Were the tales collected by the brothers Grimm widely known before they compiled them? Did the more popular ones (Snow White, Cinderella, Red Riding Hood) match the ones more popular before they collected them? Were they immediately of academic interest?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Why are the Archbishop's of Canterbury and York the respective heads of the Church of England?

I know the monarch, the Queen, is the Supreme Governor of the Church, but how did these two bishoprics become the most important and not London?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Did South American countries develop the notion of a "frontier" similar to that in the United States?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Is there any evidence that the Romans knew of Ireland, or did they think the British Isles consisted solely of England, Scotland and Wales?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why were some early medieval states larger than ones that came directly after them?

Right now I'm in a college Western civ class, and I've seemed to notice a general trend: directly following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire (well around the 600s through to the 900s time frame in Western history) there seemed to be a period of states that were marked by relatively huge borders, with what must have been similarly large populations in them. These were medieval kingdoms, with what must have been a huge amount of power, think like the Carolingian Empire, the Bulgarian Empire, the Empire of Greater Moravia, the Kingdom of the Visigoths, Aquitania, and I'm certain even more that I'm missing now. In some cases; the differemces between these countries and the ones that spawned them is not so dramatic, like the kingdom of the Franks compared to France itself or the kingdom of the Visigoths to Spain, but at least in places like Bulgaria, the differnce in power hat these medieval kingdoms held seems to be dramtically different, and this kingdom in particular was quite powerful, at least for its time and compared to its neighbors. Is there any reason for this, or is the appearance of such kingdoms purely coincidental.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why did Jainism and Buddhism mostly die out in India under Islamic rule? Why was Hinduism the faith that flourished?

3 Answers 2017-12-14

When did the tradition of three meals a day/fixed eating times start to spread?

Animals usually eat when they're hungry right? Humans must have done that up until a certain point. Anyone?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Could this picture be related to the February 6th 1958 Munich air disaster ?

My grandfather was a British journalist working for the Daily Express, and he traveled all over Europe for work. He is the man on the right on this photograph. We are trying to obtain more context around some of his photographs. This particular photograph is supposed to have been taken in 1959/02/10 or 1957/02/10. /u/squopmobile on /r/wherewasthistaken asked whether it had to do with the Munich air disaster (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Munich_air_disaster). Assuming the correct year is 1958, the dates seem too close to be a coincidence.

Photo: https://i.imgur.com/hu8tdTl.jpg

Who is the man standing between the two photographers ? I tried going through the list of survivors of the crash, but couldn't find a close match.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why was 1984 an important novel of its time?

Reading the hugely popular novel, it struck me that Orwell had gotten a lot of inspiration from world war II but also the communist USSR. What threats, politically, historically, or economically were posed to the general British citizen at its time?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

What did East African families look like during the time of the Atlantic slave trade?

EDIT Title should say West African. Maps are hard. Also assorted typos.

One of the slavery apologist arguments I heard from a friend of mine is that "The Atlantic slave trade wasn't really breaking up families, because Africans back then didn't have any concept of marriage; whoever you were sleeping with at the time was your husband(s) or wife/wives".

I'm normally pretty good at refuting the usual apologist arguments but this is something I haven't been able to find reliable information on, even though it reeks of BS; even if they don't have an organized religion or one man/one woman lifetime commitments most cultures have developed a concept like marriage, even as simple as "ownership" of a woman/group of women. I understand if this is better asked on r/askanthropologists but I'm trying here first.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why is musical theater associated with gay men?

Not sure if this is the right place to ask, but as the title says, why is musical theater associated with gay men? In every musical I've seen that had a romantic plot or subplot, the romance was always straight, be it South Pacific or Phantom of the Opera. On top of that, a lot of musicals seem to have things in them designed to cater to straight men. While I haven't been able to see Chicago on stage, if it's anything like the movie I can't imagine a gay man would get much out of, say, When You're Good To Mama.

However, the connection is there, for whatever reason, and if it isn't the content of the musicals themselves, the only thing I can think of is some kind of historical event. Were there any famous gay musical actors who were out before being out was a normal thing or something?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Was heat stroke deadly in Classical Rome?

The 'Notes on the Author' section of my copy of The Aeneid says that Virgil died from a heat-stroke while sailing from Greece to Rome. Was heat-stroke really that serious an issue, in ancient times?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in December 14 2017:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

3 Answers 2017-12-14

Looking for a book recommendation regarding the "gunpowder empires".

Hi, just wondering because I didnt see anything on the Safavids or Mughals in the booklist specifically. I'm interested in reading some kind of comparative about the three big "gunpowder empires" of the Ottomans, Safavids, and Mughals, or any good book about these three either individually or together.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Were the light horses in the modern period physically better compared to the light cavalry of Antiquity/late Antiquity?

So my understanding of cavalry in Europe is that from the Medieval period to the modern period there was a transition from heavy warhorses to lighter cavalry due to technological advances. Now light cavalry had always existed, especially in the Roman Empire where they had dedicated horse breeding centres.

Were these modern period horses better from a physical perspective or simply more modernly equipped/trained? I would suppose it comes down to the definition of better, in the context of light cavalry I'd imagine the criteria are: greater endurance for given size, greater speed for given size, more intelligent/ more easily taught and less easily frightened.

Another way to phrase this would be, if two horses looked exactly the same and had the same size and shape except one was from late antiquity whilst the other was from the modern period, would there be a difference? Had selective breeding in the modern period produced a horse that performed better given the same physical characteristics, or did it simply produce a horse with more of those preferable characteristics that a horse in antiquity could potentially possess as well?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why and when did we start bombing civilians in World War II?

According to The Official History of the Royal Air Force, on the 4th of September 1940, Hitler said:

The British drop their bombs indiscriminately and without plan on civilian residential quarters and on farms and villages. For three months I did not reply because I believed they would stop, but in this Mr Churchill saw only a sign of our weakness. The British will know that we are now giving our answer night after night. We shall stop the handiwork of these night pilots.

Three days later, the Luftwaffe began bombing London.

Is it true that Germany did not target civilians before then? Is it true that the British were already targeting civilians? If so, when did the British start deliberately bombing civilians and why?

Thanks to /u/Bigglesworth_ and his very kind answer to my previous question, I am now researching my wife's grandfather's career before his capture.

He was in No. 7 Squadron of Bomber Command, flying in Sterling heavy bombers as a Navigator (which I understand also involved duties as Bomb Aimer). He flew on two sorties then failed to return from his third. The first was to Hanover on 14th July 1941, the second to Cologne on 30th July, and the last to Berlin on 2nd August.

According to the squadron records, both of the first two sorties included dropping incendiary devices and starting fires. Would he have been targeting military/industrial sites, or civilians?


Richards, D., Official History of the Royal Air Force 1935-1945 — Vol. I — Fight at Odds, Pickle Partners, 2014.

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Is it accurate to say that American common law is based on English common law, which is based on Roman common law? At what point in the empire/ Byzantine era did England draw its traditions from? When was this adopted? How common was this among the fledgling nation states of Europe?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

There was a notion during WWII that Rommel was the "good" German (not really ideologically a Nazi, possibly unaware of the Holocaust, died after a failed coup against Hitler). Is this still consistent with what we know of the man?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

Someone here in AH mentioned that they think that future historians will view WWI, WWII and the Cold War as one gigantic conflict or process. What is that conflict about? What's the theme?

I understand that the point is that it's too early to tell, but I was wondering if there are any theories yet.

Edit: I don't know what's going on with the Journalism tag. It added itself, disappeared for a few hours and then came back again...

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why did some slavic languages adopted a cyrillic alphabet while others a latin one?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

What helped post WW2 germany to gain power again?

After the second World War germany was divided, destroyed and poor. Now ist the strongest power in the EU and one of the strongest in the world. My question is: What made the change? What helped germany to gain power again?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Was Soviet Cinema ever widely screened in the United States?

Slew 'o questions ahead: Was it taboo to view such movies, and if so, what were the consequences? Was there ideologically driven censorship? Were Soviet films ever widely broadcast on American TV? How does their distribution in the US compare to other NATO member countries? Was there a home video or rental market for these movies? Did leftists ever have private or public screenings of these films?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

American role in the USSR's industrialization

I've read (and watched) a lot of Anthony Sutton's work on US-USSR economic relations, he's generally viewed as a kook, but some of the stuff he talks about is well-established (e.g. Ford and the GAZ plant, Averill Harriman and the Georgian manganese). What is the consensus, was the US' role in the USSR's modernization decisive?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why did the Romans put so many resources into conquering Britain instead of Germania?

3 Answers 2017-12-14

Salty About History

Before expansive trade routes and adequate transportation, how did land locked areas like mongolia, or tibet, or any place far from the ocean/salt seas get salt to make things like preserving meats a common thing?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

⯇ 2945 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start