Given the proximity of the Qing Empire, were they aware of what was going on with the Mughals and British?

Good evening, I was curious about a lecture I had yesterday. He's a great history teacher but I was confused at how perhaps not so prepared the Qing were against the British. I only ask this because the news about what was going on in the Indian Subcontinent and the British Empire(And its East India company) should have went to the Qing Empires knowledge and helped them better prepare themselves and now repeat what happened to the Mughals, to happened to them. So, what was it that made the Qing so unprepared against the British? why weren't they prepared since the Mughals were very close to the Qing Dynasty geographically.

If you're confused about what I am asking, feel free to ask for clarity. Thanks for your time:)

1 Answers 2018-03-22

How old are finding aids for libraries or archives? Would a university library in Europe in the 1500s have a detailed list of books and materials held in the library, and their location in the stacks?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Did sculptors and arts patrons of the Renaissance prefer undecorated white marble sculptures partially because of racism?

The Washington Post recently published this article about a new exhibit at the Met displaying sculptures that use color, as opposed to 'traditional' sculptures that are generally undecorated marble. In the article, the author claims that the preference for undecorated marble emerged in the Renaissance and was "bound up with racist ideas about human beauty and civilization." That's an interesting explanation, and one that I've never heard before, usually people point exclusively to the Renaissance artists (erroneously) mimicking Roman and Greek statuary. Is it an accurate statement? The author's description of the history of sculpture uses some terms heavily associated with modern American discussions about race ("privileged," "marginalized," "whiteness"), which makes me wonder whether they aren't mistakenly wandering into presentism. Does anybody know?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

In expansive ancient Empires with widespread multilingualism (such as the Roman Empire), did multiple languages ever fuse into Pidgins, Creoles, or Mixed languages?

For instance, I know that in the Roman Empire, many people would speak both Latin and Greek, along with a more more localized tongue such as Coptic, Syrian, Thracian, Gaulish, etc.

Also, to clarify the definitions I'm talking about:

  • Pidgins: A very basic mixture of simplified languages, which usually develops in places where there is trade between two parties that do not speak the same language.

  • Creoles: Typically these are Pidgins that have evolved into a full language, to the point where they are spoken by a community in day-to-day life.

  • Mixed languages: A semi-controversial category that may or may not exist, depending on who you ask. This is a language that uses elements from two separate parent languages, in roughly equal amounts - to the point where it can be considered as descending from two different families.

And I have one final question: if there are not any examples of these types of languages in the distant past, then why not? Are these categories of languages somehow unique to the modern world?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Were "missing/stolen suitcase nukes" really a thing?

(not trying to be political just want to give this question some context)

I worked as a studio cameraman and a very right leaning US TV station in the late 90s. One semi frequent topic was how Bill Clinton wasn't doing enough to find these missing suitcase sized nuclear devices after the fall of the USSR. The frequent narrative always being communist hardliners using them or them being sold to Iran/Palestine/other Boogeyman of the week.

Were these small nukes ever proven to be real, and if so found?

2 Answers 2018-03-21

What are the origins of the words "blacklist" and "whitelist"?

I am curious about the origin of the terms "blacklist" and "whitelist", and couldn't readily find a useful etymology of these words.

  • in what context were these terms originally used? Do these terms predate the blacklisting of Hollywood actors by McCarthy?
  • did these terms originally have racial connotations, or is there something else to it?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

What is the first written record of the term "Imperium Romanorum" or other terms specifically referring to Rome as an Imperial entity?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Did any technology exist in the fifteenth century that would have made marine chronometers possible?

Did scientists know about harmonic oscillation? Looking back from the present, are there any theories about how timekeeping could have been made more efficient (not even necessarily at sea) with technology that existed in the fifteenth century?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Games like Crusader Kings 2 point out the ease of converting pagans (or at least the Norse) to Christianity. Was this ease in converting heathens an observed phenomenon? Are there any explanations as to why this was so?

Heathens as in what the Norse I believe called themselves (or rather those who believed in non-Christian gods), not as a pejorative.

1 Answers 2018-03-21

During a history lesson i was taught that the Japanese were ready to surrender already during the summer of 1945, before the use of nuclear weapons. Is there any truth to this?

2 Answers 2018-03-21

The Holocaust: What was in it for top Nazis?

I teach university-level courses that include one on genocides and politicides, so I've done plenty of academic reading on the topic of mass killing in general and the Holocaust in particular. Usually, I can "explain" a genocide or politicide as part of a larger plan that is expected to benefit the leaders of a country (or colony) -- perhaps to dispossess people of their land, perhaps to get rid of a politically-threatening group, etc. Whatever the plan is, the leader(s) responsible for it use it to reinforce their political authority and capabilities. This is adequate to explain the Armenian Genocide, the Rwandan Genocide, Burundi's Genocide (1972), and politicides in various Communist countries. It does a passable job at explaining why Leopold behaved so differently in Belgium (where he was politically constrained) and Congo (where he ruled unchecked and demanded profit at any Congolese price). It can even explain the genocidal German campaign against the Herero.

But I'm always stymied by the Holocaust itself. Why did the Nazi leadership (the only people whose opinions on the issue really mattered) find exterminating Jews to be so important that it trumped even military (diversion of scarce resources such as transportation, alienation of local populations who might have been recruited against Stalin, etc) and economic (e.g. slave labor or at least cheap highly-skilled labor) considerations? Put simply, why did top Nazis think that they would be better off in a world in which they had eliminated (rather than merely dispossessed and enslaved) Jews? Was this related to their drive to consolidate, retain, and expand their political authority -- and if so, how?

I checked the FAQ and didn't see the question put this way, and I'm hoping professional historians (I'm a political scientist) can help me out here.

2 Answers 2018-03-21

Why did fascism appeal to so many communists and far-left supporters when it first appeared?

Edit: I'd like to clarify that I'm not trying to further any political point or make a comparison between socialists and fascists

I was just genuinely surprised by the fact that that so many orginal fascists were former socialists (to my knowledge)

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Is there any evidence that any of the allies knew what the Nazis were doing before they joined the war?

And if so, did anyone enter because of this?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

What were Leonardo Da Vinci’s Michelangelo’s, and Raphaels’s take on the Protestant Reformation? Did they blindly support The Catholic Church or have any opinion on Martin Luther or his 95 Theses?

I know both Da Vinci and Raphael died shortly after Luther posted his 95 Theses (Da Vinci on 1519, Raphael on 1520) on 1517. But Michelangelo lived till 1564, and worked on many art pieces during the Protestant and Catholic-Counter Reformation; did he ever reveal his true opinion on the Catholic Church?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

How was the Soviet Union considered 'communist' when people still used money?

I don't understand how people consider Soviet Union to be Communist, not only did they use money but they bought consumer goods. It seems like it was more 'state capitalist' than socialist or communist. Why do people consider it to be communist?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

How did scientiest go about designing and testing the first nuclear reactors, and how did it go?

Studying on nuclear reactors, I see that they are quite dangerous to contain in such a way that they don't melt down. Back in the early days of the Manhattan Project, how did they go about making the first reactors, and what problems/incidents did they encounter?

Same question can apply to the Soviet program shortly afterwards as well, if relevant.

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Did Shakespeare wear an earring?

In multiple portraits of Shakespeare he is wearing a gold hoop earring. A few places I read said that earrings were somehow associated with poets in Shakespearean times, and one place even suggested that the artists might have added it in as a joke.

I know it's a bit of a stretch considering how little we know about Shakespeare, but is there any information on this?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

In Alice and Wonderland the Blue Caterpillar says "Who are you?". Is Carrol making a reference to a popular joke about a judge at the time of writing?

I remember a teacher I had in Middle School talking about all the math Lewis Carrol did and topical references made in his writing. One of the examples she gave what that the line "Who are you?" from the caterpillar was referencing a joke at the time of writing. (I'd call it a meme now, but I heard this story in like 2007 before that word gained popularity).

Basically during a trial some judge told a defendant "And who are you?" and the courtroom found it hilarious, and the story got really popular so people would say "Who are you?" as a joke response to things. I assume in a similar way to "That's what she said". Or made it was a popular joke at the time so when the judge said it, that's why it was so funny? I don't really remember.

I have tried a couple times to find a source or reference for this but never have, and don't know how I'd go about searching it.

1 Answers 2018-03-21

In Band of Brothers, Donald Malarkey asks a German POW where he is from. He is surprised to hear Eugene, Oregon and the POW explains his family "answered the call" for all true Aryans to return to Germany. How common was it for German/Austrian-Americans to leave the USA and return to Germany?

Was the call explicitly for the war effort? How far in advance of the United States joining the war were people returning to Europe?

4 Answers 2018-03-21

How comes Finns were able to domesticate deer while Native Americans were not?

I've seen these old timey pictures and heard these stories of Finnish people domesticating deer. Everything from riding deer to milking deer to hurding deer.

The answer I often hear ask to why the native North Americans didn't domesticate as many animals as South/Central America or the Old World was because there existed fewer domesticatable animals (animals that would be docile enough to domesticate). They generally will list Bison and Deer as examples of animals that people think could be used as beasts of burden but are just not domesticatable.

Even then I've seen videos of ranchers riding Buffalos no problem, but then people will say it's because those Buffalos have been bred with cows to be more docile.

Why didn't the native North Americans domesticate reindeer? I don't really that much of a geographic or life style difference between much of the people like the inuit and the finns.

Is it down to the deer being too different a type of deer or something?

I just keep asking myself why native North Americans didn't advance enough to a pasturalist life style despite sharing very much in common with steppe nomads.

Anyways, hope you can answer my question(s).

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Why is it that most of Communist countries (Somalia, Poland, Angola, Democratic Republic of Afghanistan, Yugoslavia, etc...) fell with the Soviet Union but China didn't even though there was massive civil unrest there?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

What was the general public’s reaction during the broadcast of “War of the Worlds”

I just watched a video about water towers where Neil Degrass Tyson talked about how during the broadcast people were shooting them thinking they were aliens.

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Opinions on 'The World of Late Antiquity' by Peter Brown?

https://www.amazon.com/World-Late-Antiquity-150-750-Civilization/dp/0393958035

A video on youtube told me that it's possibly 'the best thing since Gibbon', which seems extreme. What are your opinions?

1 Answers 2018-03-21

Need help identifying German WWII soldier(SS?) Pics of man/uniform inside.

My friend knows I know a little bit about history... But it's nothing like you guys. I hope this is the right place for this.

His grandfather was German and fought in the war.

His German family refuses to talk about the man pictured in the link. He's my age, 36 and is curious. This isn't Nazi worship or anything. He knows nothing about his grandfather and is just curious. He assumes his grandfather was conscripted. But if the guy is SS, that's not likely the case.

He looks SS to me, but again, I probably suck at this. The badge on the left pocket could be an infantry assault badge or tank destroyer?

Any help? Thanks.

2 Answers 2018-03-21

How much has the strategy of chess evolved over the years? Were there players in the medieval era who could consistently beat a modern grandmaster?

Oftentimes in histories you find figures who were famously good at certain games, like chess or cards. Would their skills have been comparable to modern day expert players, or is it more like Olympic events, where modern athletes could best their predecessors handily?

4 Answers 2018-03-21

⯇ 2743 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start