When did it stop being normal for Leaders (Generals, Kings, etc) to die in battle?

Lately I have been seeing lots of news stories about Generals being killed on the front lines in Eastern Europe. I know this must have been quite common before modern communication technology came into being, but when was that? Was this common in the 18th century? 19th? Did it vary by region? Or was it never really common, and this is just my modern biases?

1 Answers 2022-06-06

At first glance there are many similarities between Byzantine Basilica (Like the Hagia Sophia) and many mosques in their structure. To what extent did Byzantine architecture influence later architecture in Islamic Arabia, Persia, and beyond?

2 Answers 2022-06-06

How did Japan rapidly industrialize during the Meiji Restoration, and why was it allowed to do so by the at the time Imperial Powers like the UK, France, and the United States?

2 Answers 2022-06-06

The Netherlands. What was the country and culture life before the dams? What were the specific catalysts behind building the dams?

1 Answers 2022-06-06

Did the Anglo-Saxons really exist?

In her book The Emergence of the English, Cambridge professor Susan Oosthuizen argues that our entire understanding of the Anglo-Saxons is based on outdated and disproven assumptions, that recent developments in history, archaeology, genetics, and linguistics indicate that we may have it all wrong, and that the Anglo-Saxons as we understand them may never have existed, and their invasion of Britain never happened. She gave a video lecture on it in 2020 which can be viewed here: https://vimeo.com/425282049. What are your thoughts on this? Are there any other academics who have supported or refuted her arguments?

2 Answers 2022-06-06

Why didn't Argentina's invasion of the Falklands trigger NATO's Article 5?

1 Answers 2022-06-06

How did tourism work in ancient times?

I was reading about Sparta the other day and while reading, saw that by the Roman times, the Spartans were reputedly a tourist attraction for the Romans. This brings me to the question, how did tourism work in the ancient world? Wouldn’t it be dangerous for people to leave their homes in large, crime ridden cities for extended periods of time?

1 Answers 2022-06-06

Why did Christians stop celebrating Jewish holidays like Passover and Hanukkah?

In the New Testament it specifically mentions Jesus and the people around him celebrating Passover and Hanukkah. Why did Christians stop celebrating these holidays when Jesus, Mary, Joseph and the apostles all would have celebrated these holidays as well as presumably other Jewish holidays that date back prior to Jesus’ life?

1 Answers 2022-06-06

Why was there such backlash from religious groups to Harry Potter but not other series like Lord of the Rings?

Good afternoon y’all! I’m hoping this subreddit might be able to provide some insight on a question I had: Why was there such backlash from religious groups to the Harry Potter series (1997) but wasn’t to the Lord of the Rings series, either books (1950’s) or film (2001)? Back when the Harry Potter books were being released the catholic school in my town banned them from being used in book reports or school activities with the reasoning that the books showed magic in a positive light and being used for good. This logic seems to me like it would apply to Lord of the Rings as well, for example Gandalfs role as a wizard who used magic for good. Any insight any of y’all could provide would be greatly appreciated! Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2022-06-06

What did soldiers in ancient battles do when they had to relieve themselves?

It's my understanding that it wasn't unusual for ancient battles to go on for hours of nonstop fighting. If you were a soldier on the front lines and you really had to pee or poop, would you just go right where you stood and keep fighting? Or would you run off to the side quick to do your business and then run back. Not sure if there'll even be any sources for this I'm just curious.

1 Answers 2022-06-06

Is this battle cry based on french military history?

In many film depicting World War 1 there is a french battle cry that they shouted when going over the top.

In this scene at around 1:55 the commander shouts it and the men repeat it

It sounds like “En la mort” or “A la mort”. Does anyone know the exact words or the meaning of the words if it has been used before or is a part of french military history? Also when it first appeared. Thanks

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Did any pre-colombian indigenous groups have cultural signs of homophobia, or was it truly a western import?

I've seen indigenous activists argue that homophobia only existed in the America's following colonization. Considering the large variety of cultures inhabiting the America's pre-columbus, did any have evidence of practices we would recognize as homophobia?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Why is old writing (pre 20th century) so tedious and hard to follow?

Aurelius's "Meditations", Plato's "Republic" and Smith's "Wealth of Nations" are very similar in that they are written in a very abstract language. There are either no introductions to various ideas or arguments the authors wish to make. And if examples are being given, they are long winded and exhaustive. In "Wealth of Nations" Smith will give "the cobbler, and the smith, and the portman, and the shipwright" etc when just one or two examples would have been fine. And many very basic "obvious" ideas are explained.

In one hour of reading, I can "digest" 10 times more ideas out of a modern book like "Selfish Gene" than I could out of an old book like "Wealth of Nations". And I wonder why is that the case.

4 Answers 2022-06-05

Did Austria want to join the German Empire of 1871?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Did foreigners and diplomats face segregation in the United States in the 60s and before? if so, how did this affect diplomacy between the US and foreign nations?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

[Noob Question] Native American Cultures/Empires/City States, how advanced were they compared to ones from Old world during the same time period ?

I'm looking to know how ahead or behind they were in terms of science, mathematics, technology, medicine, military etc. compared to the prominent people of the other side of world (Europe, Asia, Africa).

I know Native Americans are not just one group of people. I'll list them groups of people (the ones I want to know about).

This question is inspired by the video "Timeline of the Pre-Columbian Americas" of Youtube channel "Useful Charts". So, I'll list the ones I'd like to know about in the order he explained it. Also, I listed them from Oldest to Newest (for the lack of better words).

  • Mesoamerica -
  1. Olmecs
  2. Zapotecs / Mayans
  3. Toltecs
  4. Aztecs
  • North America -
  1. Dorset People
  2. Hopewell Traditions
  3. Mississippian Culture
  4. Great Puebloans
  • South America -
  1. Nazca
  2. Huari / Tiwanaku
  3. Incans

I listed all these doesn't mean any of you have to answer all of them, learning about one at a time is perfectly fine. I gave the list of names because I thought it'd help me break down what's' there to learn about.

I should also inform you that, I'm not a historian. So, explaining things in easy to understand manner is highly appreciated. Also I may need to ask further questions based on your answer.

Thirdly, If I've broken any rules or wrote the question in such a way that it makes it difficult to answer, please do let me know. I'll try to edit or delete+repost properly.

Thank You.

EDIT : I've discovered the FAQ.

1 Answers 2022-06-05

How many years did it take to complete Rome's 250k miles of roads?

I just saw this map, and it got me wondering about the timeframe for that expansion. https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/v590ov/roman_empires_250000_miles_of_roads_reimagined_as/

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Prior to industrialization, were there any personal transportation vehicles/devices? Similar to roller skates, scooters, longboards, etc.?

I did some reading here and it seems that bikes would've been a little too complex to manufacture prior to industrialization, but it seems strange to me that in the past we don't seem to find people using something like a simple scooter (maybe like a wooden segway with 4 wheels, for example) or skateboard to get around, or at least for leisure.

I can see them maybe not being the most practical if they were flimsy or a bit awkward or if streets were of poor quality, but do we have any record of people trying stuff like that out, or at least thinking about ways to not have to walk everywhere without needing a beast of burden?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | June 05, 2022

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2022-06-05

The USA appears to have schools with a unique and strong focus on school pride, are there any historical events which contribute to this school culture?

I understand other countries have school pride (particularly around sports), but American Pep Rallies, Homecoming, and Spirit Week seem unique. I remember hearing that the US school pride gain significance in the lead up to the US joining WWI. However, I can’t seem to find any connections on line. Any help would be greatly appreciated, thank you.

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Door-to-door salesmen were still among the best ways to sell books in the late 1950s/early 1960s. When did that change, and what lead to their decline?

According to Wikipedia, after The Great Books series flopped on launch, Encyclopedia Britannica turned to traveling door-to-door salesmen, who did much better.

...through that method, 50,000 sets were sold in 1961...According to Alex Beam, Great Books of the Western World eventually sold a million sets.

Encyclopedias and similar reference books were still big sellers as late as 1990, but door-to-door salesmen had mostly disappeared by then. So what social or economic forces lead to their decline? Were book stores becoming more common? Were people buying them through department stores?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

How were hand-drawn maps detailed accurately in the early 1900s?

I have been reading about the various expeditions of Harry St John Bridger Philby and was wondering how he would have added detail to him maps . I understand that he carried a prismatic compass, theodolite, and a chronograph watch by which he could find his longitude, latitude.

He mentions how he prepared a piece of paper by sketching on it the relavent lines of longitude and latitude for his travels. I presume that each time he took a reading of his longitude and latitude he would mark his location on the map but how would he have filled in details such as cliffs, mountains and mountain ranges from ground level with any level of accuracy?

Examples of Maps byMr Philby

1 Answers 2022-06-05

What is the history of the fishing pole?

When did fishing poles start to be used regularly and what did they look like? How did they advance, and what did the significant advances look like?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

What did Arabian Knights call themselves, during their time?

I'm assuming we call them "Arabian" Knights today as the closest identifier to their skill and nobility as warriors, akin to European Knights of the same period. Comparatively, you wouldn't call a gladiator a Roman Knight, or a samurai a Japanese Knight. So did they have their own proper identifiers during their time?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

For many oil-rich countries, the abundance of oil becomes some sort of "curse" that destroys or prevents democracy from happening. Examples are Iraq and Venezuela. How were Norway and Canada inmune from this curse?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

231 / 7255

Back to start