What did knights do?

Towards the end of the Early Middle Ages and beginning of the High Middle Ages, what would a knight spend their time doing? Specifically a knight who wasn't born into nobility and had been knighted for their bravery?

Edit: Also, do they have someone to "report" to?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

North and South Korea's autonyms are Choson and Hanguk respectively, despite claiming legitimate rule over the same nation and geographical region. Why the difference? How and why did each country choose each name?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

How brutal were the Vikings really and were they really the superior and more fierce warriors than the English?

Did they really mindlessly murder and rape everything they came across or was this exaggerated by the English perspective?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

How were indigenous communities near the Arctic Circle affected by post-Columbus transmission of germs, foodstuffs, technology, etc?

I’m more so curious about the epidemiological aspects of New World-Old World transmission as I have never read much about its effect on Arctic natives. I’d be interested to learn more about how their experiences may have aligned/contrasted with those of other indigenous communities through the Americas

1 Answers 2020-05-11

How much was WWII actually about the Holocaust? In school I was told that the Allies "had to stop the holocaust," but also afaik most countries waited until the war was a threat to them before joining. Was this a narrative that was added after the fact? Or did it influence the war much at the time?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

What kind of boat is the boat in Rembrandt's "Storm on the Sea of Galilee"? It looks. . . odd.

This is (or maybe was, sadly) a famous painting, but I haven't been able to find anyone else who thinks the boat looks strange.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Storm_on_the_Sea_of_Galilee

At first glance, it looks like the front of the boat is to the left and the back is to the right, as there are little pointed prow-like ends there. But no, the mast is off to one side. So apparently the back half of the boat is a sort of semi-circular design, then there's this irregular bit that sticks out in front, where the mast is. But the front looks almost unfinished, more like rocks than the front of a boat. The overall design seems roughly triangular, with those pointed bits sticking off to the side. And the mast still looks off-center to me.

I've never heard of a boat that looked like that. Were there any such designs in the seventeenth century Netherlands, or maybe in Roman Palestine? Can someone find me a clearer picture of what this boat might have looked like? Or had Rembrandt somehow just never seen a boat before when he went to paint this?

I've been googling this and found nothing, so I wanted there to be at least some record on the internet of someone asking this question.

Edit: Here's a drawing in the Wellcome Collection, based on the painting, where the boat can be seen a little more clearly, and it looks even more odd: https://wellcomecollection.org/works/u3etf9s9

1 Answers 2020-05-11

To what degree did those in South Vietnam outside of the government support the Vietnam War and the establishment of a non-communist state? In addition, would it be accurate to characterize the government of South Vietnam as a puppet dictatorship?

I'm not sure how accurate this is, but my current perception of the Vietnam War is essentially that of the US seeing the Vietnamese people democratically choosing a communist government and intervening in their affairs solely due to fear of spreading communism. This led to a war that was completely unsupported by the Vietnamese outside of the extreme minority and officials in Diem's government, which was essentially a puppet dictatorship -- that is, conflict in Vietnam began as an anti-imperialist war against the French, after which the country would have peacefully established an independent government that would have happened to be communist, but the US took over for the French and began a brutal aggressive war for the sake of "saving the Vietnamese from themselves." This position is mostly based on

  • (a): Eisenhower stating that 80% or more of the Vietnamese public would have supported a communist government, and

  • (b): The fact that Diem's puppet state was brutally authoritarian and repressive, and maintained its power only because of consistent US support.

Due to this view, am I being unfair in characterizing the South Vietnamese government and military essentially in the same bin as Vichy France in WWII? Clearly the Vichy regime did include officials and soldiers who were French, but the vast, vast, vas majority of the population was awaiting liberation from the occupying Nazis, and those who worked with the Vichy government and army were merely collaborationists and essentially traitors working with an occupying power -- wouldn't the same apply to the South Vietnamese, who were essentially fighting on the side of an invading imperialist power against their own nation's right to self-determination?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

In the movie Lincoln (2012), Lincoln tells Alexander Stephens of the inevitability of slavery's abolition, mentioning that even some Southern state's will ratify the 13th Amendment. Stephens resignedly says "Tennessee and Louisiana" almost immediately. Why these states?

Additionally, did something similar to this exchange actually take place? Were Tennessee and Louisiana (and Arkansas, which Lincoln mentions) easily identifiable as those most amenable to Union terms?

The exchange in question, for those curious.

2 Answers 2020-05-11

What happened to monks after the printing press?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

According to the perfume section of Scents and Flavors, a 13th century cookbook, musk would be kneaded with tragacanth to "form into apple shapes". How were things like this "solid" used as a perfume?

The cookbook hints at radically different ways of using perfume but is (as much as possible) an exact translation so is missing context to the perfume section (well... and all other sections).

In a similar vein, is Al-Kinfi's “The Chemistry of Perfumes and Distillations" available in English translation? Articles reference it as being widely used so I expect it survives but I keep hitting dead ends.

1 Answers 2020-05-11

Why didn't the British modernise the Brodie helmet design very much in World War 2?

The British Brodie helmet was used in World War 1 as its shape was good for deflecting shrapnel and loose material from causing head injuries for the Brits in the trenches. It obviously had a good design and use in World War 1, but trench warfare was obviously much less widespread during World War 2. The Brits were one of the longest fighting nations in the war, fighting from 1939 - 1945, so time wasn't a factor to its lack in design change.

Why is this? I had always assumed it was to keep costs low, as the war had a great impact on Britain's economy. For example, the Brits decided to stop importing the American Thompson SMG and instead invested in the less reliable and less well performing STEN gun due to its lower cost and ease of production. With the Germans offering an obviously superior design with the Stahlhelm inspiration couldn't have been a factor, so it's always somewhat puzzled me.

2 Answers 2020-05-11

What did a tercio actually look like in battle?

A lot of the depictions of pike-and-shot warfare from the time (see, for instance the images from the Wikipedia articles for the First and Second Battles of Breitenfeld) show tercios deployed in line, almost shoulder to shoulder, trading musketry with their Swedish/Protestant League opposition. Other images (such as this from Lutzen) show them deployed in a checkerboard formation, though still very close to each other, and other engravings from the same battle show them deployed into line by the time that they have closed with the enemy.

I have read before that the tercio would be deployed in a checkerboard formation with 200 or 300 metres between formations, but none of the engravings and illustrations I have seen show anything close to that. Is this a case of artists creating more dramatic images, or choosing to portray the feeling of a battle rather a reality? Were there actually gaps on an Early Modern battlefield large enough for pike blocks to conceivably miss each other and drive straight on through, assuming that the skirmishers and officers let them do so?

3 Answers 2020-05-11

What happened to Old Zealand?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

Why is it that in Civil War movies, General Lee wears (Confederate) Colonel ranks while other Confederate Generals wear different ranks?

So I’m currently watching Gettysburg and General Robert E. Lee is wearing three gold stars, which is the Confederate equivalent of a Colonel. However, other Generals like Picket or Longstreet are shown wearing a much more elaborate General rank, with three gold stars covered in a gold wreath.

Also, how come the Confederate officers have such a varying wardrobe of uniforms? Some guys are wearing pretty elaborate fancy uniforms with a dress-like coat over it along with two rows of buttons while others are wearing either a single or two sets of gold buttons. Why do many different uniform types?

So what gives? What’s the deal here?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

How did book binding evolve during the early modern period?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

When and why did it become mandatory for kids to go to school?

1 Answers 2020-05-11

Looking for articles and books that are about/or/ include sections on ancient egyptian jewelry

Hi! I’m wondering if anyone has some links or knows some sources that they can pass along about Ancient Egyptian Jewelry, I’m writing an art history paper about the evolution of jewelry in ancient Egypt and its use as evidence of the culture’s evolution through time. Using my university’s article search I only seem to find a couple tidbits about specific pharaonic funerary goods, etc. Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2020-05-10

[Indian/Mughal Food History] In Mexican history, wheat was expensive due to the crops sensitivity to the climate, and was associated with the rich, the general population would eat corn tortillas. Though it seems in Indian history, wheat roti was the standard, was wheat not expensive there?

Traditionally in Mexico and much of the South Americas, tortillas were made out of corn flour, it wasn't until European colonialists introduced wheat to their lands that wheat flour tortillas became a thing, yet still it wasn't common amongst its population as due to wheat crops needing more attention being more sensitive to the climate conditions, it was quite expensive and more commonly dined on by the rich and elites. Corn/maize was always easy to grow, and thus cheaper, more common, was largely used by the common folk to make their tortillas.

In Indian culture it seems like wheat roti/paratha/breads were always the standard. Even though wheat seems more native to Asia, wasn't it still expensive to cultivate, assuming similar climates to what was in Mexico at the time? Indian breads are also made from lentil flours and rice flour, how widespread were these?

1 Answers 2020-05-10

The King's Court's duties

I was just watching an episode of The Tudors and there was a scene where Edward Stafford, Duke of Buckingham, holds a bowl for King Henry to wash his hands in then is dismissed.

Was this a common thing? For lesser nobility to wait on the King?

Are ladies-in-waiting a similar thing for the queen?

1 Answers 2020-05-10

Looking for Books on the middle ages

What are some good books covering the middle ages specifying on western history?

1 Answers 2020-05-10

Did vikings sing sea shanties?

Asking for uhh a friend.

1 Answers 2020-05-10

I was reading Assassin's Creed Odyssey novel lately and there was a moment where ship's captain Barnabas and his crew hid Adrestia (their ship) underwater in some lagoon. Was that technique of hiding ships real and is mentioned somewhere or is it just fiction?

1 Answers 2020-05-10

How were cannons secured on age of sail warships?

I always wondered but nothing came to mind, all the cannons i've seen on age of sail warships are on wheels so when they are fired, it would make sense the recoil pushes them back.I'm guessing this isnt the case because then the cannons could just roll around the ship if it was in an awkward angle.Then i thought maybe they were tied around the gunports but then the recoil could potentionally break some of the boards.Please explain this i can't live without knowing it.

1 Answers 2020-05-10

According to Yale History Prof. Paul Freedman, Romans were 50% Christian by 337 and 90% Christian by 390. Is this at all accurate?

In this YouTube lecture at 22:00, I was astonished to hear Freedman state the following:

Not only were 50% of the people, perhaps, Christian by 337 when Constantine died, but by 390, the time of the emperor, Theodocius, and his death 395, probably 90% of the population was at least nominally Christian.

It's my understanding that Christians remained a minority for some time after Constantine. Is Freedman correct? Where is he getting these figures?

3 Answers 2020-05-10

Did Han China encounter any noticeable economic shifts due to the collapse of the Western Roman Empire?

I know that the two states seldom interacted directly with one another but they were both integral points on the Silk Road

1 Answers 2020-05-10

1345 / 7255

Back to start