My anthropology professor says that Karl Marx was not a Marxist. Why is this?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Some people claim the story of Moses' birth and adoption mirrors the story of Sargon of Akkad. Is there any evidence of this?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-06-22

How important were the various Enlightenment thinkers as a cause for the French Revolution?

I was educated in France and I remember being taught that Enlightenment thinkers were an important cause of the Revolution. How true is this?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Why is Ullysses S. Grant on the 50$ bill?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Why is sliced bread considered one of the greatest inventions of all time?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

When Rome had to raise armies instantly, where did they get the equipment?

Example: During Octavian's rise to power, he had to raise several new legions to fight Caesar's assassins. From what I've read, the troops included a lot of veterans, so training wasn't a huge issue. And the money was provided by Caesar's will.

But where do you just acquire thousands of standard-issue swords, shields, pila, etc. that a first-century BCE Roman legion would require, on such short notice? Were there stockpiles just sitting around? Or would he have to hire every swordsmith and armorer in Rome? A previous question theorized that veterans probably didn't keep their equipment, and if so Octavian would've needed to resupply them all himself somehow.

(This is specifically about post-Marian Rome, where the state provides the equipment, rather than the other method of "if you want a shield you better buy the damn thing yourself")

1 Answers 2017-06-22

What happened to the Etruscans? Why aren't they around anymore?

I know the Etruscans lived in Italy. I'm guessing they probably were conquered by the Romans at some point but I'm having trouble finding a definitive answer.

So what happened to the Etruscans?

2 Answers 2017-06-22

Who would join the piracy life?

Let's take the Golden Age of Piracy, for this topic. How was the profile of someone who would embrace the life on sea? Poor/Rich? Family men? Workers? Farmers? Did they only accept men with military/sailing experience or the pirates followed the "rookies welcome" style of recruitment? Did they have any source of "code" that forbid certain classes (based on religion, skin color, etc.) to join them? Basically, how the life of someone would be like for that person to think that piracy was the right lifestyle choice?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Nietzsche called Christianity "Platonism for the masses". Would (some) ancient Romans (around the time of its spread/persecution) agree or even make such considerations?

And if it makes sense - did ideological/philosophical concerns play a role in Roman persecution of Christianity?

2 Answers 2017-06-22

What did WW2 propaganda flyers dropped over enemy territory say? Were they effective?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

We always read about Roman emperors building amazing structures in Rome, but did they even care about major Roman cities outside of Italy? Seems like they never got any special projects built outside of Rome.

I forgot what special I was watching, but it was going over the history of the Roman emperors. One historian said it was kind of an unwritten rule that Roman emperors must build something big and new in Rome during their reign. Nowhere in that special did they mention special projects in London, Paris, or even Constantinople. When I thought about it, I realized there aren't any special structures in those cities on the scale of Rome's projects. Am I wrong, or did Rome just not care about other major cities?

2 Answers 2017-06-22

When did people start cleaning their butts? And what makes it that animals dont do the same?

I know, weird question.

1 Answers 2017-06-22

To what degree was European economic prosperity dependant on resource extraction out of the various colonies?

As an European descendant living in an African former colony, the narritive that that Europe enriched herself at Africa's expense is pushed pretty hard. While it seems true that Europe owes a fair amount of its success on its extractive colonial approach, the degree of influence colonial exploitation played is seems up for debate.

3 Answers 2017-06-22

In popular culture and meme posts there's a stereotype correlating living in Southern states and incest. Is there any historical reason why this stereotype is a thing? Why aren't Northern American states associated with this stereotype instead?

2 Answers 2017-06-22

How did the Romans keep track of years before they converted to Christianity?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

A lot of Roman and Ancient Greek deities and mythological figures seem to overlap. How widespread was this practice? e.g. Did Jupiter have a similar "origin story" to Zeus? Did Roman religion/mythology have an equivalent to the Titanomachy?

I was quite into Greek mythology as a kid, and remember reading that Zeus and the Olympian gods were the children of Chronos and Rhea. Chronos, scared of being usurped, ate his children, but Zeus fought back, freeing his siblings, and this led to the titans being overthrown.

I also remember that Zeus was equivalent to Jupiter, Hermes to Mercury, Poseidon to Neptune, etc. Given how Roman religion absorbed and adapted a lot of culture from around the empire, how much detail did they keep? Did Roman mythology/religion have an equivalent of the Titanomachy, or did they just pick and choose the best bits?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

With the Atom Bomb ready to go in August 1945, were the battles of Iwo Jima and Okinawa strategically pointless?

2 Answers 2017-06-22

What evidence was there of Vietnam Vets being spit on and mistreated upon their return?

A friend of mine says that it is just a myth but I'm skeptical.

2 Answers 2017-06-22

Did the Achaemenids use a den of lions to punish criminals?

In the Bible (Chapter 6 of the Book of Daniel), Darius the Mede was forced to sentence his friend Daniel to be thrown into a den of lions, in accordance to a law that he created to force people to worship him. When he found that Daniel was alive through God's angel closing the lions' mouths, he ordered his soldiers to throw Daniel's enemies and their families to the den to be eaten by its lions.

I wonder, did the Achaemenid Persians use lions' dens (other than hanging on the gallows, as shown in the book of Esther) to execute criminals?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

What lesser known knowledge (i.e. other than the egyptian pyramids) was lost during the fire in the Library of Alexandria?

Are there more unknown facts about the Library of Alexandria? What else was lost during the fire?

Alexandria always fascinated me with its unique architecture and economical importance.

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Was the use of chemical weapons anticipated by any military immediately before the First World War?

Within a year of the outbreak of war, chemical weapons were used on a large scale on the Western front. As I understand, the gas first used (chlorine) was not developed specifically for the war; its' mass manufacture and its' effects were well known.

Was the widespread use of gas anticipated? If it was, then why were precautions (PPE and drills) not undertaken before the war? Or did the deployment of chemical weapons take the participants by surprise?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2017-06-22

Common use oils other than olive, in places other than Europe?

Hello there, I just read a thread here on the use of olive oil in the mediterranean, both in pre-roman times and during the roman era.

I use this reddit both for entertainment and education (call it edutainment), but also as a resource base for a massive "con-world-building" hobby of mine. In this light, I wondered,

Given the importance of oils for human societies, what other oils were used in non-mediterranean bronze and/or iron based civilizations and to what extent were they significant in terms of regional trade.. China, Meso-America, Sub-Sahara, Andes?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

What are active questions in Holocaust research?

And sidequestion: do you think Holocaust research is worth funding anymore? There are definitely legitimate concerns that antisemitism is still alive and active today, even in mainstream, academic, and/or liberal circles, but my question is about funding Holocaust research, not Jewish studies.

The general public isn't close to "forgetting" the Holocaust like, say, the Peloponnesian War (chosen because historically significant, huge scale, well-documented, but knowing about it is limited to good students).

Haven't we already mined all the answers to how the Nazis manipulated the Germans?

Sorry if these questions are in poor taste.

1 Answers 2017-06-22

How true is the statement "National Socialism and Stalinism are essentially the same ideology"?

1 Answers 2017-06-22

What would be the Middle Ages' equivalent of today's "memes"?

'Meme' is obviously quite a new word, but was the simple, overly relatable joke format around in some way back then?

To be extra specific: I'm asking about Western Europe, between the 12th century and the 13th century.

1 Answers 2017-06-22

⯇ 3326 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start