimates from Amnesty international of only around 400 of Batista's men, with obviously some estimates going to around 3,000. To me this seems like the basic actions of country that just overthrew a fascist regime, and it has always seemed disingenuous to count the revolutionary or defensive war deaths as part of a nations crime (like people do with the USSR and Germany).

I have never heard a single American see the hypocrisy in our own overthrow of Britain, and the countless deaths that occurred. So did we execute any remaining loyalists after the war, I understand many fled to Canada and England, but did we hold trials for anyone?

1 Answers 2020-07-17

I'm a merchant traveling through continental Europe in the High Middle Ages. What obstacles might I encounter in terms of customs, border security, etc?

1 Answers 2020-07-16

How can scholars tell the difference between Socrates and Plato, when Plato is one of our only sources on Socrates and since Plato seemingly puts so many ideas into Socrates’ mouth?

Did Plato ever draw this distinction in his own work? Thanks.

1 Answers 2020-07-16

1208 / 7255

Back to start