Why did Spain not participate in WWII with its fascist allies?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Books on the legal tradition of islam?

Hello! Recently my interest has been piqued by Islam's legal code and how it effects Islamic governments that identify as islamic. I was wondering if any of you well read people have book recommendations on sharia's implementation in government and how it is laid out in the Qur'an. Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Why is Pearl Harbor considered an intelligence failure?

In what way was the attack on Pearl Harbor an intelligence failure? To me, the term intelligence failure seems to imply that the US could've known that the Japanese were going to attack but failed to act upon this information.

So does this mean it was an intelligence failure in terms of collection? But then again, what info was missed out in terms of collection then?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

What was the day to day life of a pilot in WWII?

What did pilots or other crew do when they weren’t up for a mission? Like how often or how long were furloughs in between their missions? My grandfather was a Lancaster Bomber Pilot and he flew around 20 missions, but was in active service for several years during the War. What would the average pilot do in the time between missions?

2 Answers 2019-01-09

When the atomic bomb was dropped on Japan, as this bomb was a top secret project, what was the reaction of the American and worldwide civilian population to the existence of the weapon?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Any recommendations for books on Ancient Greek colonies, particularly the ones established furthest from Greece? (along the coast of modern France and Spain, in the black sea, North Africa, etc.)

Of particular interest would be anything that goes into detail about the social history of these cities, how the Greeks who settled interacted with indigenous populations and how day to day life was led

1 Answers 2019-01-09

Did the US decisively defeat Iraqi forces in the Battle of 73 Easting because of superior technology, training, planning or a combination?

Specifically the Battle of 73 Easting, but the 1st Gulf War in general was a decisive defat of the Iraqi military, with very little loss of personnel and material. Was this due to severe discrepancy in technology (IR sights/night vision/depleted uranium rounds), training of troops (use of hull down tactics) or strategic/operational planning? Obviously it’s a combination of all but what was the main factor?

1 Answers 2019-01-09

The Troubles

I'm looking for suggestions on the best book or books on The Troubles in Northern Ireland... Anybody got any recommendations? Thanks!

2 Answers 2019-01-09

A question on the logic of the Netherlands going to the Spanish Habsburgs

Hey AskHistorians,

This has been bugging me for a while. I understand how the Seventeen provinces of the Netherlands ended up in Habsburg control - via the Burgundian inheritance crisis etc. However, when it came to the abdication of Charles V, and the division of his lands between Austrian and Spanish branches of the dynasty, what compelled them to grant the Netherlands to the Spanish?

I'm probably wrong here, since an embarrassing amount of my knowledge of the period comes from Europa Universalis 4, but werent the provinces de jure a part of the Holy Roman Empire? It strikes me as odd that, firstly, Ferdinand did not automatically inherit the provinces as the new Emperor. Secondly, that Charles or his court imagined that the Netherlands would be better ruled from Spain when a) the Spanish Empire was already spanning the globe and the crown's focus would be largely in Asia and the Americas and b) the Netherlands are separated from Spain by its two principal rivals France and England, is really bizzare. Surely they woukd have been better managed by a ruler with a power base in the country next door?

2 Answers 2019-01-08

Is Viktor Frankl's account of WWII concentration camps contentious to historians?

I've been reading through Viktor Frankl's book Man's Search for Meaning about his concentration camp experiences and psychological theory of meaning-making. My reading and interest in his book has primarily though an existential lens and for personal reasons, and to this end it seems like a good book, but I've recently found criticisms about him and his book. I would like a historian's perspective.

Wikipedia has goes into it on his book page and the author's page. In short, some argue his works come off as victim blaming. The idea that people can rise to the occasion and create meaning in even the horrific conditions might inspire, but his apparent insistence that everyone can do so might denigrate those who didn't.

I'm tempted to recommend the book, but I don't want to do so if people are likely to takeaway the wrong idea or if it's historically contentious.

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Can you recommend any books or documentaries about people who worked within the Nazis with the goal to bring them down?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

How did Habsburgs have title of "King of Bulgaria" in 16th - 18th century? And where exactly is "Kingdom of Cumania"?

So today reading I found this "In the Late Middle Ages the Kingdom of Hungary, or to be precise, the union of the Hungarian-Croatian states that had existed since 1102, was one of Europe’s important powers. It was a middle power whose rulers boasted nine royal titles by the last third of the thirteenth century, or as their impressively long Latin-language titles claimed: “Dei gratia Hungariae, Dalmatiae, Croatiae, Ramae, Serviae, Galitiae, Lodomeriae, Cumaniae, Bulgariaeque rex etc. …”, that is, “By the grace of God, King of Hungary, Dalmatia, Croatia, Rama [i.e. Bosnia], Serbia, Galicia, Lodomeria, Cumania, and Bulgaria, etc.”"

This is list of all titles of Habsburg rulers in 16th and 17th century:

  • Dei gratia / divina favente clementia electus Romanorum imperator, semper augustus, ac Germaniae, Hungariae, Bohemiae, Dalmatiae, Croatiae, Sclavoniae, Ramae, Serviae, Galitiae, Lodomeriae, Cumaniae, Bulgariaeque etc. rex, archidux Austriae, dux Burgundiae, Brabantiae, Styriae, Carinthiae, Carnioliae, marchio Moraviae, dux Luxemburgae ac superioris et inferioris Silesiae, Wierthembergae et Thekae, princeps Sveviae, comes Habsburgi, Tyrolis, Ferreti, Kiburgi et Goritiae, landgravius Alsatiae, marchio Sacri Romani Imperii supra Anasum Burgoviae ac superioris et inferioris Lusatiae, dominus Marchiae Sclavonicae, portus Naonis et Salinarum

that is in English

  • By the Grace of God Emperor of the Romans, forever August, and King of Germany, Hungary, Bohemia, Dalmatia, Croatia, Slavonia, Rama (i.e. Bosnia), Serbia, Galicia, Lodomeria, Cumania, and Bulgaria*, etc. Archduke of Austria, Duke of Burgundy, Brabant, Styria, Carinthia, Carniola, Marquis of Moravia, Duke of Luxemburg, of Upper and Lower Silesia, of Wurttemberg and Teck, Prince of Swabia, Count of Habsburg, Tyrol, Kiburg, and Gorizia, Landgrave of Alsace, Marquis of the Burgau in the Holy Roman Empire, of Upper and Lower Lusatia, Lord of the Marches of Slavonia, of Portenau and Salins*

With quick search I was able to find that first person where we see with this title is Sigismund of Luxembourg - but problem is that I was not able to find how did he get that claim? He is nowhere listed as king of Bulgaria but in title. As he lived from 1368 to 1437, and we know that Bulgarian Kingdom stoped existing in 1422 with Constantine II. it's safe to think he obviously had some claims for Bulgarian Kingdom but I cant find source of his legitimation - for now I cant see any connection from marriage or family? Also I could be wrong and he is not the first Habsburg to use that tittle? So question is:

  1. How did Habsburgs get claim on Kingdom of Bulgaria? And was it Sigismund that took it first or not?

For second question - Cumania. First I have this from wikipedia, "Cumania diocese became part of the superior archbishopric of Esztergom, determining King Béla IV of Hungary to add "Rex Cumaniae" (King of Cumania) to his titles in 1228, and later to grant asylum to the Cumans in face of the Mongol invasion."So my question is:

  1. What exactly is Cumania in this context, when speaking of kingdom? Where would we put that kingdom on map? I was albe to find this map of where Cumans lived in 13th century, but it for sure cant be "Kingdom of Cumania" since that region is already under "Kingdom of Hungary"
  2. What is legal background of Bela IV. taking that title? Cause Cumans in Hungary had no geographical connection to old Cuman "realm" - so how did Bela IV. claim title of "King of Cumania", and also why would ruler just add title like that (apart from wanting to have more of titles)?

And last question for both Cumania and Bulgaria:

  1. since both titles did not appear in "Grand title of the Emperor of Austria" when did, and why, Habsburgs drop claim on it?

​

2 Answers 2019-01-08

Was smallpox blankets a real thing?

If someone can direct me to a post where this has been answered please do but

​

I was in class where my teacher had said that Andrew Jackson was a bad guy because he gave small pox blankets of the Indians but I found this strange as germ theory wasn't developed until 23 years later from when the Mandan outbreak occurred? can someone help I know biological warfare was used before this but I just dont think its true. If you may also cite some sources. Thanks in advance

​

TL;DR: Was Smallpox blankets a thing if so please provide sources if not the same.

1 Answers 2019-01-08

My colleague told me today, that his family fled Vietnam when he was 7 years old and that his family fought against the North Vietnam. What happened to those who fought against North Vietnam and stayed after the war ended?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

What was Jerusalem like before the Crusades?

I'm currently writing an essay on Islamic history and I just got to the Crusades. My understanding is that Jerusalem was conquered by 'Umar, or Omar, from the Byzantines, and he treated the Christians and Jews there with respect. However, I've recently read that it was the Seljuk Turks that conquered it from the Byzantines, and that they treated the Christians and Jews horribly, and that's what sparked the first Crusade. Which is correct? Or am I completely misunderstanding the whole situation? I'm a little under the weather so my brain unfortunately isn't functioning at full capacity.

Also, if the Seljuk Turks were the ones to conquer Jerusalem, what did they actually do to the Christians and Jews?

Finally, any books or articles you can recommend on the early history of Jerusalem and the Crusades?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2019-01-08

A century after Muhammad, a Berber King in Morocco proclaimed himself his successor and wrote down "revelations" in a book also called Quran, with 80 chapters and somewhat different rules and teachings. What do we know about this "Quran 2" and its followers?

His name was Salih ibn Tarif, and his Wikipedia article has some details about his life and teachings.

However, I'm very doubtful since the sources mentioned seem to be later detractors, and I don't have the expertise to identify what is real and what is propaganda. I fear that like with many Christian "heresies", their opponents might have exaggerated things to make them seem more silly or ridiculous for everybody else. Rules like ten obligatory daily prayers instead of five seem impractical, and unlimited wives and divorces remind me of "free love" accusations against some heresies, so I don't know if I should believe what I'm reading.

I'm also doubtful of the association I found with political motives (independence from the Umayyads) and/or Berber identity.

Did this Berber Quran survive, or can we trust the sources we have about it? What were its real teachings? And is it true that it really gained followers, lasting three centuries in the region until it was crushed by the Almoravids?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

In medieval times when people drank alcohol heavily, how were babies able to be born healthy (without fetal alcohol syndrome)? Was their alcohol different from today's drinks?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Help me learn something about this painting

I found a picture of what looks like a painting on the Internet which I liked (I don't remember its exact source), it looked something like an 18th century painting. I used image search engines to find out something about it but it got me no results. I'm new here and I'm not sure if this is related to the subreddit but I'd like anyone to recognize the era or nationality of the painting, maybe even name the painting. Here's the image I found https://postimg.cc/21ckmQsz Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2019-01-08

Did the Kingdom of Bohemia ever come under attack by the Mongol Empire?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Since the Native Americans frequently died due to lack of immunity to Euopean disease why didn't the Europeans share the same fate from North American disease? Is it just not talked about?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Is there any country music influenced by or that sounds like Soul or Blues music?

See title. Though Im not sure this is exactly the place I want to be...but heres to trying!

​

Im asking cause I told a friend I thought Chris Stapleton sounded like something Id hear Otis Redding sing in terms of the sound and style. So it got me wondering, since Otis Redding was around during the 60's, when I THINK country music sounded VERY different from how it sounds now, could there have been some cross pollination of genres back then and what some examples of country music that was influenced, collaborated with, or sounded like what primarily African American music sounded like in that time whether before or after de segregation.

​

TL:DR

​

Are there any country musicians from the 60's that sound like soul music? Specifically from Georgia just for my curiosities...

2 Answers 2019-01-08

Did George Washington have the same level of protection and security as modern day presidents and other American political figures?

It seems today that you couldn't stand within 50 feet of a president or high level political figure without an army of secret service and other security. I'm being hyperbolic, but it still stands true that the protections are crazy.

I guess I'm wondering did George Washington or any other original United States colonial & revolutionary politicians have similar security? If not, at what point did the security become so intense for presidents in the United States?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Does my cup of Red Rose tea bear any resemblance to the tea drunk by our ancestors 100, 200, ...1000 years ago? Has tea always been basically the same? Has it always been associated with caffeine?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Why did The Wright Brothers got all the credit for ''creating'' the airplane and Santos Dumont's contribution to aviation was almost forgotten, speacially in The United States and european countries?

Most people in America have never heard of Santos Dumont, also in in Europe. Without him, aviation wouldn't be the same. The answer seems pretty obvious, but I wanted someone to discuss that.

1 Answers 2019-01-08

Is there a connection between the Irk Bitig and the I Ching?

Both are divinatory texts that should contain 64 prognostications (although the Irk Bitig contains errors leading to 65 prognostications) and both are known from China. Is there any historical evidence for a connection between them?

1 Answers 2019-01-08

⯇ 2186 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start