How do historians discriminate rumors of the time from actual events?

I recently watched a video by Thoughty2 "7 Most Terrible Tyrants From History" ( https://youtu.be/EBKMmgKLm8I ). It mentioned Wu Zetian, who was said to have killed her own daughter to frame the current empress.

It seems like a weird detail to know about a historical figure considering it would be very bad for her (supposedly) if that information got out. If people knew of it before she had such power, she would (I assume) be punished. If instead the information surfaced after she got enough power that it wouldn't matter whether people knew or not (i.e. was empress), how would people have found out. There wasn't any fingerprint or DNA analysis available at that time so it seems like it would be very hard to figure out who did something long after a murder happens.

So this brought up the general question, how to historians figure out what should be believed and what shouldn't.

And yes I do realize that there are sometimes no definite answers to some events. Also I don't know much about Chinese society around 600AD or on Wu Zetian, other than the Wikipedia search. So even if my information is wrong, my question still stands lol

3 Answers 2017-03-19

How did 10th century Islamic "assembly lines" of manuscript copying work? Did they have any precedents?

I was reading the Wikipedia page on the Islamic Golden Age, and it says "Islamic paper makers devised assembly-line methods of hand-copying manuscripts to turn out editions far larger than any available in Europe for centuries." However, the cited source deadlinks.

I find this interesting, as I was unaware of any pre-Industrial Revolution precursors of this type of labor.

1 Answers 2017-03-19

Where should I go to graduate school?

Hello historians! I'm pursuing a BA in History at the University of South Florida and I'm only two semesters away from heading on to graduate school. I'm concentrating on Irish and Celtic history. I'm still torn over medieval and revolutionary (17th-20th C).

I'm compiling information on graduate programs in the US and Europe. My wife and I are in central Florida, USA, and she'll be finishing up her MA right as I finish my BA, so we have freedom to move. I'm fluent in English, my Latin just needs some brushing up, and I'm working on Irish and Italian non-academically. I'm studying Digital Humanities as well and I'm getting better at Python.

Is your school great for Irish studies? Have a Celticist in an otherwise strong medieval program? Are you a professor at Trinity College Dublin and you want an American graduate student? I'd love to hear from you.

2 Answers 2017-03-19

Was Cleopatra a princess before becoming Queen

1 Answers 2017-03-19

Is there any merit to the theory that the USSR was preparing to attack Germany before Barbarossa?

Pretty self-explanatory.

1 Answers 2017-03-19

Stalin's economic policies and their impacts

Hi Reddit! In school we were asked to research up on the next chapter, namely stalin's economic polices and their impacts. I narrowed it down to 5 year plans , industrialization of the country and collectivization. So does any of these policies have more success than failures, vice versa or equal success and failures?

Personally I think collectivization was a failure due to him killing the kulaks(rich peasants) if said they were to resist giving up their land, leading to a loss of lives

I think that the 5 year plans were a success as they greatly boosted the their resources, but reduced their standard of living

For industrialization, this led to shortage of houses due to people going to the city to work in factories

What do you all think? Feel free to disagree with me!

1 Answers 2017-03-19

What was the impact of Lenin's death on Bolshevik party Leadership?

1 Answers 2017-03-19

Is it fair to say that America caused the global (1930s) Great Depression? Were other countries' economic systems as responsible?

1 Answers 2017-03-19

Combat Deaths in The Pacific Theater

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-03-19

How accurate is Neil Gaiman's Norse Mythology?

I was given the book as a gift, and I'm wondering how accurate the novelization is to the Sagas and Norse mythology that it is based off of. I'm a huge Neil Gaiman fan so I'm sure I'll enjoy the book regardless, but I'm interested in how historians familiar with the Norse feel about it.

2 Answers 2017-03-18

Why were the Magyars against Austria-Hungary asking Romania for help against the Serbains, but were fine with them going to Bulgaria for help?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

What do Historians think of the works of Grover Furr?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

In pre-columbian times, were the native americans spread evenly across north america?

It seems like a very large portion of native american tribes living in what is now the united states that we still hear about today, or that are well know, live/lived in 1) the dakotas 2) alabama and florida or 3) the four corners region.

Where these places actually populated more than other areas?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Roman religious changes

I'm after an object that is proof of religious change in a Roman province around the Principate period of 30BC to around 284AD, but an important one. I've been wracking my brains and my books and can't find many good examples. Do you guys know any off hand?

Thank you.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Why did Germany declare war on US on Dec. 11th, 1941

I know that Germany and Japan were allies, but couldn't Germany have just remained neutral in the Pacific?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

Which drugs did humans first start using and when?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

With the current flow of refugees from poor, war torn countries such as Syria being a contentious issue in western politics, I wonder; how were the rich, Russian aristocracy treated as refugees after the 1917 revolution?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

The english occupation of France

Im but a layman in this area but the generall felling i get by reading about the english medieval occupation of some parts of France that the english was truly a force to be reckon with and my question is this. How is it that a small country like England could win against France which by what I understand was a bit of Medieval powerhouse severall times over? Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Why was monarchy in Italy abolished in 1946 even though the monarchist and liberal forces in Southern Italy eventually won the civil war?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-03-18

I was once told that the Crusades were caused by overpopulation in Europe and the drive to colonise new lands east- How true is this and relevant compared to more well known religious/political causes?

As per the title. Thanks to everyone in advance.

2 Answers 2017-03-18

Why didn't the U.S. use lever-action rifles during WWI?

Lever-action rifles such as the Henry 30-30 became commercially successful near the end of the American Civil War in the later 1800s, and even saw use by Union troops, which is a part of why they decidedly won, when many Confederates still relied on flintlocks.

Such a style of firearm became very popular among the American civilians as well, and remains an icon of American history.

If this is the case, then why didn't the U.S. military (or anyone else, for that matter) employ such a style of rifle during their involvement with in the First World War, instead relying upon the slower, more prone to jam bolt-action?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-03-18

When did monotheistic religions arrive in the Near East?

I'm currently working on a university assignment and my topic is pilgrimage in ancient Greece and the Near East. I have Christianity down as it generally spread through Constantine. I am unsure about any one dominant monotheistic religions though. I know Islam arrived in Arabia around 632 CE (or presumably earlier as that was when paganism) was eradicated, but what about the other regions?

Thank you in advance.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

How did Otto Von Bismarck become the leading face of German unification in the 19th century?

Was it through his influence as a leader? Did the German states want to unify and he was the one to step up? Any answer or correction to my question is greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

When did humans start drinking cow's milk?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Why did Japan not attack USSR in the world war 2 and instead chose to attack a neutral US?

I am aware that there was a pact between Japan and USSR, but given all the events that took place in the WW2, a act seems hardly like a deterrent.

My point is, Nazis had launched an attack on USSR 6 months ago, and were hugely successful thus far. Then, why did Japan not chose to join that attack and finish off USSR before attacking US? From what I know, it seems nearly impossible that USSR would have won a two front war, given Churchill's inaction and no other powers by their side.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

⯇ 3535 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start