How close was the Old World from discovering the New World right before Columbus?

Okay, let's try again. I'm not searching for examples and the question doesn't involve the history of the American continent.

I repeat: I'm basically trying to understand how could the New World have been discovered without Columbus, but since alternate history questions aren't allowed...

... I'd like to know what "Old World stuff" was going on around the American continent in that second half of the 15th century, before Columbus expedition. Which were the nearest Old World presences?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Who was the man that went to India to see a solar eclipse and was presumed dead until he returned 4 years later?

I remember reading about an Englishman in the 1800s, I think he was a philosopher or scientist, who went to India to observe a solar eclipse but on that particular day it was cloudy so he decided to stay in India for a few years and waited for the next one. He then returned to find out he had been presumed dead and his wife had remarried. Is anyone familiar with that story?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Were Nazi's socialists?

I've seen this argument posted way too many times on Reddit, and people (mostly American people) furiously believe that Nazi's were socialists because the word contains "Nationalsozialistische". During my history lessons however, I seem to recall that they weren't. My teacher told me the word was just used to convince others of their good intentions for Germany. I did some research on it myself but it seems to me they're just not a socialist party. Weren't they on the other side of the spectrum? (The right, instead of the left as some people claim)

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Battle of Passchendaele

Can I please get an in-depth answer about how this battle looked like, what led to it and what ended it. The more detailed the better, if it has been answered before, a link should suffice.

2 Answers 2017-08-20

Was the British Empire a "typical" empire or unique compared to other empires?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Why was Stalin's power in the Bolshevik party apparatus able to beat Trotsky's power in the Red Army? Why did the latter not come to his aid?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Why didn't Sir Cyril Radcliffe draw the borders for Kashmir?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

To what degree did pagan and crypto-pagan traditions and beliefs still exist in late medieval western Europe?

While Christianity was undoubtedly the dominant faith in Europe and had been for centuries by the later middle ages were there any pockets of old beliefs that had either wholly resisted conversion or had partially integrated in a kind of syncretic​ folk religion?

4 Answers 2017-08-20

Did acting Quasetors have the right to vote in the Senate?

I have read that the Roman Senate was made up of ex magistrates, which makes sense because to qualify for any higher position they had to be a Quasetor first. However, does this mean that acting Quasetors could not vote?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | August 14, 2017–August 20, 2017

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

6 Answers 2017-08-20

How was Hitler allowed to rebuild Nazi Germany in the light of WW I reparations

Can someone explain to me how a bankrupt Germany was able to become almost a superpower (probably the strongest in Europe) after a complete default?

2 Answers 2017-08-20

Why did the Scottish - English border change from being where Hadrians wall stands?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Grandfathers WW2 Royal Naval History, where can I research?

Hi, so my ageing mother has found a trove of information relating to her fathers (my grandfather) time in the Royal Navy.

We have a variety of medals, RN numbers etc etc

How or where can I use these details to find out more about the ships he served on and the locations and could I find out or create a time line of his time in the Navy?

Any help would be really appreciated.

Cheers.

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Could the Kingdom of Italy have been formed in the Late Middle Ages?

I read that Gian Galeazzo, the first Duke of Milan in the 14th century, "had dreams of uniting all of northern Italy into one kingdom, a revived Lombard empire". He was able to conquer several cities in Northern Italy before dying. How close was he? Could he have claimed the medieval Kingdom of Italy if he had been successful? I know that the Holy Roman Emperor had de jure rule over the region and that the Kingdom was a constituent of the Empire. Would he have allowed it? What were his reactions to the Duke's endeavor?

2 Answers 2017-08-20

Could Wehrmacht Heer soldiers refuse to carry out orders?

We all know the "Just following orders" excuse but would German soldiers actually risk something serious by refusing to carry out orders?

I am, of course, talking about orders related to war crimes (Were war crimes an actual, formal and codified thing during WW2, by the way?)

2 Answers 2017-08-20

Since ancient romans knew the world was a sphere why they never tried to reach China navigating the atlantic ocean to avoid the parthian prices ?

Romans, or roman merchants at least, surely knew China was a thing and the Parthian were exploiting their position to re-sell silk and other precious resources to Rome at higher prices so, why merchant never did what Columbus did ? I mean, Phoenicians already knew how to navigate without being close to a coast so i believe romans knew too.

2 Answers 2017-08-20

How much prize money could a crewman expect to earn during the Napoleonic Wars? If they wanted to save/invest it, how would they go about it? Would it be enough to buy their children a commission?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Did USA and the USSR create nuclear artillery during the cold war ?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-08-20

WWII German Perspective

Disclaimer I am not looking for this because I, in any way, shape, or form seek to relate more with Nazis or to emulate them or anything of the sort.

Anyways... I consider myself a WWII enthusiast... enthusiast may even be too strong, but I've read quite a few books on that time period and find it fascinating.

Lately, I've been wondering if there are any widely available books out there, in English, (my German is still very, very weak) that tell stories from the German soldier's side. I'm not looking for propaganda pieces (although those would be interesting), but more stories of battles and what not on the German side. I know the victors write the history books and all, but I'm hoping there's at least something out there that is reputable and at least some what well written.

Apologies if this isn't an appropriate question for this sub. Let me know if not and I'll move it. Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Henry Morgan and Alexandre Exquemelin

Hi, I'm wondering if anyone can tell me if there is any evidence that the writer Alexandre Exquemelin actually sailed with Sir Henry Morgan? I have read allusions to crew lists, but nothing concrete. Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-08-20

Was splitting the Roman empire Into two a distinct reason for the fall of Rome?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

When and which political parties have supported slavery and racism?

If Abraham Lincoln was anti-slavery, not racist and a republican, and Andrew Johnson was pro-slavery, racist and a democrat. When did the roles switch(since generally, now, the racism tends to be accredited to the opposite parties)?

Thanks

1 Answers 2017-08-20

British involvement in US civil war

I remember as a child going on a trip to a fort near Canadian and US border. There they said during the US civil war the forts prepared to defend against a British attack because they feared the British would side with the south in the name of the cotton trade or something similar

Is this true?

Is there any possibility the British would have attacked to secure cotton?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

How did officers in the First World War effectively communicate to artillerymen on where to fire and how did artillerymen know how to aim a cannon to accurately fire a shot/barrage?

I like history and the first world war intrigues me. After playing the game Verdun I was wondering how artillery worked in the Great War.

1 Answers 2017-08-20

When the rest of South America became independent, why did French Guiana still choose to remain a colony?

1 Answers 2017-08-20

⯇ 3186 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start