Would a medieval Catholic church service be recognizable to a modern Catholic?

Language aside, would mass be performed in a similar enough way for a modern Catholic to follow along? How far back in time can you go before the ceremonies, etc would become unrecognizable?

4 Answers 2018-06-27

Is there any agreed upon date that the United States overtook the United Kingdom in military strength on the North American continent? Was this remarked/acted upon in the US or the UK/Canada?

1 Answers 2018-06-27

If a mother in ancient Rome couldn't produce enough milk for her baby, what would she do?

I assume the answer for upper classes would be to hire a wet nurse. But what if no nurse were available? What did Roman bottle/formula technology look like?

1 Answers 2018-06-27

Why weren't there any pre colombian empires in the modern day USA?

2 Answers 2018-06-27

Looking for a composer who invented new musical scales...

Hello, I have a weird question for you. I'm looking for some obscure composer that my grandfather used to tell me about.

I come from a family of musicians. When I was very little, my grandfather used to tell me stories about this composer who lived some time in the past, who was obsessed with finding new ways to create music. He believed that the heptatonic scale (the one we use today) could be further improved, so he spent his entire life looking for new mathematical ways for frequencies to resonate in a pleasing way to the human ear.

Obviously, my grandfather embellished, telling me that this composer would lock himself in his room and create sounds and tonalities that were other-wordly and abnormal, and that his house-keeper once accidentally heard them and soon afterwards committed suicide. He'd tell me that this composer once wrote a concerto based on his new scale, and the audience ran screaming from the theatre, traumatized and scarred for life. He also said that no human who ever listened to that music would ever dare to sleep again with the lights off.

Since both my grandfather and father died long before the age of the internet, I could never corroborate these stories. I have tried googling to find this supposed composer but it's really hard to find appropriate keywords.

My question, did such a composer ever exist, or did my grandfather make the whole thing up for his own amusement? Not like a composer who created creepypasta-level music that killed people, but a composer who tried to invent new music. Do any of you know of anyone who fits this description?

(I know it sounds weird and silly, but other composers with similar legends surrounding them have existed. For example, Paganini was thought to have made a deal with the Devil.)

1 Answers 2018-06-27

How long after WWII did it take for Germany, or Germans, to view the Nazi era with shame?

1 Answers 2018-06-27

At what point in history did the British Monarchy go from having power to becoming a figurehead? The shift obviously came after 1215 and the Magna Carta, and also after the English Civil War. I’ve heard it can be traced to the house of Hanover, but when and why?

1 Answers 2018-06-27

What was the Japanese public reaction to The Humanity Declaration by Emperor Hirohito?

Why also was he kept alive/in power after the Allied occupation and not executed like a lot of the military hierarchy which killed, raped, tortured etc. in his name?

1 Answers 2018-06-27

What happened to all of the Nazis after world war 2 was over?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-06-26

As the USA did never declare war on North Vietnam were American POWs under protection of the Geneva Conventions or unlawful combatants?

To my understanding protection under Geneva Conventions is only valid in officially declared wars.

1 Answers 2018-06-26

What was Prussia's society and culture like? Where do I learn more about this topic?

I'm just curious about this because usually I see people on the internet talking about "Prussian Discipline" and how amazing their military and political achievements were. I am curious about life for the citizen in Prussia, was it full of discipline? How militaristic was their culture? Was their social mobility? Tolerance? I would like some sources that I can see on these topics please.

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Why did Medieval kings so often defy the Pope despite an excommunication’s implications for their afterlife?

The example which immediately comes to mind is King John, who continued exploiting money from his clergy even after he was excommunicated. In the case of John and other similar princes of this era, why were they so willing to go against a Pope’s orders if they genuinely believed that an excommunication could lead to them going to Hell. Could they have not actually believed in the Catholic church’s power over their souls, or were they simply willing to accept possible damnation for worldly gains?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Why has persecution been so common in Jewish History?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

In the 1745 Jacobite Uprising, Bonnie Prince Charlie's army made it as far as Derby before turning around, apparently on the advice of his council. Why did he decide to heed their warning? Did he believe that he could continue his rebellion from Scotland?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

What impact did plate armor have in the decline of the English Longbow?

I thought the longbow became less popular due to the time and effort of training archers, especially as (1) guns became more common, and (2) the post-plague heyday of successful, well fed, empowered peasants with spare time began to wane.

This article says that longbows were less effective as plate armor became more common. While the chronology generally matches up, I thought plate armor was reserved for the ultra-rich. Were there enough knights on the field (and/or did regular soldiers have access good enough armor) that the longbow's efficacy was meaningfully diminished?

https://m.warhistoryonline.com/medieval/longbow-rise-dominance.html

2 Answers 2018-06-26

With the Norman Conquest of England in 1066, the English language began rapidly changing. What other long-term cultural changes did this event bring about within England?

I am primarily interested in what political policies were adopted by the English people, what long-term impacts diplomatically the Norman Conquest had upon England and its neighbors, the economic consequences of the invasion, and the impact of the Conquest upon the average English household.

1 Answers 2018-06-26

What was football like in 1300-1400s England?

I never understood how soccer and American football were variations of the same origin sport until I saw how rugby was played, which made me wonder what that original sport was. As near as I can tell gameplay effectively amounted to "move the ball down the field however you want" with virtually no rules. So, why was called football? It seems like people wouod have been carrying and throwing the ball mostly if that was allowed.

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Why is it that Japanese swordsmanship was preserved with some elements of it (Like kendo) even being taught in Japanese schools while European swordsmanship was almost forgotten had to be rediscovered through fencing manuals?

3 Answers 2018-06-26

What parts of the United States were the Native American tribes in prior to the Louisiana Purchase?

My understanding is that the Cherokee lived in part of Georgia prior to the Louisiana Purchase. What parts were they in? And were there other Native American tribes in areas that were claimed by the USA? If so, which ones and where? What was the relationship between the fledgling USA and those tribes?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

What are some good primary and secondary sources for the Albigensian Crusade?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Is the Spanish title of Don equivalent in rank to the English/French Sir or was it a different level of nobility?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Was there significant push back or resistance to Nazi Germany's hosting of the 1936 Olympics? Considering their openly hostile attitude and policies towards other races, was there significant boycotting or protesting by athletes or in other countries?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

Can someone tell me about old sea lore??

I’m researching sea lore for a pirate themed thing I’m making and I’m interested in mythology aspects to incorporate. I know of the classic Kraken of course but what other mythological creatures “roamed” around that same time period. I don’t really mind which mythology origin it stems from (Norse, Greek, etc.) I just want to know what kind of beast were right for that period that I could further research.

1 Answers 2018-06-26

How many American colonists actually fought in the Revolutionary War against Britain?

I was watching a Vice video documentary on a militia group named the "3 Percenters." They got their name from the belief that only 3% of American colonists actively fought against the British. I find that number to be very low.

So my questions are;

- How many Americans actively fought against the British and what percentage of the total population would this have been?

- What percentage of fighting-age men would this have been?

- Is this number comparable to other wars?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-06-26

How did Ancient Romans count many years?

I know they didn’t use the Gregorian Calendar system, but at 1 AD what did they call that year? What did they call following and preceding years?

1 Answers 2018-06-26

⯇ 2550 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start