To what extent would the Norse/Vikings have been aware of the Jewish people? Were there ever Jews living among the pre-Christian Norse in any significant number?

The Vikings interacted with both the Christian and Muslim worlds, and since the bulk of the Jewish diaspora settled in Europe and the Middle East, it stands to reason that Vikings must have raided or traded with them on occasion. Do we have records of any such contact, what the two cultures thought of one another, etc.?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Mississippi did not ratify the 13th until 1995. Does that mean that before 1995 if someone owned a slave there, a state court couldn't do anything about it?

What is the significance of it not being ratified? Why bother ratifying it if the 13th already passed?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

What would I see if I were to watch a field-battle between two "large armies" in Europe during the High Medieval period?

Disclaimer: From what I know there is a general lack of knowledge regarding the actual "juicy details" of battle in the medieval period. If there isn't enough information about this to answer I understand.

This question is asking about the details of a field battle in this area and period from initiation (archers?, taunts?, formations?) to end (rout?, surrender?, execution?). This includes things like how & when cavalry and infantry would've been most commonly deployed against the enemy in this area and period.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Arguments for being a Loyalist during the American Revolution

I'm an American, and also an Anglophile. Like everyone else, I've become obsessed with the musical Hamilton, and I started to wonder which side I would have come down on if I'd been alive at the time. We don't hear much over here about the reasons for remaining a Loyalist. What, in your view, are the best reasons for an American colonist to remain a Loyalist leading up to and during the Revolution?

3 Answers 2017-12-14

Do Tell us about Eleventh-century Lombardy Primary Sources?

A moderator deleted my question in another discussion, but suggested that I could ask it separately. So I'll kind of anagram the title and ask it here.

Spotty sources are the plague of a lot of history. How does 11th C Lombardy look on this sort of issue -- was 11th C Lombardy starting a upswing in sources, or did it start earlier, or later? The later full Renaissance started, I gather, in northern Italy; was there a similar precursor there to the "12th C renaissance"?

What sources are about? Chronicles by monks? Business documents like, say, for trade or land management? Government documents? Letters? Memoirs? Fiction?

^(help us, /u/AlviseFalier)

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why was the British defence of Singapore so weak against a significantly weaker force ?

I have been watching WW2 in colour and in S1E5 the narrator stated that the Singapore garrison of 100,000 men surrendered with a force of 90,000 men against a force a third of the size . What caused such a dreadfully weak defence ? presumably the soldiers would be professional well trained soldiers due to where they were positioned ? The British seemed to fold pathetically weakly in the region .

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Why the required conceit of questions? Could users not just post essays or explanations of topics that interest them?

Inspired by this comment. Why be wed to the question-answer format if its just kabuki? Why not pre-written topics alongside questions, with corresponding flair? I bet it would generate a lot more view on a subject if users saw an already written subject ready for consumption, rather than some mini-thesis going unread in a question with 5 votes.

3 Answers 2017-12-14

What do we know about the people living in Britain at the time of Julius Caesar's invasion?

Were they Celtic, Germanic, neither? Were they sedentary or nomadic? In general how did they compare to the people living in Gaul on the other side of the channel?

2 Answers 2017-12-14

The Japanese "Edo Period 1603- 1868" is widely viewed as a peaceful and stable era, to what extend is this true? Where the Tokugawa shogunate really able to keep the peace for 250 years or was there uprisings and civil disputes?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

What do Primary Sources Tell us about Eleventh-century Lombardy?

1 Answers 2017-12-14

Did the Anglo-Saxon rebels in 1070 and King Svend II of Denmark have have a truly common goal; and how good was the situation for Svend before he was payed to leave.

So in 1070, there was a rebellion against the new king of England, William the bastard, by his Anglo-Saxon subjects. The king of Denmark, Svend II had a claim to the throne of England, based on the fact that his grandfather was King Sweyn Forkbeard of England. Were the Anglo-Saxons and the Danish fighting together just because they both wanted to depose William the bastard, or did the Anglo-Saxons actually decide that they'd rather be ruled by Danes than Normans, and that they wanted to help Svend II claim England?

Also, it says in Wikipedia that Svend II actually had a rather favourable position in this invasion, so why would he decide to leave for a bit of money? Also, why couldn't he have just taken the money then not actually left or something? I mean he is a Viking after all, isn't he?

After looking at the other candidates for the English throne, Harold Godwinesson has no blood relation to any previous King of England, Harald Hardrade is only going between old promises between Hardecnut and Magnus and William the bastard is, unsurprisingly, a bastard. It seems as if, apart from Edgar Ætheling, Svend II is the obvious choice when it comes to inheritance. I mean it's not like Sweyn Forkbeard had a strong claim to the throne or anything, being just a Viking invader, but it's better than literally nothing.

1 Answers 2017-12-14

[META] Ask Historians has a huge listed of flaired users. But many popular questions seem to be answered by the same three or four users, no matter the subject. Do "superusers" discourage a balance of contributions?

13 Answers 2017-12-13

[Journalism] To what extent was Hearst responsible for the failure of "Citizen Kane?"

1 Answers 2017-12-13

What happened to the Maccabees after they drove out the Greeks?

In the spirit of Hanukkah, I'd figure I would ask. Did the Maccabees form an independent Jewish kingdom? Were they defeated by another foe?

1 Answers 2017-12-13

Why didn't any Middle-Eastern or Asian powers such as the Ottomans or Chinese colonise Australia?

I was just reading this post from last year and had this follow-up question https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4j76ir/why_did_it_take_so_long_to_discover_australia/

1 Answers 2017-12-13

What impact did cotton fabrics have on fashion?

What impact did the development of cotton fabrics and their more widespread adoption have on fashion? Was there an immediate switch from wool or other fibres? In particular, was there a backlash against cotton at any stage?

1 Answers 2017-12-13

Why did Rosa parks get such widespread media attention? Why was she not “swept under the rug” or generally ignored?

I’ve asked this here before with no answer.

1 Answers 2017-12-13

How did industrialization eleviate need for farm workers?

With like 80-90% working in the farms, how did farming survive by loosing such a large workforce to factories? At the time I don't believe tractors were available so what happened there?

1 Answers 2017-12-13

What percentage of gladiator fights in Rome would have ended in death?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-12-13

The Nazis propagated the "Stab in the Back" myth - but what did they argue that the Jews actually *did* to cause Germany to lose WWI?

Of course, they blamed other political enemies too, like the bolsheviks and whatnot. Proponents argued that these "enemies" betrayed the German army and the country, but how exactly did these "enemies" accomplish that? Did the Nazis have any proof?

1 Answers 2017-12-13

How did the Mongols defeat armies with just cavalry?

First off, i don't know much about military tactics, but from my laymans perspective surely the whole point of having infantry/cavalry/archers etc in an army is that they all have strengths and weaknesses on there own, but combined they make up for each others deficits. So how did the Mongols rely so heavily on Cavalry and still be successful.

2 Answers 2017-12-13

British Royal House of Windsor Question

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-12-13

What is the context of this Japanese soldiers in the picture? Is it real?

I have been surfing around the internet and I came across this image, I would be delighted if you could provide me with some context. (If it is real of course!)

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-12-13

I have two questions about the Confederate Constitution and what it means.

Article 1 Section 9.2 of the Confederate Constitution says: Congress shall also have power to prohibit the introduction of slaves from any State not a member of, or Territory not belonging to, this Confederacy.

Article 1 Section 9.4 says: No bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law denying or impairing the right of property in negro slaves shall be passed.

I was hoping someone could explain what both of these mean, I'm confused to their actual purpose/what they accomplish. Hope I did this correctly!

2 Answers 2017-12-13

Have there ever been any serious attempts to develop Central Park?

Either in full or partially. Saw a picture of it this morning and it just looks like prime real estate.

1 Answers 2017-12-13

⯇ 2946 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start