How did Colonial Empires economically Benefit from there colonies?

Like did The British Raj give a percentage of there income to Britain or the fact that India has a lot of cotton and because it was under imperial rule British factories could get cheaper prices?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Were spear shafts ever made of anything other than wood?

So I'm a writer, and as a bit of a challenge to myself I'm working on a story involving a society where there are no available trees. In some cases there are alternative resources that can be used where wood would be (coal for fire, bone for handles), but one sticking point I keep hitting is the spear. Basically every society on Earth developed the spear at some point, but did any society ever develop spears made of something other than wood?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Latin America had multiple revolutionary groups and movements; however, why did only Cuba and Nicaragua succeed in overthrowing their governments?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

African historians of African history

I was looking at the Introduction to African history course at SOAS and all the books recommended were by white men. Are there any good introductions to African history that are by actual Africans?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

The Imperial Japanese Army has a reputation of being brutal in the period leading up to and during the Second World War (including the Second Sino-Japanese War), but is there any record of cruelty in the wars fought earlier (eg. First Sino-Japanese War, Russo-Japanese War)?

I have recently done some reading on the International Military Tribunal for the Far East as well as the individual participation of Japanese generals and officers in either sanctioning or initiating particularly brutal practices towards PoWs and civilians in occupied territories. However, I am curious to know whether this extreme harshness that the I.J.A. is largely remembered for today is unique to its conflicts from the 1930s onwards, or whether they had a history of poor treatment prisoners and subjects in previous wars.

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Why were the British able to beat the Qing so badly?

I’m currently doing some reading on the Qing and China in general during the early modern period and one thing that I feel isn’t really explained enough about China is how they began their decline. Obvious the end began when the British began the opium wars opening China up and forcing the unequal treaties, but also from what I’ve read China was a self sufficient hegemon of East Asia, they limited trade because they had all they needed and had no need of western goods. What cause a century’s old dynasty like the Qing to be in a state during the middle of the 19th century where the best defense again British steam warships was wooden war junks (An analogy I’m using to represent Qing China as a whole seemingly being far behind the British in technology and strength).

Edit: also if you have any good sources for info on China, specifically of China and Chinese politics from the beginning of the 19th century up to the Second World War Id really appreciate it.

1 Answers 2020-02-27

When did the terms "Mohammedan " and "the Mohammedan religion" get replaced by "Muslim" and "Islam"?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

What were the conditions of the Nazi POW camp Stalag Luft I ?

Hello AskHistorians, I've been doing research on my grandfather who flew in the Air Force during World War II, he was shot down and captured in Germany sometime in 1943, and he was held as a POW in the prison camp Stalag Luft I.

I am curious about the treatment of the prisoners there, and if there are any resources I can look into to find firsthand accounts of others who may have been held at the camp during the time my grandfather was there. Thank you in advance for any information you can provide

1 Answers 2020-02-27

I'm a married woman in Civil War America. I live with my husband in Virginia while my parents live in Maryland. How easy would it be for me to travel freely between the Union and the Confederacy?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Is the bible reliable?

Can the bible be considered an historical source for Jesus? Is it a trusthworthy source?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | February 27, 2020

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

8 Answers 2020-02-27

Why did (some) royal mistresses such as Madame de Pompadour wield so much power that they were likened to Prime Ministers at times?

What I'm talking about:

Through her position as court favourite Pompadour wielded considerable power and influence; she was elevated on 12 October 1752, to duchess and in 1756 to lady-in-waiting to the queen, the most noble rank possible for a woman at court. Pompadour effectively played the role of PRIME MINISTER, becoming responsible for appointing advancements, favors, and dismissals, and contributing in domestic and foreign politics.[20]

The royal consort (the Queen) was sent there by some other royal/noble family to gain influence in France (maybe I'm wrong?), so if a random woman that the King fell in love with, can just supplant the consort and many times, have even more influence than her, why would anyone want to send their daughter to the king?

In the first place, why did the king and the court at large, permit the mistress to have so much power? France was pretty sexist, even at the time, no? The Salic Law and whatnot. So why was a woman that was not even a royal consort, and (sometimes) not even of noble birth, allowed to act almost like a PM?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Did Roman citizens in far flung colonia still vote during the Republican period? If so, how would the geographic challenge be met?

I’m a newly retired citizen soldier born in Rome and I retired to a colonia in Eastern Iberia in 190 BC. Do I still vote? Do I have any civic involvement in the wider Roman state aside from that in my own colonia? If so, how would my votes be cast?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Serfs and slavery in Middle Age England - Who did the manual work post the Black Death?

My understanding of this topic is extremely limited to what I learnt in early senior school and I saw a comment somewhere that caused me to question what I had been taught.

The version of history in England I was taught - that I now recognise was probably massively simplified - was that prior to the Black Death (so circa 1200 on) your average peasant was a serf who lived on a noble's land and was basically indentured to live there and work for the noble his or her whole life, a kind of slavery. The Black Death happened and as a result, the workforce reduced by huge numbers and suddenly the workers held much more economic power than before and were able to dictate wages and living conditions to a much greater extent than before and improved conditions and lives.

But my knowledge stops there and never really picks up. I'm aware that there were slaves in England later on, but it occurred to me that if your average Englishman was dictating his wages and rights, there must have been a requirement for cheap manual labour still, and this surely came from somewhere? Was this slavery - of 'foreigners', or Englishmen? Was the Black Death really as revolutionary as I was taught?

Thank you for any answers!

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Was Early Modern African Cavalry Financed By The Slave Trade?

In one of those perennial "I read it on wikipedia" bits, the claim was made that:

States like Dagoma in northern Ghana, Nupe and the Yoruba kingdom of Oyo in Nigeria were very dependent on imports of horses, usually financed by the sale of slaves.

With the explanation that horses had to be imported because of difficulties breeding and losses to tsetse flies. This would be during the period of the slave trade with Europe and the Americas, so I'm curious if this was a "fourth angle" of the Triangular Trade. But is this an accurate assessment? Were human beings sold in part to finance equestrian pursuits in Europe?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

When did the presumption that men should have short hair and women should have long hair come about??

1 Answers 2020-02-27

How powerful were translators during ancient, medieval or early modern times?

Theoretically, they could influence politics greatly by deciding what and how to translate.

3 Answers 2020-02-27

European interference in China has often been cited to explain not only why the Taiping Rebellion took place, but also why it was so protracted. But how far back ought we to trace this history? Is it sufficient to consider the impact of the Opium Wars, or must we go back further than the 1840s?

I've never felt entirely happy about the strong focus on opium in the histories I've read. How significant were attempts to introduce Christianity, and general disruption to life in the coastal provinces caused by the development of European trade? Did British and French interference exacerbate much older tensions within China?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

How many art/artifacts in museums are the real deal?

Sorry if this is the wrong sub, not sure where else to put it.

I recently visited Museo Soumaya in Mexico City, which made me think: Are all these pieces the real deal? Someone could just destroy the piece easily..

So is everything in a museum a replica, or are there genuine pieces that are displayed inches away from public without glass in between us?

3 Answers 2020-02-27

I’m a Medieval English peasant. How much am I concerned with personal hygiene?

I keep seeing the film trope of the peasant covered in filth, apparently fine with it. However in my own life I am disgusted by unclean habits and smells, from myself and other people. Would a peasant be ok with it or are the “dirty peasant” tropes exaggerated?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Any sources for reading about CIA, NSA, or just secret intellegence over all? Good non fiction.

I am very interested in learning the goings on of intellegence agencies. Historical or current is fine with me

1 Answers 2020-02-27

In WW2 where exactly did Germany push through to France on the Ardennes?

Did they actually push through the forests and the large hills of the Ardennes “fabled” by the french impassible, or did they still go through the Ardennes but just by paved roads?

From what pictures I’ve seen the trees were quite old, so I don’t expect a Tank could blitzkrieg through there, and if it would it would give the French enough time to defend which is not what happened.

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Is it good to read older secondary sources to get a better idea of the historiography of a subject?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

In the film Flags of Our Fathers, a man falls overboard and it is stated that he will be left there as they could not stop the whole fleet. Was that an actual policy of the navy at the time?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Why is there so much focus on England in Medieval history?

When I say focus I am referring to the tendency in the United States (possibly other countries?) to not only use England as an example in history books, but also focuses on them quite a bit in media. The focus is so much on England, France, and the fighting against Islam that people hardly know any nations besides the two. The "Holy Roman Empire" and the Eastern Roman Empire are glossed over at best. Is this because of the common English language and culture? Did the English leave more documentation than most other nations? I am guessing the former since the later is not really true.

1 Answers 2020-02-27

1492 / 7255

Back to start