I am a German farmer in the mid 1800's that wants to move to the New World for "a better life". How do I choose which country to emigrate to? What advantages/disadvantages do Canada, the USA, Brazil, and Argentina have that would make me choose one over the other?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

What does “Forget Hell” mean in the context of the Civil War?

I collect Zippo’s and was given a presumably racist Blue Bird lighter by an older woman. The back has a confederate flag, and the front has a Confederate Soldier holding a flag saying “Forget Hell”

2 Answers 2020-02-08

What Exactly are Structuralists and Intentionalists?

For example, I'm writing a paper on Stalin, and one of the claims is that Stalin managed to rise to power because of the ineptness of other leaders. Would this be considered a structuralist or an intentionalist argument?

So basically, my paper is on how Stalin rose to power, and has three arguments.

1.) Structuralist argument -basically the USSR was corrupt AF and Stalin's(or another dictator's) rise to power was inevitable

2.) Intentionalist argument - basically Stalin was smart AF and outfoxed everybody.

3.) The aforementioned argument that Trotsky was arrogant AF and basically Stalin was lucky.

Does this sound about right?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

How did ancient libraries keep track of who was checking out books? Did late fees exist? How would libraries react if you lost or damaged a book?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

What would a European traveller find in Istanbul's markets in the 16th century?

I tried to find primary sources that describe what goods and foods would a European find in Istanbul in the 16th century, but descriptions of the city are more focused on the old churches and new mosques than on the marketplaces. I am a teacher and want to help my students imagine the atmosphere of smells, flavours, and movements of the everyday life in one of the largest trading centres of the period. If you could recommend primary sources (I can sort of manage with sources in English, French, Italian, Latin, Spanish or Portuguese -sadly, I can't read Turkish-) I would be really grateful.

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Did Medieval/Renaissance Western Europe have places that taught people Martial Arts?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

How did/has the Belgian Royal Family dealt with the horrific legacy of Leopold II?

I know that they are not directly descended from him, since he had no children. And I also know that Belgium as a whole hasn't been great about reckoning with its past in the Congo. But since the Congo was technically Leopold's own pet project for a while, not under the administration of the country, how much of a reckoning has the Royal Family gone through, publicly and privately? I assume that any republicans/anti-monarchists in Belgium would use this as Exhibit A in their case against having royalty in the first place.

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Magnus Hirchfeld was the most amazing person I’ve ever heard of; he did so many incredible things, from inventing the word “homosexual” to being a Jewish homosexual himself. I’d love it if someone went into detail just about his life, but if that’s too broad what about the institution he founded?

I’m also curious as to his motivations for starting the institute, how it was run, any specific people we know who lived/were treated their, etc.

Also, how did the Nazis find out about him? Did they always have plans to burn his institute and books? Where is his research today? Is it digitized anywhere? How religious was he? Did he speak Yiddish or Hebrew?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

I am Dutch, but I would like to read a book about American history. Does anyone have a good recommendation? We don’t get taught American history in the Netherlands so I would like to read one that doesn’t assume I already know certain parts of the history.

2 Answers 2020-02-08

Saturday Showcase | February 08, 2020

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2020-02-08

What would convince potential Roman army soldiers that after their 25 years, they would receive land and citizenship?

I understand record keeping was second to none.. but surely there would be many complications ?

2 Answers 2020-02-08

Was Mussolini worried about Hitler turning on him "the day after"?

I'm especially talking about late in the war, when there were tons of crack German troops in Italy.

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Were there any events where Elagabalus was visibally homosexual or transgender?

I'm just wondering

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Where did the young Dutch Republic get the timber, pitch, hemp, iron, etc it needed to build and maintain its enormous fleet of warships and merchant vessels?

The Dutch Republic was a very small country, and lacking in forestry resources (as far as I know).

Yet during the late 16th and early 17th centuries-- while still fighting for independence from Hapsburg Spain-- the United Provinces were able to build up a large and powerful navy, carve out a significant colonial empire, and successfully defend their shipping lanes around the globe. By the middle of the 17th century, the Dutch fleet was the largest in the world.

I assume this required heavy imports of naval supplies, especially timber. Where did those materials come from, primarily? Did rival countries like Spain, France, England, and Austria attempt to block such strategic imports through embargoes, blockades, and/or mercantilist trade policies? If so, why did their efforts fail?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Help finding a destroyed castle and any facts about it!

Hey reddit! I’m doing some family research and am looking for drawings of a German castle that once belonged to my family but has since been destroyed. Here is what I know about it!

The castle was given to Maximillian Steiner by Ludwig of Bavaria in 1311, the castle was originally won in a battle against Günther, the bishop of Würzburg. The name changed from Günthersburg to Steindorf. Maximillian died in the battle against Fredrick of Austria at Mühldorf in 1312 and his wife died shortly after. Once the castle was run by Maximillians grandson, Ludwig gave the family name of Steindorf to (another) castle Bassenheim. When there were no male heirs the original Steindorf castle was then sold to Lord Von Kitzbüchel and later in the religious wars destroyed.

The Steiner and castle coat of arms is a red bear on a silver field if that helps any!

I’d love to have some type of image of this castle or any information anyone can find so that I can paint something for my grandmothers birthday as she loves our family history.

edit: formatting and elaboration

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Ottoman rule in Greece - how oppressed were the Greeks?

An odd question, I work at a school that is predominantly Greek. We’re currently up to the Ottoman Empire and have just covered the fall of Constantinople in 1453.

A student then asked me if we were going to cover the “400 years of slavery under Ottoman rule”. I gave a muddled answer, as honestly whilst imperialism is never fun for the oppressed, I was under the impression that it wasn’t the worst experience. They got to keep their religion and a lot of rights when compared to say Muslims and Jews in other parts of Europe or the experience of Indigenous people globally.

So simple question: did the experience of Greeks under Ottoman rule warrant the term “400 years of slavery”?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

What was the original meaning behind the Paisley pattern?

A while back, I was told that an old Persian interpretation of the textile pattern was that it represented “the universe moving around you.” Essentially, the point of what I heard was that it celebrated individualism and self-identity.

Is this true? Is this another pattern? Does this conflict with the “tree of life” interpretation of the pattern?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Are there any "normal" buildings in the city of Rome pre-410 that have survived in some form to today?

Apartments, villas, etc.? Not ruins, but restored/repurposed.

3 Answers 2020-02-08

Why did armed naval vessels stop having sloped armor?

The old ironclads of the Union and Confederacy had slopes, and seeing how in WW2, the T34 had quite an effective sloping armor, I was wondering what were the fundamental issues (be they scientific or not) that dissuaded modern navies from having them post 1860s.

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Why was Germany vilified after WWI?

I understand the vilification of NAZI Germany during and after WWII.

But why was Germany vilified and treated as the evil perpetrator at the end of WWI - especially considering that the initial antagonists were Austria and Serbia (although Germany did push Austria to be more belligerent than they may have otherwise been)?

WWI didn't exhibit the tremendous cruelty and inhumanity of WWII (even with the chlorine gas attacks).

Why wasn't WWI treated as just yet another costly and stupid war caused by jingoism and adventurism and why wasn't Germany treated as the guys who just happened to be on losing side in that war?

Related question: why wasn't Austria treated as harshly as Germany (I realize the Austro-Hungarian empire was dismantled but the Austrian remnant wasn't vilified the way Germany was)?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

The American Civil War

So I am 13 years old and am trying to head-start my plan to become a historian So one of the main topics I'm researching is the American Civil War I've mostly been using the Shelby Foote books and some others, along with the official records My question is, is there any good online site for good Civil War information?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

What was the Ottoman Empire's attitude toward communism in the early 1920's?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Pre 1800s how was money transferred between bank accounts across different countries?

For instance, if I was an American businessman planning a trip to Italy would I have to physically bring all of the money I wanted to spend with me? Additionally, what measures were put in place to avoid fraud?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Any idea of the civilization that built the maltese megalithic Temples?

I have been obsessed with these temples for the past year and just want to know of the society that built them. They must have been at least somewhat advanced to be able to build such grand structures.
But then again, there has never been any remains of cities found, so they must have been just a simple agricultural civilization with the capability of building grand temples to worship their "fat lady" statues.

Any one familiar in this field, know much about the people of this ancient period?

1 Answers 2020-02-08

Did woman casually hang out in saloons in the old west?

Not exactly sure if this is the right spot to ask but figured it was worth a shot.

Aside from “saloon girls” and prostitutes, would women go to the saloon with their husband or casually drink at a saloon?

1 Answers 2020-02-07

1526 / 7255

Back to start