Why do we seemingly accept the massive numbers given by Roman sources about their battles in antiquity, but disregard others as being "exaggerations"? What's the evidence that 80,000 Romans did in fact fight ar Cannae, and that this is not just another wild big number Polybius uses for impact?

2 Answers 2019-08-08

Why did the vice president switch from being the second place finisher in the US presidential elections to a ticket with the president?

Why did the vice president switch from being the second place finisher in the US presidential election to a ticket with the president? If you read the 12th Amendment it would seem like they intended to have it as it's own election? Was this change a major contributor toward the present day two party system?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

"No taxation without representation!" Did the American colonists ever seriously ask for representation in Parliament?

"No taxation without representation" is the rallying cry of the American Revolution that centuries of schoolchildren have learned. But it seems like all the protests were over the fact that Parliament was trying to tax the colonists, not over the fact that the colonists had no representation. Before the Stamp Act of 1765, did it occur to any colonists to be bothered about their lack of representation back in Britain? Or were their colonial legislatures enough for them? And, rather than demanding the repeal of various acts of taxation, did any prominent colonists try to push to gain representation in Parliament instead? Was that ever even a possibility?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

Why did Mikhail Gorbachev give the title of President to himself when he had already secured his power as General Secretary?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

What was a "cake" in 18th century France? How common was it? Was Marie Antoinette's "Let them eat cake" as bad as it sounds?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

On what grounds is Churchill remembered as a good leader?

The more I read up on Churchill, the more he seems to just be one long line of luck and failure with little to know actual skill to his career. From the failures of the Gallipoli Campaign, to his mismanagement of India, to his failure at Dunkirk and the small hot-cold war of the Blitz, and the incidents with pollution and state affairs post-war, he seems to have more often talked his way out of responsibility than actually doing much of anything.

​

What am I missing? Why is Churchill remembered as a great leader? Is it just that he was the guy who happened to be in the hot seat when victory finally came, so he took what credit he could and folks just remembered that final happening? I cannot grasp on what grounds Churchill is looked up towards.

1 Answers 2019-08-08

Did Cavalry Troops become emotionally attached to their mounts?

This question came up regarding some reading about the US 26th Cavalry Regiment in the Philippines during WWII, but the question extends to any and all cavalry troops, whether they are medieval knights or 19th century hussars or whether they ride horses, elephants, camels, or whatever.

Did cavalry-men become emotionally attached to their mounts, sort of how one would become attached to a family pet? Would these men give names to their mounts and form bonds with them? If someone had their horse shot out from underneath them, or were forced to butcher their own mounts for food (like the 26th Cavalry) would that effect them emotionally, or would it be no different to a modern soldier loosing a Humvee for example?

I've never heard or read about any examples of this, but it does seem like something that would be easily glossed over or overlooked if it did occur.

2 Answers 2019-08-08

Why didn’t the Japanese surrender after V-E Day?

Logically, your biggest and most powerful “ally” (Germany) surrendered. Why wait for the US to drop two atomic bombs? Was it the belief in the emperor’s divine crusade or all out fear of Americans invading the homeland?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

Options for Digitizing Microfilm? Any advice?

Hello all! I'm an undergrad completing a research project for my Honours thesis. I'm currently working through a diary that is proving quite difficult to understand due to the author's poor handwriting, and thus is taking a lot of time to decipher. I'm looking at this diary currently on 35mm microfilm but only have it on loan from government archives for a few more days. My university has a ScanPro® 3000 All-In-One™. Is there a way to digitize this document quickly instead of manually going through each page. I'm working with a 20 year period of diaries and it will take ages to go through manually. Perhaps another software or a feature I've missed in Scanpro? ! Any advice? I'm not experienced with this technology. Cheers!

1 Answers 2019-08-08

What would a WWI soldier do if their gas mask was breached? How effectively could they be repaired in the field, if at all?

I've seen a video of a 'field repair kit' for Americans which consisted of 3 plaster strips for small tears, but other than that I've had trouble finding anything else on the topic. Did other nations distribute similar kits? Could they do anything if a lens broke?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

How did boxing and horse racing fall so far in American culture?

1 Answers 2019-08-08

What advancements allowed aerial warfare to evolve from triplanes to precision drones within a century?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

Where does the culinary history of Chinese food and Chinese takeout diverge?

Some years ago, I (an American) got Chinese takeout with an Australian friend, while living in South America. We both got exactly what we were expecting when we ordered orange chicken, despite being from two different countries and being in a distinct third country.

"Chinese" takeout is fairly uniform throughout the world, and all of it distinct from actual Chinese food. Why is this?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

Why didn't Operation Barbarossa start in May 1941? Couldn't this have added an extra warm month for offensive operations?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

In most games, bandits are nameless NPCs to be slaughtered by the player. In Medieval Europe, who would have been these bandits?

2 Answers 2019-08-07

The battle of Yorktown in 1781 is often said to be the last major battle of the American Revolution, but the treaty of Paris wasn't signed until 1783. What happend in the interim and was the prospect of continuing the war ever seriously considered by any of the belligerents?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

When do historians use museums for research purposes?

I have been traveling throughout a lot of Turkey recently and went to a lot of museums. Some were really cool (Check out the Roman statue museum in Antalya if you can) but I wondered how a historian could possibly use the relics in museums to help their research. Mentioning the previous examples, are there any fields that would study museum statues in order to gleam something about a time period? Would there ever be a time that a historian would ever study a specific statue in a museum? This is just an example and I would love to know about any type of museum that a historian might use.

Sorry if this is obvious to a historian and if this goes against the rules I will make sure to delete this post. Thank you very much!

1 Answers 2019-08-07

What was the role of the Royal Navy Submarine force during the Cold War?

I understand that Britain did not have a submarine based nuclear deterrent till 1998, but I know that we have had an active submarine service for donkeys years. What were the role of submarines during the Cold War?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

Looking for history of KKK in Shelby, NC in the 20s? 30s?

Long story short I found a blank paper application to join the Knights of The KKK in a house I was junking in Milwaukee, WI. How it ended up here I am not sure. The perforated slip that would be filled out and sent in is still attached and blank. The mailing address lists Shelby, NC.

My question is when do you think this document would have been sent out in relation to activities of the KKK in that area?

Also, I am not really wanting to keep it. I’m open to suggestions about what would be a place to transfer ownership of this to either a collector or a museum.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2019-08-07

What kind of armour did soldiers use in WW1 and WW2, and why?

In pictures, soldiers normally seen to have helmets, though helmets that only cover the top of their head, not the sides. Why not? They also don't seem to wear any kind of body armour, bullet-proof vests, etc. Was that because it wasn't available? Or too impractical?
Or did they wear more armour, that just isn't obvious in pictures? Did certain kinds of units wear more armour?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

WW2 Command and Control, Mission Control

What were the differences between national C2 systems and performances?

We all have been told that Germans were advanced. Everyone tells me that "Germans were better", "Germans were much faster", "It gave advantage to Germans". All sources of information also leave it on the same level. None seems to be able to give facts or numbers, not even academic guess. Don't understand me wrong, Germans definitely had an advantage but... How big was the advantage? Proofs? Studies? Statistics? Academic guess?

I understand that experience, nation, year, unit, formation, equipment had much to do with this. The list probably has more items. The question is vague and it is more like an interesting subject to have a chat.

I have not been able to find resources or don't know right keywords to search. It can be that the subject is well documented. In that case, if there are literature you know, videos, webpages, documents, resources of any kind, I would be interested for sure.

1 Answers 2019-08-07

I would like to learn about world history, where do I begin?

I am a history noob, was barely interested in history during school. But given the political situation I feel I should learn more about world history. But I have no clue where to begin. Any resources would be highly appreciated.

2 Answers 2019-08-07

In "Homage to Catalan" Orwell describes the people of Anarchist Catalonia as referring to each other as "comrade" (rather than "señor" or "señora"). Would the people of Catalonia have actually used this English word, or a Spanish translation of it?

If they did use a translation, would it be "camarada," or "compañero/compañera"? Or maybe something else?

1 Answers 2019-08-07

I did some looking around and found that wheels and sails weren't used for any practical purposes until the bronze age. What makes it so that these technologies weren't used until metallurgy had developed to the point of using bronze?

It seems like it should be usable with stone age level technology. A cart could be used to move things around on land and a sail could be used to move boats on water without having to paddle them.

1 Answers 2019-08-07

All but one of the planets are named after Roman gods, why is Uranus named after a Greek god?

I began to wonder why all the planets are named after Roman gods, except Uranus. Why does it not follow the convention?

Also, as far as I can tell, all the major moons are named after the Roman gods, except for Phobos and Deimos (the moons of Mars, which is also a Roman god). Why is there this disconnect?

And yes, I am aware they are (mostly) all the same gods, but just with different names. I would like to know why this handful of celestial bodies break the convention.

1 Answers 2019-08-07

⯇ 1831 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start