Why wasn't Germany simply dissolved altogether after WW1 (or WW2) and the territory divided among the neighboring countries?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Is the Han identity a modern construction in China? Which cultures were incorporated?

/u/bitparity mentions [here] (https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6du18i/i_asked_this_4_days_ago_and_got_no_answer_so_here/di5xmv8/) that the Han identity is less of an ethnic one, but more of a "constructed" one. What is the current historic consensus on the Han identity in China?

Which cultures were incorporated? Is there a modern resistance movement?

3 Answers 2017-05-29

Did environmental concerns existed in Europe in the 16th and 17th century in the sense of conservationism and/or environmentalism that we know today?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Scipio is told to have salted Carthage's soil. Have there been other, but documented instances of purposeful depopulating a region?

I was reading up on this brief Wikipedia article on the subject and have a following question:

I would like to know what other means were used to achieve similar effect. The only instance I know now is the Korean DMZ, in which case the means are purely diplomatic and "agreed" upon. Buffer zones however do not seem to meet similar criteria Romans were going after. Carthage was not to be a buffer zone as there was nothing to buffer from (to my understanding). If so, what means were used? Other chemicals, reforesting, deforesting, cutting access to water? Also, why?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

How accurate is this depiction of medieval fighting?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkDDBL7jNew

Here we see a couple of full contact fights with medieval gear and blunt weapons. I wonder how accurate this is? Like did fighting really look like this back then with hitting the opponent several times until one would fall over or was one strike enough to penetrate the armour/injure the knight? In movies they parry a lot and try not to get hit at all because this could mean death but here it seems a lot more offensive and getting hit doesn't do much damage. I wonder what difference the blunt weapons make in the fighting compared to sharpened "real" ones.

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Good magazines on modern history?

I have been reading a lot of history magazines that feel badly researched. What are some good magazines you would recommend on modern history?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

In the Communist Mannifesto, Marx and Engels write "Communism is already acknowledged by all European powers to be itself a power", yet we consider Marx and Engels to be the founders of Communism, where did the ideas of Communism originate from and what influence did they have before 1848?

Marx and Engels write: "A spectre is haunting Europe — the spectre of communism. All the powers of old Europe have entered into a holy alliance to exorcise this spectre: Pope and Tsar, Metternich and Guizot, French Radicals and German police-spies.

Where is the party in opposition that has not been decried as communistic by its opponents in power? Where is the opposition that has not hurled back the branding reproach of communism, against the more advanced opposition parties, as well as against its reactionary adversaries?

Two things result from this fact:

I. Communism is already acknowledged by all European powers to be itself a power.

II. It is high time that Communists should openly, in the face of the whole world, publish their views, their aims, their tendencies, and meet this nursery tale of the Spectre of Communism with a manifesto of the party itself.

To this end, Communists of various nationalities have assembled in London and sketched the following manifesto, to be published in the English, French, German, Italian, Flemish and Danish languages." Was communism already a political force before the publication of the Communist manifesto, or are they referring to the general idea of labor movements?

2 Answers 2017-05-29

When and how did secterian violence within christianity start to decline?

assuming it has at a rate higher than violence in general since the 1500s. I was thinking about the sunni/shia fighting going on and thought "why didn't christianity have that?" when I remembered that's much if not most of what christians did for a long time there. I'm curious how it was possible for protestant/catholic wars to largely end.

1 Answers 2017-05-29

What's highest rank ever attained by a drafted soldier?

4 Answers 2017-05-29

To what extent did timing play into the decision to revolt against the British during the American Revolution?

IOW, why did it happen when it happened and not sooner/later? Were the drivers mainly sociopolitical or was there a sense of British sovereignty over the 13 colonies as unfeasible in the long term? Did the pro-revolution forces think/predict that the American colonial system would probably face collapse anyway by the start of the 19th century or something similar?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Did the Japanese Empire have a plan B I'm fighting the Americans since there were no aircraft carriers at Pearl Harbor?

The Japanese Empire was created a few years before the 2nd Reich was created, and fell a few months after the 3rd Reich fell. This empire had lived through the failure of both the Schlieffen Plan and Operation Barbarossa. In secondary school I was taught the Japanese simply didn't have the wartime economy to keep up with the U.S., and after majoring in General Asian History, that's still what I had learned. But I had just thought, surely this empire must have had a backup plan if they couldn't destroy the aircraft carriers at Pearl Harbor. I can't see an empire with a strict military honor code which has read the Art of War many times to go into war against the U.S. without a plan to win and make the U.S. sue for peace. Would they really risk everything on Pearl Harbor being a victory or did they have a backup plan in place?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Why Was Asian Contact with the New World Limited Compared to Europe?

Obviously with major exceptions (like the original settlement of North and South America 20,000 years ago, or the colonization of Hawaii) why did Asia have so much less contact with the Americas than Europe did in more recent history? The Norse colonization started in the late 10th century and European colonization started in earnest in 15th century. The distance from Spain to Trinidad is 4,000mi and the distance from England to Virginia is 3700mi. The distance from Japan to California is 5,300mi which is larger though at its smallest point the continent is separated from Alaska by only 55mi. Is it that most of that [Siberia/Russian] area is lightly inhabited and colonization required major civilizational might? But is 1,300mi enough of a difference to account for the lack of Japanese contact?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

If history is written by the victors, why do we remember the 300 Spartans that died fighting the Persian Empire as heroes?

additionally: Are there any other notable examples from history which break this rule?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

(ww2) Were russian commisars shooting retreating soviet troops at most engagements

I think most people with a passing knowledge of the soviets in WW2 are aware of the russian commisars who stood behind the lines of the advancing troops and opened fired on retreating troops. how prevalent was this across the entire soviet army? Was it at all engagments?

When did this start as well? Was this introduced from the beginning? or after some major losses in the early days?

As an add on, what exactly was a commisar? I've heard them refered to as political officers, so am I right in guessing they were trying to uphold soviet or stalinist values in troops?

2 Answers 2017-05-29

What might Aristotle's syllabus for Alexander the Great have looked like?

Aristotle is said to have tutored Alexander until the age of sixteen, so I'm curious about the types of things he might have had in his curriculum. I'd imagine it wasn't just philosophy, but I'm not an expert. Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-05-29

What percentage of medieval wounded were amputees?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Pirates liked the Bahamas because they could traverse the dangerously shallow waters with their smaller vessels to escape larger enemy ships. How big was too big for a ship to sail through the Bahamian archipelago in the Golden Age of Piracy?

I didn't receive any answers the last time I submitted this question.

1 Answers 2017-05-29

The book 1177bc: the year civilization ended focuses entirely on the Mediterranean & near East yet references a similar collapse in Europe, can anyone expand

He references a potential reason for the collapse of Greece being refugees from European nations, another collapse in Afghanistan reduced the ability to produce bronze. So what can you tell me about the wider world during the collapse and its lead-up

1 Answers 2017-05-29

In the 1640s, Chinese pirate/warlord Zheng Zhilong had a corps of 300 African musketeers he had purchased from the Portuguese. Would these African slaves have been Catholic?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

What gave the invading Gauls the edge against the Greeks on their invasion in 3rd century BCE? How did they overcome the phalanx?

Any insight onto the nature of how Gallic and Greek warfare collided would be amazing.

1 Answers 2017-05-29

Who is Schliemann, and why is he such a controversial historian/archaeologist?

This comment chain describes a historian/archaeologist who seems to be at best controversial and at worst viscerally hated. What's the deal with him?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

What happened to the civillians of Constantinople after its conquest by Mehmed II?

Most stuff that i read only mentions that he either preserved the city and stopped any efforts of destroying it or he ordered a ransack for 3 days, but not the fate of the civillians (except for that one book by Roger Crawley, where he mentions that all civillians got enslaved)

2 Answers 2017-05-29

Did cavemen have anxiety?

1 Answers 2017-05-29

How did painters react to the invention of photography? Did they oppose it or did they embrace it as an emerging art?

4 Answers 2017-05-29

I'm looking for sources to learn about Rome

I am not a history nerd by any history nerds estimation, but I do enjoy learning about certain areas of history and plan on getting into history more. Up until this point one of my major historical blindspots has been Rome. What are some good documentaries, podcast episodes, and books that can help me learn about the subject. Ideally I'd like them to be comprehensive but not overly long.

2 Answers 2017-05-29

⯇ 3376 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start