Why did the Native Americans believe that a British victory in The War of 1812 would protect their lands? Is there any evidence that it would have?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

In the postbellum American south, white people like Rebecca Latimer Felton seem to have believed that black men raped white women in tremendous numbers. I can understand being paranoid about miscegenation, but where did they get the notion that interracial rape had reached epidemic proportions?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

The alternate history of the Romans discovering gun powder and using it on invading barbarians is a common one, however when Constantinople fell in 1453, gunpowder was already used in cannon and very early muskets. Do we have any record of Byzantines using gunpowder based weapons?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Many trace the start of policing in the US with slave patrols tasked with catching run-away slaves. What is the historical basis for this? What was the genesis of policing in countries that do not have a history of slavery?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

What happened to the Hitler Youth children after the war? Did they receive therapy or something to address what they experienced during their time in the organization?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

How was the Emancipation Proclamation enforced? I doubt that slave masters just let their slaves go, so how did the enslaved leave? Did Lincoln provide any follow up with some type of task force?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

what percentage of slaves were black?

i am in an argument with some white supremacist and that guy is trying to hold the point that theree were more white then black slaves, that wouldn't make sense right? the european slave ships went to pick up slaves in africa to ship them to the americas or am i wrong here?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

In 1820, Maine became its own state after seceding from Massachusetts. But Massachusetts doesn't even border Maine, so why did it own Maine in the first place?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Why did France, rather than Germany, adopt the Frankish identity?

I find it quite odd that the Franking identity was established in what is now France (Gallia), and not Germany (Germania)

Why did East Francia fade into obscurity, yet West Francia embraced the title, and its descendants named themselves after it? The Franks were certainly closer to the other Germanics east of the Rhine river, than the Galloromans of the west. Whether that is culture (maybe until the adoption of Christianity), language, and/or heritage.

You'd think that Germany would be more likely to continue with the Frankish legacy, but in a very short time they separated themselves, despite being the Franks' origin (Franconia), and were called Regnum Teutonicum (Teutonic Kingdom) Meanwhile the latin-speaing Gauls (Galloromans) of Gallia adopted their name which still lives on as France.

2 Answers 2020-06-20

How did the switching of the Democratic party and the Republican party happen?

So I am British, and I have been hearing in the news and elsewhere on Reddit that before the Civil War, the Republicans were against slavery, and the Democrats were for it. However afterwards, the parties slowly switched and now the modern day Democrats were once the old Republicans and vice versa. Could someone confirm if this is true, and if so how did it happen?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Why isn't there a Hindu or Buddhist equivalent to Biblical scholarship and academia?

(If this question is not fit for or relevant to this sub, then I sincerely apologise and I will delete this post accordingly. If this is the case and if possible, it would be helpful for anybody to direct me to any other answers elsewhere on either Reddit or the internet as a whole, or point me to better areas to posit this question)

There is a large historical field of discussion related to the Bible as well as early Christianity and Judaism; its authenticity, accuracy, context, authorship etc. and archaeological and historical work is continually carried out and discussed from as wide a range as the historicity and life of the 'real' Jesus, to the influences early Christianity has been subject to from nearby faiths or belief systems. There are many comprehensive works that have been written analysing both early Christian and Jewish works as well as records of said religions by outside or secular observers. Consequently, there is a great, and often very interesting, amount of easily accessible literature available discussing practically every aspect of these religions in depth.

However, then why is there not an equivalent for the Hindu and Buddhist religions? Whilst I understand that these faiths fundamentally differ from Abrahamic religions, it is not as if there is want of religious and philosophical literature and texts available for these faiths nor as if there is a dearth of history, context, and authenticity to determine or analyse. The existing literature that is present is nowhere close to as detailed, extensive, in-depth, debated, or based in real archaeology as Biblical academia is, nor is there anywhere near as much of it available. Heck, we have 2 different (generally very active) biblical academic subreddits, yet none for Hinduism or Buddhism.

Is it largely due to a fundamental difference between the scriptures of the Dharmic and Abrahamic faiths? Or is it simply a bias in that Christianity and Judaism in western academia is more relevant culturally and religiously (I believe a majority of Biblical academics are Christian) and so these are likely to be studied far more, and also have a larger history of study behind them?

Thanks in advance for any answers.

3 Answers 2020-06-20

Why did Churchhill believe that a focus on the Mediterranean instead of the French northern coast would best deal with the expansion of the Soviet union?

I am watching the Battlefield series and I’m currently on the episode: “The Battle of Normandy” and this statement is made. It is not expounded upon. Why did Churchill believe that the invasion of Italy was more important to dealing with the future of the Soviet union?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

What kind of manuscripts did monks copy?

Was it religious texts only or did they also read and write about science, history, geography,..?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

A statue of Albert Pike was toppled in Washington DC last night. Who was this guy?

I read his wikipedia page and a short article on the Smithsonian, but that just left me more curious. Was he a slave owner? Did he support the cause of slavery? Was he more motivated by his work with Native Americans?

What's up with this guy?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

During the French Revolution, there peasants and “commoners” who supported the king and the nobility? Were there nobles who supported the revolution? Why?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Did France play a major part in helping the American Revolution be successful for Americans?

Seeing a ton of social media posts about "Rah Rah Americans! We know how to kick ass in winning revolutions", I wanted to avoid being taken in by propaganda and make sure that something I did a project on back in middle school is actually true. Basically, it was that American soldiers at the time of the Revolution were very sloppy and ill-trained in warfare, especially compared to the British at the time who had all the military tactics. Then I believe it was Baron Von Stueben of the French military (I could be completely wrong on that part) stepped in and trained the soldiers under Washington's command to be able to fight back against the British army. How much am I accurately recalling?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Is the term Anglo-Saxon (or any study of similar scope) inherently racist or anachronistic? Should subjects that study Anglo-Saxons (or other studies of a similar nature) change or not exist at all?

A while ago I decided to look up information about the Anglo-Saxons and was surprised to find this article from a while back.

It makes quite a few claims that surprised me and I’m not sure what to make of them. Apparently Anglo-Saxon as a term or as a discipline of study is inherently racist and anachronistic.

I’ve used the term Anglo-Saxon in the past. Was it racist or a-historical to do so? Should departments like ASNAC (and apparently AMES?) not exist in the first place?

2 Answers 2020-06-20

I am a Christian during the 14th century, before the publication of Dante's inferno. What was the common belief regarding heaven/hell during that epoch

I've recently read that the concept of heaven was adapted by the early Catholic church from the concept of Elysium, whereas in the Bible it states only entry to "the kingdom of God".

Is the perception of heaven during for christianity wholly due to the Roman pantheon's influence and then appended by Dante's works?

Where does the concept of hell stem from? Is it a biblical concept or was it also adapted by the church somehow?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

How do historians retain so much information?

I'm thinking about going back to school and finishing my history degree. I've done a lot of recreational reading of history books throughout the years. I always stop to think about things while reading but after I finish a book I rarely can recall a single thing I'd learned while reading. Academics always seem like sponges that memorize everything they read.

26 Answers 2020-06-20

In Karl Marx's original idea of communism; is the individual rights of a human man incorporated?

In the history books we were taught that many if not most of so called "communist" governments do not have a good racket for human rights. It is well known that the Soviet Union would suppress many of its critics; even to the point of sending them to prison camps.

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Why didn’t Nazi Germany conquer the Middle East for oil instead of attacking Russia?

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Saturday Showcase | June 20, 2020

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Was the repression of homosexuality in Christian teachings a reaction to Roman sexual culture, which subjected slaves to the sexual domination of masters? It seems plausible that homophobic religion would appeal to male slaves humiliated and raped by their enslavers.

1 Answers 2020-06-20

Were the Nazis ever concerned about the brain drain of intellectuals fleeing Germany? Did they take any steps against it?

Or were they so convinced by their ‚Aryan supremacy‘ that they didn’t conceive of the utility of said fleeing intellectuals?

2 Answers 2020-06-20

Why didn't white South Africans (Afrikaners) make a separate all White country in the Cape area, when they had all of the power, right before they were made sure that the Apartheid regime would fall?

2 Answers 2020-06-20

1261 / 7255

Back to start