How would gladiator games, chariot racing or other sports of ancient Greco-Roman times compare with today’s World Cup football[soccer] from a spectator perspective?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Three Magi visited Jesus, yes? So, how did Zoroastrians view Jews at that time?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Are we really approaching 2068?

The Julian Calendar was created by Julius Caesar and came into effect in 45 BC. We’ve since changed to the Gregorian Calendar, but it’s only days different.

I find it very hard to believe Julius Caesar proclaimed it to be 45 years before the birth of Christ, and that the first 45 years would count down, not up.

So my full question: what was the actual date on say 1/1/45BC at that time? And how can we say we use the Gregorian Calendar when we seem to be 45 years adrift from it?

2 Answers 2022-12-15

Back when it was orthodox for male actors to play female characters, was it not in the least bit controversial when they kissed the male characters, dressed like womem etc?

I was reading midsummer nights dream and in parts of the play a group of laymen are rehearsing a play, none of them seem resistant to having to play the woman's role and one of them even wants to because he says he would be good at it. Maybe it's my country's culture but most modern men would find it controversial or at least not ideal to act like women, and also embarrassing to read all these lovey lines to a man even if they are just acting. Was this not the case in Shakespeare's days? Is this strict idea of masculinity a modern thing?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Why didn't the United States declare war on Japan when Japan invaded the Phillippines?

considering Hawaii wasn't a state until 1959, and it had the same territorial status the Phillippines, why was Pearl Harbor the catalyst for US involvement in WWII?

2 Answers 2022-12-15

What happened to obsolete Allied tanks during WW2?

What happened to the Matildas, Crusaders, M3 Lees, BT-7s after they became obsolete at or around 1943? I know that some were still used in the China, India, Burma theatre or at the Pacific theatre and some were converted to SPAA or SPGs but that doesn't account for all of them. Where did they go?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

where in italy was the roman army primarily recruited from during the late republic/ principate?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Was German always considered an intimidating/scary language or are we conditioned to think that way because we see Nazis speak them in movies?

Before Nazi Germany, was the language considered such an intense and harsh language?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Did Pedro De Pais, 3ft tall Spanish knight actually exist?

I've been reading the story of Chevalier Bayard, the famous French Knight. There is a particular story of him holding a bridge against a charge of Spanish knights led by a 3ft tall knight who was hunchbacked named Pedro de Pais. He ends up captured. Outside of this story I can find no reference that this guy ever existed despite the story hailing him as a brave and famous knight. In the story the French and Spaniards are on opposite sides of the river Garilliano. Gonzalo Fernández de Córdoba commanded the Spaniards.

2 Answers 2022-12-15

Are 'Political History' and 'Auxuliary Science' the right words for the stuff i describe in the post?

So, in hungarian, we call the the branch of history that deals with rulers, how long they ruled, what treaties that made, whom they were succeeded by, what wars were closed by what peace agreement, etc, "Politika történelem" which would translate in to "Political history". Would that be the right word for it?

Also, when History is studied through the perspective that is also the purview of another science, like economics, sociology, demographics, we call that a "segédtudomány", which i think translates to "Auxiliary science". For example, in this context and in this perspective, if you study the economy of let's say medieval france, Economics is used in that case as an auxiliary science of history.

Are these the right english terms for the things I described?

2 Answers 2022-12-15

Is there an argument for The Great Famine in Ireland being a genocide?

I am aware of a debate around whether or not 1932-33 famines in Ukraine and Kazakhstan were acts of genocide perpetrated by the Soviet State, and neither sides absolve the Soviet government from causing or contributing to the starvation.

I am also aware of consensus being that the British caused or contributed to the famine in Ireland. Is there an argument that this was a genocide? If so what are the main points of argument, if no, what are the main reasons why it is not a genocide?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Would the Sengoku Period in Japan feel like a period of upheaval, anarchy and constant war, or was life "normal" compared to earlier periods?

To clarify. The Sengoku Period is often portrayed as a period in which a power vacuum (if such a thing even exists) caused almost a century and half of near constant civil war. That's just the thing, just how constant was it? To the average person that lived through this period, were the scourges of war all that those generations would've ever known? Or was life for a civilian more os less normal if the place they lived wasn't where a specific conflict happened? (I imagine the year of 1560 was pretty miserable for the peasants in the village of Okehazama for example). Did the wars of the Sengoku have any economic and demographic impact on Japan?

Is it possible that the Sengoku Period's "anarchy" may have been overestimated by later sources that lived in post unification periods like the Edo period? Kind of like how Enlightenment thinkers painted the medieval era in Europe as a "Dark Age"? I don't have any specific reason to think this, I guess is just my skepticism at work.

Turns out those were multiple questions, sorry. I had trouble articulating my doubts.

Thank you for your time if you read that.

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Regarding the sinking of the HMAS Sydney by the German auxiliary cruiser Kormoran in WWII: there are theories alleging "that the German commander used illegal ruses to lure Sydney into range". What would an "illegal ruse" be here?

As the title states, I am curious as to what an "illegal ruse" would be a time of war. I know there are all sorts of rules in war (i.e.-Geneva convention and the like), but I can't for the life of me think of what an "illegal ruse" might be, and why it would be illegal.

2 Answers 2022-12-15

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | December 15, 2022

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2022-12-15

In 1977, General Hackett and others wrote a "future history" book, The Third World War, taking place in a near future 1985. How plausible were the assumptions made in its setup?

It's been a while since I read it and my cataracts are such that reading physical books is a problem, but from memory,

  • Italy has elected a Communist government and largely withdrawn from NATO

  • India has become a loose confederation of states and is disintegrating

  • Angola, Mozambique, Botswana and Zambia have formed an anti-apartheid confederation to threaten South Africa, backed by the Soviets

  • Jamaica has gone Communist too and eclipses Cuba as the main Communist country in the Carribbean.

How many of those things were either genuinely possible or at least widely held to be plausible in 1976-77? Or is it all just moving pieces on the board to facilitate the narrative?

3 Answers 2022-12-15

What happened when a future saint died in medieval Catholic Europe?

Supposedly when Polycarp was burned at the stake his followers " took up his bones, which are more valuable than precious stones and finer than refined gold ". There the process of creating relics seems pretty clear. For later religious figures, particularly those who died in less dramatic fashion (Hidegard of Bingen?) were there rules or are there accounts of how to collect and authenticate personal effects, or even body parts? Disputes over who has the true relic -before- it was put in a reliquary? Was it o.k. to open tombs to get at this stuff? I know there is a large literature about the cult of saints and relics, but what little of that I have read seems to focus on the part after the parts were boxed up and certified, as it were. What happened in the period between the death of a future candidate for sainthood and relics ending up in a cathedral or the collection of the Elector of Saxony?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

What was Finland like during the Viking Age?

Throughout history, it feels as though the Anglo-sphere’s view of the lands surrounding the Baltic has been understandably shaped by the Viking cultures and the progenitors of the contemporary Swedish, Norwegian, Icelandic and Danish states.

Information on Finland, however, during this ancient and early-Medieval period before the Swedish crusades seems really sparse, and altogether lacking - at least in popular history.

What was Finland like during this broad period, and was it roughly analogous to the Vikings? Did they have a similar culture, did they practice raiding, etc. The Finnic pantheon seems similar to their Norse neighbours, was this due to cultural exchange? What were the events and customs that shaped life for them?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

why do people explain historical events in present tense?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Why do so many historians continue to refer to refer to countries as "she"/"her", given this usage has long fallen out of use in speech and most other kinds of writing?

This isn't meant to be a political question—people have been calling countries "it" since long before feminism was a thing. Calling a country "she" in most contexts would draw attention to itself as an odd affectation—it certainly wouldn't go unnoticed. I've been binging history books over the last couple years, and this usage, even in recent books, always jumps out at me.

(Before someone starts making some comment about it being a relic of Anglo-Saxon having had gendered nouns, the Anglo-Saxon land was of neuter gender, not feminine; this argument is often brought up to "explain" ships being called "her", when the Anglo-Saxon sċip was also actually neuter.)

EDIT: Some more examples form books I've read recently:

A Concise History of Germany by Mary Fulbrook (2019):

  • "... regularising Germany's relations with her western neighbours ..."
  • "... by which Germany was to increase her navy to one-third the strength of the British navy ..."

Battle Cry of Freedom by James M. McPherson (1988):

  • "... warned that the South might secede if her rights were not protected."
  • "... settlement of the Texas boundary dispute in favor of New Mexico with compensation to Texas of $10 million to fund her pre-statehood debt."

A People's History of the German Revolution by William A. Pelz (2018):

  • "Bavaria shared her Catholic faith and much of her foreign policy with the Austrian Empire ..."
  • "... he wrote bitterly in his diary about England and her allies ..."

1848 by Mike Rapport (2010):

  • "France would also not hesitate to protect her neighbours - specifically Switzerland and Italy - in their own attempts to democratise or to unite ..."

Iron Kingdom by Christopher Clark (2007):

  • "The interests of the monarchy thus demanded that Vienna abandon her unreliable British ally and sue instead for the friendship of France."
  • "... massive Habsburg acquisitions in the Balkans would give Austria the upper hand over her Prussian rival."

Crucible of War: The Seven Years' War and the Fate of Empire in British North America, 1754–1766 by Fred Anderson (2001)

  • "... Pitt’s strategic vision still focused on attacking France’s imperial periphery rather than her armies in Europe ..."
  • "... Pitt’s evident determination to strip France of her empire, humble her diplomatically, and in effect dictate the peace terms ..."

2 Answers 2022-12-15

What did the ends of the front line look like in WW1 on the western front?

I’m referring to after the end of the race to the sea in 1914. Did it go all the way to the Swiss border in the south? Could you watch combat on the Swiss side of the border with no threat to your life? And on the Belgian side, did the frontline go all the way to the channel?

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Legitimacy of WWII Japanese so called “operation ketsugo”?

Disclaimer: I am not someone who regularly reads into WWII history or almost any history to begin with, and am severely ignorant when it comes to the topic at hand.

Recently I’ve been doing a little bit of research on the different sides and perspectives of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings, trying to understand for myself why the bombs were dropped and whether or not it was truly the “best” course of action (trying to be careful with my words, the bombings were definitely tragic no matter what anyone says).

I stumbled upon a few reads that justify the bombings by bringing up the potential amount of both American and Japanese casualties if a land invasion were to occur, mentioning a so called “operation ketsugo” where civilians would be taught and encouraged to raise arms against would be invaders, saying that it would be a fight to the last man, woman, and even child. This intrigued me but I quickly realized that I couldn’t really find much more about this supposed policy aside from the few articles I was reading. “Operation ketsugo” is mentioned by name in the Wikipedia page for operation downfall but doesn’t even have its own Wikipedia page where I can go look for sources

Any information pertaining this topic is greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Is there any historical basis for Pirate Talk?

“Arrr” “Me Hardies” “Avast ye Land Lubbers” etc.

1 Answers 2022-12-15

Historically, leaders who were called "Crazy" or "Mad" seem to be either admired as ferocious in battle or disrespected as genuinely mentally ill. We equate the terms now, but was there a linguistic difference that's been lost to us?

I started wondering about this use of crazy or mad after watching a show on Crazy Horse (1840-1877), then came across Haakon the Crazy (1214) and Othenin the Mad (1338) all the way up to my personal favorite, Mad King Ludwig (1845-86).

1 Answers 2022-12-14

How did Mormonism transition from a rogue, semi-threatening religion against which President Buchanan sent military forces, to a mainstream, non-threatening American religion no one gives a second thought to?

1 Answers 2022-12-14

The modern borders of Brazil extend much further west than the boundary line established by the Treaty of Tordesillas in 1493. Why is that?

1 Answers 2022-12-14

19 / 7255

Back to start