How much of an impact did the Civil War have on what is considered the Wild West?

You see things like Jesse James who was heavily influenced by the events of the war or the fact that the railroad became a vital point to the Unions success during the war and it's boom in later years.

How did it affect people going west or the general politics of the era?

1 Answers 2019-12-30

Saw a photo showing Military Police on a landing craft on D Day WW2 claiming the MP was there to shoot anyone who did not get off the boat. Is this true?

1 Answers 2019-12-30

When did people know what year it was?

Did people in the year 1 know it was the first year? Or did they know when it was year 200?

1 Answers 2019-12-30

What mythology would a 800-900 CE person living in what is now England believe in?

What are the main mythological animals, beings, spirits, etc. that an inhabitant of England, living around the time of Alfred the Great, would believe to be real?

I’ve been reading up a little, apparently Merlin would not yet have been developed as a character, though the mythological stories of Welsh and Roman heroes who would later become Merlin were around. Elves were believed in, and were seen as fair, white humanlike people, beings capable of inflicting sickness on humans. Dragons would not be seen as dinosaur-like beings with four legs and wings, but instead were thought of as large serpents. The ancestor to the word “dragon” wouldn’t even be used, and wyrm would be more common. Folk magic was used to treat illnesses and such.

What other stuff can you tell me about the mythology believed in at this particular time?

2 Answers 2019-12-30

Was there ever a supreme commander of the Axis’s forces?

I know that Dwight D. Eisenhower was the supreme commander of the allied forces, my question is if he had a Axis counterpart.

1 Answers 2019-12-29

In the Christmas story, King Herod orders the execution of males age 2 and under in Bethlehem. Historicity of the story aside, would Herod actually have had the power to do this, and what would his Roman overseers think of his actions?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Is there a consensus among historians as to the role of the Treaty of Versailles in WW2?

In all my history classes where it came up, (French, then later American schooling) the Treaty of Versailles was portrayed as punitive and the primary cause of WW2. I've always understood this to be common wisdom.

I randomly started listening to an interview [1] of Jeremy Black on the subject where he is extremely critical of this view. He seems to imply historians familiar with the subject are in agreement that the Treaty of Versailles was not the cause of WW2.

I'd be curious to know what the scholarly consensus is if there is one. Also, if he is right, I would be interested in understanding why pre-college history teachers still teach Versailles as a main cause of WW2.

[1] https://newbooksnetwork.com/the-treaty-of-versailles-on-hundred-years-on/

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Is there a general consensus, hitorically/politically, on why certain German symbolism or iconography reminiscent of the Nazi regime is considered acceptible (e.g. the Iron Cross of the modern Bundeswehr), whilst others are not (e.g. a swastika on anything, anywhere)?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Is there evidence of organized single combat taking place during battles of antiquity?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Did the Ottoman Empire have a noble class of warriors similar to the knights of medieval England?

While I have been researching the janissaries from the Ottoman Empire, please correct me if I’m wrong, but it seems like initially (at least before the 16th century) they were all “slave soldiers”. I.E. children taken from their home and militarized.

However, I am wondering what the wealthy did with their children who wanted to become soldiers. Was this an option? Where there any “knights” in the Ottoman Empire? Are there any good books on the subject?

Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2019-12-29

I have a pic of my grandfather (no loner alive) somewhere in the UK during WWII (Canadian Army). He’s leaning on a bench with an old building in the background that I can’t place. Any advice on how to track this down or a group of people that would be interested in helping me find it?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

How many individuals were deported under the McCarthy era, and why?

How many people were deported under the McCarthy era, and what made a person qualify for government surveillance, arrest, or deportation?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

In Norse mythology Odin, along with his brothers Vili and Ve, create the Universe. But centuries prior to Christianization of the Scandinavian peoples only Odin appears to be worshipped with his brothers practically dissapearing. What happened to their cults?

An interesting theory I heard is that Odin, Vili, and Ve may have come from the same primordial Indo-European Vedic religion that Hinduism derived from - where their corresponding gods being Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva. However to this day those 3 Hindu gods have sizable cults, but by the 10th century it appears the 3 most popular gods were Odin, Thor, and Freya.

Did Vili and Ve even have cults to begin with or did they become some sort of background character?

2 Answers 2019-12-29

Did gay brothels exist in the 1930s and 1940s?

There is a lot that has been written about female brothels which catered to the rich and famous like straight Hollywood stars but there is not that much written about gay brothels even though I'm sure gay prostitution existed. So did any brothels like that exist and where they run similarly to how a female brothel is ran?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

The Holy Roman Empire is usually represented on maps as a large number of semi-independent states, while its neighbours are usually presented as a single unit. How accurate is this?

I can understand why this would be accurate in the 18th century as other states such as France and Britain were centralizing more into the beginnings of a unitary state, while the Holy Roman Empire's states were all practically independent, but in earlier centuries wouldn't the level of decentralization have been similar, with vassals having significant power while the kings of France or England would at times have only nominal authority over their vassals?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

How much of America was colonized in 1712-1715? Writing a story in that era.

And I really don't know history very well. Any other info you can provide helps too, like the climate, the relationship with the UK, if any Germans came to America and vice versa, stuff like that.

1 Answers 2019-12-29

The Deaf community today is split on the use of cochlear implants. Was there similar anger and argument during the spread of hearing aid use?

2 Answers 2019-12-29

Why did Japan and South Korea turn into a democratic state with little corruption but other East Asian countries did not?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

What's the history of American Sign Language? How did come about and how was it standardised?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

When did ASL signs become such a frequent accompaniment to children’s songs, and how has it affected mainstream perception of ASL?

It seems the intention is to teach some signs, but they often just function as another sort of fingerplay instead. How has the ASL community reacted to these kinds of uses?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

When the Mughal Empire controlled much of the Indian subcontinent, was there an attempt to impose a national language on the populace?

India is an incredibly diverse place, which many, many local languages and dialects. I know the early Mughals spoke Persian, but was there any attempt to standardise and impose a language throughout the empire?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

How could socialist Yugoslavia borrow money from the IMF in the 1980s without having to engage in far-reaching economic reforms like other countries have had to do?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Battle of Shrewsbury report?

I'm having a bit of trouble finding a detailed report on the battle of Shrewsbury (1403), does any of you guys know of some reports or where to search?

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Reading recommendations

Does anyone have any good recommendations for books about the Paleolithic period of human history?

I'm interested in any book regardless if it's about the lower, middle or upper Paleolithic.

1 Answers 2019-12-29

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | December 23, 2019–December 29, 2019

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2019-12-29

1593 / 7255

Back to start