Timothy Snyder states that there is no official French history of WW2 because "more French soldiers fought on the Axis side than the Allied side."- Is this true?

Video with the comment : https://youtu.be/wDjHw_uXeKU?t=1198

1 Answers 2017-12-07

A large portion of modern English last names are derived from medieval guilds - the candlemaker's guild for 'chandler,' or the saddlemaker's guild for 'Saddler.' Does this also hold true for last names in other cultures? Was last-naming by guild/occupation a thing in France, China, Russia, etc?

3 Answers 2017-12-07

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in December 07 2017:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2017-12-07

Why was the Netherlands targeted during the 1973 oil crisis?

I know why the US was targeted (because they delivered arms to Israel which helped them win the Yom Kippur war) but why was the Netherlands targeted?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Did the ancients have a concept of historic site preservation like we do? Like did Romans in 300 AD think that buildings like Colosseum and Pantheon are old and need to be preserved?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Why did the IRA agree to a ceasefire in 1994? Why did it break down in 1996?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Why is Vatican City in Rome?

After Emperor Constantine moved the Roman capital to Constantinople from Rome because of the amount of pagan symbolism on Rome, you would think that the Papal State would have taken residency in Constantinople instead. So why was Vatican City in Rome and not in Constantinople? Was there ever a time where they were planning on putting it there? What was the deciding factor, if any, that made the Vatican in Rome?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Did Soviet soldiers watch movies while deployed during WWII?

Inther media, American (and often British) soldiers watching movies while deployed in Europe during World War II is a common scene. On the Eastern front, what was the film situation for Soviet troops? Did they have access to entertainment via motion pictures to the same extent that their Western counterparts did? What kinds of movies did they have, if any?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

I was told to repost my question here long ago: Do you see the Rise of Christianity and Fall of the Western Roman Empire as being directly correlated, mere coincidence, or somewhere in between?

I personally think the belief of a God being much greater than previously deified emperors likely changed the perspective and mentality of the empire and subsequently led to its eventual collapse. I'm not well versed on the fall of the empire and have yet to read Gibbon, but I know many of you are and have. What are your opinions/claims?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Was the Roman Republic a Nation State

My friend and I are in a debate right now as to whether or not the people of a country felt a sense of nationalism in one's country before the treaty of Westphalia. One of us argued that as far back as the Roman Republic, a state existed that felt a sense of nationalism/ patriotism. Where as the other person argued the idea of a nation state wasn't conceived until relatively recently in history, and that since other cultures during the era of the Romans identified more with the people that surrounded them, rather than as a culture, that there is no way that Romans could have been nationalistic, and thus an Anti-Example. So was the roman republic a nation state of people, that felt a sense of nationalism in Rome, or not?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

What's myth and what's truth about the legend of Rasputin?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

In "Hunt for Red October" the Russian sub Captain says "Your conclusions were all wrong, Halsey acted stupidly" what was he referring too?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

In the 1910s, did anyone feel anxiety about increasingly widespread and affordable electronic lights?

For most of recorded history, nights were long and dark. Even among the very wealthy, candles were an extravagance that were only burned in large numbers with company (one visitor to an 18th century Virginia aristocrat's home noted with awe that when the worthy gentleman had guests over, he had six candles burning in a single room).

But in the early 20th century, we saw the rapid expansion of electronic lighting in the form of incandescent light bulbs. I'm not sure how long it took for them to become affordable to most people, but surely even in the 1910s more and more people were experiencing nights illuminated by electronic light.

This seems like a profound change in the way we experienced the cycle of day and night, one that perhaps had dramatic implications for the way we understood time and what kind of activities could take place after the setting of the sun.

How did people feel about this? Unalloyed joy at "progress?" Anxiety about this change in how we view and interact with the night?

3 Answers 2017-12-07

Why is Easter Island controlled by Chile and not a European power or the USA?

Easter Island seems like an important Pacific island outpost, given its relative isolation. Why didn't one of the colonial powers take control of it?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Why did the West fear communism more than they did fascism during and near WWII?

Near the rise of the Nazi party, Stalin recognized the threat that Germany posed to Russia, and didn’t want a repeat of Germany invading Russia as they did in WWI. So when Stalin reached out to Britain and to France to say “let’s isolate Hitler” they turned him down because the only thing that the West feared more than Hitler was Stalin.
So then Stalin’s only option was to make a nonaggression pact I’m 1939 with Germany knowing that it was only a matter of time before Hitler turned his back on him in 1941 with the Barbarossa Operations.

Edit: 1941 from originally posted 1949

1 Answers 2017-12-07

What were some differences between the Fascist regime in Italy and the Nazi regime in Germany?

I was wondering about this recently. When talking about the fascism of 20s and 30s Europe, Germany is always the big bad guy, while Italy is left in the shadows? Is there a particular reason for this ? Was Italy a more benign fascist state? Was it less racist?

What were the differences between the two states, politically, socially, economically, etc. ?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

How could the Russian empire in 1917 a impoverished feudalist nation with a duality of master-slave, turn to be the second world power on 1940 with a record growth economy.

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Is this Vice article about Gandhi accurate?

https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/ezj3km/gandhi-was-a-racist-who-forced-young-girls-to-sleep-in-bed-with-him

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Were there famous bands in ancient times?

Were there any famous bands that traveled the country/world for money like the Ancient Greek version of The Beatles as an analogy.

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Were Douglas MacArthur's criticisms of how Chester Nimitz conducted battles in the Pacific legitimate?

In American Caesar William Manchester quites Douglas MacArthur as saying after the Battle of Okinawa: "The Central Pacific command just sacrificed thousands of American soldiers because they insisted on driving the Japanese off the island. In three or four days after the landing the American forces had all the area they needed, which was the area they needed for airplane bases. They should have had the troops go into a defensive position and just let the Japs come to them and kill them from a defensive position, which would have been much easier to do and would have cost less men."

MacArthur was a brilliant general, but his vanity and jealousy of other military commanders were also legendary. Does MacArthur's criticism of the strategy of driving the Japanese off Okinawa make sense? Or were there reasons why MacArthur's approach wouldn't have worked?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

In Mark Mazower's The Balkans, he says that the mountains in the peninsula did not present a barrier to invasion. Is this true? Why?

The text in question: "Unlike the mountain chains guarding the necks of the Iberian and Italian Peninsulas, the Balkan ranges offer no barrier against invasion, leaving the region open to easy access and attack from the north and east. On the other hand, their irregular formation hinders movement between one valley and the next." (Page 3, The Balkans: A Short History, 2002)

How were actual invasions of Balkan territory affected by mountains? Moreover (if you'll indulge me), how have Balkan peoples thought of the relationship between themselves and the mountains around them? I recognize that that question is immensely broad.

2 Answers 2017-12-07

I know that in Ancient Rome Christianity wasn't illegal par se but that Christians were persecuted because they refused to worship the emperor and also they taught others to not worship the emperor. Were Jews, who are also monotheists, persecuted for the same reasons?

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Why didn't Japan and the Soviet Union fight a bunch during World War 2?

They're like right next to each other, and yet they may as well have been neutral to each other. I've heard that maybe the Russians finishing their fight with Germany and possibly hoping to invade Japan (to get a communist North Japan maybe) was as much if not more of a motivator for the Japanese to surrender; but why weren't they shooting each other around 1943-44?

3 Answers 2017-12-07

How did one become a torturer in the Middle Ages?

If you were a ruler during the Middle Ages, where would you look to find a torturer? Among your own guards? The executioner?

I realize that there was probably a lot of variation, given that "Middle Ages" covers a LOT of years. I'm just trying to get a sense of what kind of background a torturer might have.

1 Answers 2017-12-07

Should the Cold War have turned into a conventional war, what were the US's plans for replenishing losses? Tanks, planes etc cost much more and required much greater skill to make than in WW2

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-12-06

⯇ 2960 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start