100 years ago today, the Balfour Declaration was made. In light of their agreements with the Arabs (and their secret agreement with the French), why was this declaration made?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Why were Confederate leaders never brought to trial for war crimes?

Or were they? What little I know is that most went on to live profitable happy lives. To some extent, that the commanders and politicians were not brought before the Supreme Court for war crimes, traitorism, etc contributes to their heroic mythos in the south to this day, doesn't it? I mean, openly rebelling and waging war against the federal government could be seen as a war crime right?

At Nuremberg the opinion was that it certainly was(granted the Nazi party lied, murdered, and coerced it's way into power)..

Anyway, it just crossed my mind. Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-11-02

During the holocaust, why couldn’t Jews just say they weren’t Jewish/convert?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Did polygenism play a role in the devellopement of scientific racism?

Polygenism is the theory that human races have different origins. It was somewhat popular before theory of evolution took hold.

When I first came across this idea, my modern sensibilities made me think that this might be racism. That in turn made me curious if the principles of polygenism played a role in the evolution of scientific racism.

1 Answers 2017-11-02

What was your favorite course as an undergraduate student and why?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-11-02

In elementary school I was taught that Native Americans hunted buffalo by chasing them off cliffs. But what about the peoples of Kansas, Oklahoma, or Nebraska who lived on incredibly flat prairies?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Why didn't the British West Indies join the 13 colonies in the American Revolution?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

When did we separate belief from entertainment in storytelling?

When did people start writing or telling stories strictly as fiction, that was not intended to be believed by the audience? What was the earliest written/published work of fiction? And were mythologies like the Odyssey actually believed by their audience at the time or were they more for entertainment?

2 Answers 2017-11-02

What is the best book about the Spanish-American War?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Did the Kriegsmarine ever stand a chance of winning the Battle of the Atlantic?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

How accurate is the representation of Egypt in Assassin's Creed Origins?

I apologize if this type of question isn't allowed. To make this question a bit less general, I'm especially interested in the world itself - for example, how accurate are the clothes that people wear or their day-to-day lives? What about architecture and agriculture? In sum, would someone from Ptolemy XIII's Egypt recognize the world as Egypt at that particular time?

4 Answers 2017-11-02

Where did the First New England School style for early American music come from?

We're singing "Sherburne" in my chorus for our upcoming fall concert, and it's very different from other 18th century music we've sung! (E.g. Mozart.) According to the Wiki page for Daniel Read,

While the classical music era was in its heyday in Europe, American composers of "serious" music were setting hymn tunes in three- and four-part a cappella style, with simple folklike melodies and little regard for functional harmony.

Why were the American composers writing music like this? Is this how earlier 18th and maybe even 17th century folk/popular music in Britain sounded?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

When the Soviet Union fell, were there interviews for elderly people who happened to still be alive from the Russian Revolutions and what their thoughts were on the U.S.S.R.'s rise and fall?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

What did "tall, dark and handsome" mean? When did it come into vogue? What traits did "dark" refer to?

Was 'dark' referring to the person's appearance or ethnicity? If not, did it have to do with the person's aesthetics in any way?

2 Answers 2017-11-02

Why does everyone murder Mongol envoys?

Khwarezmid Empire executed a convoy of Mongol merchants, and later envoys largely unprovoked. Mstlslav of Kiev executed Mongol envoys, even though all the envoys wanted to say is that the target was the Cumans and not Kiev. The Japanese eventually executed Mongol envoys as well. Currently listening to a history of the Mongols, and provoking the Mongols seems like a spectacularly stupid action, but opposing nations kept executing Mongol envoys. Why?

2 Answers 2017-11-02

Is the Fischer Thesis the accepted explanation for how World War One started?

I don't study history but while learning about WWI and the collapse of imperial Russia the Fisher Thesis came up. I didn't think much about it (the premise being that Imperial Germany was ultimately responsible for WWI) until I just recently came across an address by John CG Rohls (he gave it on November 6th, 2014).

I have always assumed, and been taught, WWI was sort of inevitable, and the result of short-sightedness on the party of ALL parties involved. But Rohl's address argued pretty strongly against this and said the Fisher Thesis was the best explanation, and the way he talked about it made it seem like it was the orthodox position to take. Is there a consensus among historians about what caused World War One? Or is this really not considered too important to debate about, and a lot of interpretations are viable.

2 Answers 2017-11-02

How was round Earth reconciled with T-O maps in the Middle Ages? Did scholars believe the other side of the globe was an empty ocean?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

What did people wear in 1600s Sophia, Bulgaria?

I realize that Sophia was part of the Ottoman Empire at this time, so they might have just worn what Ottomans wore, but if they did, I only have a vague understanding of what that looked like anyway, so, I need some help on this either way. It's been unreasonably difficult to find answers on Google for this.

I'm also looking more specifically for what Sephardic Jewish people in that time and place would have worn, really, but I know that it's possible, even probable, that they mostly wore the same things as their Muslim neighbors. Still, if there was anything about the way they dressed that was different, I'd like to know that, too.

All that said, if you have other knowledge about 1600s Sophia, especially that would apply to the Jewish population there, besides clothing, that, too, would be very welcome. I'm trying to write a story, so, I want to get a decent understanding of the setting.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Did any futurists, etc. successfully predict that the creation of an internet accessible to all would result in the creation of "information bubbles?" I'm curious if anyone saw the free dissemination of information resulting in an increase in the belief of conspiracy theories.

As the internet has changed all our lives, I'm curious in the modern history of the internet if anyone saw this coming early on. Here is an example of what I am talking about:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/01/far-right-conspiracy-theory-us-civil-war?CMP=fb_gu

Is there a particular thinker that gets credit for predicting this phenomenon?

Perhaps, earlier work pre-internet about the correlation between easier dissemination of information and the rise of conspiracy theories would be insightful as well.

Thank you, /AskHistorians

1 Answers 2017-11-02

How did vikings manage to conquer such vast areas of land from England, AD 800-1000?

To me, if I look at it, vikings were in a disadvantage: they were outnumbered, their supply lines were long (and could not get new men during winter), had no true allies to speak of, land was unfamiliar and local populace probably hostile. Yet they conquered much of current England and held it for a long time. How?

3 Answers 2017-11-02

Any good books/reference materials about the history of signage?

A while back I was looking at some of the oldest pictures ever taken. Most of these are cityscapes, and I found it fascinating the types and wording of the signs put on all the buildings. After all, aside from newspapers, if you wanted to address people, you made a big sign. Stuck on your house or establishment.

Are there any good or popular books about the history of signage? It was a such common form of public communication in times past, but I can't recall ever seeing anything about it.

1 Answers 2017-11-02

Is the German "Erika" song a Nazi song, or could it be considered independent of the Nazi regime?

There has recently been a heated discussion in a different subreddit about the so-called Erika song (it's also available on youtube). The main question was/is: can it be separated from the Nazi regime and enjoyed independently, or is it tied together with the Nazi regime and could be considered Nazi "propaganda"?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

What were the Roman cheeses like?

I mean, "cheese" is a rather broad category. Do we have an idea of what variety of cheeses Romans had, and what their closest equivalents are now? Are there any contemporary Italian cheeses that closely resemble the ones eaten by ancient Romans?

2 Answers 2017-11-02

How did the transformation of the Eastern Roman Empire into the Byzantine Empire happen? When is it correct to speak of a "Greek Empire" rather than a "Roman Empire"?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

What was it like in the moments leading up to the atomic bomb dropping on Hiroshima?

I'm asking because I am writing a novel where the moment before dropping is important to the story.

So to clarify, what was it like? Were there air raid sirens going on, what was the weather like, and so on. I can't seem to find anything about this, apart from the date and the exact time of the detonation...

Additional question: Were stores open that morning? I know the US were conducting air raids and conventional bombings on Japan at the same time as the atomic bomb dropping, so would let's say a bookstore be able to be open in Hiroshima at that time?

1 Answers 2017-11-02

⯇ 3030 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start