Was it reasonable for the Japanese to have won the war in the Pacific? The fact that they preemptively struck against the USA implies that they believed they could win, but in reality with the gift of hindsight was a Japanese victory likely? And if one was to speculate how possibly could it have happened?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
1 Answers 2017-12-07
I know this is a dumb question but explain like I’m 5 please.
I understand the basic desire for Israel and Palestine to “own” Jerusalem but I’ve wondered since my Sunday school days why the city can’t be made a country in an attempt to bring peace and make it a neutral Territory. I also understand that The Vatican is a very special case but so is Jerusalem.
You all are typically the most logical and factual r/ask community so I figured asking here would yield the most comprehensive answer in terms of historical precedent, and context. I’d like to disregard current affairs as much as possible.
I’m also not sure how to flair on mobile, sorry
2 Answers 2017-12-07
Hello, this is my first post on Reddit, so cheers to whoever finds this! In the midst of finding ways of procrastinating studying for finals, I stumbled across a list of things "Americans" do that make others from different countries / cultures angry. One of the actions listed was that people from the states refer to their home as "America" instead of the "US". I was just wondering how the name "America" become synonymous with the US, in spite of the fact that there are 23 countries that make up North America, and another 12 in South America?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
What made the Armenians distinct from other Christians?
2 Answers 2017-12-07
[deleted]
1 Answers 2017-12-07
I've been reading about the Second Punic War lately, and I keep coming across instances of armies lining up to fight a pitched battle, and then one or both declining to fight.
I seem to recall more than a few occasions of this behavior in Italy, and Scipio's most famous battle in Spain was won because they spent a few days lining up and not fighting enough that Scipio could trick Mago into using his same deployment. Livy even describes Hannibal as "refraining from battle" when the Carpetani are descending on him north of the Tagus.
What am I missing here? I can understand the lack of a battle when both armies don't want to fight, but how is it possible that one army could decline to fight, and the battle wouldn't happen? How could Hannibal refrain from battle and just encamp on the river bank? Scipio was declining battle so he could bait Mago presumably because Mago held the upper hand. Why would any general who had the upper hand and seeing that his enemy didn't want to fight refrain from ordering an attack (aside from obvious reasons like the weather or unfavorable terrain that negated his advantage)?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
1 Answers 2017-12-07
I was watching a Forgotten Weapons episode and gun Jesus mentioned this happening around the five minute mark. I was wondering if anyone could elaborate.
1 Answers 2017-12-07
It's one of Reddit's favourite history tales, but I wonder if any of it is true. What really did happen? When did the characterization as a "war" start? Are the often repeated details about it (that Emus won, especially) the truth or embellishments that no one bothers to check?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
1 Answers 2017-12-07
Today in one of my classes a student told me that Abraham Lincoln owned slaves, who were connected to some house he owned in the South. This seems like trash, but he might have been confusing Abe Lincoln with someone else. Is this true? And if not, is the student confusing honest Abe with another person?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
Although Israel’s official capital is Tel Aviv, the country has long considered Jerusalem as its unofficial capital. Jerusalem, which is one of the oldest cities in the world, has been formally divided between Israel and Palestine for nearly 70 years, yet changed hands many other times throughout the course of its over 5,000-year history.
1 Answers 2017-12-07
I'm writing a book set in that time period and it would be nice to know how to correctly describe a soldier of that time.
1 Answers 2017-12-07
2 Answers 2017-12-07
The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make /r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. You can also catch the latest episodes on SoundCloud and Spotify. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!
This Episode:
Today as it is our 100th episode (and we are fast approaching 700,000 subscribers) we have decided to do something a little different! We have a panel of AskHistorians Moderators to talk about AskHistorians Under the Hood--what it is like to moderate and run the worlds largest academic history forum. AskHistorians has grown a lot in its six, nearly 7 years of existence, spawning several articles, helping several careers, several academic panels (which you can hear on earlier episodes) and this podcast! So if you have no interest in AskHistorians as a reddit community, this podcast might be of less interest to you. But regardless we have a great lineup today. The format today will be brief discussions of individual moderators about different aspects of AskHistorians followed by period of comment by the whole panel!
Today we are joined by
/u/bernardito, better known as Stefan, flaired in Modern Guerrilla and Counterinsurgency, to talk about the development of the subreddit and his own development. You can also catch him on episodes 39 and 40 talking about Algeria and Counter-Insurgency.
/u/commiespaceinvader, also known as Joe, flaired in to Holocaust Nazi Germany and Wehrmacht War Crimes, to talk about holocaust denialism, the academic theories underpinning academia and AskHistorians, and the emotional labor of working on a very difficult topic. You can also catch him on episodes 91 and 57 talking about fascism and Intentionalism and Functionalism in the Holocaust
/u/snapshot52, known as Kyle, flaired in Native American Studies | Colonialism, to talk about theory in a non-western and subaltern points of view, and the difficulties and pleasures of this. You can also catch him on episodes 75 and 80 talking about Indian Policy and Indian Sovereignty and Cultural Genocide against American Indians
/u/chocolatepot, known to her friends and family as Cassidy Percoco, flaired in the History of Western Fashion, to discuss what it is like having interests that are contrarian to the reddit hivemind and culture, and what it is like to bring women's history to life. Catch her on episode 45 talking about Regency Era Fashion
/u/Iphikrates, known as Roel, flaired in Greek Warfare, to talk about being an expert in a field where the academic view is diametrically opposed to the public one, and how AH is a perfect opportunity to do something about it because the questions come from the public. Catch him also on episode 81 discussing Iphikrates and His Reforms
Finally we will have
Questions? Comments?
If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on.
If you like the podcast, please rate and review us on iTunes.
Thanks all!
Previous episode and discussion.
Next Episode: /u/ThucydidesWasAwesome is back!
Want to support the Podcast? Help keep history interesting through the AskHistorians Patreon.
13 Answers 2017-12-07
1 Answers 2017-12-07
As I understand it, Guadalcanal halted the Japanese drive south short of Australia, but did the Japanese military even have the capacity to launch a full scale invasion/occupation of Australia?
1 Answers 2017-12-07
Was this something that happened straight away, or later? And was it primarily for social (such as the veneration of saints being associated with corruption in the Church, or something like that), or theological reasons?
2 Answers 2017-12-07
Let's determine pre-modern as before the industrial revolution.
1 Answers 2017-12-07
there is a scene in the movie empire of the sun where the kamikaze pilots sing a japanese song during their ceremony. it is also heard in the beginning of this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r-THeBQyYZA
1 Answers 2017-12-07
Now and then, we like to host 'Floating Features', periodic threads intended to allow for more open discussion that allows a multitude of possible answers from people of all sorts of backgrounds and levels of expertise.
Today's topic is 'Buy The Mods A Friend A Gift'. As holidays approach, we have seen an uptick in questions relating to book recommendations, and while those are generally fine here, we thought we'd collect them in one place. In this thread, we invite users to share what fun historical books they've run across recently, and hopefully give us some context as to why they are good!
We are open to recommendations of both books of Actual History and historical fiction books. To make sure these are useful to readers, please follow these basic guidelines:
If you're recommending a book, please write a couple sentences about why you found it interesting/useful/worth reading. It's fine to link to reviews, but be aware that links to commercial sites (e.g. Amazon) sometimes trip the Reddit spam filter; if you don't see your post show up, message us in mod-mail and we'll check on it.
If you're asking whether a book is good, make sure to provide enough context that it can be answered: "Is Eric Foner's book good" gives us 25 to choose from; "is Eric Foner's Reconstruction good" is much more answerable. (n.b. it is.) A good place to start if you want to ask about books is our Books and Resources List.
As is the case with previous Floating Features, there is relaxed moderation here to allow more scope for speculation and general chat then there would be in a usual thread! But with that in mind, we of course expect that anyone who wishes to contribute will do so politely and in good faith.
6 Answers 2017-12-07
I have heard of a saying "On land we pray to God, at sea we pray to Thor" and I assumed this must have come about during conversion attempts during the Viking Age. So did the Norse ever try to convert people in the UK? What evidence do we have that they continued pagan practices in their newly conquered territory?
2 Answers 2017-12-07