During the Hundred Years’ War between the Valois and Plantagenets did the majority of common soldiers fighting for the Plantagenet come from England proper or the parts of France the English crown controlled?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Why didn't Italy colonize the Americas?

It's basic knowledge. Everyone knows that Amerigo Vespucci (from Italy) discovered the Americas. Then Cristoforo Colombo came second. So, why didn't Italy colonize the Americas and let other powers do that?

2 Answers 2022-06-25

What was the African Theater like in the First World War?

Most of pop history focuses on Europe and the trench warfare there, but many of the European countries had immense colonial empires. What was the war like in Africa?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Can somebody point me to a book about medieval swords?

I was wondering if there's a modern book that is basically a catalogue of medieval sword, preferably 2 handed ones? I'm drawing a medieval piece and need real life references.

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Why is Smith such a common English last name when it seems like it would have been a relatively uncommon profession, with most places only needing one blacksmith?

2 Answers 2022-06-25

Why were the Moors portrayed as black?

Moors are typically portrayed as black or dark skinned in art and European culture. Despite them being predominantly North African, why were they portrayed as black?

Was this due to some Moors being of Subsaharan heritage or more of a broad generalisation applied to North Africans?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

90’s Norwegian black metal bands were infamously violent towards Christianity and churches. Did this antagonism originate within the metal subculture, or did it have roots in other movements of the time?

In the early 90s, black metal musicians in Norway were famously anti-Christian, explicitly promoted Satanism and Paganism, and were collectively responsible for a string of church burnings. Did this approach to religion originate within that particular community, or was it based on other cultural trends or non-metal subcultures? In particular, I’m interested in the calls to action against places of worship, and the motivated return to worshipping historic Norse Gods.

2 Answers 2022-06-25

European discontent with American foreign policy 1945-1952?

I was wondering where I could find any documents that were against American influence on the integration of Europe between 1945-52. Specifically relating to The Marshall Plan, Truman Doctrine, ERP, and any policy resulting from those.

Thank you

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Did the US know that there were Soviet spies stationed in New Mexico during the Manhattan project?

US secretary of war, Henry L. Stimson (1940-45) stated that "having this weapon rather ostentatiously on our hip, their suspicions and their (Soviets) distrust of our purposes and motives will increase." (from the book "Atomic" by Jim Baggott) This quote is spoken in a way that the US thought they were at the forefront of military technology (A-bomb wise) but was spoken at a time were nuclear intelligence was sent to the USSR practically daily. Did the US know that there were spies on US territory, or at least, that the Soviets were making serious progressions in project "Enormoz" (Soviet a-bomb development)?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

What did the Nazis thought about the race of their Japanese allies in WWII?

Within my understanding, Nazis in World War II had the view that the “aryan” race was the superior one, and the only one which needed to exist. So in those lines, what did the Nazis thought about the “non aryan” appearance of the Imperial Japanese Citizens. Do they didn’t care?, Did they thought it was bad?, Or maybe in secret, they hated them? I hope this is not a dumb question to ask, but it has come to my mind and Im very interested on how that worked. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Camouflage for standard infantry wasn't widely adopted by European armies until the turn of the 20th century, so why did both sides of the American Civil War settle on relatively drab uniforms 40 years earlier?

Was it just a coincidence? I know the Union and Confederates were drawing from the same military traditions and physically taking from the same armouries so their internal similarities don't suprise me. I also know they barely had standard uniforms as such and they were pretty ad hoc, especially in the south.

But was there some deliberate attempt to be inconspicuous on the battlefield, and understanding that it was just good standard practice? And if so what culture and previous experience informed this break with European traditions at the time? If it wasn't a coincidence was there something unique about the American battlefield that made camouflage expedient?

I know camouflage was pretty much an ancient concept and had seem limited use by everyone in the gunpowder era for sharpshooters etc, but it also seems it was never considered broadly practical and necessary until smokeless cartridges were introduced (and in many cases for a long time after). Except in the United States where the plain uniforms are there in the 1860s, along with all these other 20th century premonitions like widespread use of trenches, steam power, telecommunications etc.

Also, did any European observers remark on the American uniforms at the time?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

During the Revolutionary War, why did Vermont become independent state instead of being one of the 13 (14) Colonies?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

When did the Kings of France start speaking French?

Bit of a strange question , if you'd allow it. I just came back from a trip in Northern France and visited a lot of the medieval historical sites. At the Palais de Tau in Reims, they implied that Hugh Capet was the first King of France that spoke 'vieux francais' instead of 'francique' . in the crypts of Saint Remi and St. Denis , the names of the queens and princesses were distinctly Germanic sounding , such as 'Bertha , Evochildis, Clothilde , Guntheuc, Fredegund, Theudechild, Ragintrudis, Wulfehundis , Bertrada...etc'. After the 800s they seem to have taken on more French (?) sounding names like Adela, Eleanor, Anne and Isabella. I saw that the Oath of Strasbourg was the first written text in 'old French' dated in 842 , which is a generation before Hugh Capet. Would it be correct to assume that by then bilingualism had taken hold in the aristocracy and completely disappeared in a generation?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

What happened to the Confederate soldier that fired the shot that killed Stonewall Jackson?

Been listening to a few Army War College lectures on Youtube about the Battle of Gettysburg and its mentioned a few times that Stonewall Jackson was killed by friendly fire but for the most part that's all that is said about it, but it got me wondering about what happened to the guy that fired that shot.

Did he get court martialed and booted from the army, did he suddenly find himself volunteered for something that was pretty much a death sentence, was he taken into the woods and quietly disposed of or something else entirely?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

Aside from consanguinity, what reasons could I present to the medieval Catholic church to attain an annulment? And do we have examples?

I'm assuming it differs much based on gender and class, so I'm asking from the perspective of a male member (prince, king, etc.) of a royal family (prior to the reformation).

  1. What arguments could I present that are legitimate/likely to persuade the Catholic church to grant me an annulment besides consanguinity?
  2. Do we know of any medieval noblemen/women who attained annulments where the reasoning wasn't consanguinity (I am of the understanding that this means the spouses are too closely related)?

1 Answers 2022-06-25

What did abortions look like through the ages?

Do we have evidence of early abortions? Was it a taboo?

1 Answers 2022-06-24

What was the point of the German Confederation (1815-1866)?

1 Answers 2022-06-24

So many babies were abandoned in Medieval Europe that many churches provided drop-off places for mothers to safely leave newborns so they wouldn't be taken as slaves or killed by the elements/wild animals. What happened to these kids in the church's care? Were they all destined to be monks?

2 Answers 2022-06-24

Sparta famously killed newborn infants that its elders deemed unfit. But Plato promotes infanticide for eugenic reasons, and the Carthaginians sacrificed babies in religious ceremonies. Was infanticide fairly widespread in the ancient world? Did most societies practice it in some form?

If so, should we assume that thinkers like Plato were giving cover for a tradition that had its route in economics/scarcity? Something else?

1 Answers 2022-06-24

Megathread: Roe v Wade overturned by the US Supreme Court

As many of you are likely already well aware, this morning the Supreme Court of the United States released a decision overturning Roe v Wade, the 1973 decision that recognized a constitutional right to abortion in the US.

AskHistorians is not a place to discuss current events, argue over modern politics, or post hot takes. There are plenty of other spaces to do that! We do, however, realize that this moment has a lot of history leading up to it, and will be a focus of a lot of questions and discussions on AskHistorians and elsewhere. Therefore, we are creating this megathread to serve as a hub for all of your historically-based questions about abortion in America, Roe v Wade, historic attitudes towards abortion, the politics of reproductive rights, and other relevant topics.

Our rules still apply here, especially our rules about civility and the 20 Year Rule. We will remove comments that break these rules.

If you would like to learn more, we have a lot of answers already available on the subreddit, including

This list is far from exhaustive, but will hopefully give you some background on common questions we get asked about abortion.

33 Answers 2022-06-24

Are Snorri Sturluson’s accounts of Harald Hardrada’s life trustworthy?

Many of the records of King Harald’s life comes from Snorri’s accounts, namely Haralds saga Sigurðarsonar and I was wondering, due to Snorri’s reputation as a propagandist and some of the rather… outlandish events of the saga (the escape from Constantinople among them) can we trust these accounts or are they just more of Snorri’s propaganda? Are there Kievan, Italian, or Byzantine records that confirm some of the events or are they entirely fabricated?

1 Answers 2022-06-24

For a medieval army, what was "foraging" like whilst in friendly territory?

Whilst in enemy territory, supplies that were needed to feed the army were presumably taken by force, but what about when the army is marching or encamped in friendly territory? Was it still essentially plunder, or were the peasants (or their lord?) compensated for the goods? Was any consideration ever given to ensure that the villages supplying the army weren't starved ?

2 Answers 2022-06-24

How did an army know they were fighting an enemy, not a team mate?

Europe - 1400’s

Let’s say England have invaded France. Most low level soldiers on both sides would have have the same type of armour. Steel and swords

Amongst the madness of war wouldn’t everyone blend in and look the same. How would they know at a glance that the solider next to them is an enemy?

1 Answers 2022-06-24

Where can I learn more about my city's (Alexandria, Egypt) history?

I'm not really into history and never really cared. Big debate on whether I should or shouldn't care but that's for another time. However, I live in Alexandria, Egypt and Im pretty sure you can say that it's in the top 10 most important cities when it comes to world history. Maybe thats bullshit but all I know is it's significant enough and I wanted to learn more about it.

I'd love it if it was in video/documentary format rather than "go read ____" as I said, I find history incredibly boring and a video will help keep my attention. Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-06-24

What was the weight of carts/wagons used for land transport in the Mediterranean area in Roman times?

I am writing a paper about land transport using oxen carts and wagons in Roman times (including some computing simulations of where these could move or not depending on their load) and I am finding difficulties in defining the dimensions and weight of the different types of wagons/carts in use in Antiquity.

I have checked several books/papers on the topic (Raepsaet, 2002; Raepsaet 2016; van Tilburg, 2012, amongst others), but I can't find this piece of information anywhere. I am particularly interested on the cart known as plaustrum, which seems to be the typical rural cart used to transport agricultural produce and goods, but I am open to suggestions of other types of carts. It seems they found a possible (preserved) example in a rural villa in Boscoreale (Italy), but I can't get the book (De Caro, 1994) anywhere to check if there is a detailed description that would include this information...

Any help or ideas would be most welcomed! (And thanks in advance!)

1 Answers 2022-06-24

210 / 7255

Back to start