When did Native Americans (or indigenous peoples in other countries across America) begin to organize across cross-tribal lines? When did indigeneity (in contrast to Europeanness) become a meaningful identifier for Native groups?

In broad strokes, today Native peoples across the United States (and across both North and South America, really) identify with one another as members of a broader group needing to maintain solidarity against colonial/European structures (despite enormous differences in culture/language, etc.). Whereas, my assumption was that 400 years ago Native peoples in New England cared (or knew) little about the struggles of Native peoples in Central America, for example. When did this change?

2 Answers 2019-11-14

I often hear people say that the New Deal had failed in lifting the Nation out of the Great Depression and that it was infact world war 2 that saved the U.S. is there factual evidence to support the New Deal or was it really ww2?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Why was it difficult to develop atomic weapons once fission was discovered?

It seems that once you discover that unstable heavy elements like uranium can undergo fission chain reactions, it shouldn't be that complicated to develop a bomb utilizing this mechanism. Yet it took tons of scientists and money to develop the first atomic bomb. What were the major obstacles impeding the development of atomic weapons once fission was discovered?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Books about Ottoman Empire

Hello, I am looking for books about the history of Ottoman Empire, possibly including the time of the Seljuks to learn about its inception. Could you tell me about some good books on the subject? There are many and I can't pick. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Was the bengal famine of 1943 a genocide?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-11-14

How did American Jews in the 1930s/40s respond to the US government's refusal to accept Jewish refugees like those on board the MS St Louis? Was there a significant move to put pressure on the government?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Mohammad Mosaddegh, a known socialist icon in Iran, essentially served in the Iranian Governemt from the mid 1920s to 1953 when he was ousted. Were their socialist figures he collaborated with or was most if his ideology spurred from his time at Sciences Po?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

I had once heard the British(?) Navy tricked bar patrons into joining the service by dropping coins in an unknowing drinker's glass and then taking a sip. Does this sound familiar to anyone? I think they made clear bottom glasses so people could check their drink before sipping. Anyone have details?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Did rationing in the United Kingdom during the Second World War affect the wealthy?

Did industrialists, aristocrats, and the royal family actually feel the impact of rationing?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

While Washington's men were suffering at Valley Forge and eating fire cakes, what did generals eat?

I teach 8th grade US History, and I felt this was a great question from a student. While other men were starving and eating fire cakes, my students joked that Washington probably got wine, steak, and cheese. But in all seriousness, what were the differences in how generals ate compared to their soldiers during the Revolutionary War?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Book recommendations about the Roman empire all the way through the fall of Constantinople

Hi! I have had a sudden interest about the history of the Roman empire; from the beginning and how it became so powerful; to the fall of the western Roman empire and how it continued as the bizantine empire.

As the title says I was looking for recommendations in books to learn about all of this.

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Königsberg was occupied by soviet union in 1945 and renamed Kaliningrad. It remains as a peculiar Russian enclave. Why was the city never returned to its rightful owners?

Other areas claimed independence when soviet union collapsed. Why was kaliningrad never returned to the original owners? The area is nowhere near Russia and was never historically part of Russia. Similarly, the case of Gibraltar has been an ongoing issue between Spain and England. Has this also been the case between Poland and Russia? Has there been demands of ending the occupation of Königsberg or is it accepted as belonging to Russia?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | November 14, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

8 Answers 2019-11-14

Did the quality of life of the serfs improve post-bolshevik revolution?

How did the life of the lowest of serfs improve, if it did at all, following the October revolution? Was the Soviet government at least successful in improving the quality of life for the lowest classes of imperial Russia compared to their earlier lives? Not counting the great famine period, but the period after the revolution till the start of the famine.

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Why didn't the five nation army make any offensive operation towards Constantinople in 1917-1918?

Especially after the Bulgarian retreat and the signing of the Bulgarian Armistice why did the Allied army not move towards Thrace and instead pushed into Serbia? What kind of resistance did and could the Ottomans pose on that front? Couldn't the allies ford the Hevros river like they had done other wide rivers in the Western and Mesopotamian front and force the Ottomans to make peace directly?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Why are Children Nursery Rhymes so eerily dark?

So many nursery rhymes have such a dark nature to them such Ring Around Rosy, Rock a bye baby, Jack and Jill, London Bridge is Falling, Mary Mary Quite Contrary. They all talk of either destruction, death, or misery. Im so curious has to the origins of this and why, of all genres of music, why this has made its way to children?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Can the Russian Revolution be called a communist revolution according to marx' views?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

How do guerilla groups organize themselves?

How do militia groups like Hezbollah and Taliban that have members in the tens of thousands organize themselves? How does their chain of command work? How do they make sure that everything goes according to plan?

When you’re talking about such huge numbers of people, isn’t it almost guaranteed that at some level some guy is going to refuse orders or disagree with them? Or that some member might get disillusioned and rat everybody else out? Especially in these scenarios where the head command is in hiding and, I assume, rarely seen by other members?

How do they recruit people? How do they make sure that their new recruits are not spies or aren’t some stupid disillusioned people who are going to mess up the whole plan?

In the military, the country has strict laws and martial courts and protocols to protect against disobedience and such things, I assume these organizations have an equivalent system in place? How do they enforce it?

If this is not the correct place to ask this question then would you kindly direct me to the appropriate subreddit?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Was there any movement between the social statuses of Eta and Hinin in Edo Period Japan?

So for example a beggar or the child of one who was classed as Hinin be able to join a leather workers Za and become an Eta? Or would an Eta family in debt sell their daughter to a brothel like many commoners were forced to with her becoming a Hinin due to her status?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

It is all Woodrow Wilson's fault! I've read that there's a sort of party game where you can manage to pin every single XX century disaster to Wilson. Is it itrue?

As of late, I've read an interesting answer here on AskHistorians on Italian intervention in WWI, and an unanswered followup question asked if Italy managed to gain what it was promised before the war, which as Italian I remember the answer being "No, because Wilson vetoed it, and this lead to a huge malcontent and ultimately the rise of Communism and the very foundation of the Fascist Party in Italy".

Then I've read somewhere else that US intervention in WWI broke a substantial stalemate and preventend a ceasefire/peace treaty in 1916, prolonging the war until Entente countries totally disintegrated the Central powers in what might be the first case of "catastrophic success", whose humiliation led to the rise of Nazism, and leading up to the Bolshevic Revolution in Russia.

I also remember that he can be held responsible for the Black Tuesday in 1929 and the rise of Fidel Catro in Cuba.

Is it a thing? Is there any historical truth behind these allegations?

2 Answers 2019-11-14

What dating system did medieval European monarchs use??

I’ve been listening to a historical podcast lately and the podcaster refers to dates using C. E. But what date would say king Alfred the Great actually have used?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

What happened to the majority of Nazi war criminals at the end of WWII?

What happened to the majority of Nazi war criminals and their collaborators at the end of and after WWII? I am mostly thinking of people who did the killing directly such as SS personnel or camp guards. Were most of them killed? Captured? Escaped?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

How did the Italian Renaissance occur in the 14th century when the Black Death was in full effect?

The Black Death slowed economy, debilitated society, and started riots, how can it be possible for a renaissance to occur while millions are dying?

It doesn't make a lot of sense for a Renaissance of arts and culture to flourish while people are focusing on not-dying. I read somewhere that there was a period of religious enlightenment during the Bubonic Plague, as people wanted a faith to pray to for the hope of survival, as well as flagellation occuring to punish humanity for the plague, but weren't people also believing that if they were to die anyway, then there is no point to continuing their daily prayers and traditions?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

Podcast Reccommendation: US Intervention in Latin America?

Would love to learn more about this topic! Any episodes or whole podcasts about this?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

What was the daily life of an Ottoman Janissary like?

What were things they were allowed and not allowed to do in comparison to other types of slaves within the Ottoman Empire?

1 Answers 2019-11-14

⯇ 1665 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start