I know the Germans at least disliked the KKK, as this was a [propaganda poster used in the Netherlands.] (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/f8/Liberators-Kultur-Terror-Anti-Americanism-1944-Nazi-Propaganda-Poster.jpg) But I wonder how the KKK felt about the NSDAP.
1 Answers 2017-12-03
I ask these questions because I never heard of this division until I came across a photo:
It alleges these are the members of this SS division were mostly Bosnian Muslims, they are depicted above performing Islamic prayers. From limited, admittedly non-scholarly tertiary sources (I only find blogs and wikis that regurgitate the same limited knowledge on this topic). I understand their involvement as a foreign division of SS troops was to protect their homeland, rather than the propaganda and Aryan supremacy of Hitler's Reich. It also states Himmler's fascination with Islam in its ability to create 'Fearless soldiers'. My findings also suggested that some of the most decorated German soldiers from the European theater were apparently from this division.
My understanding of marginalized persons in Nazi Europe included the Jews, Communists, homosexuals and fringe intellectuals. What accounted for the accommodation of these Muslim troops' customs and rituals? Would the remnants of their actions be what led to eventual crisis in Bosnia and Herzegovina in the 90s?
I posted here in hopes a historian can help a fellow intellectual follow a lead with scholarly sources or material for further research. I would be very appreciative of this sub's help to develop my research prospects.
I find this incredibly fascinating as in my entire American school education my knowledge of "Muslim troops" were from European colonies or allies to the Vichy. I never heard anything about a regiment of this type or Muslims in the European theater other than an anglo-indian spy Nora Baker (Noor Inayat Khan) which was through my own research out of a scholarly institution.
2 Answers 2017-12-03
2 Answers 2017-12-03
One source says Hitler had wanted to invade as early as 1924, even a conservative estimate has to be at least 5 or 6 years of pre-planning. And, though initial successful winter, bad roads (or no roads,) break-down of equipment are some of the major excuses as to why the invasion ultimately failed. Yet, I can find no book on the subject of German planning, solutions to.
It seems they just took the same attitude as if they were invading France w/no added precautions to the wilderness of Russia
4 Answers 2017-12-03
thank God they didn't and we still had the fuel to launch our fleet against the Japanese war machine.
1 Answers 2017-12-03
Has a Shogun ever denied someone some request that an Emperor granted? Would the Shogun be forced to agree with the Emperor? Has someone important (like a Shogun) ever insulted an Emperor? What was the result?
4 Answers 2017-12-03
How could the Germans inflict such a crushing defeat on Rome?
2 Answers 2017-12-03
I want to know some more about how Anatolia- a Greek-speaking Christian region inhabited by people as diverse as the Kurds, Armenians, and Georgians- became a well-known Muslim country with a distinctive and diverse culture in its own right. I understand some of it must have come down to conforming to norms and taxes placed on non-Muslims, but it still astonishes me.
4 Answers 2017-12-03
The South is known as the Bible Belt in the US and I was wondering why did it become more religious than the Northern US.
Edit:
Where I got the idea from:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_religiosity
1 Answers 2017-12-03
Hello!
We are a panel of both regular AH contributors and guest Egyptologists who have been roped into invited to an AMA. With new releases like Assassin's Creed: Origins and a general uptick in Egypt-related activity around these parts we thought it was high-time for another ancient Egypt mega-thread. /r/AskHistorians has previously featured a massive thread on Egyptian history throughout time but this thread will focus specifically on ancient Egypt and hopefully give you a chance to let us know what burning questions are on your mind concerning the ancient gift of the Nile.
"Ancient Egypt" is usually taken to mean a roughly 3,500 year span of time which we are going to define as around 3,100 BCE to 400 AD. That said, neatly packaging social and cultural trends into discreet packages is often trickier than it sounds so take this as a general guideline.
So what questions about ancient Egyptian civilisation have had you wondering? Here to answer these queries and shed light on all the tombs, temples, and textile trades you can wave a torch at is our team of panelists:
/u/Bentresh - Specialises in Bronze Age Egypt and Mesopotamia.
/u/cleopatra_philopater - Specialises in Hellenistic and Early Roman Egypt, with a special interest on social history.
/u/Khaemwaset - Specialises in the Old Kingdom, and in particular the construction of the pyramids.
/u/TheHereticKing - Specialized in general ancient Egyptian history.
/u/lucaslavia - Specialises in Pharaonic Egypt.
/u/Osarnachthis - Specialises in Egyptian language.
79 Answers 2017-12-03
I'm not the best at Chinese history post Qing Dynasty, but I do know China was riddled with civil war from 1912 when the Republic of China was founded all the way until the rise of Mao and a Communist China. But to my knowledge, between 1912 and 1931 when the Japanese first attacked, the Republic wasn't overthrown and replaced with a new Republic.
1 Answers 2017-12-03
Mind you, this was a country that was significantly poorer than Portugal not too many decades ago. It is now the country with the 7th highest median wage in the world.
How was this even possible - what makes South Korea so special for it outpace any other country in the world during this time frame? Even the Miracle at the Rhine was nothing, in its scale, compared to this.
Even today, South Korea has growth rates not unlike those of developing countries, even though it has a very developed economy.
How?
2 Answers 2017-12-03
I don't know if i'm missing something obvious, But their performance and design strikes me as the kind of plane that would be good at shooting down bombers. Everything i see lists them as fighter-bombers though.
3 Answers 2017-12-03
They even got the positioning of them all correct!
What are your thoughts
1 Answers 2017-12-03
Today:
Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.
6 Answers 2017-12-03
Before water was safe and folks drank booze for hydration was there a higher percentage of the population dependent on alcohol? Other than just for hydration...
1 Answers 2017-12-03
5 Answers 2017-12-03
I know it's an oddly specific question but I can't seem to find anything online that helps.
2 Answers 2017-12-03
Every time I see a map of the bubonic plague, there is a large space of modern day Poland and Belarus that aren't highlighted. Did this mean the plague avoided these locales completely, and if so, did the people living here have specific bodily resistances against the plague?
2 Answers 2017-12-03
2 Answers 2017-12-03
Dragons feature prominently in medieval art. Did people believe they were depictions of real creatures or were they interpreted as allegories? Did scholars believe in their existence or was there a difference between the beliefs of ordinary people and educated people? Edit: I’m thinking about European medieval people here.
2 Answers 2017-12-03
I am aware that Russia didn't have Siberia when Columbus discovered America, but surely the information about another continent could have reached someone in Russia or China.
1 Answers 2017-12-03
1 Answers 2017-12-03
The more I learn about bayonet charges in history, the more I hear that deaths due to bayonet combat were rare and bayonet charges usually resulted in either the defenders retreating or the chargers being massacred.
Was bayonet fighting ever really a thing or was it just something that has been romanticized?
1 Answers 2017-12-03