1 Answers 2018-06-25
I have been looking through the sub trying to find an old post I read quite some time ago I believe it was wrote by u\sunagainstgold, but I may well be confused.
I will do my best to explain the general gist of the post but am going to struggle a bit; apologies.
The post was regarding historiography and the ....importance of the west in the narrative while overlooking events in other parts of the world/even a Eurocentric view of history
I seem to remember it was explaining why this occurs and how academia is "currently" changing this view.
This may be totally wrong but I thought the answer somehow involved challenging the view of everything the west does as of more importance than discoveries in other places of the world.
Again, I apologise for the vagueness of my question as it is based on partial memories and my searching skills are not returning anything at all.
This from the UN kind of touches upon what I am looking for however it was definitely a post her that I am after: Western historiography and the problem of Western history (J. G. A. Pocock)
The post I suspect probably more than just mentioned Edward Gibbon. I have looked through the posts of “Historians' views of Edward Gibbon's "Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire"” But have not found what I am after.
If no-one knows of the post would they mind giving me information on the enlargement of the west in historiography?
If this post doesn’t meet the rules I am happy to report it in short answers to short questions.
Thanks
1 Answers 2018-06-25
3 Answers 2018-06-25
Additionally, did they recruit settled peoples other than the siege engineers from China?
1 Answers 2018-06-25
2 Answers 2018-06-25
1 Answers 2018-06-25
In several months I'm starting to study history in Europe. Due to our history course in school I know a decent amount of European history of the 19 and 20th century, but I'm interested in what other pieces of literature are a great way to learn more.
Thanks in advance
1 Answers 2018-06-25
Hello I'm from the western hemisphere and don't much about eastern cultures. I was wondering if someone could explain to me what influences Russia had on India and/or vice versa; any topic you like from culture to society or architecture during any time periods from the 20th century back to the 17th century.
Any bits of information are helpful, if you know something please contribute! :)
1 Answers 2018-06-25
1 Answers 2018-06-25
Just finished watching Band of Brothers on Amazon video, and near the end I had this lingering thought. In the last few episodes the Germans were with the Americans in Austria I believe directing citizens, and then later one of the captain's meets with a German general who addresses his troops.
I'm just thinking, these guys just fought each other for 5 years, how would the allies be able to trust the Germans to not shoot them when their backs were turned, or go rogue and what not. Same thing in the Pacific, how would they be able to trust any of the former enemies after WW2 knowing they'd been trying to kill them for years?
1 Answers 2018-06-25
I was reading this article and it claims,
Despotism and dictatorship did not exist in traditional African political schemes. In fact, the famous British economist, the late Lord Peter Bauer, noted this in his book, "Reality and Rhetoric: Studies in Economics of Development" where he wrote, "Despotism and kleptocracy do not inhere in the nature of African cultures or in the African character." Stateless societies such as the Somali, Igbo, and Tiv—which are characterized by the rejection of any centralized authority or “government”—did not have leaders who could be despots or dictators. Rather, these political systems stressed customary law and emphasized justice, or the establishment of justice, as the ruling principle.
King Mswati III is often portrayed as the prototypical “traditional” ruler, his bad deeds emblematic of an unsophisticated and backwards political society. However, an examination of history reveals something altogether different. Rather than corruption and despotism being inherent to traditional rule, it is the undermining of traditional checks on executive authority by the colonial state that has left the population exposed to the whims of their despotic king. Moreover, by writing traditional checks, such as destooling, out of the political narrative of Africa, the colonial legacy has painted a false picture of African leadership. It is time to re-examine the traditional priority of executive accountability, and once again hold Africa’s leaders to task.
2 Answers 2018-06-25
What do we know about his experiments?
How much support did he get from the Soviet government?
2 Answers 2018-06-25
1 Answers 2018-06-25
1 Answers 2018-06-25
I mainly talking about the Bohemian part. Why not "that Austrian corporal"?
1 Answers 2018-06-25
The story I've been told long ago was that a tribe called the Scotti invaded present day Scotland from Ireland and conquering the Picts. This, like many other conquest narratives I've seen, sounds very hard to believe. What really happened between the Picts and the Scots?
1 Answers 2018-06-25
In "Patton, Montgomery, Rommel Masters of War," Terry Brighton said that as part of Eisenhower losing a bet to Montgomery on how fast Sfax could be taken, Montgomery won a B-17 to use for personal transport during the war.
"The second skirmish was triggered by Monty on April 10 when the Eighth Army, following Messe's retreating troops, entered Sfax. Sometime earlier, during a meeting at which General Bedell Smith represented Eisenhower, Monty had said that he would take Sfax by April 15 and asked if Bedell Smith wished to make a bet of it. The American, perhaps not realizing that not realizing that Monty was in earnest, said that if he got there by the date Eisenhower would give him anything he wanted. Monty replied immediately that he wanted an American plane: "A Flying Fortress complete with American crew to remain on the US payroll, my personal property until the war ends." On April 10, having taken Sfax five days earlier than the bet specified, he immediately sent a signal: "Mosr Immediate. Personal from Montgomery to Eisenhower. Have arrived Sfax. Recall our bet. Despatch Flying Fortress."" (Patton, Montgomery, Rommel, 186)
Brighton brings up the aircraft whenever Montgomery used it, but doesnt mention the fate of the B-17. My question then is what came of the plane? Did it see further action, get scrapped, put in a museum, or was it used for some kind of training?
1 Answers 2018-06-25
1 Answers 2018-06-25
Was the public generally supportive? Was there any degree of opposition to the policies and those enforcing them? If so, what?
3 Answers 2018-06-25
I'm looking for the period between roughly 500bc and 500 ad in Europe, Northern Africa and the Middle East. I'm curious if a general overview exists of what kind of fuel was used for home and industrial uses. Was it just wood? Charcoal? Was coal available? Google is failing me and giving wrong-period information.
Thanks so much for your time.
1 Answers 2018-06-24
It seems to be a tactical victory for the Union to the same extent that Gettysburg was a victory for the Union. The Confederates were driven out of the North and were able to escape with heavy casualties on both sides.
1 Answers 2018-06-24
Was it comparable to western systems in any way (even if it wasn’t implemented in practice).
Obviously, the Soviets cracked down pretty hard on political opponents, but I’m more interested in “regular” crime (theft, murder, ...). I assume that they were interested in actually getting guilty people and avoiding innocent people, so how would a trial proceed? Did they keep any elements of tsarist Russia’s judicial system?
Was the USSR’s judicial system applied in Eastern Europe or did they keep similar systems to what they had pre-WW2?
1 Answers 2018-06-24
I keep hearing this argument from thinkers like Ben Shapiro and most notably Jordan Peterson. I'm not as comprehensive in the subject compared to others, but I noticed whenever this question is proposed it is followed up with little detail or evidence. Before I go any further, I don't underestimate the value of Judeo-Christianity has on Western culture, but is it embedded in it? Why does religion have to influence culture? Can't culture influence religion? Why couldn't Western culture be embedded in Greco-Roman values? Many of Western laws and ethics are derived from that time period. The entire subject seems incredibly complex to grasp, considering the amount of history and subjects one would have to understand to even grasp the idea of the Western culture. I just wanted to ask someone who has a more in-dept understanding on the subject. I just see the argument composed by Shapiro and Peterson to be low hanging fruit and without any really evidence.
1 Answers 2018-06-24