Origins of the Holocaust

Which argument, the functionalist or intentionalist argument, do you think has a higher chance of being correct based on the current evidence available?

i.e. which argument do you agree with: the Holocaust was always the plan of the Nazi regime, or, the Holocaust was more of a spontaneous plan that sort of evolved over time, or was an example of the Nazi's just clutching at straws.

2 Answers 2019-01-26

German Grenades

What was the designer logic behind the German tomahawk grenades? These would be the grandes most commonly seen in WW2 with the wooden handles. Were they supposedly easier to throw or was there some other purpose in their design? I feel like they would have been cumbersome and heavier to carry around.

1 Answers 2019-01-26

How did the rolling pin become the stereotypical implement housewives in fiction use to chase after their deadbeat husbands/good-for-nothing sons?

There are many kitchen implements that would be as useful, if not more so, for this purpose. A ladle and a pan come to mind spontaneously. However, at least in modern stories, the rolling pin seems to be the instrument of choice. How did this come about?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Were there ever dark skinned people part of councils in the british royalty during the years 1400-1600?

I just watched Mary Queen of Scots and I was intrigued on how they had a dark skinned person part of Queen Elizabeth’s council and he often traveled to Scotland to speak to Mary Stuart. Is this possible or is this just a stunt to support all races in film?

2 Answers 2019-01-26

Why did Spain remain neutral in ww2?

Wasn’t it obvious that spain would be a target after the allies were defeated?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

How public was antisemitism in German politics prior to WW1?

Did German Jews have any indication in 1912-ish that a great percentage of their neighbors sought to murder them? How violent was the public antisemitism of the German Empire?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Did ancient Egypt before contact with Greeks and Romans have a considerable black Nubian population?

So I watched some videos about ancient Egypt and saw that the 23 dynasty of Egypt was ruled by Nubians, so It made me think if Nubians had a certain huge percentage of Egypt.

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Saturday Showcase | January 26, 2019

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Questions concerning Cyrus the Great and The Achaemenid Empire during his rule

  1. I'm sure many of the then separate countries were practicing slavery. I'd imagine being conquered by the man who made the first ever known declaration of human rights would result in some complications and I'm especially interested in how the Babylonians reacted when Cyrus famously freed their captive Jewish population. So how did they react? What were some of said complications? And if anyone has enough time on their hands, what about some of the other places still practicing slavery?

  2. For the areas of the empire where slavery was successfully abolished or was never all that widespread in the first place, who were the farmers if not the slaves?

  3. How did the Greeks view Cyrus during and/or after his rule?

Thank you to anyone who answers any one of the questions in advance.

edit: grammar and formatting

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Is what we consider the fashion of past decades what fashionable people wore then, or what the majority of people wore then?

2 Answers 2019-01-26

If I'm new to history (as a hobby), I know some general information about history, what books could I read, to start forming a more in depth understanding? Where should I begin?

2 Answers 2019-01-26

Broad question, what can people tell me of early 11th century Iceland ? I’m reading up for what I am portraying in re-enactments so all information is helpful, thanks

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Was there ever any attempt by the Anglo-saxon kingdoms of the British isles to seek help from the Angles and Saxons of the continent during the viking age?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

I'm a rifleman in the trences on the western front of WW1. After a long period on the front line I get pulled back to a rest period. Is there a training regime? Do I get special training to replace fallen specialists from my unit?

And in general, what was life like for a soldier on the western front when he was not on the front line? Did they train? Are there images of front operation bases away from the front lines? Are there recommended books or other sources on that topic? Thank you very very much in advance!

2 Answers 2019-01-26

Why does the French-Algerian war receive so little attention?

I read today that France sent 500,000 men to Algeria in the 1950s, comparable to American commitment in Vietnam. Terror attacks in metropolitan France killed five thousand people. One of the world's leading democracies faced a military coup, and was forced to blow up a nuclear bomb to avoid it falling into the coup's hands.

How have I never heard of this!?!

4 Answers 2019-01-26

Why was Aristotle's successor, Theophrastus, not renowned as his predecessors? Aristotle was taught by Plato, who learned from Socrates

There are major courses for philosophy of Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, but few people can name the works of Theophrastus. Why were his works not as intellectually powerful or influential?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Why would Germany be collecting barcodes in the 80’s

I’ve been reading the graphic novel Marzi, about a girl growing up in communist Poland in the 1980’s. In one story, a boy in the community has a medical condition that he needs to travel to Germany to get help for, but can’t afford it. So the German authorities say if the community sends them barcodes starting with the number 4, they’ll help them. According to the narrator, they had no idea why Germany wanted barcodes, but did it anyways. I also have no idea why they would want barcodes. Google has no idea why they would want barcodes. Does anyone here have an idea?

2 Answers 2019-01-26

How militarily significant were Hannibal's war elephants? How advantageous were they in battle?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Was there ever actually a “right to trial by combat”? If so, when, where, and how was that right invoked and administered?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-26

Why have Jews been at the receiving end so many times in history?Eg.Nazi Germany, Babylonian Exile etc.

1 Answers 2019-01-26

What were the major differences between the Chavin, Nazca, and Moche cultures in the ancient Andes?

In terms of culture, how were they different? Were the religions the same? I’m just curious as I’ve read about them and would like to know more.

1 Answers 2019-01-26

I'm a rural citizen of a Soviet Social Republic wake up in 1991 to the news that the USSR has dissolved; in what concrete ways (legal, societal, etc) has my life changed?

2 Answers 2019-01-26

Does the hacking, slashing broadsword fighting seen in many medieval movies have any basis in actual practices?

I'm talking about the type of swordplay seen in this clip from Macbeth, the "high guard" slashing seen in this clip from Kingdom of Heaven, and so on.

I've read (in apparently reliable sources like this article) that actual medieval broadsword fighting was much more focused on lunges and thrusts, intended to get the tip of the blade inside the enemy's armor and inflict a wound as quickly as possible.

My question isn't "Did experienced medieval knights fence with more speed and skill than modern stuntmen," because the answer to that is obviously "yes."

I'm more asking whether the type of hack-and-slash fighting we see in movies ever was practiced in the medieval period — say, for showboating at tournaments, maybe — or if just it's a flat-out fabrication of modern filmmakers.

1 Answers 2019-01-26

How did lions become such a common symbol in European heraldry considering they aren't native to Europe?

1 Answers 2019-01-26

What percentage of arrows hit the target during medieval warfare?

So I've been watching some medieval war movies lately and notices that it seems like a super small percentage of arrows actually hit the target, are these movies representing how archers would have fought in the past? Is this at all possible to find out?

3 Answers 2019-01-26

⯇ 2153 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start