I know that the Romans were very organized in battle, but in the thick of fighting each other, how could they tell friend from foe? Did they alter their uniforms?
1 Answers 2018-06-08
1 Answers 2018-06-08
During WW2 rationing, once a person used their ration stamps to purchase something, say a pound of butter, what did the grocer do with the stamps? Did the government reimburse them the price of the goods?
Or did the people pay on top of using their rations?
2 Answers 2018-06-08
In popular culture native americans are often presented as having no concept of private property, as having a much more gender-equal and less prejudiced society than Europeans, and as being generally more peaceful and environmentally sustainable. How much of this is based in truth, and are there examples of more warlike or imperialistic Native American civilizations?
1 Answers 2018-06-08
Garum, the characteristically Roman fish sauce, was all the rage in Ancient Rome. What happened to it? At what point did people stop eating garum?
1 Answers 2018-06-08
1 Answers 2018-06-08
So a friend of mine has been researching her father, who died several years back, and managed to get his army discharge papers from 1979, and we have a couple of questions about the papers:
If y'all could be of any help, that would be fantastic!
1 Answers 2018-06-08
Reading about him I'm left rather confused as to where his hatred of Britain came from. It doesnt appear that he had any previous conflicts with the UK pre ww2 and his ancestry doesnt suggest anything that would make him anti British (not Irish catholic). What made him into such an anglophobe that he refused to take British advice in avoiding U-Boats and such?
1 Answers 2018-06-08
I've been searching for music in the united states, and as you know, most of music has afro origins, for example, jazz, rock, blues, were all made originally by black comunities, and at the start, were found to be 'innaproapiate' for white listeners until many white artists began forming rock bands (for example), this is all clear. but i havent been able to find any information about what would white populations hear if it wasnt black, or atleast black inspired music.
1 Answers 2018-06-08
In the fantasy community, when building a world (which is often analogous to medieval Europe) a common impediment arises. When populating this world, determining the occupations of its denizens is challenging. Those who wish to be faithful to historical examples have few resources from which to draw. The most frequently (and often only) cited reference is Medieval Demographics Made Easy by S. John Ross.
Mr. Ross provides a table of occupations with their incidence rate based on population size. For example, for every 1400 persons there will be one spice merchant and for every 350 persons there would be one barber. However this information is drawn from one source: a reference to the 1292 tax roll of Paris found in the end notes of Life in a Medieval City by Frances and Joseph Gies. The Gieses had pulled this information from a French manuscript by Hercule Géraud Paris sous Philippe-le-Bel. These occupations were based upon surnames in the tax record. Thus John Smith was a blacksmith, etc.. I’m sure by now you can see the blatant pitfalls. A concise rebuttal to Ross’s calculations can be found in an old blog post by Bob Traynor who brings attention to many of the errors and wrong assumptions drawn by these sources.
Here’s the interesting thing; there are scores of advice blogs for games masters, fantasy authors, and world-creators that link back to this one source. Numerous spreadsheets and online calculators use this data as their primary reference. For over a decade Ross’s article has been the go-to source with little to no alternatives.
This leads me to my question for you r/AskHistorians; what sources can be used to determine the prevalence of a given occupation in a typical medieval setting? What occupations would be a near certainty in a settlement of say 1500 people? What about 15,000?
Please, help bolster an entire community of writers and game masters.
TL;DR – Many medieval world-builders draw demographic data from one questionable source, where should we look instead (e.g. how many butchers, bakers, and candlestick makers are there in a medieval settlement?)
2 Answers 2018-06-07
Who first depicted the world in the orientation we commonly see today? Was there a reason they orientated like that - maybe based off of early compasses - or was it just a coincidence that North points to one of our poles?
Same with the other directions. Who decided which direction would be West and East? Were they originally related to North or have a different origin?
Thank you ahead of time!
1 Answers 2018-06-07
Obviously the joke is that young Republicans are furiously Googling for answers to support Trump. I am not one out there to support the assertion, but am curious about the situation.
1 Answers 2018-06-07
Most cities grow organically, so they end up being a hodge podge of random areas put together and grown out over time -- this can result in all kinds of winding and diagonal roads leading every which way. Manhattan looks like it was planned to be a grid from the beginning. Was it planned? Did they one day just decide to convert everything to a grid, and they had to tear down buildings and roads that didn't fit with the grid system?
2 Answers 2018-06-07
2 Answers 2018-06-07
2 Answers 2018-06-07
1 Answers 2018-06-07
I'm interesting in piecing together what religious practices amongst the urban citizenry would have been like in the century or so just preceding the dominance of Christianity - so let's say approximately 200 to 350ish or even 350 to to 400ish. That might be two different questions though. In order to couch the question I specifically mean amongst the urban populations in Italy or Greece (although they might be different?) and not in the frontiers or Near East. I ask because the way it always seems presented makes it sound like this dramatic replacement of the traditional Greco-Roman pantheon, but doing my own readings it seems to me that many of the core components were already in place (Neoplatonic concepts of monism to monotheism, consolidation of gods into a smaller pantheon, and Orientalization of Roman religion). So anything you know or recommendation for books or papers would be helpful. Cheers.
2 Answers 2018-06-07
While 'Greater Romania' encompasses seemingly all Romanian nationalist territorial claims, I've seen a few references to other areas throughout history and was curious as to the origin of the Romanian claim on these places;-
"For us the mountains and plains of Bukowina, where Stephen the Great has slept for centuries. In our moral energy and our valour lie the means of giving him back his birthright of a great and free Rumania from the Tisza to the Black Sea"
I was curious about the origins of these claims, and also whether there were ever any greater Romanian territorial aspirations beyond the interwar Greater Romania?
1 Answers 2018-06-07
1 Answers 2018-06-07
Wouldn't they have written down how make it?
2 Answers 2018-06-07
A few years ago I visited Greece (Athens and Khania, Crete) and realized that despite knowing the broad strokes of Classical Greek history, having read both the Iliad and Oddysey, Plato's Republic, some Aristotle, and a lot of Greek drama in school, and generally feeling like I have my ish together where Ancient Greece is concerned, I just don't know a lot about everyday life in Ancient Greece.
In contrast, I can tell you what Ancient Roman graffiti was like, what street snacks people in the Roman Empire enjoyed, where Romans went on vacation, how Roman cemeteries worked, what the specific places of worship of various Roman era religions were like, a little about hairstyles and fashions over the years, etc. Some of that is from traveling in Italy and I suppose can't be picked up easily in a book. But I'd love to get a little more basic understanding of this sort of thing regarding Classical Greece. I'd also like to know more of the history of the Classical Greek world outside of Athens and Sparta.
Are there any good book recommendations that might help here? I love popular history that I can easily find in my local library or get on audiobook from Audible, but I'm potentially interested in scholarly stuff too.
1 Answers 2018-06-07