Might be a sensitive topic, but hopefully I can articulate this question adequately. When did the historical Judea/Palestine region shift in demographics of ethnic Jewish to Arab? How did Europe as a whole become such a diaspora of Jewish people?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Who really invented flight first?

I was reading history books as a kid and I remember this one thing that stuck with me, even until now, that was written in one of those books. It talked about how the Wright brothers actually met a man who had either already started building a working aircraft, or had already completed it (my memory is hazy). The Wright brothers then bought it and made it their own for a good while, until they finally released it with no mention of the help from this other man. I can’t seem to find any mention of this man. Even though there is a lot of debate on who really flew first, none of them match the description of this man. Does he even exist?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

What’s the historical consensus on Caesarian, son of Cleopatra? Was he really Caesar’s kid?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Why do so many greek myths feature individuals being changed into other objects or animals

I was reading through the metamorphoses and noticed that a fair amount of the myths have one of the characters being turned into either an object or an animal, examples being narcissis being changed into a flower and Io into a cow. Why was it that so many greek myths feature shapeshifting of some fashion? That is also to include the gods, who frequently change their form.

2 Answers 2020-02-28

I'm a 20 year old living in the crowded and polluted streets of London in the 1800s. There's filth and disease everywhere! Why do I choose to stay here? Why don't I move to the countryside and find work as a farmhand or maid? Surely it's better than London!?

2 Answers 2020-02-28

Did the empire of Japan ever have a chance to beat the USA in World War II?

Was Japan, especially the Navy, ever in a position to beat the US? Both at sea and in general?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

What new information about Toussaint L'Ouverture and the Haitian Revolution has come to light since C. L. R. James published "The Black Jacobins" in 1937?

My reading group discussed this book yesterday, and it came up that it's now considered outdated. The one detail that was brought up on that subject was the omission of the fact--possibly known even at the time of writing--that Toussaint was himself a slaveowner. I knew nothing about the the man or the revolution he helped lead before reading this book, so I'd like to know how the current understanding of him and the conflict differs from James's.

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How did the police in Nazi Germany operate?

It seems to me they were "federalized" to help in state surveillance and extermination actions, but I don't want to jump to conclusions. Sources and book recommendations would be nice.

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Friday Free-for-All | February 28, 2020

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

10 Answers 2020-02-28

Hi! I'm Dr. Megan Hunt, cultural historian of the civil rights movement. I study how your favourite films about civil rights have shaped how we understand the movement itself. I'm here to answer your questions about civil rights for Black History Month. AMA!

Hello everyone! I am Dr Megan Hunt, Teaching Fellow in American History at the University of Edinburgh. My interests are in the African American civil rights movement, and the American South more generally, as presented in educational materials and popular culture - particularly Hollywood film. I have written on films such as Selma, The Help, Mississippi Burning, and To Kill a Mockingbird, and am currently working on a book about civil rights, race, and religion in Hollywood cinema. I have also explored how civil rights is taught in the US and the UK, and the significance of educational standards to public memory of social activism. I am happy to answer questions on the movement itself or its representation in cinema/television and schools. I will be back to answer questions at 3pm GMT.

EDIT: Thank you so much for all of your questions! And I am very sorry that I have not been able to answer them all during the AMA.

35 Answers 2020-02-28

Why did the Nazis recruit little girls to distribute porn in Austria?

From A Life of Erwin Schrödinger page 236.

Early in 1938, portents of disaster appeared in Austria. AN intense auora lit up the sky so that in many districts fire alarms were sounded. The plague birds appeared in Vienna, albino sparrows with russet splotches like dried blood on their wings, and little girls were recruited by Nazis to distribute pornographic broadsheets to passers-by.

No citation.

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How did Russians not discover The America’s first?

I know Native Americans crossed over from Russia, but how did Russians (or whichever nation was in the Eastern most part of present day Russia) not sail to Alaska in the 4000+ years following? Even the Pacific Islanders managed to make it to Hawaii, so I can’t fathom Russia or Japan failing to explore to the northeast.

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How does peer review work for Historians? And some questions about the Lost Cause in that context. Possible mistake has been copied by different historians? And some more questions

Q1: How does peer review work for historians? Especially considering its inherently a social study, subjective, human based (both the studied and person doing the studying), interpretive discipline? There is a huge swath between negationism and requiring agreement with the orthodox narrative. It seems like there are threads on the evolution of science and peer review here, but nothing on peer review for history journals.

Q2: For some reason, it didn't occur to me that peer review for history journals existed until recently, like right about just now. I started doing research for a speech in my public speaking class, and my topic was on the alt-right and bad history (Lost Cause, the "flag" and the monuments), I joked that I would have gotten shot for this speech if I was in Texas but maybe not because of my skin tone (I'm of Chinese descent), and then I also realized that joke was probably a bit off-color, but didn't say anything because I had to give my speech. Reflecting upon my poor performance (I also made some mistakes I was warned about ahead of time, was quite incoherent and rambling, and took 10 minutes instead of the allocated 5 because I was ill prepared and didn't practice), I knew that Lost Causers had won in the school system, but this question hit me, "can the persistence of said beliefs (sorry if this breaks the 20 year rule, but if it does, then I'm only asking up to the limit) be attributed to the lack of understanding of peer review and lack of (public) access to proper historical resources?" I know the Lost Cause has been around for quite awhile due to people like Jubal Early and Jefferson Davis, but has it simply been that peer review hasn't been around long enough or hasn't diffused properly?

Q3: Also. I think I found a mistake, that might have spread to another author, but I have been unable to verify because I'm a poor college student, and the databases that I have access to don't include recent scholarship, which means you have to go to the academic journal itself and pay more money.. which I don't have, and I hope my school does have.

The Wikipedia articles are suspiciously close in the quotes, and according to the forum post, it looks like a mistake was made, first made by Blight (I even read one of his other articles in the research process and glanced through others, he seems quite credible), and another person copied his mistake, named Budiansky, which seems to have made its way to both Chernow's Grant and Egerton's Wars of Reconstruction. Am I wrong? Its possible maybe both Longstreet and Mosby felt the same way and said it in a similar wording that caused a mix-up?

https://civilwartalk.com/threads/longstreet-quote.120507/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Longstreet#cite_ref-FOOTNOTEChernow2017857_213-0

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_S._Mosby#cite_ref-74

Q4: Are books published separately not part of the print magazine peer reviewed?

Q5: I asked my communication professor who teaches my public speaking class in question this, but didn't get much of an answer (just saying use best judgment and keep in mind the parameters of your speech and that it just depends on the topic and length, but if you actually have to give a serious enough speech, it might be worth giving out a separate sheet of references), but how many sources is too much? See, I was outlining for my 5 minute speech, and I was unsure what to talk about, so I just started writing down thoughts, and then trying to make some coherent bullet points, and then just started typing and making sense of them. I actually broke some of the assignment rules on structure for the speech, but I ended up typing a 2.8k word monstrosity, which would have taken at least 30 minutes (if I speak at a normal pace, maybe 20 at a debater speed), and I had 35 sources. Not all of them were peer-reviewed works, but how do I know whats too much for the level of depth I can go into for a general undergraduate college audience? And how do I not misrepresent historians? Something tells me this is the exact problem science communicators have when it comes to climate change. In hindsight, I should have just discussed the bad history, and made a side-mention of the alt-right, and maybe cited a thorough search history from stormfront to show the prevalence of those beliefs.

PS. I was unsure what I wanted to major in, I ended up going Poly Sci (its really not a science, but I might open up the postmodernist critics of the (natural) sciences) since I want to become an attorney, and eventual politician, but I have too many interests, including history, so I apologize for asking so much. I just hope legal citations are not this complicated, good thing all opinions are in public domain and free.

Edit 1:

Q6: this thread here: https://civilwartalk.com/threads/counting-the-confederate-service-records-of-black-and-mulatto-men.142783/, actually does appear to have a list of the thing that I've seen claimed as a myth. I don't have an account, (because I've been busy and I don't want to read through another TOS and PP, sorry I'm a privacy pidgeon, I would but I don't have time) so I can't look through the evidence. Judging from their first page that describes the requirements/methodology, it seems that this is legit.

Regarding the methodology, right from the post

" If desired, additional information related to the individual, such as US Census records, Freedmen’s Bureau records, and USCT records may be posted in addition to at least one of the specified types of documentation/evidence.

Acceptable types of documentation/evidence:

  • roster
  • muster roll
  • parole paper
  • compiled service records
  • “carded records” from the National Archives or Fold3
  • pension applications and official communication related to applicants and/or pensioners
  • Other "official" documents

Unless specifically addressed by period documents, it is not the intent of this thread to speculate on motivations; whether these men volunteered, were conscripted, or were forced into service; whether or not they supported certain causes; or status, whether free or enslaved. If you’d like to discuss these questions, you’ll find plenty of other threads here at CivilWarTalk dedicated to those topics.

Thank you in advance for complying with the intent of this thread."

In my opinion, I'm guessing the high standards is to prevent Lost Cause apologists from inventing/exaggerating rumors or what have you.

Maybe the high standards explains why the numbers definitely seen off compared to what seems to be the general consensus (that various slaves were forced by masters to work as auxillia for the Confederates, but were never officially counted by them). It seems like to counter bad history, that they have a pretty high bar for what they would count. Could something like this pass peer review muster? Like instead of citizen science, would this by citizen history? (Please don't ban me for asking a question about something that alot of sources say is a myth but my curiosity led me to this thread). Maybe its too recent to be part of peer review?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Why was Medieval European art less true to life than the art that came before and after? Was this due to skill, materials, or something else?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Who decided north is up and south is down?

I remember seeing some old European maps (probably from the Middle Ages, but I'm not sure), and East and West where on the vertical axis, so I guess someone at some point just decided that north is up and south is down and everybody just dealt with it? I think it's pretty obvious why they were put on the vertical axis, but is there a reason why they aren't inverted? And when did that became the standard?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How necessary were the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

I often hear it said that the cost in lives and resources to successfully invade the Japanese home islands was so high that dropping the bombs was the best option. If this is so, how clear was it that the bombings were the right decision? Also as a followup, what alternative strategies were the allies looking at besides the bombs?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How did the Roman Republic integrate conquered peoples?

It's been a little over 24 hours, so I'm throwing this back up here.

I was wondering how the Roman Republic was able to maintain a nation built, as far as I can tell on military conquest, together for centuries without it being in constant revolt.

I'm mostly interested in early Rome before it expanded outside of Italy, but more information would be appreciated.

So:

  • How did the Romans keep people in conquered places from revolting or declaring independence at the first opportunity?
  • Were conquered people better off when ruled by Rome? If so, what made Roman rule superior to "barbarian" rule?
  • What potential weaknesses were there in whatever system Rome chose? What were the strengths?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Did the Andean Natives know how to knit or crochet pre European contact?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Why does the country of Niger (according to the link) have 12% lactose intolerance, whereas virtually every other country in Africa - especially sub-Saharan Africa - have over 70% lactose intolerance? Sorry if this is a bad question but I really did not know where else to post.

Lactose intolerance maps

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Have sleep patterns always been the same? I read recently that in the past few hundred years the eight hour overnight was not the norm and people would get up in the middle of the night and spend time together before returning to sleep. Is there truth to this?

4 Answers 2020-02-28

What were the earliest computer viruses like? How did they infect and affect computers?

I think this question falls within this sub’s purview. I was just wondering what early computer viruses were programmed to do. And how did those viruses get installed or run on unsuspecting computers?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Doesn’t Julius Caesar count as the first Roman Emperor?

He may not have had the title of emperor, but neither did Augustus. (Imperator just means commander) He was Dictator for life and had great religious power as the Pontifex Maximus.

1 Answers 2020-02-28

Did champions really fight in their armies’ stead, and if so, how common was this and what are the origins?

1 Answers 2020-02-28

How Useful is John Julius Norwich's "Short History of Byzantium" as an Introduction to Byzantine History? Is It Full of Errors or is It Broadly Correct?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

Why was there no river valley civilization along the Mississippi?

1 Answers 2020-02-27

1491 / 7255

Back to start