What were some common explanations for Static electricity before the discovery of how it actually worked? Especially curious about how it was explained with domestic cats.

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Was the Asterix' village actually in France?

Hi everybody, I hope today is a nice day for you. I'm currently working for a Belgian comics publishing house, and my boss asked me to investigate about a rumor he heard: It says that "the village of Asterix and Obelix", so a little village that was able to resist Roman's assaults for a very long time while all other villages eventually felt, actually existed but was located in Spain instead of France. In addition, according to this rumor, Goscinny and Uderzo would have "copied/taken" the base for their story from another comic/book that talked about the same Spanish village mentioned above. Does anyone have any information about this rumor, or about any "real" inspiration that led the authors to create this comic? Every information will be useful, thank you very much for your time

1 Answers 2020-03-05

An heir for Elizabeth I

I was wondering. As Elizabeth had no heir, nor planned to provide one, why did she not accept Mary Queen of Scots as her heir? It would have saved a lot of bother and it was still the Tudor line through Henry VIII sister. Did she have other plans? Or was it that if she accepted she opened herself up to assassins and plots?

2 Answers 2020-03-05

Did the Confederacy ever have a plan to annex Maryland or its Eastern Shore?

Obviously the main goal was to secede, but Maryland, being a slave owning state with many confederate sympathizers, remaining in the Union, had to aggravate the CSA, right? With Lee's army marching as far north as Gettysburg, was there ever a discussion as to if secession was solidified, that an attempt to invade and annex Maryland or parts of it with large slave populations like the Eastern Shore would be made?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Chernobyl: Conspiracy or Tragedy?

On 26 April 1986, the world witnessed the worst disaster in nuclear power generation’s history.

- Reactor no. 4 of the Chernobyl nuclear power plant (Ukraine) observed an immense power surge.

- Resulting in the build-up of pressure.

- Blowing off the concrete roof.

- Releasing radiation particles in the atmosphere.

Many conspiracy theories have surfaced behind the actual cause of the explosion. Any expert insights?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

During and immediately after WW2, military leaders like MacArthur and Zhukov had major influence within the governments of the United States and the Soviet Union. Did this have any impact on the aggressive, confrontational, militarized nature of the early Cold War?

Reading about North Korea's famous songbun policy of the military's power over civilian government made me wonder if there were any parallels with allied governments at the eve of the Cold War.

2 Answers 2020-03-05

Why did a thriving rock music scene emerge in Cambodia of all places during the 60s and 70s? Did South Vietnam and Laos also experience a similar music boom during the same period, particularly from US exposure?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

On the acquisition of nuclear weapons during World War II by imperial Japan and Nazi Germany

I've heard it said that the Japanese were relatively further ahead in their own nuclear program at least in terms of fully fleshed out theory and some of the mechanics than that of Nazi Germany mostly due to greater establishment support compared to the "Jewish physics" that the Germans at least originally viewed it as.

Is it true that they were and if so by what margin were they?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Were records about jews in Russia destroyed during/after the bolshevik revolution?

My great grandparents escaped persecution while the Czar was still in power. I want to learn more about them and there ancestors but my mom told me all records about jews were destroyed.

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Why was the sun often depicted with a face in the Middle Ages and Renaissance?

I've been reading the book Cosmigraphics by Michael Benson which goes over the history of depicting space, and as I'm nearing the end it's really striking to me how so many Western depictions of the sun give it a face.

Here's an example by Andreas Cellarius: https://publicdomainreview.org/collection/the-celestial-atlas-of-andreas-cellarius-1660

I find this very mysterious. From what I can tell, none of these things mention the sun being any kind of character or being. I've never seen one of these suns talking or anything. So why does it have a face?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Where there any demons or monsters in the Aztec or Maya belief system?

1 Answers 2020-03-05

Could Germany invade England in WWII?

I understand the Luftwaffe could not destroy the RAF. But could the Luftwaffe provide adequate air cover for German landing boats?

Am I misunderstanding how easily RAF could sink German landing ships?

2 Answers 2020-03-05

In a lecture given to the Institute for Advanced Study Kotkin claimed that David Glantz has vastly exaggerated the success of the Red Army during the war and that it fought poorly. Who is correct?

Link to the lecture.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NV-hq2akCQ&t=25s

Glatz is obviously a historian of war focusing on WW2 so he probably knows what he's talking about.

But Stephen Kotkin probably knows more about Stalin than any western historian so...

Who is correct?

2 Answers 2020-03-04

BETA Test: AskHistorians Mass Messager and Weekly Round-Up

Hello /r/AskHistorians!

We are pleased to be testing out the Mass Mailer feature for a new /r/AskHistorians Weekly Round-Up. This is a new Beta feature that the site Admins have been kind enough to allow us to be involved in the testing of. This being the first second test, we really want to hear your feedback on what you would like to see this feature look like in the future. Not everyone got the mailer, as it is an A/B test, butt we welcome feedback from everyone!

We have a brief survey which you can find here that we would greatly appreciate participation on, and also please consider weighing in here in the thread to offer your feedback and discuss things further! If you really don't want to recieve this though, there is a link to opt-out, while remaining subscribed to the subreddit, at the bottom of the message you received.


A Recap of AskHistorians 2020-02-25 to 2020-03-03

Popular This Week: You might have clicked too early, so here are the responses to some of the most upvoted questions from the past week:

Things You Probably Missed: Great stuff flies under the radar every week! Here is a selection of responses the Mod Team enjoyed, but didn't get the attention they deserved:

Features You Might Have Missed:

Features Coming Up:

For more great content of the past week, don't forget to check out the most recent Sunday Digest as well!


Again, this is a new feature that we are only just starting to test out. How it is tweaked and changed depends on what we hear back from you. We want to know how this feature can better serve our readership. Please participate in the survey, or this thread, to share your thoughts!

9 Answers 2020-03-04

were there any abolitionists in antiquity?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

What was political life in Macedon like while Alexander was campaigning in the East?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Did Russians actually walk through minefields in WW2?

When and where?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Roman use of spears in battle

I have always been under belief that over time Romans stopped using spears and instead switched to swords, with some groups like triarii using it longer. But I have gotten into argument with other person who believes that they used swords as only secondary weapons, that they instead of throwing all pilum away used the last one for close quarters combat. And as evidence they sent few Roman reliefs showing Romans using pilum. So I would like to ask which one of us is in the right

1 Answers 2020-03-04

How organised were large scale medivial open field battles?

Were there more often just big masses crashing against each other or was fighting in formation more common?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Were Zeppelins safer than airplanes in 1930s?

Hindenburg crossed the Atlantic 13 times if I'm correct, but They made it a huge deal when airplane crossed it.

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Need help with catalogue/database about Roman Achaean epigraphy

Hello everyone,

I'm writing a thesis on the imperial cult in Roman Achaea, but I can't seem to find any comprehensive overviews of epigraphic evidence of the region. The online datebase of Heidelberg gives some insights, but I still find it too random to use correctly (especially since most information can only be found in journals which require a subscription). With epigraphical evidence, I mean inscriptions, statues, etc. with Roman/Greek text.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-03-04

How did the British class system play out in term of enlistment during the First World War? And was there a social or cultural change after the war amongst ‘comrades in arms’ that transcended class boundaries.

Would working class and middle class men intermixed along the front? Did the upper class serve and if so were they the officer class, or would this have been below their social standing?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Are there any good books or articles about Lord Sidmouth’s spy network in Britain in the 1800s?

I was reading an article about the Cato Street Conspiracy and it mentioned Lord Sidmouth having a spy network that was almost as successful as Walsingham’s under Elizabeth I. I tried to do some basic research, but couldn’t really find much.

1 Answers 2020-03-04

First President of the US NOT Washington?

Today I found out Washington was technically not the first President of the United States, but was the first POTUS under the US Constitution. Why is it that John Hanson, the first US president, gets nearly no ink relative to Washington, et al, and why is he relatively seldom discussed? What makes him either not a "real" POTUS in the sense we think of today, or less relevant than Washington and his successors to the general American public?

1 Answers 2020-03-04

Automobile in 1902

I was hoping someone could help me with insight about the likely nature of the automobile described in a passage from the journals of Alfred Doten, dated April 10, 1902, Carson City, Nevada:

A locomobile from Reno, the first, belonging to O J Smith, or in his charge came to Carson this PM, via Virginia [City] – Created quite a sensation, being first ever seen here, at VA, or in Reno. Punctured a tire and had to lay up in front of Raycraft’s stable for repairs – Horseless carriage puts up at a horse stable – Returns to Reno tomorrow by direct route ...

Any insights about the possibilities in 1902 in the American West would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2020-03-04

1481 / 7255

Back to start