Why is it that the ethnic cleansing of Muslim men before the genocide of Srebrenica (1995) is not referred to as a genocide?

At what point do people speak of a genocide? For example: in July of 1995 the Srebrenica genocide of Muslim men took place in Bosnia, but a few years before (1992) 700 Muslim men where tortured and killed in a village just 10km from Srebrenica but people don’t use the word genocide to describe this event. Why is that?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Academic works on the role of trees & forests in human societies

I'm looking for academic works on—or containing something on this topic—the role of trees & forests in human societies. For instance: forests as a resource (for example sawmills), trees have been used as landmarks, places of political gatherings, hanging trees, etc.

1 Answers 2018-04-29

It has been alleged that Israel played a role in creating Hamas in the 80s? How true is this claim and how substantial did they aid this process, if at all?

Resubmitted due to poor wording of question.

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Regarding the Reconquista, where did the Spanish come from and how did they come to believe they had a right to the whole Iberian peninsula?

So to my understanding, when the Umayyad conquest of Hispania happened, it was a Visigothic kingdom but then when the Spanish eventually took over, culminating with the Granada war nearly 700 years later they seem to treat it like they were the rightful rulers of Iberia the whole time, and I'm wondering where did the Spanish who "took back" the Iberian peninsula come from and how did they come to believe that the whole thing was rightfully theirs in the first place?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

How did the British lose the Battle of Singapore, while the invading Japanese force was three times smaller then the defending force?

3 Answers 2018-04-29

Any book recommendations for Cromwell and Bismarck?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Are there really 3 types of historians?

Recently, while conversing with a friend, I commented that I was thinking of buying a good history book (XIX century). He jokingly told me to save money because I was going to have to buy 3 books. I asked him why. He responded that, in order to see all points of view we have to buy a socialist historian, a liberal historian and the neutral one. We laughed and the conversation shifted but it got me thinking. Do you agree with this idea? And if so, can you give examples of such authors? I apologize if this isn’t the most adequate sub. Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Would our modern usage of Latin or Ancient Greek be comprehensible to ancient speakers of those languages?

We like to pepper modern English, in particular our scientific and technical terms, with Latin/Ancient Greek words and phrases, and it recently occurred to me to wonder whether any of them would make sense to an Ancient Roman or Greek native speaker. Would species names like Homo sapiens or Felis catus make sense? If I called something ad hoc, sui generis, ad hominem or ex nihilo, would a native speaker understand them to have the same meaning I would? If I told an ancient Greek physician I had hepatitis or schizophrenia, would he have the slightest chance of working out what I was talking about? Would any of it sound like normal speech or would it be like going to a doctor today and complaining of gutsouching, or accusing someone I'm having an argument with of managainstness?

(This question inspired by own recent bout of pericoronitis, which apparently is a combination of Greek and Latin elements and thus would probably sound extremely silly at best.)

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Why did the Irish, Italian and Russian immigrants to America develop organised mobs while other European immigrants like the Germans, Greeks, Poles and Scandanavians did not?

Was it a cultural thing? Was there something unique about their immigrant experiences? Am i wrong about the existence of other European mobs because of a lack of coverage in media?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

How were the Mongols able to conquer Russia when more modern armies from Napoleon and Hitler failed spectacularly?

Is Mongolia's winter a comparable environment to Russia? Do cavalry work better in snow than I'm thinking? Was there a more complex strategy to it all?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

What are good non-partisan books on the history of the Israel - Palestinian conflict?

2 Answers 2018-04-29

Was Hitler a vegetarian and if he was, why do some say that he was not?

I have been in a debate on the subject of Hitler being a vegetarian and so far it isn't clear to me if he was or was not. Many websites suggest that he was, but also many say that he wasn't. They claim that he did in fact eat meat such as sausages, others deny those claims.

Whom should I trust? Which sources can be trusted (on this subject)?

I know that this question has already been asked, but I don't know why it is claimed that he wasn't a vegetarian.

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | April 23, 2018–April 29, 2018

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

5 Answers 2018-04-29

Was talking in a theater more acceptable in the era of silent films? Or was the audience still expected to keep quiet?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

How was Thailand able to remain independent with everyone around them becoming colonies?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

As I understand it, the earliest Christians expected Jesus to return imminently, or at least within their lifetime. How was the Church able to handle it, and even grow exponentially, when this didn't happen? At what point was this no longer the predominant expectation of new converts?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

In the Gallipoli campaign for Battlefield 1, when you capture a objective, you pull down the Ottoman flag and replace it with a red Australian flag. Was this flag actually used during World War I?

If the flag was used, was this flag only used by the Australian Imperial Force or was it used as a national flag before being changed to the more familiar blue?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Charles Dickens's father spent time in debtors' prison. How did they work? Inmates were charged room and board, already unable to pay their debts; how could one hope to ever get out? Was there a set 'sentence', or were prisoners simply dependent on others paying their way back into society?

2 Answers 2018-04-29

Why did the French embrace Napoleon, a man who declared himself benevolent emperor of France, right after fighting a revolution to depose and kill monarchs?

Visited Les Invalides recently and it's nuts how fond people's nostalgia for Napoleon is.

Why did the French love Napoleon, even when he began to embody what he revolution sought to destroy?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Can Louis-XVI be blamed for the failure of France's constitutional monarchy?

I'm studying the french revolution and this seems to be a pretty major issue. Where does the blame lie for the failure of France's constitutional monarchy. A lot of historians discuss this but in a reasonably indirect way which brings me to my second question:

Are there any historians who deal with this question directly? I'd love to read a historian making an argument one way or the other rather than just going through the narrative of the revolution and subtly lacing it with their own opinions.

I'm having trouble untangling the factors and deciding what my own opinion is on this topic

thank you

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Was the Cadaver Synod justified?

Were the charges levelled accurate, and did the trial in general lead to anything more significant in the Catholic church?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Why didn't Australia acquire nuclear weapons during the Cold War?

Numerous nuclear weapons tests were conducted on the Australian continent, including Operation Hurricane, the test of the United Kingdom's first atomic bomb on the Monte Balle Island archipelago, in 1952 followed by two more tests in the same location as part of Operation Mosaic in 1956.

So why didn't Australia ever take inspiration from it's allies and begin acquiring nuclear weapons of it's own to protect itself?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

During WW2 , the Soviets were said to be not have enough ammunition/shells/bullets to fight the Germans. But weren't Soviet a heavy-industry focused country? Why were there not enough supplies?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Is it fair to say that Austria is the country that bears lineage of the Western Roman Empire?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

Is there any indication as to why the German Army didn’t take the chance and try to destroy the British Army outright at Dunkirk?

And, if they had, what would the war have looked like?

1 Answers 2018-04-29

⯇ 2663 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start