Was there an actual historical Jesus, and, if so: Where do we draw that evidence from?

First: I am not by any stretch of the imagination a Christian. Just curious.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

What did ancient Egyptians call their kingdom?

Modern Egyptians don't call their country 'Egypt' because that's the name the Greeks gave it. Instead they call it Misr, which is Arabic and possibly originates from the Babylonian term for the place.

So what did the people who built the pyramids call their civilization? What name did the pharoahs use to describe their lands? Is there a name that is recorded in hieroglyphics?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Why is the Sherman Tank (75mm cannon) considered a medium tank, while the Sherman tank (76.2mm anti tank gun) was considered a lot more powerful. Is 1.2 mm that big of a difference?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

There is a brief mentioning of Roman merchants reaching China from the "south sea"(Vietnam?), where did the Romans set sail from to end up there? Did they discover a route to the Indian ocean before Vasco de Gama via Europe or was it through their Asian territory they set sail?

Just an interesting topic and seems less known of that the Romans and Chinese had some diplomacy or trade directly at one point or another. How would they go about sailing there and back to Rome?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Why do the uniforms worn by the Army and navy look so similar between different countries and why have they changed very little since WW2 or before?

To preface this question I want to give some context, I am a soldier in the US ARMY and recently I have been watching World War II in Color on Netflix and I noticed that most, if not all of the countries showcased in the series are wearing similar uniforms, the German, US, Japan etc. I can understand why duty uniforms might look similar, necessary kit like helmets, ammo pouches and so on are worn by everyone because in war these things are necessary, But why are the things like the dress uniforms for the Navy so similar with medals and so on placed on the same side with the same hash marks and stripes on the sleeve and the same neckerchiefs on, I'm not sure if it's so other countries will be able to recognize who is a higher value Target and more easily be able to recognize people of other ranks and so on.

To sum up my question, why do different countries in different parts of the world all wear similar uniforms in the military, both historically and today.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

I've often seen it claimed in the context of imperial/global history that mapping was a crucial way in which European empires could subjugate local peoples. But... how? Why was mapping such an effective tool of colonisation?

This question reflects my own somewhat sketchy knowledge of recent developments in the field. It often seems to be taken as a given in some historical works I've recently read that surveying and mapping imperial spaces was a vital plank of colonisation, directly enabling the defeat and subjugation of local peoples, a factor that's sometimes ranked alongside superior military and logistical technologies in enabling the rapid expansion of European empires, particularly in the late nineteenth century. But most texts I've read just kind of assert this off-handedly rather than explaining why mapping was so vital in this process.

2 Answers 2019-03-05

Did Gold Coinage Really Disappear from Circulation in Late Antiquity Europe?

I don't want to say "dark ages," but a book I was reading claimed that the denarius (penny, pfennig, etc.) was the standard unit of currency in circulation, and that gold coinages had disappeared. Is this accurate, or (as I suspect) is the situation more complicated?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Why was Sigismund III so intent on spreading Catholicism to new territories of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth?

As king of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, Sigismund III added Sweden to his domain and was intent on adding the Troubles-stricken Russia to it too, but from what I can gather, in Sweden, Sigismund III began constructing Catholic schools and placing Catholics in high positions (in contravention of a promise to not infringe on the religious freedoms of the mostly Lutheran Swedes). This would eventually cause a civil war within Sweden, followed by an outright war between Poland and Sweden, which ended with the destruction of the union between the PLC and Sweden.

During the Polish-Muscovite War which took place during The Troubles, he came close to placing his son on the Tsarist throne, but was outraged when one of the conditions of sympathetic Russian nobles for their support was the conversion of his son to Orthodoxy. In retaliation, Sigismund III proclaimed himself Tsar, eroding what little support he had among the Russian population.

So why on Earth was Sigismund III so intent on spreading Catholicism to the PLC's new or prospective territories, even when it was clear the people did not want to be converted from their own religions?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Why is Marie Skłodowska-Curie's maiden name dropped out in most English articles?

I'm from Poland so this question is obviously written from a Polish person perspective.

We're being taught in school Marie Skłodowska-Curie was Polish. I already got myself up to speed as to why she is considered French too and it seems completely reasonable to me - especially that Chopin, for example, is not considered French despite actually having a French father due to same criterion used for Marie - he did not naturalize.

What I completely don't get is why is Marie's maiden name dropped in sources foreign to Polish? I checked some papers and scans of old documents and historic evidence and all this suggests she actually was using both last names.

EDIT: a word.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

How common was it to own slaves in pre-civil war US for people that didn’t have plantations or some production facilities that could utilize slave labor?

I’ve heard that only around 1,2-1,5% of people in the US were slave owners. My knowledge of that period in US history is very limited but in Tom Sawyer novel it is shown that his aunt has a slave without owning a plantation.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Did our ancestors refer to certain emotions that do not exist anymore ?

To clarify: we know that our ancestors did not perceive their world and their reality as we do; for example, there's a debate surrounding the idea that blue wasn't an existing color for the Greeks, who would rather describe the sea as "green" or "shiny". The perception of smells, colors, shapes have changed drastically in the last centuries. So, was it the same for emotions? Do historians sometimes stumble upon a depiction of a feeling that doesn't exist anymore in our vocabulary or that would be considered downright weird nowadays?

EDIT: Due to a comment about the perception of blue from ancient Greeks, I modified my example to reflect that it is a debated point of view.

3 Answers 2019-03-05

Can a layman with no connection to history academia, publish a history article in history journals, given accurate academic-quality use of sources and publishing fees?

Is there such a thing as a "citizen historian" as there is a "citizen scientist"?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Did the church in England object to the days of the week in English being named after pagan gods? We’re there ever any attempts to change the names?

*were. Damn autocorrect.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

I’m trying to better understand Marcus Crassus’ portfolio. What does it mean to be an ancient billionaire? How did he spend his money, and where did his wealth go when he died?

2 Answers 2019-03-05

What did people think about static electricity before the discovery of electricity?

Static electricity is a source of energy that is very easy produce and very easily noticed (via feeling a small shock or visually seeing in the dark). So what did people think of static electricity before the discovery of electricity and what was it called? I can only imagine that it must have seemed like magic.

Thanks for any replies

1 Answers 2019-03-05

The Ottoman Empire lasted from 1299 to 1923. When did they first begin to have a comprehensive understanding of the "New World"? Are there any Ottoman maps of the Americas? When, if ever, did they establish diplomatic ties with North/South American nations?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Why did Jack Ruby kill Oswald?

Of all the suspicious circumstances surrounding the assassination of President Kennedy, this one stood out the most to me. 2 days after Oswald killed Kennedy he was assassinated by someone else. What was Ruby's motivation?

PS Please don't answer with conspiracy theories; accurate speculation please

1 Answers 2019-03-05

AskHistorians Podcast 131 - A Scholar and A Pundit: A discussion of the work of Victor Davis Hanson w/Dr. Roel Konijnendijk

Episode 131 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

Today we're talking with Dr. Roel Konijnendijk about the career of Victor Davis Hanson. Hanson began as a scholar of Ancient Greek warfare but in recent decades he has transformed himself into a pundit. We discuss the implications that this transformation had on his reputation and later work.

You can follow Roel on twitter at @Roelkonijn or on Reddit as /u/Iphikrates.

Questions? Comments?

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.

If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Previous episode and discussion.

Next Episode: u/AnnalsPornographie is back!

Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.

4 Answers 2019-03-05

Why Saipan?

Why did the United States in WWII capture Saipan first instead of any other of the Marianas Islands

1 Answers 2019-03-05

What were music audiences like in the Baroque/Classical eras (17th-early 19th centuries)?

If one were to walk into a "public" music performance in the Baroque/classical era, be it an opera, concerto, mass etc., what would one expect to see? Would the audience be mainly wealthy or nobility, lower class commoners, or a mixture of both? Would the audience be excited and involved, or calm and subdued? What would the concessions/facilities look like, if any? How would these performances compare to a modern pop/rock concert, or theatre performance?

How familiar would the audience be with the performers, composers, story, and music beforehand, if at all?

Related: how were "famous" stars of opera, or instrumental virtuosos treated by the general public? Did they have a large dedicated following?

Sorry for the many questions, this is just a topic I've long pondered! Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2019-03-05

Artists in black musical genres such as jazz, blues, and soul have historically had no problem with performing covers, ghostwritten songs, or any other type of song written by another person. Why did such a taboo become prevalent in hip-hop?

1 Answers 2019-03-05

It's often said that the East India Trading Company was almost as powerful as a nation, how powerful did it get and what was put in place to stop it happening again?

1 Answers 2019-03-04

Sir Miles Partidge and the Dissolution of St Paul’s Cathedral

Hi r/AskHistorians!

I’ve got a question for you on the back of doing some research into my family tree. One of my ancestors, Sir Miles Partridge (1488-1552) is recorded in a number of sources as “when playing with the king [Henry VIII], he staked on one throw of the dice 100l. against the bells of the Jesus Chapel in St. Paul's Churchyard; Partridge won, and had the bells taken down and broken “

This logically dates from during the dissolution (1536-41) and up to the death of Henry (1547), but I can’t find any information about how St Paul’s was affected by the dissolution and particularly when, which is making it tricky to try to date this story with any more accuracy. My understanding of the dissolution was that anything sold was recorded reasonably well (Court of Augmentations), but I’m struggling!

I know that he went on to be beheaded in 1552 at the Tower of London for allegedly conspiring against the new regime after the fall of his friend Thomas Seymour, Protector of Edward VI, but I’d love to find out more.

Any suggestions or guidance would be brilliant!

1 Answers 2019-03-04

Why was Washington moving slaves in and out of Pennsylvania? (Or was he?)

I'm in this thread which has basically devolved into basically 90% arguments on historical revisionism, how was can/'t judge people from the 18th c. for slavery, and a bit of attempts at correcting information. But even that information seems suspect, and people are attempting to correct others while slipping in irrelevant information.

Needless to say, I do not consider tHe hisTorY chAnNeL a reliable source. I've found too many articles with glaring holes in them.

So my questions:

  • Obviously, Washington owned slaves. Everyone knows this. But what's a "dower slave"? And why did he have them?

  • Was Washington moving slaves across Pennsylvania lines every six months to prevent their freedom?

  • Was this movement itself illegal?

  • What was the famous Virginian doing with slaves in Pennsylvania?

1 Answers 2019-03-04

In All Quiet on the Western Front, there was a "mad scientist" doctor who used wounded soldiers as test subjects. Is this based on any real person?

If not, was it based on a dramatization of real events, a common trope among soldiers, or some other source?

1 Answers 2019-03-04

⯇ 2087 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start