What is the difference between Swiss Pikemen formations and Alexander (well his father's anyway) Macedon Pikemen formations and tactics?

What is the difference between Swiss Pikemen formations and Macedon Pikemen formations and tactics?

On the surface of it, and with the pictures they looks very similar as men in tight formation with very long spears (or halberds at one time for the Swiss) keep the enemy at spear point with a wall of death.

  1. How are they similar?
  2. How are they different?
  3. Were the Swiss aware of the Macedon Phalanx or maybe to a lesser extent the Greek one, since the Greek one seems to have translated to Medieval/Renaissance warfare with shield formations.

thx

1 Answers 2018-03-22

What would get a man with an Anglo name classified as "Complexion: Yellow" on his enlistment into the US Colored Infantry during the Civil War?

I'm helping out with one of those crowdsourcing transcription projects and I've come across a chap from Kentucky called Thomas Stanton, who joined the 15th Regiment, US Colored Infantry.

His complexion is listed as "Yellow", which I had imagined would refer to an East Asian origin, but his name suggests otherwise. A white man with jaundice wouldn't be joining the Colored Infantry, presumably?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

The Life of a War Galley

In many movies and video games starring pirates, there are plenty of naval battles and destruction to be seen. But, in the 18th century Caribbean, what was the actual lifespan of an naval frigate? Were they often engaging in battles and destroyed, or was the reality much more calm? Were these ships lasting 10+ years, longer?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Was the black pygmy irish genocide real?

My question is: how real is this, is there evidence for it.

here is the text of the claim:

"St. Patrick born Maewyn Succat, born circa 375 AD was a Roman Brit, who completely murdered the Twa out of Ireland. The Twa (Druids) an ethnic group of small African people, wore a headpiece with a snake on it. This ethnic group is now thought to be the original inhabitants of the majority of the earth. The snake worn on their head piece(Twa also were the west African descendants of Ancient Kush and Kemet both who wore the emblem of the earth mother(snake) on their head pieces), is the meaning behind Patrick chasing the snakes out of Ireland. St. Patrick committed one of the largest genocides/mass murders of more than 200,000 Africans again ordered, sanctioned and funded by the Eastern Othodox Church by Pope Celestine I. He then taught Christianity to the land. He was sainted posthumously for the vile inhumane murderous act of slaughtering the Twa. A mere sacrifice for the spread of Christianity.The Leprechaun is our African ancestor originally from Guinea. This is the only portion about the Twa/Druids that is mainstreamed and given a false depiction as a white Irishman.The people of Guinea to this day still practice the magic of the forest healing, and making medicines from fermented brews (beers) that can cure many illnesses. The name "Guiness Stout" is a feminized brew that comes from many traditions that are brewed from "The Land of the Woman," known as Guinea, West Africa"

Here are the sources cited to support it: A Book of Beginnings by Gerald Massey The Primitive Glory of the Kymry (author unknown) Ancient and Modern Britons: A retrospective Vol. 2 Specifically the section "Magi of Ireland" The Origin Evolution of Religion (author unknown, possibly the same book as above) pg. 419, 427

3 Answers 2018-03-22

Why is Delaware its own state? Why did they not at least get the rest of the Delmarva peninsula?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Why did the Plantagenet kings bear lions on their coat of arms?

I know that the french referred to the animals on the coat of arms as leopards but why would anyone think of using either of these two animals in 13th century western europe?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

When (and why) did Britain drop the 'Great' from its name?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

How common was atheism/agnosticism in classical antiquity?

I was reading from ‘The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire’ and Gibbon states that “... the ingenious youth... resorted to Athens... were alike instructed in every school to reject and to despise the religion of the multitude.” In other parts of this chapter ‘Of the Union and Internal Prosperity of the Roman Empire, in the Age of the Antonines’ he also speaks on religions use to appease the masses and how the intellectual class were not necessarily believers but performed the rituals and rites to appease their fathers.

My question is, was atheism more common in antiquity than what is typically prescribed (Not just the belief of a few but rather widespread). Also is the Rise and Fall a good source and used in contemporary studies or has it fell through in certain aspects? Published in 1776 it is relatively modern.

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Why there wasn't such a thing as Nuremberg trials for war crimes commited by the Empire of Japan during WWII?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

I am a Private of the BEF in France, 1939. What brand of cigarette will me and my fellow soldiers smoke?

I know that GIs typically smoked Lucky Strikes etc but, what would the average Tommy be smoking at the outbreak of War?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

How long would a typical viking raiding trip last?

I was wondering with the technology of the time how long the journey from Norway to Scotland or England would be? And also how long they would stay during an average raid?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Thursday Reading & Research | March 22, 2018

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Research is intended as an academic free-for-all, for the discussion of all issues historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • New developments or discoveries in the field

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • Your current research interests or projects

  • The goings on within the academy

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters historical discussion, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2018-03-22

What were Native Americans doing during the Civil War?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Did the majority of pagans rulers who converted to Christianity really become Christian or were they doing it for political reasons?

A 2 examples that i know of who did it for political reasons : The first duke of Normandy and Vladimir of Kiev. Was this the norm or were the majority of the converts true believers?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Treatment of Muslims in the Kingdom of Sicily

Roger I of Sicily, founder of the kingdom of sicily, is best known for securing and solidifying Norman control of Sicily. How were Muslims treated under Roger and his immediate successors following the siege of Palermo and creation of the kingdom?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Why in the US are alcohol, tobacco, and firearms lumped together under the same regulatory agency?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

We (Art & History Museum in Brussels, Belgium) need your help solving this mystery (more info in comments)!

Hello /r/askhistorians,

We're closing in on solving this. I'll keep you guys posted!

Update: on the site of the Flemish and Walloon public broadcasters. And again, you saw it first on Reddit :)


We (the Art & History Museum in Brussels, Belgium) currently have a temporary exhibition about the Wolfers family (famous jewlers from Brussels) and Victor Horta (famous art nouveau architect).

During this exhibition the curator received this silver box. We know some things about it, but there is also alot we don't know. That's why we need your help (updates below!)

Here is what we know (see album):

  • It's a silver cigar box, made by Wolfers (there is a quality mark on the back: triangle with three stars, 800 and Wolfres freres). The 800 is a gradation of the quality of the silver.
  • On the front is says Zur Erinnerung an Gemeinsame Arbeit in Belgien. Brüssel, den 1. november 1918. This translates to 'In memory of the joint work in Belgium. Brussels, the first of november, 1918'
  • The box traveled from Belgium (where it was commissioned/made and bought) to Germany and back to Belgium

Here is what we presume:

  • The names on the box are officials (not military personnel: it would be very likely to have a military grade engraved together with the names)
  • The box is a souvenir for people who worked together in occupied Belgium. With this in mind, it's not unlikely there were more of the same boxes made and handed out (there are 16 autographs on the box, perhaps 16 of these boxes were made)
  • The box was made/commissioned as a souvenir as soon as this group of people realised the war was over (the date is prior to the armistice: 1 november 1918 vs 11 november 1918).
  • There are 14 autographs on top of the box, 2 on the front. Perhaps the two on the front are from the officials in charge
  • There is one autograph (on the front) that is perfectly readable: Brinckman(n). All the others are open to discussion.

We would like your help with the following:

  • Best case: you have seen this (kind of) box with someone you know (a neighbour, relative,...) and know more about it.
  • The signatures are not at all clear: we would like to know the names of everyone that signed (this might help in locating those persons or finding out more about them)
  • We would like to know more about the context: who were these people? What was their job in occupied Belgium?

update: This was already posted in lots of other subreddits, and we might have some leads: 'Brinckmann' might be this guy. 'Zöbisch' might be Septa Zöbisch, an opera singer, who knew Brinckmann. Brinckmann was involved in the German 'Flamenpolitik', a way to win the hearts and minds of the Flemish (article about that here in Dutch) through promoting culture. Nothings sure, but as said this might be a valuable lead.

Thanks in advance to help us solve this mystery!

9 Answers 2018-03-22

Lord Kitchener, British Secretary of War for the early part of the first World War, was a lifelong 'confirmed bachelor'. Was this code? Would this have made his personal life the subject of scrutiny at the time? Would it have affected his career?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Kongming Zhuge Liang

I am a fan of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, I have often heard that Kongming's actual historical achievements were no where near how they are portrayed by Luo Guanzhong. I am very proud of the Sleeping Dragon and idolize the fictional Liu Bei, what were Kongming's actual greatest accomplishments as strategy is concerned?

2 Answers 2018-03-22

What was the impact of christianity on the renaissance?

I feel this is a particularly misunderstood period and would very much appreciate some factual historical answers to this question. Often the church is considered a bulwark against advancement, in science in particular, but also its impossible to escape that many of the artistic masterpieces of the era were religious, sponsored by the church and in general usually about christianity.

What sort of mechanism did they use to exert their will on the artistic (and educational) world and what were the main goals of the church in carrying out their will?

What role did the church have in facilitating or hindering the advancements made at the time, in Italy in particular. I understand that the renaissance is a modern idea for a long period of time that involved slow change.

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Is there any reputable sources of Nazi party membership statistics?

I read in an article that the Nazi party grew to over 100,000 registered members by 1928 and that statistic would be invaluable for a research paper I'm writing. The problem is, I can't use the statistic if I can't find a reputable source on it, which I have been having difficulty finding. Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-03-22

How come the fact that the Earth is spherical was discovered thousands of years before gravity?

Surely the logical process from finding that the Earth is a sphere is -Why aren't we falling off? -Ah, falling goes towards the center of the earth -Never really thought about the force of falling and how it acts before. We should name this!

2 Answers 2018-03-22

Why didn't we go after Josef Mengele after he escaped to South America?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

What bayonet did US Marines use during the revolutionary war?

As this is the revolution, I’m not sure if there is one set one, but what was the most popular and widely used? I’m hoping to start a collection of them through all the wars. Thanks in advance gents.

1 Answers 2018-03-22

Did the Manhattan Project make Allied victory in World War II inevitable?

Considering that the United States used nuclear weapons on Japan in August 1945, and didn't plan to deploy them against Germany because they were deemed unnecessary for Victory in Europe, it seems like there's a strong argument to be made that once Germany gave up on seriously pursuing atomic weapons research, and the US dedicated itself to producing usable nuclear weapons at any cost, that Nazi Germany was pretty much always living on borrowed time. If anything, it dodged a nuclear bullet by capitulating when it did.

Am I off base here? I'll try to steer clear of alternate history scenarios by asking more specifically - have any historians made arguments for or against this line of thinking?

1 Answers 2018-03-22

⯇ 2742 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start