How valid is the claim that the Pacific War dragged on because Japan wanted to keep their Emperor but the allies refused? Also, what is it with the Americans' decision to spare Emperor Hirohito?

1 Answers 2020-03-16

The Marginalized Historians Floating Feature: A special feature to highlight contributions from historians who identify as members of marginalized groups or minorities

2 Answers 2020-03-16

The Resistance and Anti-Colonial Histories Floating Feature: An open thread to highlight the stories and histories of resistance and anti-colonial opposition

5 Answers 2020-03-16

The Migrant and Diaspora Histories Floating Feature: An open thread for all to share the stories and histories of migrants and displaced persons from all times and places

2 Answers 2020-03-16

The Histories of Religious Minorities Floating Feature: A thread for all contributors to highlight the incredible histories of religious minorities through the ages!

5 Answers 2020-03-16

The Histories of Enslaved People Floating Feature: A space to give voice to the histories of enslaved people throughout time and space

5 Answers 2020-03-16

Upon King Charles II of Spain's death, the coroner reported many medical irregularities. Were these meant to be taken literally?

"His heart did not contain a single drop of blood, it was the size of a peppercorn; his lungs corroded; his intestines rotten and gangrenous; he had a single testicle, black as coal, and his head was full of water." Are any of these legitimate medical conditions that would be possible?

1 Answers 2020-03-16

The Gender Histories Floating Feature: An open thread that welcomes contributions from everyone on the histories of gender

7 Answers 2020-03-16

The Global Southern Histories Floating Feature: A thread open to all contributors to tell the histories of the Global South

3 Answers 2020-03-16

The Children’s Histories Floating Feature: A open feature to tell the histories of children through time

5 Answers 2020-03-16

The Histories in All Languages Floating Feature: A special feature which welcomes non-English contributions on any history you feel like sharing!

3 Answers 2020-03-16

Is the development of the modern clown (clumsy, big lips) related at all to racial stereotyping/minstrel shows?

1 Answers 2020-03-16

Was there any serious opposition to the introduction of breech-loading cartridge rifles in the European and American armies of the 1860s?

1 Answers 2020-03-16

Why did it take so long, till Steel helmets got introduced?

In 1897 the French Canon de 75 modèle 1897 appeared. This gun is considered to be the first "real" modern piece of artillery and was capable of firing shrapnel, as well as high explosive bullets. Yet it took another 18 year till the first Steel helmets hit the field.

Why did it take so long to come up with a way of protecting the heads of the soldiers from artillery fragments? Was there simply no need for said way of protection before WW1?

2 Answers 2020-03-15

How come during the 18th and 19th centuries more cavalrymen used swords than lances compared to the Renaissance or Medieval era?

I was looking at some pictures and I noticed that lots of Napoleonic dragoons and cuirassiers just used swords while only some regiments had lances. Why was this, when armored knights armed with large lances dominated earlier battlefields?

2 Answers 2020-03-15

How did one prove citizenship in the ancient world, specifically in Roman territory?

Acts 22 sees Paul about to be scourged by Roman soldiers until Paul interjects that it is unlawful for a Roman citizen to be scourged. The soldiers and tribunes seemingly take only Paul’s word, at least that is all that is mentioned in the text, on the matter and immediately cease with his punishment, for fear of punishment themselves.

Paul was obviously a learned man, able to write and speak Greek, but he was also a Jew in Roman territory, just like the crowd which initially got him almost scourged. The swiftness with which the Roman soldiers attempt to scourge him suggests that they naturally assumed he wouldn’t be a Roman citizen.

How did one prove citizenship in such situations? Are there other examples beside the Acts of the Apostles that we can go off of?

1 Answers 2020-03-15

Did Alexander the Great and Diogenes really know each other? Is it true that Diogenes told Alexander: "move, you are casting a shadow" as a reply for "what can I do for you"?

1 Answers 2020-03-15

In 1916, Charles Evans Hughes resigned from the Supreme Court to run for president against Woodrow Wilson. How was this viewed, through the lens of judicial independence?

Was this seen as normal? Did it cause any concern about politicization of the court system?

1 Answers 2020-03-15

Why did the idea of Pan-Asianism fail?

From what I understand the idea of Pan-Asianism was adopted in the early 20th century by key Japanese figures in an attempt to "unify" Asian countries against the influence of the west, essentially the white race. As an ideal it sounds pretty interesting to remove colonial rule over China, India, and the rest of South East Asia. Japan had proved itself as a Asian powerhouse of the time especially after it's war with Russia, so it makes sense that they would want to "lead" something like this. So what went wrong, and why did other Asian countries not want to join Japan?

I also looked at this post that discusses Japan coming to war with the US during WW2. This is the first time I've heard of Pan-Asianism, so please correct me where I'm wrong and provide resources for me to learn.

1 Answers 2020-03-15

I am a wealthy Roman Knight in the late republican period. What was my estate like? How much land did I own? What kinds of buildings/fixtures would you find on my land? Did I have any economic/agricultural/educational activity take place on my estate? Who lived and worked on my estate?

Additional questions: -Did I have a dedicated ‘staff’ that supervised specific aspects of the estate?

-Did I have an appointed individual who would manage my estate when I was off fighting or traveling?

-Would I ever consider hosting public cultural or religious events with large numbers of lower-class attendees?

-Did I muster or train recruits on my estate?

1 Answers 2020-03-15

How well did Oda Nobunaga treat Japanese Christians?

I was doing a bit of research on the Sengoku Era and found this forum post that paints Oda Nobunaga as a sort of forward-thinking Japanese savior who was done in by the Buddhist hierarchy of the time who went on to hunt down Japanese Christians. They seem to posit that Nobunaga's Japan would've been a relative utopia and that his massacre on Mt. Hiei was necessary for this revolution. While I understand that a lot of Nobunaga's most infamous deeds are often exaggerated in Japanese fiction, this seemed a bit embellished too, so I have to ask, is this characterization of Oda Nobunaga accurate?

Source: http://hispanismo.org/english/15681-oda-nobunaga-visionary-who-open-christianity-16th-century.html

1 Answers 2020-03-15

When we find a piece of intact ancient pottery, would it typically have been a special piece that was treasured by the culture, or would it have been the average Joe's cheap flour pot that just happens to have survived?

1 Answers 2020-03-15

Why are Jews so widely prosecuted throughout history? What happened at the very beginning?

2 Answers 2020-03-15

What would be in and around a medieval port?

Hello everyone, like the title suggests I am trying to find out what type of buildings and facilities would be in and around a medieval port.

This is just for a (not so) little Minecraft build of a town but if you're just here to answer the title I am more than happy to hear your response.

I also have a building that had two floors, the first has a area with desks that will be the place where people pay for port space and all and the second floor lyes empty. The floors can be swapped.

I would be happy to hear all of your suggestions/input.

P.s. I'm new to reddit, if this is in the wrong subreddit please point me the right way. This post doesn't seem to be allowed in ask reddit

1 Answers 2020-03-15

If you compare the list of top US universities in 1920 to the list today, it’s completely the same except for the addition of California. What factors have stopped newer universities from rising to the top?

2 Answers 2020-03-15

1462 / 7255

Back to start