What evidence is there of Josef Mengele's involvement in Auschwitz?

I've searched Google and this subreddit but didn't seem to find what I was looking for. I've been learning a bit more about the Holocaust recently and I came across a site that claims Josef Mengele's actions were greatly exaggerated in the more recent decades. It claimed that we only really have eyewitness testimony and that this testimony about him was vastly different in 1946 than it was in the 1980's. For example, the stories of his experiments on trying to change eye colours or stitching twins together to conjoin them. The article claimed that we never found any physical evidence of this and that survivors were never tested to confirm these things happened.

Now I know that there are Holocaust deniers and the likes out there, so I'm not buying into it without question, but I'm wondering what evidence there is other than eyewitness testimony that, while unlikely to, could have been exaggerated or misremembered?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Inquiring for help about 19th century Farmers

Hello Reddit Community Historians. My name is Joshua. I am seeking aid in the main concerns of Farmers at the end of the 19th Century America post Civil War. What were their main concerns? Were interest charges and storage costs a huge problem then? What about Freight Rates and Commodity Prices?

Thank you in advance. This is to help me with my Social Studies Exams.

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Were ancient peoples aware of time changes?

Would traders moving between Europe and Asia be aware that sun seemed to rise earlier as they traveled east and later as they returned west?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Worst reddit ever. Everything is deleted, banned, or punted.

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Today I have seen a video about the partition of Pakistan and India, made by Vox. It talks about the British..'incompetency' or refusal to carefully divide the two states. Why were divided in the first place?

The video also shows how the colony was very diverse and mixed. It made it very difficult to divide the colony because every district was diverse.

But why were they divided at all? It doesn't seem like the division, or the partition did much good..a lot of people died and chaos ensued.

I do not know much about this topic at all so please forgive me if I said anything that I shouldn't have or if I said it in a wrong way. It would not be intentional.

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Historical texts & how we have them as sources today (Classical Era)

I am interested to know how old primary and secondary sources survive and can be read (via reproduction, copy, translation) today. Examples such as Polybius’ Histories, how do these ancient texts content appear thousand of years later with minimal alteration

Bonus question: Are there any primary sources lost to us but mentioned in other sources that would be invaluable to modern historians. Eg another contemporary source mentioned in Polybius as an example?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Is there evidence for voluntary migration of Sub-Saharan Africans to the Caribbean and today's Southern states of the USA in pre-Columbian times?

I'm curious if there could be. The point that was raised, were favorable ocean currents and wind patterns.

1 Answers 2019-06-27

In the TV show Good Omens, Crowley is shown wearing sunglasses in ancient Rome and in Elizabethan England, among other times and places. Are these accurate representations of things worn in the period or just Crowley looking characteristically awesome?

For reference,

Crowley in ancient Rome

Crowley in Elizabethan England

Crowley in revolution-era France

Crowley in Victorian London

Did people commonly wear sunglasses in these times and places, and if so did they look like this? Or is this just how Crowley rolls?

(Also, is his Elizabethan era hairstyle- and beard-style- period accurate? Because that would be the only possible excuse.)

2 Answers 2019-06-27

The WW2 German Air Force raised over 20 Infantry Field Divisions from nearly 250k excess airmen to help the Army fight the ground war. Why did the Luftwaffe have so many spare personnel?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luftwaffe_Field_Divisions

According to the wiki, these "divisions were raised from 200,000–250,000 Luftwaffe ground, support, and other excess personnel."

200,000-250,000 seems like a massive excess of spare personnel to me. Were these airmen only freed up as the Allies destroyed more Luftwaffe aircraft and facilities, thus destroying their original air duties? Or was the Wehrmacht just horrible at people management? It seemed like it would've been more efficient and effectively to have originally just sent these men to the Heer when they were first recruited.

1 Answers 2019-06-27

The holocaust was a terrible horrible event and the fact that it happened is disgusting. However, Hitler did a lot of (inhumane) scientific experiments on his victims. Would we be where we are now in the medical and scientific worlds without those experiments? If not, why?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

My Grandfather served in the 24th Division of the US Army in the Korean War as a frontline infantryman in the 10 months before they were pulled out and sent to Japan. What would he have experienced?

My grandfather told a few stories about the war, mostly funny stories, a few sad stories, but almost nothing about actual combat or details about where he was or what he was doing.

He was drafted and was in Korea for 10 months before being pulled out of the war and sent to Nagasaki. I know he was fighting against Chinese soldiers at the time. I believe he was a BAR gunner.

What would he have likely experienced, which parts of Korea would he have been stationed in (besides Busan/Pusan)?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Before Hitler, who was used in common speech/writing as the worst person to have ever lived?

Hitler is commonly used as an insulting comparison for people being too authoritative or asshole-ish. Saying “don’t be a Hitler” or “calm down Hitler” are common enough to where he is regarded as one of if the not the worst person in history. Who took this mantle before him? Are there any historical examples of a separate person being used before Hitler took their place?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Historians of Reddit, how did you get to where you are today?

A somewhat unusual question, I know! I'm not sure if this kind of question is permitted here, but I am looking for advice.

I am an undergraduate student about to enter my senior year, and I am currently debating whether or not I want to pursue my PhD in History or my Masters in Teaching. If anyone here completed their PhD, what was your concentration, and do you have any regrets?

4 Answers 2019-06-27

Britain in 500AD

I'm working on an Art project about King Arthur but I'm going more on a historical approach rather than a fantasy one. Now I read that Arthur is from today's Wales area and some sources says that Celts lived there. Now I'm not sure how true is that and would like some clarification on that matter. Next I'm interested in religion and lettering system at that time. Were they Christian or were they Pagan? And what kind of lettering did they used?

I'm sorry if this doesn't belong here

1 Answers 2019-06-27

In 1803, the U.S. made the Louisiana Purchase for $15 million. How was this large amount of money transferred before currency was handled as it is today?

This question was sparked by the great question on the purchase of Alaska and I was wondering if there might have been anything different due to it being about 60 years prior. Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-06-27

According to legend, Romulus and Remus were the children of a vestal virgin raped by Mars; did Roman religious practices predate the city? Was the pantheon distinctly Roman or inherited from earlier civilizations (and how accurate is the depiction that it's just adapted from the Greeks)?

(sorry for not tagging nsfw; I should have known better)

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Did the USA have a plan other than bombing Nagasaki and Hiroshima?

I heard about this some time ago, saying that it is hard to believe but it would be more terrible than the nuclear bombs, but I can't seem to find anything abour it anymore.

3 Answers 2019-06-27

Why is the Alaska Purchase treaty written in French and English, and not in Russian?

This is the document I'm curious about. Only the Tsar's ratification is written in Russian. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/29/Czar%27s_Ratification_of_the_Alaska_Purchase_Treaty_-NARA-_299810.pdf

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Why is it that America was discovered only so late in 1492 if Alaska is so close to Russia?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

How did the United States Army structure itself prior to the Brigade Combat Team?

Context: The modern day Brigade Combat Team is a modular structure comprised of "plug-and-play" Battalions. The US Army moved to this force structure post 9/11 as a solution for fighting counter insurgency conflicts. If you keep an eye on the news you will see that the US military is trying to refocus on conventional symmetric warfare vs the asymmetric wars we have been fighting in the Middle East.

I am in the Army and was brought up in the doctrine of the BCT and I am wondering what a conventional force structure looks like. What did it look like in Desert Storm? Vietnam? Korea? Where can I find further reading on this?

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | June 27, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

9 Answers 2019-06-27

Was the American constitution in any way influenced by the English Republic?

I'm almost finished reading The English Republic 1649-1660 by Toby Barnard, and it struck me that a few of the attempts to build a working government seemed to be somewhat similar to the balance of powers seen in the American constitution.

Of course, it wasn't truly balanced, since Cromwell always had most of the power. But it seemed interesting to me that what I know of the later Constitution almost seemed like an edited version of the Instrument of Government, in the sense that powers were shared between the Lord Protector, Parliament, and the Council of State.

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Did any civilizations inhabit the Sahara before it became a desert?

I'm curious if there could be undiscovered ruins buried beneath the sands.

2 Answers 2019-06-27

Given that guns are not legal (and assault weapons are very uncommon) in the UK, where did the IRA get their weapons from during the troubles?

I've seen images of IRA soldiers during the troubles sporting rifles, and given how uncommon they are and how difficult I'd assume they'd be to get hold of, it left me wondering how they managed to get so many and where they came from.

....asking for a friend /s

1 Answers 2019-06-27

Is the story about the movie 300 with King Leonidas and his Spartan Troops holding off King Xerxes massive Persian Army blown way out of proportions or is their more truth to it?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-06-27

⯇ 1900 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start