Were ancient Athenian citizens better suited (than in modern times) to grasp the political issues of the day, and familiarize themselves with candidates for office?

Bertrand Russell's book on Western Philosophy, and Edith Hamilton's The Greek Way seem to suggest this was the case. But I don't recall them going into detail so I'm hoping the folks here may be able to assist my understanding.

1 Answers 2022-06-05

Whenever a servant comes or goes in Downton Abbey, a great deal of importance is placed on securing a good reference. Is this accurate? What was the hiring process like for domestic servants in the early 20th century?

2 Answers 2022-06-05

Why did marxism come to dominate the international socialist movement as opposed to the works of men like Proudhon, Kroptokin, Tucker, etc?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

We know that ritual suicide was more or less common in Japan among the warrior class. Was it common among regular people?

There tons of stories about samurais and ninjas and other warriors killing themselves in a number of situations, but what about regular people?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

How did the 1970s energy crisis impact the commercial nuclear industry?

Researching for a story about a lobbyist for private atomic industries beginning on Earth Day and ending around Three Mile Island.

Any examples you can provide pertaining to specific companies/products/services would be incredible. I know that globally proliferation emerged in a big way but I’m trying to focus on industries in the domestic US.

Also whatever resources you might suggest is welcome.

Thank you kindly for your input

1 Answers 2022-06-05

WW1/WW2 cruisers were very much the successors to Age of Sail frigates in terms of role and design parameters. Both were fast, reasonably-armed warships capable of independent operations over long distances. So why then were they classified as cruisers, and not frigates?

1 Answers 2022-06-05

How much knowledge was actually lost because of the fire of the Alexandria library?

Some go as far as saying it contained documents about prototypes for steam engines or inventions way ahead of its time and we would be ~100 years ahead of it hadn’t burned

Other say that not so much

1 Answers 2022-06-04

During the 70's or 80's, were there any people sounding the horn about how big a thing the internet would become, before it went public? And how accurately did they predict its impact on the world?

Hi there, so as per the title, I'm wondering if there were any of those "dude this thing, the internet, it's gonna change everything, you'll be able to do this, that, blah blah blah" people out there?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

What was the goal of the Tianamen Square protestors? What causes were they protesting for?

Since the 33 year anniversary is today, I was wondering what the protestors wanted? I know many were students, but did they want a capitalist western style democracy? Government reform like the Soviet Union? Or something more specific? What were their goals?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Why did the US army, never adapted the rank of "Field Marshal"?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Did Vikings use to cut the head of enemies and put it near their backside? why?

I've seen the Northman a few weeks ago (I won't make any particular spoiler), and in one scene the head of an enemy is chopped off and then put near his backside.

A friend of mine said vikings used to do this in order to avoid evil spirits to raise from the dead body, but in another work (Vikings tv series), so in other circumstances, a character explains that this action was done to vilify the victim.

So I ask, which of these hyphotesis could be the most realistic, in your opinion?

3 Answers 2022-06-04

Speaking of fascists in France, again, is there a better explanation for France's collapse during WW2 than William Shirer's explanations?

I read Shirer's Berlin Diary and Rise & Fall of the 3rd Reich several years ago. Shirer's explanation for why France fell to the Nazis so soon has the ring of truth to me more than others, but I'm one of these amateurs who has read a few books rather than some people in here with proper expertise.

IIRC he acknowledges some practical matters like the Maginot line not being long enough when Belgium fell and Nazis could go around it, forests that France did not think tanks could get thru, but German tanks had improved. Gas stations on main roads = tanks have fuel nearby unlike 1918. OK. That's certainly part of it. He spends much more time and ink on cultural rot. He characterized the French military as half sympathetic with communists/Stalin [still Hitler's ally] and half sympathetic with fascism. He also mentioned that the French military upper management was a bit of a gerontocracy. The typical French general, or a realistic characterization, was 75 years old and still had a grudge about grievances his grandfather, also a general, had against the English from the 19th Century. Meanwhile, the typical Nazi general was in his upper 40's, physically fit, got there on merit and hard work, ate the same food as his men, and had less of a feudal nobleman aristocrat vs. a sullen peasant relationship with his fighting men than the French.

Shirer is a journalist writing history and not a tenure-track historian, but he was there and tells a good story. My spidey sense is that this cultural type of reason is (1) difficult to measure and directly observe, (2) no longer fashionable after 7 decades of red scares among academics and knee-jerk pro and anti political correctness. Counting tanks and recording the average age of generals is more concrete, so we are inclined to give it more weight, but my gut says Shirer is onto something.

Anyhoo, France & WW2 has been addressed lots of times here, but please address Shirer's take on it if possible.

2 Answers 2022-06-04

Why did Varangian Guard keep their axes?

Over the course of the history of the Varangian Guard, they consistently adopted Byzantine Greek equipment for shields, armour, and lighter weapons but continued to use the two-handed Dane Axes throughout the period of the Varangians in the Eastern Roman Empire. Why did they keep the axe? And on the other hand, if the big axes were vastly superior, why didn’t others adopt the axes?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

what was the process that led to the discovery that Pseudo-Apollodorus (author of Bibliotheca) wasn't Apollodorus of Athens?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Washington considered his French & Indian War service record a disappointment. Were there any specific officers in the American Revolution he felt were more qualified to command?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

How do we know that the egyptian heiroglyphs are translated correctly?

I know Im just some ignorant fool asking a most likely stupid question and I may have just come across misinformation. However, I will be that fool and still ask until I understand.

While looking into the meaning of egyptian hieroglyphs I've come across a few inconsistencies that concern me a little bit.

For example:

  • adding vowels where there supposedly arent vowels(this may just be to pronounce them?)

  • converting the heiroglyph into the english alphabet(?) And then translating the meaning(I could just be sorely misinformed on this)

-And the big one that gets me is the flat squiggly lines[waves?], where they each have different number of points.(i.e. some of them have 4 top points and 3 bottom points, some have 6:5, some have over 10, etc.) It seems those lines have a very specific purpose, but I'm seeing them being copied down incorrectly. Idk it just seems like a big deal if its not being copied correctly.

Anyways, if it isnt obvious already, I'm really just looking into this as a hobby. I havent really looked enough to find actual books that broach on this topic yet. So as a bonus, if you have suggestions for books on this topic, I'd appreciate it if you let me know.

1 Answers 2022-06-04

What was coffee like before electricity?

I am a musician, and the 18th-century composer Johann Sebastian Bach is known for having spent time at Café Zimmermann in Leipzig, and for his "coffee cantata" in which a woman declares her love for coffee (in cheeky comparison with her beau).

But how did they make coffee before electricity-powered machines? Was it just ground roasted beans soaked in fire-heated water? Or were there machines that produced pressure like modern espresso machines but with manual pumps? I know that air pressure for Bach's organs was produced using big bellows, could it have been a mechanism like that?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Saturday Showcase | June 04, 2022

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Where did the archetypal "fantasy dwarf" culture come from?

I get that dwarves and the basic outline of them come from Scandinavian folklore, but there's also a lot of stuff that don't seem to be clearly based on it, but are also ubiquitous throughout fantasy media.

  • Angular, intricate architecture and material culture

  • Deeply-ingrained clan and/or caste distinctions

  • Relatively high level of technology and mechanisation, sometimes to the disfavour of magic

  • Grumpy, stubborn personalities

  • Harsh, guttal language dominated by velar consonants

  • Tendency towards Scottish/Northern accents in English

  • Runic alphabets

Where did these come from? Are they based loosely on traditional Dwarven attributes, or created wholecloth?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Did other ancient civilizations believe Greek Myth as fact?

I'm reading Herodotus for the first time, and he claims that three entities (Persians, Greeks, Phoenicians) all mentioned accounts, however differing, of the kidnapping of Io, Europea, Medea, Helen.

I'm familiar with these myths, and it makes sense to me that the Greeks would regard these myths as historical, at the very least the Trojan War they would.

What stands out to me is that Herodotus spoke with Phoenicians and Persians who ALSO made reference to these GREEK myths, as if they were historical

How could this be? Did these barbarians hear the Illiad? Were these myths based in history? Has Herodotus simply made things up?

And as a follow up question, how could the Persians possibly cite these myths as a source of animosity between them and the Greeks, when these events would have happened ~900BC or prior, and the Persian Empire wasn't created until 400 years later?

I asked this in a discord but I felt like the question wasn't really answered ... do we have any way of knowing a real answer to this?

This is going to bother me forever if I don't get an answer haha, I would love to hear all your thoughts on it ...

Thank you very much in advance.

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Most *entertaining* book(s) on the Byzantine Empire?

Several posts on this sub have asked for the “best” books on on the Byzantine Empire—typically from the perspective of a student or aspiring historian.

I’m asking from a bit of a different lens:

Can you think of a book on Byzantine that is:

— Gripping — Engaging — Narrative, or has narrative aspects — Possibly biographical

I’m a layperson, not a historian or student of history in any real sense, but have recently discovered a keen interest in western classical history presented through a narrative perspective by absolutely lovvvving Philip Freeman’s biographical works on Alexander the Great, Julius Caesar, and Hannibal. They were complete page turners, while still feeling balanced and factual.

At this point, learning about the Byzantine Empire seems like the somewhat chronological next step.

I realize there’s a ~1000 year history here. Any period—or a high level overview of the whole empire—is of interest as long as the book is entertaining, and not simply a dry factual work.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-06-04

In a 1994 episode of the Simpsons they make a lot of jokes about the Republicans party being evil. When did it become culturally normal to characterise the party this way?

In the 1994 episode “Sideshow Bob Roberts” the republicans are shown to be meeting in a large stormy castle, with unambiguously evil characters like Mr. Burns and Dracula, and they have secret chant.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oSLJKoqwMV4

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sideshow_Bob_Roberts

I know that this was the party that was started as an anti-slavery party. At (roughly) what point did it become the party that pop culture would unapologetically characterise it as the “evil” party?

2 Answers 2022-06-04

Historians, movies have always depicted temples to have booby traps. What is the most detailed booby trap or contraption that has ever been discovered?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

Does the term "decadence" have any value to the history field at all outside of historiography?

It's mentioned constantly in pop culture telling of history and seems to basically be used as a truism to explain the decline of empires. From my perspective its use seems to depend entirely on the user's idiosyncratic collection of perceived social ills. It seems so broad, non-specific, and opinion-based that any specific useful meaning that could be derived from its use is lost.

My question is: does this term have any practical application in the modern field?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

It took 7 years to go from the Wright brothers first flight to Pusher's launch of an aircraft from a Naval vessel at sea. What was it like trying to convince the military that airplanes launched from naval vessels would be effective weapons?

It seems obvious looking back that the military would figure out how powerful aircraft launched from naval vessels would be, but a quick Wikipedia puts the first naval launched aircrafts, and even first use of them in war, surprisingly soon after heaveier-than-air flight was even demonstrated.

Given the degree that war-faring sea-vessels would need serious infrastructure changes to adapt to carry and land airplanes, and the fact that early combat airplanes had serious drawbacks, how did these guys convince the bureaucratic nightmare that is the US military to invest in such technologies? My understanding is that combat airplanes in the first couple of centuries were, yes, effective at carrying light bombs but that what they carried was nothing compared to the artillery a naval vessel could carry, and that additionally such airplanes had zero ability to counter other planes or even harm an armored ship. Basically why bother keeping a couple planes on board in place of another massive cannon? Was it just that they the planes were beneficial as scouts and as their combat proficiency improved naval ships made more and more space for them until we ended up with full-on aircraft carriers?

1 Answers 2022-06-04

232 / 7255

Back to start