How did Switzerland and Liechtenstein manage to stay nutral in WW2?

Outside of the obvious hard to conquer due to being mountainious, how did both countries avoid getting involved in WW2. Both countries are german speaking or have segnificant german speaking populations, so knowing Nazi idiolgy I would assume Hitler would have considered them natural german land. Hitler also didnt seem to care about nutrality, for example he invaded Luxemburg. So how did both countries manage to stay out of the war?

1 Answers 2022-09-04

It turned out that the central thesis of Maines's Technology of Orgasm wasn't true. Has there been any more recent scholarship on the early history of the vibrator?

So the image of an oblivious physician masturbating a woman and not knowing anything sexual was going on has been debunked. But that leaves a lot of questions that I still have, especially about what vibrators were doing. Were there women's whisper networks like for abortifacients? I'm curious, but trying to look around even in scholarly databases all roads still lead to Maines. (And just using Google is... not helpful when trying to research the history of vibrators.)

1 Answers 2022-09-04

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 04, 2022

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2022-09-04

When did the trope of haunted/cursed Native American burial grounds start?

I’m reading Pet Semetary at the moment and was curious as to when the superstition around Native American burial grounds became a thing? How far back does it go? Was Pet Semetary instrumental in thrusting it into popular culture and American folk lore?

1 Answers 2022-09-04

How were people of other religions (Muslims,Jews etc.) treated in the Crusader states that formed after the First Crusade?

1 Answers 2022-09-04

The year is 1250. I am attending what will be known as the University of Cambridge. What am I likely studying and what does my day most likely look like?

2 Answers 2022-09-04

Following a post about the practicality of the 17 and 18 century armies uniforms, I found out about the importance of the camp followers. I'm curious on what happened with camp followers if an army was defeated or captured? Where there some (unwritten) rules on how they should have been treated?

1 Answers 2022-09-04

Paris was reportedly the largest city in Europe in the Middle Ages. In the 14th-15th century its population was 200,000, and higher than Constantinople. Why?

2 Answers 2022-09-04

In Ron Chernow’s biography of George Washington he comments that the crossing of the Delaware was especially treacherous for the continental army “since most of the soldiers couldn’t swim” (273). Is this true? When did learning to swim become commonplace and what lead to that cultural shift?

I would have thought that childhood in 17th and 18th century North America would have included the occasional dip in ponds and rivers and that swimming would have been more commonplace even back then.

1 Answers 2022-09-03

What's left of the mongols in europe?

Recently I've read quite a lot about the mongol empire and almost all texts mention the size of the empire at its peak, stretching from korea to vienna (or other places in central/eastern europe). I know that they didn't stay for long in europe and eventually retreated, but I'd like to ask how much mongol culture remained and/or wether any artifacts have been found. cheers

1 Answers 2022-09-03

How salient was the transition of the written language from Norwegian to Danish in post-reformation Norway?

I’m very interested in Norwegian language history, and the Reformation is commonly thought of as a watershed moment for written Norwegian, since it marks the end of the linguistic epoch conventionally known as Middle Norwegian and heralds the arrival of Danish as the official written language in Norway.

But lately I’ve been wondering to what extent that shift was actually noticeable among the literate population of Norway, since in all the reading I’ve done on this subject I’ve never once come across contemporary comments on the shift.

During the Reformation in Scotland, for instance, we see that the replacement of Catholic liturgical texts written in Scots by Protestant ones written in English was explicitly criticised by at least some members of the Scottish clergy. So what of the situation in Norway? Was the difference between written 16th century Danish and Norwegian so minuscule as to be imperceptible to the general public? Was the so-called infiltration of written Danish so gradual and sporadic that everyone simply failed to notice? Were there other political and/or cultural reasons at play? Or have I simply not been looking at the right sources?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Was disguising your ship during war common practice and was it seen as fair practice?

I recently watched Master & Commander and during their chase of the enemy they disguise themselves as a whaler. Was it common to do this, and was it seen as fair practice, particularly in this period of "gentlemenly" war.

1 Answers 2022-09-03

What was daily life like for the nobility in the crusader states?

Were there any major differences between the nobility in Outremer and in Europe due to different cultural influences?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Why is arms & equipment procurement so messy? How long has American military procurement been messy? Were people lamenting over (equivalent) billions spent on decades-long R&D programs only to result in minor incremental improvements & cancellations back in 1922?

... the same way they did and continue to do throughout the later 20th century to today?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

How much did borders matter in Europe in the Middle Ages?

Whenever I see old maps of Europe, they often look like this with hundreds of tiny states. How much did these borders actually impact things like travel, commerce, and communication?

2 Answers 2022-09-03

Why did the Praetorian Guard still exist after betraying the emperor numerous times?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

When French and English troops destroyed the Yuanmingyuan (Old Summer Palace) during the Second Opium War, which parts were damaged beyond repair and which parts were left untouched?

I am working on an alternate history short story which features the Qing Dynasty modernizing after Empress Dowager Cixi dies in 1875 due sickness (I'm pulling off a Schrödinger's cat scenario as she actually did get sick that year in the real timeline but didn't die). It's been a while since my past attempts to create the world if such a story but have started fleshing it out more thanks to a collaboration with u/Telemannische_Aias.

Lately, I've been thinking about the Yuanmingyaun and the idea of the Guangxu Emperor moving his official residency to there had been restored. I imagine the parts that were damaged beyond repair being rebuilt, but with more western style buildings. Obviously, Xiyang Lou would easily get fully restored to its former glory, but I'm talking more about the spots that were destroyed that had Chinese buildings. I read online that only 13 buildings survived intact, most of them in the remote areas or by the lakeside. Those buildings would later be destroyed by the Eight Nation Alliance in 1900 in the real timeline.

That being said, which parts of Yuanmingyuan were damaged beyond repair and which parts were left untouched after the Second Opium War? Feel free to mention the function of those destroyed areas.

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Was Magna Grecia a contemporary Toponym? How did the Greeks call Sicily and southern Italy or the other areas they settled?

I'm writing a novel about ancient Greeks settling in Italy Sicily and Libya. How would they call these areas? The novel also involves them going to Delphi to ask for advice about settling there. How would a city go about asking for such a divination? And would a typical divination of such nature be delivered?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

No American cities had police departments until 1854, how was crime handled in the 2 centuries before then?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

The Catholic Church Claims it is a direct continuation of Jesus' ministry, how accurate is this?

That is, did a disciple of Jesus found the organization that would later develop to the Roman Catholic Church?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

What was the experience traveling to Nazi Germany as an African American before the US was at war with them?

Let me be very clear here, I mean an African-American, and I mean before the war. There’s very little info on how tourism in Nazi Germany was (and for good reason), so I’m actually quite curious. I presume it’d be extremely racist, but I struggle to find any first-hand accounts.

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Do we know anything about Cyrus the Younger's Milesian concubine?

According to the Anabasis (at least in the edition I'm reading), Cyrus the Younger had two concubines*. One of them, a Phocaean, was taken by Artaxerxes II at Cunaxa and appears in a few other histories e.g. Plutarch. The other, a Milesian, is noted as escaping in quite daring fashion from Artaxerxes' forces and rendezvousing with the Greek rearguard defending the Cyrean baggage train.

But after that, she seems to disappear from the Anabasis. Do we know what happened to her? Did she accompany the Ten Thousand on the long march home, or break off and run elsewhere? For that matter; do we know her name? My guess is probably a resounding "no" to all of those questions - but I thought that if anyone would know, it would be this sub!

As an adjacent question: do we have a sense of what it might have been like to be a royal concubine at this time?

*Not sure if that's two chief concubines or if it was actually just two women.

1 Answers 2022-09-03

What’s the general scholarly consensus on the Rwandan “Double Genocide” theory/what’s the general scholarly consensus on RPF’s killings towards civilians, esp civilian Hutus?

I recently been reading up on the Rwandan Genocide and I’ve read about the “Double Genocide” theory which posits that there were two genocides in Rwanda in 1994, one against the Tutsis and one against Hutus.

Normally I’ll dismiss these types of theories because “Double Genocide” is very common refrain for genocide deniers but there seems to be some scholarly weight behind it with scholars Christian Davenport and Allan Stam who apparently worked for the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda supporting it(even stating the number of deaths between the two genocides were equal) and “In Praise of Blood” by Judi Rever also supporting the theory.

I’m not really sure what to think because on one hand, the RPF is known to have committed countless atrocities during the time period and most people don’t deny that, but it seems convenient for the worldview of Rwandan Génocidaires for there to be two genocides of equal weight.

So with that being said, what’s the scholarly consensus on this theory and RPF atrocities against civilians, esp Hutu civilians?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Did Sparta, at its height, have an especially effective military?

I am having a discussion with someone who claims they had a mediocre military that lost more than it won, even at its peak. This seems unlikely to me and is inconsistent with the Wikipedia article on Sparta.

Is there a consensus among historians on whether Sparta’s military was especially good, at its peak?

1 Answers 2022-09-03

Do you believe the historical text you research with 100% certainty, or are you always skeptical of text being falsified to some extent? Do you choose what to believe/disbelieve based on your interests?

First of all, I’m sorry if this makes me sound ignorant or naive.

How many of you out there believe historical literature to be true?

I find it hard to believe that historical and political text no matter how old has been falsified to some extent… and this makes it hard for me to believe in any of it. Like any time I am to do any type of historical research I take it with a grain of salt… knowing, that to some extent this text is falsified.

When I’m doing research or reading how can I look back and allow myself to believe ? Or be less skeptical?

Edit 1: grammar 🤓

1 Answers 2022-09-03

133 / 7255

Back to start