Why didn't the british conquer Nepal & Bhutan?

When looking at the British Raj one can see that they not only controlled India but also Pakistan, Bangladesh and Myanmar. Why didn't they also controll Nepal and Bhutan which would be easy to conquer?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Total War PC Games show ancient warfare as taking place between formations of soldiers on wide open battlefields in rectangular formations. How accurate is this as a portrayal of battle?

The Total War series of video games are obviously designed to be fun and accessible to players. Nevertheless, all of the entries in the series, specifically in this case Rome 2, portray battles as taking place between formations of soldiers on wide open battle fields.

Whether a Roman cohort or Gothic swordsman, soldiers exist in units which move and fight in generic rectangular formations. Battles are localised to a small area with the whole army engaging within short distance of each other.

I understand that this is a simplified portrayal for the sake of gameplay and technical limitations, but just how far removed is this? For example, would a Gallic (sp?) “army” really draw up in complex formations against a Roman legion? Would it be a local affair, or would battles take place across a much larger geographical area, like in more recent times?

I really want to try and imagine what these engagements would look like.

1 Answers 2018-06-17

As a citizen of the Soviet Union or Communist China, how would I actually get a job? Would I apply to open positions, be assigned a job by a government agency, or was there some other method? Could I change jobs if I don't like my current one?

If anyone knows how this worked in other communist countries I'd be interested in that too

1 Answers 2018-06-17

What was the "right of passage" for georgian teenagers? Did they travel? Or go to some sort of finishing school?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Did Jesus really have 12 disciples?

The number 12 seems to be an important number in many spiritualities: Ancient Greek mythology, Norse Mythology, Buddhism, and Judaism just to name a few. Is the number of disciples just a coincidence, or did Jesus really have 12?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

As far as I understand, wine and vinegar are both produced by fermenting grapes under similar conditions. In Ancient Greece, was it a matter of luck for the winemakers whether they'd get wine or vinegar?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Geneva convention on civilians during war

A while ago I remember reading somewhere about how the Geneva convention laid out ground-rules not allowing counteries to take ownership of civilian life during war.

Not quite sure how they addressed it, I might be mistaken and it wasn't the Geneva convention at all.

I'm looking for an international rule/law which addresses usage of civilian life during war.

1 Answers 2018-06-17

how was propaganda before Stalingrad, and how did it change after the defeat?

I'm researching how the defeat at Stalingrad changed the way in which propaganda was implemented in Germany, and was wondering especially how the image of both Hitler and the German folk changed. If the propaganda before 1943 was about the unification of the folk, did it then become about the survival of the German/Nazi ideals against Bolshevism? Thank you

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | June 11, 2018–June 17, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

9 Answers 2018-06-17

Why didn't the Roman era make a wide use of long swords or other weapons with a longer blade but in the "Dark Ages" of Europe's loss of Roman knowledge this became standard?

I'm not sure if I worded this correctly. To my understanding (and I am VERY bad with Roman history) the late Roman period with the East and West Empires saw many "barbarian" tribes use longer swords which are "kinda" a precursor to medieval long swords. So these weapons were around during the Roman's time (for simplicity I'm talking about the two empires before the Western empire fell, so not talking about medieval Byzantium). I understand the Romans were very organised and had a set way of doing things and their short Roman swords worked well, but was the long sword ever implement? Why wasn't it more widely used in the empires yet in the dark ages it became the norm?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

What is the best way to quickly learn about Greek history?

This was posted originally on r/history, but I hope I'm in the right place this time.

My husband and I are going to Athens for our honeymoon in less than 2 weeks. We love going to historical sites, but as neither of us recalls much from our history classes, a refresher would be very helpful. Does anyone know of a good book, podcast, or video series that might help guide our trip?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Olympics Games is one of four Panhellenic Games. Have organizers of first modern Olympic Games thought about reviving the rest of competitions?

Edit: The other three Games are Pythian, Nemean, and Isthmian. According to Diogenes Laertius, Plato wrestled in Isthmian games.

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Drug use by soldiers during WW2

Some scholars have proposed the idea that use of stimulants such as pervitin (methamphetamine) or other drugs like alcohol may have been responsible for war crimes committed by soldiers on the ground. On the eastern front it’s clear that the conflict between fascism and communism was an existential struggle and heinous acts were often supported by the higher ups. Another example is in kamikaze pilots who were also given methamphetamine before their suicide attacks. But apart from “sanctioned” war crimes is there any cases where atrocities were committed by soldiers clearly under the influence or was drug use so prevalent it’s impossible to discern the cause?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Did Europeans in 10 AD refer to the year as 10 AD

1 Answers 2018-06-17

I've read on this sub that people used to be nostalgic for the 1890's during the decades that followed. What about this time were they nostalgic about? and what was the asthetic like in terms of culture and politics and business?

5 Answers 2018-06-17

Where any medical advancements made from the human experiments at concentration camps?

Rather morbid I know, but I've wondered for a while what (if any) advancements in medical related things (understand of diseases, disorders, treatments etc.) were made due to the human experiments conducted by the Nazi's at concentration camps

1 Answers 2018-06-17

How did people tell the time before clocks? Did people in Ancient Greece just say ‘We’ll assassinate the king at midday’ then everyone turn up hours apart..... genuinely wondered this for many years!

2 Answers 2018-06-17

How did torture of witnesses in Roman law work?

I'm aware that torture was sometimes required for legal trials. How did it work? Both legally (what were the circumstances) and in terms of what kind of torture?

As a related question, how long did this law continue?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

When did musicians stop considering volume of an axis of dynamism and how does that relate to the current focus on pitch-based dynamic in popular music today?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Alliterative verse seems to have fallen out of fashion in modern English compared to ME and OE. What do we know about the shift away from this particular linguistic device?

This comes up in language games quite often in modern Mandarin, but seems to have largely disappeared from modern English verse. I know such linguistic trends come and go, but knowing relatively little about English, I was hoping to learn more about the apparent trend.

1 Answers 2018-06-17

How did the Code Napoleon survive the downfall of Napoleon?

The spread of the Napoleonic legal code throughout Europe was tied to Napoleon's military victories. After Napoleon was defeated, why wasn't his legal code rescinded by the victors, both in France and in the other countries of Europe?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

What was the “year” in ancient times?

In say 50 bc they wouldn’t have called it 50bc. That was decided later. So what calendar year system was used? What year or équivalant frame of time would they have used in place of 50 bc?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Why Asia and Europe is considered different continents when there is direct land access between both places?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-06-17

Is the Rommel myth true?

There is a commonly debated myth about Erwin Rommel-that he was simply an apolitical and brilliant commander. I've researched this myself and only got more contradictory information. My question is to ask, once and for all: was Rommel a supporter of the Nazis or just a German nationalist?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

How do we know what medieval music sounded like?

Every show uses brass horns and airy flutes, but is that what things actually sound like or is it just Hollywood inventing things?

1 Answers 2018-06-17

⯇ 2567 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start